Muntadhar al-Zeidi: Who Is The Bush Shoe-Thrower?

digg Share this on Facebook Huffpost - stumble reddit del.ico.us RSS

Huffington Post   |  Hanna Ingber Win   |   December 15, 2008 11:29 AM


An Iraqi journalist who threw his shoe at President Bush has been hailed as a hero across the Middle East, and is receiving so much attention Wikipedia already has an entry for him.

Update:

Watch this video from Link TV of Iraqis demonstrating in Sadr City in support of the journalist, Muntadhar al-Zeidi. One passerby gives out candy and says: "Here are sweets to celebrate the shoe thrown at Bush."

From earlier on Monday:

Reuters reports that Muntadhar al-Zeidi will be given an award by a Libyan charity group called Wa Attassimou.

"Waatassimou group has taken the decision to give Muntazer al-Zaidi the courage award ... because what he did represents a victory for human rights across the world," the group, headed by Aicha Gaddafi, said in a statement.


The group said the Iraqi authorities should honour the journalist for his actions.

Zaidi, accused by the Iraqi government of a "barbaric and ignominious act" will be tried on charges of insulting the Iraqi state, said the Iraqi prime minister's media advisor, Yasin Majeed.

Story continues below
advertisement

The AP reports that thousands took to the streets Monday to demand his release from jail.

Journalist Muntadhar al-Zeidi, who was kidnapped by militants last year, was being held by Iraqi security Monday and interrogated about whether anybody paid him to throw his shoes at Bush during a press conference the previous day in Baghdad, said an Iraqi official.


He was also being tested for alcohol and drugs, and his shoes were being held as evidence, said the official, speaking on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to talk to the media.

Showing the sole of your shoe to someone in the Arab world is a sign of extreme disrespect, and throwing your shoes is even worse. Iraqis whacked a statue of Saddam with their shoes after U.S. Marines toppled it to the ground following the 2003 invasion.

Al Jazeera reports that the journalist's employer, Al-Baghdadiya television, has demanded his release as well. Zeidi faces a minimum of two years in prison if he is convicted of insulting a visiting head of state, according to the report.

On Monday, al-Baghdadiya suspended its normal programming and played messages of support from across the Arab world.


A presenter read out a statement calling for his release, "in accordance with the democratic era and the freedom of expression that Iraqis were promised by US authorities".

It said that any harsh measures taken against the reporter would be reminders of the "dictatorial era" that Washington said its forces had invaded Iraq to end.

But the New York Times reports that despite the widespread protests in support of al-Zeidi, not all Iraqis view him as a hero.

His action ran counter to deeply held Iraqi traditions of hospitality toward guests, even if they are enemies. Those who have cooperated with or welcomed the American presence in Iraq were more apt to side with the government in their condemnation.


Ahmad Abu Risha, the leader of the Awakening Council in Anbar Province, a group of local tribal leaders that started a wave of popular opposition against Al Qaeda fighters in Iraq, said that he Mr. Zaidi's actions were inappropriate "because the American president is the guest of all Iraqis. The Iraqi government has to choose good journalists to attend such conferences."

"This is unsuitable action by an Iraqi journalist," said Kamal Wahbi, a 49-year-old engineer in the Kurdish city of Sulaimaniya, where pro-American sentiment is strong. "His action served terrorism and radical national extremism. I think he could send the same message by asking Bush embarrassing questions."

Al Jazeera also reports that Saddam Hussein's former lawyer, Khalil al-Dulaimi, is organizing a team to defend Zeidi.

"It was the least thing for an Iraqi to do to Bush, the tyrant criminal who has killed two million people in Iraq and Afghanistan," he said.


"Our defence of Zaidi will be based on the fact that the United States is occupying Iraq, and resistance is legitimate by all means, including shoes."

The AP reports that al-Zeidi's family members expressed bewilderment and pride over their brother's defiance of Bush.

"I swear to Allah, he is a hero," said his sister, who goes by the nickname Umm Firas, as she watched a replay of her brother's attack on an Arabic satellite station. "May Allah protect him."


The family insisted that al-Zeidi's action was spontaneous -- perhaps motivated by the political turmoil that their brother had reported on, plus his personal brushes with violence and the threat of death that millions of Iraqis face daily.

The New York Times Baghdad Bureau Blog quotes al-Zeidi's brother as saying that he hated the American occupation of Iraq so much he was willing to cancel his wedding over it.

Maythem al-Zaidi said his brother had not planned to throw his shoes prior to Sunday. "He was provoked when Mr. Bush said [during the news conference] this is his farewell gift to the Iraqi people," he said. A colleague of Muntader al-Zaidi's at al-Baghdadiya satellite channel, however, said the correspondent had been "planning for this from a long time. He told me that his dream is to hit Bush with shoes," said the man, who would not give his name.


Muntader al-Zaidi appears to have a long-standing dislike of the United States presence in Iraq. He used to finish his reports by saying he was in "the occupied Baghdad." His brother said that he hates the occupation so strongly that he canceled his wedding, saying: "I will marry when the occupation is over."

