Switzerland Likely To Approve Prescription Heroin

digg Share this on Facebook Huffpost - Switzerland Likely To Approve Prescription Heroin stumble reddit del.ico.us RSS

ELIANE ENGELER | November 28, 2008 10:56 AM EST | AP

I Like ItI Don’t Like It
A placard showing a couple saying "Yes, thanks to the treatment our son could get out of drugs" is among others on display in Geneva, Switzerland, Thursday, Nov. 27, 2008. Switzerland will decide Nov. 30 in a popular vote whether to put a heroin distribution program on a permanent legal footing. (AP Photo/Anja Niedringhaus)

GENEVA — Dr. Daniele Zullino keeps glass bottles full of white powder in a safe in a locked room of his office.

Patients show up each day to receive their treatment in small doses handed through a small window.

Then they gather around a table to shoot up, part of a pioneering Swiss program to curb drug abuse by providing addicts a clean, safe place to take heroin produced by a government-approved laboratory.

The program has been criticized by the United States and the U.N. narcotics board, which said it would fuel drug abuse. But governments as far away as Australia are beginning or considering their own programs modeled on the system, which is credited with reducing crime and improving the health and daily lives of addicts.

Swiss voters are expected to make the system permanent Sunday in a referendum prompted by a challenge from conservatives.

The heroin program has won wide support within Switzerland since it was begun 14 years ago to eliminate scenes of large groups of drug users shooting up openly in parks that marred Swiss cities in the 1980s and 1990s.

Zullino's office, part of the Geneva University Hospitals, is one of 23 such centers in Switzerland.

Patients among the nearly 1,300 addicts whom other therapies have failed to help take doses carefully measured to satisfy their cravings but not enough to cause a big high. Four at a time inject themselves as a nurse watches.

Story continues below
advertisement

In a few minutes most get up and leave. Those who have jobs go back to work.

"Heroin prescription is not an end in itself," said Zullino, adding that the 47 addicts who come to his office receive a series of additional treatments, such as therapy with a psychiatrist and counseling by social workers.

"The aim is that the patients learn how to function in society," he said, adding that after two to three years in the program, one-third of the patients start abstinence-programs and one-third change to methadone treatment.

"Thanks to this policy we don't have open drug scenes anymore," said Andreas Kaesermann, a spokesman for the Social Democrat Party, part of the coalition government.

A mid-November survey of 1,209 voters by the respected gfs.bern institute indicate the program will be easily approved, with 63 percent of voters favoring it compared with 21 opposed. The poll had a margin of error of 2.9 percentage points.

Health insurance pays for the bulk of the program, which costs 26 million Swiss francs ($22 million) a year. All residents in Switzerland are required to have health insurance, with the government paying insurance premiums for those who cannot afford it.

"It's wrong that the health insurance pays for this," said Alain Hauert, spokesman for the right-wing Swiss People's Party. He said the state should invest more money into prevention and law enforcement.

Crimes committed by heroin addicts have dropped 60 percent since the program began in 1994, according to the Federal Office of Public Health says.

And, Zullino said, patients reduce consumption of other narcotics once they start the heroin program and suffer less from psychiatric disorders.

But, he added, "the idea has never been to liberalize heroin. It's considered a medicine and used as such."

GENEVA — Dr. Daniele Zullino keeps glass bottles full of white powder in a safe in a locked room of his office. Patients show up each day to receive their treatment in small doses handed throug...
GENEVA — Dr. Daniele Zullino keeps glass bottles full of white powder in a safe in a locked room of his office. Patients show up each day to receive their treatment in small doses handed throug...
Filed by Nick Sabloff  |  Report Corrections
 
Comments
147
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 Next › Last » (5 pages total)
- kfdan I'm a Fan of kfdan 21 fans permalink
photo

In many respects, Europe is far ahead of the US in it's drug addiction programs! If Marijuana were legal a hugh tax windfall would exist, if heroin programs were in place a large part of addict crimes would fall, and nearly half of state and federal prison populations would disappear! "The program has been criticized by the United States and the U.N. narcotics board, which said it would fuel drug abuse. ... " This is pure fantasy and is not supported by facts or experiences in countries with such programs!!!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:12 PM on 11/29/2008

