Tennessee Sludge Spill Community's Future Clouded (SLIDESHOW)

digg Share this on Facebook Huffpost - stumble reddit del.ico.us RSS

AP   |  BETH RUCKER   |   January 1, 2009 10:50 PM

I Like ItI Don’t Like It

HARRIMAN, Tenn. -- Tom Grizzard wonders what the future holds for a spot that once seemed the perfect place to live. His pastoral enclave boasted vistas of tree-covered hills, glimpses of the Emory River and access to fishing holes and hunting havens.

"We like it here. I'd like to die here," Grizzard said of the Swan Pond area he's called home for more than five decades.

Now much of it is shrouded in sludge after a billion gallons of coal ash spilled from a retention pond at a Tennessee Valley Authority power plant last week.

Three homes were destroyed and 42 parcels of land were damaged. The 200 acres Grizzard and his relatives own weren't soiled, but he's worried Swan Pond will be dealing with fallout from the disaster for a long time.

Photos by Antrim Caskey


Since the Kingston Steam Plant was built in 1955, the area's farmland has slowly been converted to smaller lots with large two-story brick homes interspersed with modest ranch and split-level homes and some mobile homes. All have a view of the plant's 1,000-foot-tall smokestacks across the river.

Some of the first residents in the area were workers at the plant. Most of the people who work there now are contractors from outside the area.

Grizzard and his two sons, Mike and Tom, spend a lot of time hunting and fishing on their land along the river, often right near the TVA plant.

Story continues below
advertisement

"Those two slews that were very drastically filled with the fly ash were two of the best crappie fishing holes," he said. "Especially in the spring, there will be as many as 20 people down there fishing every day."

Grizzard shot his first two geese near the plant in 1961. He retrieved one of them from the ash pile that would eventually become the pond that burst.

He couldn't get to the ash pile now if he tried. The main road into the neighborhood is blocked after being covered in sludge. Police are stationed at various points along the road to make sure only officials get through. Swan Pond residents must take back roads and school buses will have to be rerouted.

A massive cleanup effort has begun, but no one knows how long it could take because there's never been an ash spill this large in the United States. It's unclear whether the arsenic and heavy metals in the fly ash threaten the water, air and soil. It's also unclear how much exposure to the toxic elements could threaten people's health.

No one thinks recovery will be quick.

Larry Preece's property near Inez, Ky., was swamped with coal ash sludge eight years ago in a similar spill of more than 300 million gallons. He has some advice for Swan Pond residents: "Be prepared for a long ordeal."

Despite a cleanup and the passing of years, Preece said he still worries about contamination. Traces of arsenic, mercury and other contaminants were found in the Kentucky sludge, according to the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, based at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in Atlanta.

A year after that spill, all visible signs of coal waste had been removed and lush vegetation had again sprouted. But Preece said soil beneath the carpet of newly planted grass is still speckled with black particles.

Like state and federal environmental officials, Grizzard is concerned about the fly ash drying out, becoming airborne and blowing to Tennessee home sites not initially affected by the sludge.

With that uncertainty, residents are worried about the value of their homes and land.

Grizzard said he heard a neighbor's relative was trying to sell his summer home nearby for around $400,000. Now, he said, that homeowner thinks he'll be lucky to get $100,000.

The TVA has promised to get real estate agents for the displaced residents and find them housing for as long as needed.

The two families whose homes received the most damage _ Janice and James Perry and Crystell Flinn and James Schean _ told Gov. Phil Bredesen after he toured the spill site on Wednesday that they loved the neighborhood so much they didn't want to relocate.

The Grizzards also aren't willing to leave the land once owned by Tom's grandfather.

Tom's son Mike trekked into the ashen muck Tuesday to do some hunting. He returned just before lunchtime without any game, deciding not to shoot three does he spied.

"It's a great spot," he said. "I love it here. It's always been home."

HARRIMAN, Tenn. -- Tom Grizzard wonders what the future holds for a spot that once seemed the perfect place to live. His pastoral enclave boasted vistas of tree-covered hills, glimpses of the Emory Ri...
HARRIMAN, Tenn. -- Tom Grizzard wonders what the future holds for a spot that once seemed the perfect place to live. His pastoral enclave boasted vistas of tree-covered hills, glimpses of the Emory Ri...
 
Comments
58
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: 1 2 3 Next › Last » (3 pages total)

I live in TN and this is a huge and very very sad tragedy created by greed and incompetence. You see in the news where billionaires have put themselves in front of trains due to losing their fortune. Yet we have collectively lost so much more. If I were party to this in any way the train would be looking good to me right about now. That is a big difference between me, and those who are not only incompetent but willfully unrepentant.

However, we could do better and educate more powerfully if we required all Republican hacks and supporters to live in the areas of disastrous environmental toxic waste. They want to drill baby drill, ensure the drill is in their living room, the sludge is in their drinking and bathing water and their most treasured pets are consuming only imported food from China.

This takes a show me approach to the issue. Show me how right you are by walking eating living and breathing your blather! When an anti-environmentalist starts taking a bath in the morning in sludge and showing me how healthy and happy they are, then I will begin to take notice. Prior to that, the fact that they are not, but are gleefully ignorant and gleefully uncaring of those who now must, makes these people rather doomed if Karma, the Christian hell or any other after-life punishment has validity.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:08 AM on 01/07/2009
- eus I'm a Fan of eus permalink

Was this "real America"? Drill baby, drill...