The AP also reports that al-Zeidi was kidnapped by gunmen while on assignment as a journalist in a Sunni district of Baghdad. he was also arrested by American soldiers. Al-Zeidi is a 28-year-old unmarried Shiite.

He was freed unharmed three days later after Iraqi television stations broadcast appeals for his release. At the time, al-Zeidi told reporters he did not know who kidnapped him or why, but his family blamed al-Qaida and said no ransom was paid.


In January he was taken again, this time arrested by American soldiers who searched his apartment building, his brother, Dhirgham, said. He was released the next day with an apology, the brother said.

Those experiences helped mould a deep resentment of both the U.S. military's presence here and Iran's pervasive influence over Iraq's cleric-dominated Shiite community, according to his family.

"He hates the American material occupation as much as he hates the Iranian moral occupation," Dhirgham said. "As for Iran, he considers the regime as the other side of the American coin."


 
Comments
1559
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Next › Last » (36 pages total)

January 19.
I imagine thousands of people gathering at the White House fence and throwing their shoes at the White House.
Thousands.
Some carrying placards proclaiming solidarity with Muntazer al-Zeidi, demanding his release, etc.
I fear that al Zeidi will be whacked in the middle of the night regardless of his legal standing. I wish that I had the courage to do as he did.
Peace,

Bill

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:19 PM on 12/21/2008

There can be a lot of finger pointing over who is responsible for the war ... no one with any intelligence could really believe it was enacted because of one person ... but with that subject aside ... this journalist knew what he was getting into ... if he has to pay the price then so be it ... look at the outrage it has caused ... he knew that ... that's why he did it ... he wanted to play the martyr ... now it's time for him to be the martyr ... he didn't just throw his shoe at the President of the United States ... he also hit my flag ... he insulted every American ... and I am appalled at his deliberate action ...

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:52 PM on 12/18/2008

No, he did not insult me as an American. In fact I agree with the overall sentiment but not the actual action.

I agree, it was not a respectable thing to do and in fact a violent action, but it certainly reflects the sentiment of not only many Iraqis but also of many Americans like myself. Martyrdom has nothing to do with it. Here in the States we would throw a tomato. Really not that big of a deal.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:38 AM on 12/19/2008

if you think throwing a tomato is no big deal ... if someone threw a tomato at the inauguration in January at the "President of the United States" ... I bet it would be a big deal ... in fact a giant deal ... and I would be insulted ... as should every American ...

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:44 PM on 12/19/2008
- haramagoti I'm a Fan of haramagoti 12 fans permalink
photo

He should be made an honorary American, though he wouldn't accept. Bush Corp. destroys his country beyond repair and the man's miss with a thrown pair of shoes with the "Democracy" we've regime-changed into place will give him 15 years internment on top of the physical abuse he's already received? Sounds like Bush's interpretation of Democracy alright. How can a Democracy be planted into a culture and country, granted having done so illegally, by those who have no notion whatsoever of what Democracy in fact is nor what it represents? Bush's spoken definitions of Democracy have always fallen short, let alone how his actions have befitted direct opposition to Democracy's principles. Somehow this "man", better beast, made it through the political gauntlet without understanding a single thing about the country he was presuming to represent. A continuing indictment, regarding Bush Corp., of the lack of Republican naysayers and those Democrats whose military-industrial and oil investments or associated paybacks, trumped their resolve in representing the Democracy that put them in power to safeguard that Democracy against the corruption they ended up aligning themselves with.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:25 PM on 12/18/2008
- bbrecht I'm a Fan of bbrecht 20 fans permalink
photo

It's probably true that Hussein would have killed the man, but that doesn't make beating him in prison any less wrong. Bush should prove that he is better than Hussein and order that the man be released.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:41 AM on 12/18/2008

As much as I dislike (and that's a mild word for my feelings towards our still President), and as much as I admit to a certain amount of Schadenfreude: This went too far.

The Iraqi journalist knew that he was throwing shoes at the President of a sovereign power, whether he likes the US or not ( and I do understand with all my heart that he doesn't). Part of me thinks: "well done. Bush deserves this insult", but the other part says: "NO! you cannot be allowed to do this and expect to get away "scotsfree" You attacked the President of the USA. Had you tried to do this to your own Head of State, you would be punished too.

I do object, however, to the brutality of the Iraqis. You want and need to show the world that though this act was an embarrassment to your regime, you are a Democracy (?) where people have the right to a trial without being physically or mentally tortured (not that we set such a stellar example ourselves with Gitmo and renditions).

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:08 PM on 12/17/2008

I respect your words of truth.
Here are some more truths-
George Bush W. is responsible for the murders of about 1 million innocent Iraqi's.

If Some other country invaded America and killed 1 million of my fellow countrymen I think I would throw the shoe after I take off their head.

And Bush is going to get away with it, but you think the shoe thrower should pay.

I am not a Muslem or Christian or any other religion, but I see the truth and so do you.

" He is a HERO!"