Drug addiction is a medical issue not a criminal issue. Repeat that 5 times every day, US government.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:37 PM on 11/29/2008
- YeahDonkey I'm a Fan of YeahDonkey 7 fans permalink
photo

Why not the United States? Cause when you treat your citizens like moronic children, you get citizens that act like moronic children.

and of course there is no money in helping addicts. only putting them away

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:35 PM on 11/29/2008
photo

The Taliban will be outraged.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:26 PM on 11/29/2008
- flydoghead I'm a Fan of flydoghead 32 fans permalink
photo

This could never happen in American, there is too much money to be made "fighting drugs" and
building prisons.

The two groups that benefit from the drug scourge, the criminal/drug dealers and the law enforcement industry which has a symbiotic relationship with them will never allow such a solution in the U.S.A.

If we managed the drug problem what would there be to fight ?

This is big business.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:54 PM on 11/29/2008
- bartonfink I'm a Fan of bartonfink 33 fans permalink
photo

of course the u.s. decries the swiss program, there isn't any punishment involved.

our drug policies fail wholesale at every level. it is a national embarrassment, with thousands imprisoned for nonviolent drug crimes. it is a deplorable situation.

time for some change we can believe in

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:38 PM on 11/29/2008
- onalimb I'm a Fan of onalimb 5 fans permalink

Interesting. Legalization of drugs is far off in this country but I think it is the way to go.
Legalize them, control them, tax them - eliminate crime and provide $$$.
Big problem here is DEA & others making too much from it being illegal.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:03 PM on 11/29/2008
- poochytown I'm a Fan of poochytown 18 fans permalink

I've never used heroin and, God willing, never will; but I sure like the idea of a government that says "Some of our citizens have a drug problem and we need to try to help them" instead of "Some of our citizens are drug-addicted low-life scum who deserved to be punished."

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:17 PM on 11/29/2008

... and those who call for punishment are buying prescription drugs illegally in back alleys themselves!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:40 PM on 11/29/2008
- zizyphus I'm a Fan of zizyphus 107 fans permalink
photo

Good news. Heroin is addictive, surely, but so are alcohol, nicotine, anti-depressants, thyroid drugs, laxatives, etc. Does that mean that those things are all evil, and the people who use them miscreants? No, I don't think so.

There is a minority of people in the world who simply never feel happy, no matter how good life is, because their neuroreceptor sites for the molecules that give pleasure are somehow too few, or don't function properly. They can live productive lives given opiates.

I find that the prejudice against drugs that provide even a modicum of pleasure and relief is all out of proportion to the dangers of these drugs.

Methadone is much harder to quit, and more damaging than heroin. In fact, common anti-depressant drugs are quite addictive, and sudden cessation leads to suicide and sometimes murderous rages. The big drug companies don't want you to know that though. 300 million prescriptions for them written last year? In times past, melancholia was treated with opium.

The propaganda from the "war on drugs' has brainwashed the average citizen into thinking that all illegal are horrible, bad, dangerous, when in fact the destruction caused by prescription drugs is far worse.

It is past time to stop punishing people for trying to feel better by using drugs. People should also be allowed to grow their own poppies, and make the old-fashioned poppy tea our great-great-great grandmas used to make.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:15 PM on 11/29/2008

I agree with the overall tone of your post, god knows I know the misery of drug addiction first hand. However, I wanted to point out a serious error in your post, and one that many seem to make.
the medical phenomenon of physiological chemical dependence -- that which leads to physical and psychological withdrawal symptoms when the regular usage of a drug is abruptly discontinued -- is indeed related to psychological addiction, BUT THE TWO ARE NOT EQUIVALENT.
Dependence and the subsequent widthdrawl symptopms present after the cessation of drug use is seen with many different types of substances, from heart arrhythmia medication to blood-pressure medication to anti-depressents to addictive drugs like cocain, methyl-amphetamine, and Opiates. Most commonly, the physiological symptoms of withdrawal from a substance manifest themselves as an opposite effect of the clinical effect that the drug was used to provide; The withdrawl effect of medication used to lower blood pressure will be to increase blood pressure and so on. The stimulation and euphoria of Cocaine will turn into dysphoria, depression, and lethargy.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:07 PM on 11/29/2008

