Why Is Salt Lake Full Of Mercury?

digg Share this on Facebook Huffpost - stumble reddit del.ico.us RSS

MIKE STARK | August 8, 2008 06:02 PM EST | AP

Compare other versions »

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service biologist Chris Cline marks a cinnamon teal duck egg with an identification number Monday, June 30, 2008, in the marshlands along the shore of Utah's Great Salt Lake. Eggs are then tested for mercury levels. (AP Photo/Douglas C. Pizac)

GREAT SALT LAKE, Utah — The Great Salt Lake is so briny that swimmers bob in the water like corks. It is teeming with tiny shrimp that were sold for years in the back of comic books as magical "sea monkeys." And, for reasons scientists cannot explain, it is heavily laden with toxic mercury.

Exactly where the poison is coming from _ and how much danger it poses to the millions of migratory birds that feed on the Great Salt Lake _ are now under investigation.

"We've got a problem, but we don't know how big it is," said Chris Cline, a U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service biologist who has been collecting the eggs of cinnamon teal ducks from nests along the rim of the lake so that they can be cracked open and analyzed in the lab.

Three years ago, in an alarming finding, U.S. Geological Survey tests showed the lake had some of the highest mercury readings ever recorded in a body of water in the United States. The state warned people not to eat certain kinds of ducks because of the mercury.

This summer, scientists are fanning out across the lake and its marshy shoreline for the start of what is expected to be a multiyear study. The Environmental Protection Agency and the state are footing most of the $280,000 bill for the initial phase.

One major question is whether the mercury is accumulating naturally, from some as-yet-unknown source in the ground, or is the result of industrial pollution. Researchers say mercury released into the atmosphere from coal-fired power plants in the West, gold mines in Nevada, volcanoes in Indonesia or industries in rapidly developing countries such as China or India may be settling in the lake.

Mercury can cause neurological damage in birds and affect their ability to fight off diseases. High mercury levels have been detected in some of the Great Salt Lake's birds. But so far there is no evidence that it is sickening them.

"The jury's kind of still out on the impact, but it can't be a good impact," said Tom Aldrich, migratory gamebird coordinator for the Utah Division of Wildlife Resources.

Story continues below
advertisement

For all of its international recognition, the Great Salt Lake is still a deep source of mystery. The lake is the remnant of a sprawling prehistoric inland sea that covered 20,000 square miles during the last ice age and was 1,000 feet deep in places.

Today's Great Salt Lake is much smaller at 1,700 square miles, much shallower and significantly saltier _ brinier even than the ocean _ because of salts dumped by tributaries and left behind as the water evaporates.

Businesses make millions of dollars selling tiny brine shrimp, salt and other minerals from the lake, and it is a popular spot for boaters and other tourists, despite the often strong rotten-egg smell from decaying algae and other organisms, and despite the fact that practically the only creatures that can survive the salty water are bacteria, bugs and the shrimp. (Scientists say the mercury poses no danger to swimmers.)

But the wetlands and wide expanses of calm water are a powerful draw for birds, including the world's largest concentration of Wilson's pharalope, which uses its needle-like bill to gobble shrimp and bugs; the eared grebe; the white-faced ibis; the California gull; and the snowy plover.

Each year, more than 9 million birds stop by, many on their annual treks between Canada or South America and parts between, making the Great Salt Lake "sort of the Delta airplane hub of the West in terms of migration," Aldrich said.

The problem is that the lake has a peculiar combination of bacteria and chemicals that helps convert inorganic mercury to its more harmful form, methylmercury, scientists say. In some cases, the mercury gets into the brine layer on the lake bottom and makes its way up the food chain to the shrimp and then to the birds that eat them.

Once they have identified the source of the contamination and what sort of threat it poses, scientists hope to somehow reduce the amount of mercury getting into the lake, or perhaps control the bacteria that lead to the more harmful form.

"Hopefully something can be done," said Jodi Gardberg, the state's Great Salt Lake watershed coordinator.

