Maggie Gyllenhaal V. Gwyneth Paltrow: A Jumpsuit Fashion Faceoff (POLL)

All hail the return of the jumpsuit! On April 30, Gwyneth Paltrow wore a fitted navy blue Stella McCartney jumpsuit with buttons on the front, wide legs and a bare back to "Iron Man's" Los Angeles premiere. Earlier today, Maggie Gyllenhaal donned a black silk Stella McCartney jumpsuit, with no buttons, a looser fit and the same bare back and wide legs to "The Dark Knight's" London premiere.

Scroll down, take a look and vote.

Quick Poll

Who wore the jumpsuit best?

Gwyneth Paltrow

Maggie Gyllenhaal

Comments

[Dangler]

Maggie's a dog. Really, really not pretty. I just saw the new Batman and she was shockingly unattractive. It was difficult to believe that two men were vying for her attention.

[eXcommunicate]

Here's a vote for Paltrow.

[MrBluebird]

MG's jumpsuit is terrif', but her smile lights up the world.

[raker]

Gyllenhaal looks fabulous, like she's dressed for an awards show. Paltrow looks like she's wearing the $250 knock-off of Gyllenhaal's dress.

[liberation4life]

MG's got my vote.....She's much closer to the girl next door look than GP..if the vote is to be based on looks rather than character.

Now excuse while I get back to daydreaming.

[mlaiuppa]

Neither of these ladies are going to bring either the halter top or the jumpsuit back into high fashion.

[LadyFist]

All I gotta say is thank god GP cut off that hideous hippie-mop of a hair farm she was sporting for awhile. Give MG a break--she's unique. The jumpsuit is horrid...but her skin looks great.

[barackobama4prez]

They both look a mess.

[gonavy]

I agree, they both look horrible. I Love Lucy burlap dresses would look better than these jumpsuits.

[ArjenBoatsma]

The only thing I noticed is that Maggie could use a new hair-do

[EarthToZoey]

I was told once that I look like Maggie Gyllenhaal (i don't see it at all, but whatever) and so I took notice of her after that. I looked at her profile on IMDB once and the opinions on her attractiveness are very polarized. By and large, people either find her stunning or off-putting. I personally find her attractive (especially in Secretary and her Agent Provocateur campaign) but I can see the perceived "flaws" people berate her for. She does sometimes look older than her age. Her posture can be quite bad. And her face is unusual. But for me, all of those things make her a unique person and she is a beauty in her own right.

Not everyone has to look like a supermodel to be considered beautiful. And I'm willing to bet that many who critique her now wouldn't turn away a date with her if given the chance. ;)

[OsamaBushLadin]

Depends. If the date was her paying for everything, followed by a rolled in the hay, I'm game. Otherwise..., release the hounds.

Really, could anybody believe this was the best Bruce Wayne could do? While watching the Dark Knight it took more power to suspend my disbelief in that relationship, than it took accepting a man in a bondage suit with pointy ears fighting crime.

[thelilywhites]

I can't look at Maggie anymore without thinking of her in 'Secretary' and that spanking scene.

[montecore]

i don't get either of them. Gwenyth is the most overrated actress and i heard she slept with Harvey to get the Oscar. Maggie is a better actress but unless she's a sub in a bdsm fim, she's not attractive at all.

[[e-mail]]

Couldn't agree more!

[devilyousay]

Maggie. All the way. She's attractive in a real and attainable way. Not so "plastic".

[rpence]

Both of them have their work cut out for them in getting my mind off Helen Mirren. Acting-wise as well as looks-wise.

[EarthToZoey]

Helen Mirren is definitely hot.

[mamacat]

Forgive me, but both of these women are stellar examples of what it means to be an actress. Forget the contest, they are on the same team.