(part 2)
Although avoiding the symptoms caused by drug withdrawl can certainly be an incentive for an individual to continue using drugs, it is wholly separate from "addiction". Drug addiction, on the other hand, refers to the psychological and emotional condition that fuels cravings and leads an addict to continue to pursue drugs despite their understanding of the consequences and even their desire to stop. This is why alcoholics, heroin addicts and even smokers will continually revert back to using their substance *LONG AFTER* their withdrawl symptoms have faded from their last attempt to get sober.

I don't want to generalize too much, but most functioning addicts that have or had "normal" lives as functioning citizens have no desire to continue the terrible situations they find themselves in. They wholly understand their problem. They are full conscious and aware of the destruction they have created in their lives and the lives of their friends and families. Although they certainly do their best to suppress their feelings, they do in fact have an intact conscience and really do wish to stop the behavior and turn their lives around. The know the pain they cause for themselves and everyone around them only grows larger.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:08 PM on 11/29/2008

(part 3)
Their irrational, self-destructive behavior that leads to the perpetual cycle of craving and relapse is thought to be primarily caused by physiological changes that occur in the brain over the development of addiction. Many addicts feel an almost otherwordly psychological dichotomy that gets created in the psyche of the addict whereby on the one hand they feel the intense shame and remorse for their illogical behavior and the pain they have caused to so many, and yet at the same time they feel completely and utterly powerless to stop. It is not simply a matter of having a lack of will or courage to stop using and face their emotional problems, they actually have a psychological disease. This does not remove individual responsibility for an addict's behavior, but this point is important and needs to be acknowledged when discussing drug addiction and treatment. treatment.

Addiction needs to be understood and solutions crafted within the context of addiction as a social health problem -- particularly when discussing and implementing future policy decisions. Unfortunately, many countries including the United States still treat drug addiction as a criminal issue and not as a health and social one. The decades old policy of simply rotating addicts through prison and the criminal justice system has gotten us nowere and has only exacerbated the problem. Because of the nature of the condition, you cannot "scare" addicts out of using drugs with threats of prison sentences.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:09 PM on 11/29/2008

(part 4)
It has no longer become just a conscious decision of do I stay sober or do I continue to use. Their problem has become a psychological condition with real physiological effects in the brain, and they need psychiatric, emotional, and potentially medicinal assistance in order to overcome their condition and return to a normal life. We need to provide the help these people need. Not only it is morally correct and the to do so and really the only pragmatic solution to such a devestating societal problem, it is actually much cheaper in the long run. Just imagine the total financial consequences of our current drug policy. Think of the billions spent each year on widescale law enforcement, the DEA, thousands of prisons and jails, in addition to all the drug addiction related crime. Not to even mention the enormity of the gang and organized crime situation which is able to sustain itself through illegal drug distribution. I'd bet we could at least halve or more the costs to society over 10 years with a new plan that emphasizes prevention and treatment, including drug counseling, therapy, psychiatry, etc and a reform of existing drug laws.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:09 PM on 11/29/2008

Leaglizing marijuana would accomplish so much in this country. Thing of the tax benifit alone. If everyone in the process makes money on a $4 pack of cigarettes, thing of the tax potential of a $20 pack of cannibis. $5 for the Fed, $5 for the State, $3 for the County, $2 for the City. That leaves $5 for the grower, processer, packager, shipper, and outlet-(preferably a State liquor store with a minimum age requirement of 18). As I said before, if there is profit for all the parties involved in cigarettes at $4 (and how much of that $4 is taxes?), the that last $5 in cannibis should make it a popular market to explore. Phillip-Morris. RJR, and co. would gladly shift their production over. Anything to maka a buck. And yes, I have heard the arguement that no company would make money because people would grow their own. I say HA. People can grow their own vegetables too, but they choose the convience of buying them at the store. Be honest, will the majority of the stoners really go to the trouble to "grow their own"? I don't think so. Anyway, it's just a thought.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:58 AM on 11/29/2008
- zizyphus I'm a Fan of zizyphus 107 fans permalink
photo

You are absolutely right. The only reason pot is illegal is that people in our government profit more from it being illegal. Tons of it come across the borders from both sides and even with the prodigious efforts of our own US growers, the demand for pot is never met. Someone in government is being paid off, to get these millions of tons of pot across the borders.

