Consumer Spending Crumbles In Lame Economy

digg Share this on Facebook Huffpost - stumble reddit del.ico.us RSS

MARTIN CRUTSINGER | November 14, 2008 07:08 PM EST | AP

Compare other versions »

Chevrolet sales manager Tom Callahan, left, shows Edward Dollard a 2008 Cadillac DTS Wednesday, Nov. 12, 2008, in downtown Los Angeles. Retail sales plunged by the largest amount on record in October as the financial crisis and the slumping economy caused consumers to sharply cut back on their spending. (AP Photo/Ric Francis)

WASHINGTON — The worst monthly drop on record for retail sales set off new alarm bells about the economy Friday, stepping up pressure on policymakers to figure out how to combat what increasingly looks to be a severe recession. Confronting opposition by the Bush administration, Democrats in Congress said they would try next week to pass $25 billion in emergency loans for the auto industry, so wobbly that one or more of Detroit's Big Three could go under.

And the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp., also breaking with the administration, proposed having the government spend $24 billion to back mortgages and help 1.5 million Americans avoid foreclosures.

The policy differences highlighted both the waning power of President George W. Bush and the growing concern about a long and painful recession ahead.

A Commerce Department report showed American consumers in full flight, with retail sales falling a record 2.8 percent in October from September. Plunging auto sales led the way, but there were declines in virtually every spending category.

"Consumers are battening down the hatches and this reflects the depth of the downturn," said Mark Zandi, chief economist at Moody's Economy.com. "All households are panicked and cutting back _ not just lower and middle-income families who are struggling with a bad job market and falling home values, but upper-income families who are upset with their diminished nest eggs."

Wall Street had another day of lurching highs and lows. The Dow Jones industrial average, which was higher for the day as late as 45 minutes before the closing bell, took a nosedive and finished down 338 points, or nearly 4 percent.

As world leaders arrived in Washington for a summit on how to deal with the global economic crisis, Bush urged patience in his weekly radio address, saying "our actions are having an impact."

But with a steady stream of worse-than-expected economic data, Democrats in Congress and regulators at the FDIC are signaling more needs to be done.

Story continues below
advertisement

The Senate will begin debate Monday and hold a test vote two days later to try to break an expected filibuster on a bill that would provide the troubled auto industry $25 billion in new loans, Majority Leader Harry Reid said.

The White House supports speeding the release of $25 billion in existing loans to the Big Three _ General Motors Corp., Ford Motor Co. and Chrysler LLC _ but opposes using part of the $700 billion financial bailout for the automakers.

Meanwhile, the FDIC put forward a proposal that would tap into the $700 million bailout package and use $24 billion to help households avoid foreclosure. The plan would guarantee 2.2 million modified loans _ mainly risky loans made to borrowers with weak credit or small down payments _ through the end of next year.

Borrowers would get reduced interest rates or longer loan terms to make their payments more affordable and banks would receive government guarantees that supporters say will make them more willing to modify the loans.

While supporters say the proposal by FDIC Chairman Sheila Bair is urgently needed in the severe housing downturn, the administration continued to voice opposition. Neel Kashkari, the Treasury official who heads the rescue program, said the bailout was designed as an investment program, while the Bair proposal would involve spending government money outright.

The automakers and homeowners in danger of foreclosure were not the only people seeking assistance. The mayors of three large cities _ Philadelphia, Atlanta and Phoenix _ said Friday that the federal government should use a part of the $700 billion them meet pension costs, make infrastructure investments and deal with severe cash-flow problems stemming from the economic downturn.

Philadelphia's mayor, Michael Nutter, said he wanted to make sure "cities and metro areas are at the table, that their voices are being heard, that our challenges and problems are well understood, so that we can get relief."

President-elect Barack Obama, who takes office Jan. 20, has not proposed or endorsed a specific aid plan, but he has called for some help for states and local governments in hopes they can avoid raising taxes or cutting jobs.

In Frankfurt, Germany, Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke told other central bankers financial markets remained under "severe strain." Sandra Pianalto, the head of the Fed's Cleveland regional bank, was more blunt, saying the incoming data indicated "the economy is in a recession" and "the signs point to a recession beyond just a garden variety downturn."

The economy shrank slightly in the third quarter, and many economists believe the downturn has accelerated since then. Some are forecasting the contraction will continue into mid-2009, which would make it the most serve recession since 1981-82.