GREAT SALT LAKE, Utah — The Great Salt Lake is so briny that swimmers bob in the water like corks. It is teeming with tiny shrimp that were sold for years in the back of comic books as magical "...
GREAT SALT LAKE, Utah — The Great Salt Lake is so briny that swimmers bob in the water like corks. It is teeming with tiny shrimp that were sold for years in the back of comic books as magical "...
 
Comments
53
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: 1 2 3 Next › Last » (3 pages total)
- isis I'm a Fan of isis permalink
photo

Why are the scientists telling us that it is safe to swim in it?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:28 AM on 08/14/2008
- mh01 I'm a Fan of mh01 permalink

Its Probably people throwing the new high efficiency light bulbs in the lake when they break.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:37 PM on 08/13/2008
- mh01 I'm a Fan of mh01 permalink

Probably people throwing the new high efficiency light bulbs in the lake when they break.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:13 PM on 08/13/2008
photo

The Army has a chemical weapons incinerator in Tooele, Utah, just outside of salt Lake belching mercury. Magcorp is also a polluter there. Legislators in Utah could care less about protecting the public health and environment-- and the Mormon church is in the polluting business.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:17 AM on 08/13/2008

Don't suppose it has anything to do with nearby (or even remote) polluting industries? Oh no, it couldn't be that! Must do long-term multi-year study and erect massive thick smoke screens to lead right-wing Americans around by the nose.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:38 PM on 08/12/2008
photo

"often strong rotten-egg smell from decaying algae and other organisms"

Detritus accumulating in water is known to concentrate mercury in water bodies.

"The problem is that the lake has a peculiar combination of bacteria and chemicals that helps convert inorganic mercury to its more harmful form, methylmercury, scientists say." * (-- Yikes!)

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:05 AM on 08/13/2008

Unless this problem is caused by naturally occuring pollution, it can be fixed. However, when was the last time we had a Republican president who cared about pollution?

Democrats create agencies to protect us citizens, and then the Republicans work as hard as they can to dismantle those agencies when they get hold of the reins, e.g. EPA, OSHA, FDA, ICC, even the Dept. of Justice, as we have seen in the recent Alberto Gonzales scandal.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:34 AM on 08/12/2008

Richard Nixon, who sign the Clean Water Act, among many others that Bush has dismantled the past 8 years.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:42 AM on 08/12/2008

Studies funded by the Olympic Committee, executed by USGS showed that for every ounce of Silver or Gold Kennecott takes from the Bingham Canyon Mine, at the South end of Great Salt Lake, there is an ounce of Cinnabar present, a naturally occurring mineral full of Mercury. If two million ounces combined, of Silver and Gold are processed then that much Mercury is released.

Great Salt Lake is the toilet for the entire Wasatch Front. Every stream, every river, every storm drain, in Northern Utah, terminates in Great Salt Lake. There is planning underway to take more of the Bear River flow away from Great Salt Lake, thereby further concentrating the pollutants present.

State workers assume the Mercury came from the smelter, but there is deliberate obfuscation of all facts in regards to Kennecott, and the Mercury. There is work underway to set Selenium standards for the lake, but it is the Mercury standard, that has to be addressed. Kennecott's PR team works hard to defer blame and engages in huge local philanthropy.

Great Salt Lake has become a locked down, industrial wasteland. If you want to look at any part of the North Arm anymore, you can't. The causeway is locked, the roads are blocked. They are doing what they want to the Lake, including plans to drill for oil. Destruction of the Great Salt Lake ecosystem is deliberate at this point, the place is crawling with investigators who are being paid to not find the culprits.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:13 AM on 08/12/2008
photo

Huh! All one needs to do is drive through the SLC basin to determine there is something amiss. The place is so filthy with pollution. Especially at night when the industries turn up there processes. Out of sight out of mind.

This is the cost of unregulation and an example of where the EPA is. Kind've of like the mining disaster a year ago which was just recently release that the mines owners were severely responsible or irresponsible.