In fact, the FBI gave the CIA carte blanche to deal drugs, so it may be that the CIA is making the most money off it. Who knows? All I know is, pot is safer than alcohol and tobacco, and people should be able to grow their own. We should be able to sell it at farmer's markets, and compete to grow the best buds. But then the gangsters wouldn't be able to kill over the marketing of it. And the prison industry would suffer. And thousands of families wouldn't be broken up. And the US would save billions of dollars, better spent on education.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:37 PM on 11/29/2008
- onalimb I'm a Fan of onalimb 5 fans permalink

Nail on the head.
Legalize it, tax it, control it eliminate loads of crime & bring in tons of $$$.
Unfortunate that DEA & otheres would n ot profit from this so not likely tohappen anytime soon here.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:22 PM on 11/29/2008
- elgrande I'm a Fan of elgrande 4 fans permalink

From what I've read, tobacco is much more costly to grow than cannabis. A pack of marijuana cigarettes should cost no more than a pack of tobacco cigarettes, taxes included. I'm sure there will be pricier premium varieties, like fine wines, but reasonably good pot should be quite inexpensive.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:17 PM on 11/29/2008
- slaxx I'm a Fan of slaxx 37 fans permalink
photo

another thing is that marijuana is the least dangerous drug, even less so than alochol. it's non-addictive, you can still drive while high, and it doesn't cause violence and all of the other bad behaviors associated with alcochol.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:29 PM on 11/29/2008
- tomas0808 I'm a Fan of tomas0808 8 fans permalink

This is a perfect example of how European governments (minus France, which is becoming more like us) are at least willing to try to do things to bring EVERYONE into society instead of kicking some into the ditch and ripping off the rest

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:40 AM on 11/29/2008
- yappnmutt I'm a Fan of yappnmutt 70 fans permalink

as the article states the problem is not heroin. the problem are the poor heroin addicts who will steal to get their fix. heroin addicts with money are only a danger to themselves mostly but the ones who can control themselves are fully functional. this is a great program.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:24 AM on 11/29/2008

Hey, I'm Swiss and this surprised me. They may conservative but sometimes the Swiss produce a gem of an idea; it is after all, the home of the Red Cross.Inst­ead of shaming the addict, forcing him/her to hide the addiction, this is a long term,progressive idea provided the therapy works and the addict's willing.Ku­dos.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:23 AM on 11/29/2008

I like how the story describes medical heroin and its uses, and the little picture Huffington shows is that of a brick of street heroin. LOL! XD

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:04 AM on 11/29/2008

I wish the Swiss the best with that, but they have a lower crime rate than we have here in the U.S. this program would not work here

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:50 AM on 11/29/2008
- poochytown I'm a Fan of poochytown 18 fans permalink

Are you kidding? It's the illegality of hard drugs that drives junkies to steal here.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:18 PM on 11/29/2008
- zizyphus I'm a Fan of zizyphus 107 fans permalink
photo

Wrong. It would work here. We need rehab, and prescription heroin. That would pretty much kill the illegal heroin market.

In fact, I want rehab center for nicotine addicts. (Whoever has the bucks to get that one going is going to become a millionair­e.) Cigarette rehab centers would keep smokers in a nice place for week or two and let them detox away from cigs.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:44 PM on 11/29/2008

The States is such a vast country, Switzerland pretty small geographically ergo easier to monitor with natural frontiers.­We also have a pretty omnipresent well paid police force(too present for some)but we can walk the streets at night.The Stats however have many wonderful things such as strong community and freedom of speech without being judged as a kook.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:54 PM on 11/29/2008
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 Next › Last » (5 pages total)
Comments are closed for this entry

 You must be logged in to comment. Log in  or connect with 

Connect