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:26 PM on 01/05/2009

Yet, these regions continue to vote pro-republican, pro-deregulation and pro-coal power and they will coninue to do so as they wade waste deep in toxic sludge on their way to the voting booths.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:55 PM on 01/05/2009
photo

Another shining example of industry self-regulating.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:10 PM on 01/05/2009

I am so saddened by this spill but it was bound to happen given the lack of accountability big energy companies have for poisoning the environment. What I find so frustrating is the seeming disconnect between southerners who claim to love wildlife and their rural land and their support of candidates who are so determined to ruin this beautiful area of the country.

Having been born and raised in the south I understand the history of poverty, lack of education and oppression contributing to southerners having some of the most dangerous, and polluting industries. Yet being of Scots- Irish heritage myself, I think the stubborness of southerners and their reluctance to change are a far more compelling explanations of the current dismal conditions. Stubborness, inability to admit one is wrong and change course and a disinterest in prevention and oversight are all negative characteristics of the Scots-Irish character that have prevented southerners from voting in their own interests. Add into that a traditional contempt for government intervention, and you have a classic recipe for environmental exploitation.

I know this is a somewhat simplified view, but this forum dictates some necessity for brevity. Other thoughts?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:02 PM on 01/04/2009
photo

Oh yeah and the drinking water isn't contaminated... ever heard of seepage!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:12 AM on 01/04/2009

mmm, it's the new gop kool aid!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:10 AM on 01/04/2009

This is the TVA not a private for profit company, but a politician run public enterprise.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:55 PM on 01/03/2009

This better be somebody's @ss on this one. Corker, I want answers now. Volunteer voters...start wiseing up now.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:38 PM on 01/03/2009

The company found a solution for their over-filled ash pond but for the rest of us the problem will eventually run down the Mississippi to the Gulf of Mexico.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:27 PM on 01/03/2009

Clean coal?

EPA?

Clean water?

MONEY.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:15 PM on 01/03/2009

Here is what I would like to know. Previous articles said that Thallium was found near the area of the "spill". This is a hideously dangerous chemical and is required to be reported to the EPA in the Toxic Release Inventory.

Yet, when I look at the 2006 (latest available) report for this facility 37763STVKNSWANP there are no releases of Thallium reported.

Folks, you can't even use this stuff to kill rats anymore because it is so dangerous.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:13 PM on 01/03/2009

Sad to say, I think Tennessee is so far down the brainwashed conservative sinkhole that their voters will still support the GOP. It all gets down to basic education. We have to work from the ground up with public education so that future voters will have a basic understanding of how local, state and federal governments work - the way powers and responsibilities are allocated among them, why corporations and capitalism must be strictly regulated by government, and why we must pay taxes to support public infrastructure and regulatory agencies. Until then, any greedy, 2-bit conman (or woman) can successfully run for public office with the slick campaign slogan: "I'll lower your taxes!"
Wouldn't it be great if conservative Christian churches would hammer on the message that greed is one of the seven deadly sins.
I sincerely hope that PE Obama quickly realizes that "clean coal" is an oxymoron.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:32 PM on 01/03/2009
photo

Maybe the people from Tn. can get thier elected Republican reps to get a foriegn company to come in and clean up the mess, maybe some good old non union workers from mexico.
(snark)
I have zero sympathy for the people of Tn. They voted in these deregulators that look the other way for big companies to get away with this crap.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:53 PM on 01/03/2009

This statement is just like the ones I hear in Church where the visiting pastor has the gall to say those who don't vote republican are not Christians.

Just like the church this state is not 100% Republican. While the majority of the state leans right, to lump everyone into one group is wrong.

There are folks like me in this state who think more needs to be done to protect the environment, more needs to be done to keep our water and air clean, and more needs to be done to companies who recklessly continue to pollute and in the name of greed look the other way until something like this happens.

The news coverage of this compared to the Exxon spill speaks volumes about how much the rest of this nation cares about the environment.

I feel for the residents affected by this, but what I really am sickened by most of all is the damage to this precious environment it will forever be tainted from now on affecting the people, wildlife and land forever on.

The snail paced speed at which the clean up efforts are being preformed is sickening, and if you want to point fingers about voting in deregulators there are more directions than the people suffering from this. GWB and the rest of the Republicans in DC come from every state in the Union.

Those on the right who hunt or fish should pick up and join in the fight to protect the land.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:49 AM on 01/07/2009
photo

Some call it polution... the GOP calls it life.

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=5425355

Lots of goop, brought to America by the Goopers.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:45 PM on 01/03/2009

Well TVA administrators must have taken some correspondence courses from the Chinese Government on the practices of environmental calamities and obfuscation

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:27 PM on 01/03/2009

It goes farther, the EPA is saying the water is "safe". The mayor is publicly drinking it and saying how his grandbabies are chugging it down too. Not to mention the governor who said "people shouldn't be afraid of this stuff" when he visited. It's so soothing.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:47 PM on 01/03/2009
photo

As he sipped his bottled water.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:13 PM on 01/03/2009

In times like these I am reminded of the a line from one of my favorite Westerns.

A snake oil sales man is trying to convince an Indian to drink his concoction and the Indian replies then you drink it.

If it is so safe then you drink it.

They are charging school children for bottled water in the school surrounding this. No federal or state aid even for the kids. They can either tough it out and drink the contaminated water or they can cough up some cash for the clean water, capitalism at its finest.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:59 AM on 01/07/2009
Page: 1 2 3 Next › Last » (3 pages total)
Comments are closed for this entry

You must be logged in to reply to this comment. Log in  or  Connect