iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Palin's eBay Story: What Actually Happened


First Posted: 09-10-08 12:04 PM   |   Updated: 10-11-08 05:12 AM

I Like ItI Don’t Like It
Jet

"That luxury jet that came with the office... I put it on eBay!"

It's one of Sarah Palin's favorite lines on the campaign trail, repeated with such frequency that it has already become a catchphrase of the general election. As Governor of Alaska, she rid the state of an unnecessary jet using a creative and cost-effective online measure.

What is left unmentioned is that Palin didn't come up with the idea to sell the plane using eBay in the first place. Moreover, because of the unique purchasing terms of the aircraft -- which required the state to make payments amounting to $20,000 per month even if the jet wasn't in use -- the decision not to hire a broker to help sell the property appears in hindsight to have been a costly mistake.

Before the Alaska Republican took office, it was something of a standard operating procedure for the state to try to sell such big-ticket items using the online auction site. Officials had been doing it since at least 2003, three years before Palin became governor.

"It was the practice of the state to dispose of items such as this via eBay prior to listing the jet," Vern Jones, Alaska's Chief Procurement Officer, acknowledged on Tuesday.

Despite being a normal state procedure and, in the end, a costly one, Palin has highlighted her decision to put Alaska's luxury jet on eBay in every speech she has given since being chosen as McCain's vice president. It is a significantly abridged version of what happened.

By the time she was elected, there were many state items being offered on eBay. As the Anchorage Daily News reported on December 13, 2006, nine days after Palin took office and the day she announced the jet posting, the state was "auctioning 38 items on the site, including three aircraft -- two Super Cubs and a Cessna... Other items for sale included two sets of used helicopter floats ($300) and King Air exhaust stacks ($500)."

Back in 2003, the state sold an old ferry, The Bartlett, for $389,500. As Jones noted in a Daily News article at that time, "it [was] not unusual for Alaska to sell big-ticket items on eBay because the site is cheap and has a big audience."

The state jet, in contrast, was not a good fit for eBay. Palin never actually sold the aircraft online (though, unlike John McCain, she never claimed that to be the case). But more important, while the jet sat unsold, Alaska was on the hook to pay $62,492.79 every three months as part of the initial purchasing deal.

In other words, if the state wasn't going to use the aircraft, there was an imperative to get rid of it. And as her administration waited for a bidder to match its minimum offer, those payments added up.

Twenty days after putting the jet online, the Palin administration had to reissue the listing. The minimum bid had not been met. By April, the jet still had not sold despite three additional attempts. Eventually, Palin signed a contract with an Anchorage aircraft broker to help succeed where eBay couldn't. In August 2007, eight months after it was first put on sale, the jet was sold to an Alaskan businessman for $2.1 million -- $600,000 shy of the purchasing price.

"The eBay thing didn't work out very well," Dan Spencer, director of administrative services for the Department of Public Safety (the individual charged with trying to get rid of the plane) told the Anchorage Daily News in April 2007. "I am [tired of dealing with it]," he added. "I don't know about anyone else."

"That luxury jet that came with the office... I put it on eBay!" It's one of Sarah Palin's favorite lines on the campaign trail, repeated with such frequency that it has already become a catchphrase ...
"That luxury jet that came with the office... I put it on eBay!" It's one of Sarah Palin's favorite lines on the campaign trail, repeated with such frequency that it has already become a catchphrase ...
Report Corrections
 
 
  • Comments
  • 654
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (18 total)
07:09 PM on 09/12/2008
I would like to know who the Alaska businessman was who got such a deal at the taxpayers expense!
HMMMMM
09:59 AM on 09/12/2008
Wow... Obama's plagiarized lipstick on a pig quote taken directly from a recent comic strip (including the paragraph before it) isn't a story, but this is?