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:55 PM on 12/18/2008
- cjgnew I'm a Fan of cjgnew 6 fans permalink

This is a misdemeanor and should be treated as such. In a democracy, we cannot tolerate anyone throwing shoes at a foreign state simply because an individual dislikes him or disagrees with him (him includes her). He could have written an op-ed to express his feelings towards Bush, and that would have been fine. But throwing his shoe at him is a different story. Those who detest Bush on this site will probably condone this act, but I wonder how would they feel if one of those racists in the U.S. decided to imitate this fellow and threw his shoe at Obama. Just as I would have condemned such an act against Obama, I also reject and denounce such an act towards President Bush. Therefore, the Rule of Law must prevail. The journalist broke the law, and he should face the consequences. Having said that, Bush's life was not in danger. Six months in jail should be just about right in my opinion.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:20 PM on 12/17/2008
- kepary I'm a Fan of kepary 6 fans permalink

assualting the President of the United States is a misdemeanor?????

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:45 PM on 12/17/2008
- cjgnew I'm a Fan of cjgnew 6 fans permalink

The penalty has to fit the crime. I think if the judiciary were to overreact in that regard, that would only make the journalist a cause celèbre in the Arab world, which would only encourage others to do it so that they would get their 15-minute of fame. Had this journalist done this to Saddam, he probably would have been shot on the spot without even a trial. In the context that these folks have had very little experience with what is allowed in a democracy, I propose leniency, for that and the difference in culture should be taken into account. But I could be wrong.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:43 PM on 12/17/2008
- FZliveson I'm a Fan of FZliveson 89 fans permalink
photo

The movie "Wag the Dog" with Dustin Hoffman tells many truths about what we
have witnessed in the last 8 years. Watch it.
Here is a clip, a bit long, but full of wisdom.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-gHOhiRZCM

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:02 PM on 12/17/2008
photo

When you throw shoes at the leader of a country who invaded your sovereign country illegally, killing thousands of innocents along the way, you should be allowed to plead self defence.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:28 AM on 12/17/2008
photo

I do think that if Saddam Hussein was still in charge, this man would already be dead. But what I really want to say is that if I were king for a day, I would start a massive C-5 airlift today, bringing all our troops home from all our bases. Let Europe, the middle east, and Asia fend for themselves. Why do we always need to be there?
Since the Korean war, I've seen too many American soldiers come home in boxes, and for what? Next time you see a National cemetery, walk in, sit down and ask why ! How many of those poor souls died defending some other country.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:16 AM on 12/17/2008
- MCpiano I'm a Fan of MCpiano 2 fans permalink

Had he thrown a shoe at Saddam, he would have been executed.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:06 AM on 12/17/2008
photo

It was assault.
You don't change rule of law just because you don't like W. Bush.

Your right to swing your fist in Free Speech ends just before it comes in contact with my nose.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:39 AM on 12/17/2008
- medici I'm a Fan of medici 11 fans permalink

Try watching the tape. There was no contact.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:43 PM on 12/17/2008
- bavb63 I'm a Fan of bavb63 4 fans permalink
photo

Fabulous "Democracy" we've installed over there!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:27 AM on 12/17/2008
- balrog221 I'm a Fan of balrog221 35 fans permalink
photo

I opposed the action in Iraq, but when W made that reality, there was an opportunity for Iraq to benefit from US goodwill and to create something positive. Most of us hoped for a new beginning for Iraq after the Bathists were removed, and billions could have been spent on the reconstruction of the country instead of costly and destructive military deployment.

The formula for that is being deployed now 5 years later and it involves the Iraqis political will as well as the US military.

Okay so the question was not one of winning the war. Mission Accomplished and so forth. The question was as usual winning the peace. Clearly Bush totally bungled that. Instead of a surge in 2003 to secure the positive aspects of society, he allowed the country to dissemble. Factions to polarize and arm etc.

Now the opportunity is again at hand and the actions of that "reporter" were not productive in tthat they alienate the american public... that is not the enemy of Iraq, and that presents the best hope for Iraq.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:25 AM on 12/17/2008

Being a reported he should know that the pen is mighter than the shoe!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:06 AM on 12/17/2008
- Yalegirl03 I'm a Fan of Yalegirl03 6 fans permalink

At most throwing shoes is assault. I think 7 years in prison is very harsh. Can't they fine him or just give him 1 year as a slap on the wrist? Eventhough I considered naming my first born male child after Al-Zaidi when I heard about the shoe throwing, he did break the law by throwing his shoes at a dignitary . But, if he was beaten after the shoe throwing like his injuries suggest, I think he should be set free and those who beat him should be charged. If I was one of those guards I would have given him a high five rather than a beating.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:55 AM on 12/17/2008
- medici I'm a Fan of medici 11 fans permalink

I think you are quite right. It was assault but not battery (since dubya dodged the shoes as well as he dodged the Vietnam war).

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:45 PM on 12/17/2008
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Next › Last » (36 pages total)
Comments are closed for this entry

 You must be logged in to comment. Log in  or connect with 

Connect