In what has become a steady stream of layoff notices, Sun Microsystems Inc. announced Friday that it plans to cut up to 6,000 jobs, or 18 percent of its global work force, reflecting a big slump in sales of its high-end computer servers.

And mortgage giant Freddie Mac said it planned for an initial injection of $13.8 billion of the $200 billion the government set aside to support it and Fannie Mae. Both were seized by the government in September. Freddie Mac posted a loss of $25.3 billion for the third quarter and said it expected to receive the government support by Nov. 29.

Bush and other leaders from the Group of 20 nations, representing the world's richest economies plus major developing nations such as China, Brazil and India, were expected to agree during two days of talks to set up a new "college of supervisors" to oversee the global financial system. The group would include financial regulators from many nations.

Also being discussed was a system to detect financial weaknesses before they erupt into major problems.

Ahead of the gathering, a presidential panel announced plans to strengthen oversight of complex financial instruments partly blamed for the global financial crisis.

___

Associated Press Writers Alan Zibel, Christopher Rugaber, Jim Abrams, Kimberly Hefling, Julie Hirschfeld Davis, Deb Riechmann and Jeannine Aversa contributed to this report.

WASHINGTON — The worst monthly drop on record for retail sales set off new alarm bells about the economy Friday, stepping up pressure on policymakers to figure out how to combat what increasingl...
WASHINGTON — The worst monthly drop on record for retail sales set off new alarm bells about the economy Friday, stepping up pressure on policymakers to figure out how to combat what increasingl...
 
Comments
27
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:

I'm starting a campaign! Everybody. Don't pay your credit card bills for one month! Watch 'em freak!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:42 PM on 11/14/2008

Why should I buy from companies that don't even contribute tot he good of America while they reap its benefits? No sir. This pocketbooks staying shut!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:39 PM on 11/14/2008
photo

It's a start. If we all stopped paying our bills for just one month Washington would give us whatever we demanded but we sheople don't have the guts to fight the thieves.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:07 PM on 11/14/2008

Yes, and we have the nerve to call the French chicken. Hell, we they got rid of a king they got rid of him!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:40 PM on 11/14/2008
photo

They are already freakin' out with the wave of guns sells right after the election. They are starting to get the idea that we might not take this lying down after all.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:37 PM on 11/14/2008

The story here is the fall in the price of gasoline, which is good news for households. Spending excluding gasoline and cars was down half of one percent (-.5%.) The fall in retail sales is the result of falling gasoline prices (just like last year's increase in retail sales was caused by the increase in gasoline prices.) This is good news for household budgets, the cost of energy has fallen to below 6% of spending. Additionally, the fall in sales is not the result of a fall in income but rather is an increase in household savings. So if shipping less of my money to OPEC is bad news then this is bad news. If households shipping less money to OPEC and actually saving/deleveraging is good news then this is good news.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:03 PM on 11/14/2008

OPEC will cut their production soon enough and so will Russia. We will see oil prices climb again. But at least some people got scared enough to start saving a little, even though it's not nearly enough. Savings rate should be 10%, not the anemic 1-2% that it is right now.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:55 PM on 11/14/2008

If the savings rate went up to 10%, we'd see a worldwide depression. Traders are skeptical that some oil producers will actually make the cuts, particularly Russia (and Venezuela). Right now I'd be long big oil companies (especially for the dividend) but not the commodity itself, although it might get a short term jump headed into the peak heating oil season, especially when the first bout of really cold weather comes.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:04 PM on 11/14/2008
- RWG I'm a Fan of RWG permalink

The days of conspicuous consumption are hopefully over. This is the hard lesson many needed to learn to find out you can't live beyond your means forever. We are gluttons and need to go on a serious diet. This crisis will effect many of us directly and all of us indirectly. The realization that we can't just finance our way out of this is humbling and very real.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:57 PM on 11/14/2008
photo

This Just In:
The coal industry reports that they can't keep with demand. there have been a rush on their products. when asked why they say consumers say they have a lot of socks to fill this christmas... stay tuned on this developing story.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:46 PM on 11/14/2008

With the staggering amount of money that was approved for bail-out, why can't gov't give back to the American people who will spend on retail, put it in banks, pay off bills, etc.?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:35 PM on 11/14/2008
photo

Businesses need to take a hard look at middle management positions. These positions need to be eliminated and those managers given the opportunity to work on the line or get out.