You really are terrified and desperate, aren't you?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Fudgefase
Boldly going nowhere...
09:48 AM on 09/12/2008
I was going to bid on it but I didn't think it would go in the garage.
The interior shots of the moose antlers, the bearskin rugs and the pilot's chair covered in wolf skin kinda put me off a bit though.
Damn my practical nature! I could have had a real cheap luxury jet!
04:45 PM on 09/11/2008
I am certainly no fan of Sarah Palin but this story doesn't really say much. She never said she sold it on Ebay she says she put it up for sale on Ebay. McCain, with his usual grasp of the details, conflated the story into she sold it on Ebay for a profit! She did present the story as if placing a state item on Ebay to get rid of it is her original idea but she didn't say that specifically. It's no major accomplishment to do what she did. We must remember that one corrupt Republican govenor in Alaska replaced the previous corrupt Republican govenor. She's just as corrupt but she did get rid of the plane. So what!
04:27 PM on 09/11/2008
It seems Republicans are hard-wired to lie and to believe in liars; for example:

JOSEPH McCARTHY, whose actions led to years of fear and repression, black-listing, ruined lives and suicides. His assertions were based on lies, which the Republicans (as well as the ignorant electorate) believed. He was finally outed and died in drunken disgrace.

RICHARD NIXON, who was very early called "Tricky Dick" and whose lies finally led to his impeachment. He was voted in TWICE by a gullible electorate.

George W. Bush, (also voted in TWICE!) whose monumental lies have resulted in thousands of needless deaths, huge deficits after inheriting surpluses, delays in vital programs such as health care and caring for the environment while pampering what he called "his constituency", the millionaires whose incomes have soared while the middle and lower classes have stagnated.

I, the eternal cynic, after living through the above, feel sure the Republicans and ignorant electorate will once more fall for the lies and we will see President McCain and probably President Palin (God save us all!)

What in the world is wrong with Americans that they can be so wrong so much of the time?!
04:08 PM on 09/11/2008
Total fraud, Republican fraud.

See Alaska ebay account stateofalaskasurplus (17).
http://feedback.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewFeedback2&userid=stateofalaskasurplus
Before Palins advertising buddy Meg Whitman has it erased.

First sale Nov-30-03 15:09
Last sale Feb-17-07 14:28

ebay wasn't Palins idea, ebay wasn't Palins choice.

Palin elected Governor Nov-06.
Last sale Feb-17-07 14:28

But Palin Killed ebay flea market sales after she became Governor. A bad image fer Alaska she thought.
02:44 PM on 09/11/2008
wow....

what great investigative reporting..

you have a real watergate here....

thank you so much for enlightening us

Sarah for Prez!
03:40 PM on 09/11/2008
Be careful what you wish for when wishing Sarah as our President.

She has the potential to make Richard Nixon look like a choir boy.
photo
Lemmy
There Are Americans, then there are Liberals . .
01:13 PM on 09/11/2008
And you think this Lipstick debate is petty?
12:45 PM on 09/11/2008
Alaskan luxury jet : "put on E-bay" :: Iraq invasion : "War on Terror"

...the devil is in the details.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Freedoms Friend
11:01 AM on 09/11/2008
I am still waiting to hear what the brokerage fee was on the sale then we would know the true cost of the exercise, anyone?
She did not fire the Chef merely changed the job description! the person still cooked for her kids.
She took a $4000-00 pay cut as Mayor, then hired a Town manager for $60,000-00 to do the job for her, so she got $64,000-00 for doing very little, a net loss to the town of $56,000-00.
She is a fake, and a liar.
You know I love the line above McCain/Palin ticket to nowhere.
Put out the trash someone PLEASE !!
10:45 AM on 09/11/2008
Point is that this is not the first time she's made misleading statements. "Thanks, but no thanks."

No one's missing the point. We'd really just like to know all the points - not just what they want us to hear.

"Keep trying." ? Okay, we get your point. We don't need to know anything about her. Let's just swear her in.

"My house - crazy husband paid too much for it - I put it on eBay!" Funny story, but not very bright. I'd rather have candidates prove to me that they are informed than have to elect a funny story teller who's next in line for the President of our country.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LeaderofMen
Bilingual former US Marine.
10:38 AM on 09/11/2008
Funny, Cindy McCain has assured America that the only way to get around AZ is with a jet.