The bad news is that Utah is a state that prides itself with industry and commerce and screw labor and livability. I am surprised that anything can live in that basin. The good news is that the eastern half of the state is still very beautiful.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:12 AM on 08/12/2008

I know what you mean about industries turning up the pollution at night. I saw it happen at a rubber disposal facility in Los Angeles. On dark nights, they would fire up the furnaces and burn rubber right into the atmosphere in huge amounts. Dark rainy nights were the worst.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:22 AM on 08/12/2008
- isis I'm a Fan of isis permalink
photo

I live near a window factory and they paint windows at night and release the fumes. They even got an award from the EPA for using less toluene and xylene. Not none, just less. Talk about low standards! By day they tell their workers that if they vote for environmentalists they will lose their jobs.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:34 AM on 08/14/2008
photo

Sigh. So much for good stewardship of God's bountiful planet, eh ?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:31 PM on 08/11/2008

I don't doubt that industrial mining and coal fired generators contribute to the load of toxic metals. How could they not?
I think this article misses an important "learnable moment" in that a more thorough explanation of the lake's natural history and geology would have been a good idea...the lake has shrunk but not only as a result of the end of the ice age so much but also after the northern exit cut down through it's outlet into the Snake River around 5KYA when it dropped, over the course of what could have been only a few weeks or months, several hundred feet. Must have been one of those geologic events that in the geologic record is common but in human's miniscule time span of recorded history they've never been witnessed.
Shifting climatic zones, especially regarding the postion of the Hadley Cells played a large part in the drying out of the Southwest but no matter how wet it gets now the lake is not going to return to its ancestral size unless the land itself goes through geologic uplift at it's northern divide.
Trying to guage what's the ideal climate for an area is a fools errand but does reveal a lot about how little we understand climate science.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:33 PM on 08/11/2008

Odd isn't it?

Decades of ceaseless unregulated toxic input from the many sources readers can list on this page but a 'study' of actual conditions doesn't include participants from the same list - or better - a full list of pollutants and polluters?

Gee whiz. Why ever not?

As science, I don't see how this apparent exercise in look-the-other-way PR qualifies as a "study," do you?

Unless of course the terms of reference for funding were to target everything - but a full list of pollutants and polluters. Which generously allows those guilty of gross environmental degradation to remain off the public radar. The usual political suspects then can wring their hands and say - "Oh Dear! We just don't KNOW anything!" And the issue is dropped.

Not that politicians have indicated any receptivity or enthusiasm apparently on allowing anyone to ask the right questions.

It would be interesting to see those terms of reference...

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:04 PM on 08/11/2008
photo

Utah is polluted because it is THE most Republican, anti-environmental places there is. With the exception of Rocky Anderson's tenure as mayor of SLC (which has no impact on the environmental policies of the State of Utah), this problem is clearly the result of Pro-Business, Anti-Regulation Republicans. How obvious does it have to be.
Going back to Reagan, who wanted nothing more than to eliminate regulations to "get government off of the back of business", Republicans have been asking for it. In every case--the banking industry most recently, the S&L industry years ago, and now also environmental laws--we see precisely WHY we have all these regulations. Republicans JUST want to get RICH. They care for NOTHING else.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:33 PM on 08/11/2008
- Mort I'm a Fan of Mort permalink
photo

So the democrats who've served as governor during the 100 years of Kennecott pollution get free pass because it's so "clearly" only a republican problem? And the mayor of Salt Lake has no impact on any state environmental issues? What have you been smoking?

NO party is beyond reproach. They ALL play games and pander to special interest. In this case, the special interest happens to have been the single largest employer in the state. I guess they're not to blame for pumping all the toxins into the environment either because the republicans let them do it?

This is a society problem, not a party one. Businesses are in it for a profit and will cut whatever corners they can get away with. Polticians love favors, power and wallet padding more than they respect the interests of the people. And people are often complacent sheep. If it were clearly a party problem, the 6 democrat governors would have solved it long ago instead of letting it develop more and more.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:53 PM on 08/11/2008

There has not been a Democratic Governor of Utah since January 7th, 1985, when Gov. Scott Matheson left office.