All one has to look at is hospitals. There are tons of administrators and mid-level nursing management, but very few people taking care of patients. Make all of the nursing supervisors, educators, etc. go to the bedside and take care of patients. The result, better patient care, cost containment and fewer useless meetings.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:20 PM on 11/14/2008

Did anyone think this was NOT going to happen? Sweet Jeebus, I was at the grocery store the other day and couldn't believe some of the prices. Double of what they were 2-3 years ago. When you pay attention....it's almost scary.

We are certainly living on a tight budget. The organic food prices are just plain out of control, but I still manage to sqeeze them into our budget.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:54 PM on 11/14/2008

If you have to pick between "organic" food and college education for your kids, I hope you are smart enough to go for that college education.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:53 PM on 11/14/2008

You do have to eat, though.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:59 PM on 11/14/2008
photo

They wanted to drive down wages and crush the Unions, so now that's manifest itself with consumers who can barely pay for their essential basics..let alone have money for consumable goods..or saving...

Wages have been stagnant for the middle and working class for over 20 years..

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:46 PM on 11/14/2008

The game is rigged. The rich and powerful seem to win either way. If salaries are high, they will not cut profits but will increase prices - consumers get hurt. If they keep prices low they will cut worker salaries before cutting profit - consumersworkers get hurt. So because of unbridled GREED the consumerworker always get hurt no matter what. We have to support Obama as he puts together policies to shift the balance from the rich and powerful back to the people as was the case during the Clinton years. Remember when companies were willing to do almost anything to hire workers - good pay, perks, etc. Well, they flipped the script and we all suffer.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:07 PM on 11/14/2008
photo

No top line (sales) no bottom line growth, no corporate economic growth.

Trickle down is rubbish and does not work. Business are NOT going to invest in their growth and hire people when nobody is buying anything because they have not disposable income.

How to get more sales? Well, it is not going to happen until the middle class gets some disposable income. You know, spread the wealth around. But the way this needs to happen is by increasing their paychecks. What Henry Ford did to give his workers the money so they could buy his cars.

Management has to give up their fat bonuses, from mid-management upwards, and disburse their profits as salaries. Corporations have to give up some of their quarterly profits so the economy can grow in the long run. I mean, look how good their businesses are doing now (they are not).

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:17 PM on 11/14/2008

Just look at the auto industries, they disregarded the mid 70's gas crisis, they build the pinto, a failure, and loads of opec cruisers, like suv's, or F205's+, on and on without regard to the environment, future oil. Gas guzzlers when the public wanted some mileage and product quality.

Well Toyota got it, somewhat moderate gas efficency, products with longivety, they aced the whole lot and still are and even raised the rate of their product 5%+!

Just where have those quarterly/yearly profits been going? Not infrastructure, not back into the business to grow it, green it, preserve it.

CEO, top management, while squeezing the middle to death!

BONUS
Parachutes
Dividends
Board of Directors spiffs

When they stopped pay for preformance, and mnipulated the numbers for more and more goodies, they ran their companies into the ground with their BOD's help and sleigh of hand.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:04 PM on 11/14/2008

People are saving money because they fear that it is going to get worse from here on. And, as one can see, the personal savings rate is up!

http://www.bea.gov/briefrm/saving.htm

Ideally that number should be 10%, not 1-2%, but as it is, even a slightly positive savings rate it better than a negative one...

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:00 PM on 11/14/2008

How can one save when one does not even make a living wage. Most people live from payday
to payday and having to prioritize their necessities. It is a well known fact that personal income
has shrunk over the last few years, even 8 years. Taxes and everything else went way up.
I hear more layoffs are coming and I fear that pretty soon the government will not even get the
money they had counted on for their budget. So perhaps now they will close the off-shore
loopholes to hide the money of the wealthy.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:33 PM on 11/14/2008

Its time for a one-time wealth tax of say 50% for all individuals and legal tax entities with net assets over $5M. Desperate times call for desperate measures an those who have money sould pony up to help save this country.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:14 PM on 11/14/2008

It is a documented fact that the middle class has made no, make that NO GAINS since the mid 70's!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:56 PM on 11/14/2008

Well, I am saving over 50% of my disposable income. And I managed to save 30% when I made less than one fifth of what I am making now. And if you are a student and have $500 to live on a month, you eat mac and cheese and sandwiches with butter and at the end of three years you have enough money left to buy that computer to write your dissertation on.

Nobody said it's easy or comfy. But you do what you have to to build yourself a cushion, no matter how thin.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:52 PM on 11/14/2008
Comments are closed for this entry

You must be logged in to reply to this comment. Log in  or  Connect