But Sara Palin thinks her state, which is, what, a 1/3 the size of the lower 48, doesn't need one.

Personally, I think it's safer to get around with a jet in a state that size. But that's a different issue.
05:02 AM on 09/11/2008
You totally missed the point.

If you bothered to listen to the context, her point was that she made a decision to cut costs and luxuries that could not be justified by a Governor. She didn't need a luxury private jet when she could drive a car. She didn't need a private chef when she could make her own meals.

She didn't do anything out of the ordinary as the article says using eBay. She didn't say she was the first person to put government property on sale on eBay. She didn't say she sold it. Most of the people who use eBay know that just because something is put up for auction doesn't mean it will sell.

Even if it had sold for a profit, it would be so small an amount, if would have been irrelevant to the average Alaskan. If you look really close at the speech, you'll see the point was the principle.

Keep trying.

P.S. When was the last time your Governor got you a $1,200 check in the mail. See if you can find that on eBay! :-8
06:19 AM on 09/11/2008
For those who think that the article misses the point, your inability to read between the lines shows just how literal your thinking can be. You can see the issue as her doing her part and trying to be responsible however her decision to sell the jet on ebay shows many things about her ability to govern.

1. She is not a maverick: using ebay to sell items was the way it had ALWAYS been done.

2. It shows that she doesn't understand that different situations call for a change in tactics. Alaska always sells their surplus...sure, a 3,000.00 item here and there, perfectly fine. The question is, did she consult with anyone on the success of selling such big ticket items on ebay?

3. Her understanding of fiscal responsibility is limited. Sure paying a broker would have come with a price, but did she want to make a profit on the plane, or get rid of it. No broker would encourage a seller to take a hit. (Otherwise they wouldn't be brokers for long)

4. True, she does give out hefty checks to Alaska's citizens.. but, It would have been more of a challenge for her to run Alaska with out just taxing the oil companies and really being aware of how to run a state on the citizen tax base alone. By the way Obama has a similar plan to tax the oil companies just like Sarah...hummm
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
littleblackcat
11:35 AM on 09/11/2008
To lucent, and everyone else who misses the point about those $1,200 checks, I believe those checks are the distribution of the "earmarks" out of the pork barrel that ms. palin continued to take AFTER the "bridge to nowhere" was discontinued. Another repuke lie told by her; "I told Congress thanks, but no, thanks" that makes any change of mind by John Kerry look like a blink. And the repus want to yell "FLIP-FLOP" when they make more, and worse, flip-flops than any Dem ever did. We, the lower 48 citizens, are the ones paying for those $1,200 checks!
10:42 AM on 09/11/2008
She doesn't get hero cookies for DOING HER JOB. As in, following ESTABLISHED PROCEDURES.

That's not heroic, it's not taking a principled stand against government waste, it's just following the status quo.

Way to miss the point, li'l lockstepper.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
repubstheirownworstenemy
Looking for honest pols, in all the wrong places.
02:48 AM on 09/11/2008
I just watched the replay of Sarah Palin arriving back home in Alaska. She creeps me out, royally.

She gets off the plane, dutifully greets her family, makes her way to the podium greets her friends and just before she steps to the lecturn looks over sees Trig in Bristol's arms, steps over, leans over, brushes the side of his face leans forward as if she's going to kiss him and air kisses him - stops an inch away from kissing him. Obviously for effect. she sends chills up my spine. Creepy. Anybody else notice?
photo
XME
Life is hard. After all, it kills you.
04:00 AM on 09/11/2008
I didn't see that...but as soon as I heard her convetion speech, she definitely gave me the creeps in a BIG way. She strikes of as one of those Republicans you think of when you imagine the slimiest of the slimy!
05:02 AM on 09/11/2008
She creeps you out. lol! Do you have a problem with mice, too. Spiders?
photo
Harbinger08
You have the right to remain silent
08:52 AM on 09/11/2008
Nope, just snakes. The two-legged kind.
02:03 AM on 09/11/2008
McCain/Palin Ticket to Nowhere