Blaming the Democratic governors for this problem is nonsensical.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:30 AM on 08/12/2008
photo

Actually, the last Democratic Governor left in 1977, not 1985!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:40 PM on 08/12/2008

You are right! I have read other messages that blame it only on the republicans. Both parties are at fault...for all I see is that the Rs and Ds are having tea parties together while their acts of corruption are covered up through so called "opposing" organizations (EPA, etc). The RepubDemo party is at ease with the fact that most of us are convinced through propaganda to believe that the democratic party is our so called savior and the republicans are at fault! I will admit that I am young & not as well informed with politics & how the system works but ever since 9/11 I have been suspicious and therefore eager to learn as much as I can behind this political bulshit! But looking back its not only about how informed you are. There are people who are supposedly well informed through mainstream media, but still cant see past the screne, AKA the real picture. I was once convinced. I went from being a Kerry fan and couldnt believe that Bush was reelected to having no faith in either party. I am sorry to hear when people say "How could americans vote for Bush?" Just because we are a well developed country doesn't mean our election system is trustworthy! I just wish we could save our soldiers from fighting because its we the people (of all nations) that are fighting for our own governments' interests...War leaders are at disrespect for humankind and most importantly nature!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:07 PM on 08/13/2008
photo

I worked for a company on the lake harvesting brine shrimp one season, weirdest job ever, believe me. Mag Corp is a huge polluter on that lake, and because they are classified as a defense industry they aren't subject to EPA regulations, or so I was told. I do know that my crew and I would get headaches over on that side of the lake. During one particularly harrowing stretch of the season, there was a massive amount of bird deaths, and they all had quarter size patches on their breast where the feathers had fallen out. In one set I started to count all the birds I had to pull out of the pumping mechanism, I gave up at around 200. At the time they said it was some sort of disease. I'm not a biologist, ornithologist, chemist, or environmental scientist, so I don't know what was going on. Up close and personal with all that death is a real downer though, I can say that with authority.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:46 PM on 08/11/2008

forget yucca mountain.......put the waste in the Great Salt Lake......they'll never find it.....

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:45 PM on 08/11/2008

Well, if you're going to scoff at the health of the environment, if you're going to deregulate corporations, if you're going to elect politicians who will not tax or fine anybody - if you're going to vote Republican, then you're going to have stinking polluted lakes full of poison. Surprise ! Yeah, those Republicans are "pro-life" alright.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:39 PM on 08/11/2008
- Mort I'm a Fan of Mort permalink
photo

That's funny.... Utah has one of the highest tax bases in the country, some of the best governors have been democrats and the mayor of Salt Lake is almost always a dem.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:02 PM on 08/11/2008

ROTFLMAO

Are you serious?

One Democratic mayor. In Salt Lake City. Yeah, Rocky was great, but otherwise Utah is the is the reddest of the reddest states.

Does the name Orrin Hatch ring any bells?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:54 PM on 08/11/2008
- Mort I'm a Fan of Mort permalink
photo

I think it's the fault of LaPoint Ford. They're the largest Mercury dealer in the area.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:05 PM on 08/11/2008
- Mort I'm a Fan of Mort permalink
photo

Seriously, Kennecott Mine, primarily the smelter at the south end of the lake, has been polluting the environment for 100 years. The tailings piles and ponds leach arsenic and mercury, among others, into the ground and lake. Those who live in nearby Magna don't drink the water. I have, and it's nasty. But this isn't breaking news. The SL Tribune article this came from was last printed in '05.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:37 PM on 08/11/2008
photo

I think you must be right, its the dealership.

The simple facts are well known to the EPA:

Many mines extract, move, store, process, and dispose
of large amounts of waste rock and ore materials which
often contain low concentrations of naturally occurring
metals. The vast majority of this material is placed in
surface impoundments or on the land, and the metals
are reported as on-site releases to land. This previously
buried material is exposed to potential leaching by
rain, snow, and acid mine drainage, and must be
carefully managed and monitored to prevent any
surface water or groundwater contamination.
There are also air releases from ore processing and
metal refining operations. For air releases of mercury
and mercury compounds, copper mines reported a total
of 81 pounds, silver mines reported 11 pounds, and
gold mines reported a total of 4,551 pounds.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:50 PM on 08/11/2008
Page: 1 2 3 Next › Last » (3 pages total)
Comments are closed for this entry

You must be logged in to reply to this comment. Log in  or  Connect