iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Karzai Accused Of Bid To 'Legalise Rape'

First Posted: 05/01/09 06:12 AM ET Updated: 05/25/11 02:10 PM ET

Afghanistan

Afghanistan's President, Hamid Karzai, has signed a law which "legalises" rape, women's groups and the United Nations warn. Critics claim the president helped rush the bill through parliament in a bid to appease Islamic fundamentalists ahead of elections in August.

In a massive blow for women's rights, the new Shia Family Law negates the need for sexual consent between married couples, tacitly approves child marriage and restricts a woman's right to leave the home, according to UN papers seen by The Independent.

"It is one of the worst bills passed by the parliament this century," fumed Shinkai Karokhail, a woman MP who campaigned against the legislation. "It is totally against women's rights. This law makes women more vulnerable."

The law regulates personal matters like marriage, divorce, inheritance and sexual relations among Afghanistan's minority Shia community. "It's about votes," Ms Karokhail added. "Karzai is in a hurry to appease the Shia because the elections are on the way."

The provisions are reminiscent of the hardline Taliban regime, which banned women from leaving their homes without a male relative. But in a sign of Afghanistan's faltering steps towards gender equality, politicians who opposed it have been threatened.

"There are moderate views among the Shia, but unfortunately our MPs, the people who draft the laws, rely on extremists," Ms Karokhail said.

The bill lay dormant for more than a year, but in February it was rushed through parliament as President Karzai sought allies in a constitutional row over the upcoming election. Senator Humeira Namati claimed it wasn't even read out in the Upper House, let alone debated, before it was passed to the Supreme Court. "They accused me of being an unbeliever," she said.

Details of the law emerged after Mr Karzai was endorsed by Afghanistan's Supreme Court to stay in power until elections scheduled in August. Some MPs claimed President Karzai was under pressure from Iran, which maintains a close relationship with Afghanistan's Shias. The most controversial parts of the law deal explicitly with sexual relations. Article 132 requires women to obey their husband's sexual demands and stipulates that a man can expect to have sex with his wife at least "once every four nights" when travelling, unless they are ill. The law also gives men preferential inheritance rights, easier access to divorce, and priority in court.

A report by the United Nations Development Fund for Women, Unifem, warned: "Article 132 legalises the rape of a wife by her husband".

Most of Afghanistan's Shias are ethnic Hazaras, descended from Genghis Khan's Mongol army which swept through the entire region around 700 years ago. They are Afghanistan's third largest ethnic group, and potential kingmakers, because their leaders will likely back a mainstream candidate.

Even the law's sponsors admit Mr Karzai rushed it through to win their votes. Ustad Mohammad Akbari, a prominent Shia political leader, said: "It's electioneering. Most of the Hazara people are unhappy with Mr Karzai."

A British Embassy spokesman said diplomats had raised concerns "at a senior level".

Related Article: US and Iran at Afghan talks

Read more from the Independent.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST WORLD

Afghanistan's President, Hamid Karzai, has signed a law which "legalises" rape, women's groups and the United Nations warn. Critics claim the president helped rush the bill through parliament in a bid...
Afghanistan's President, Hamid Karzai, has signed a law which "legalises" rape, women's groups and the United Nations warn. Critics claim the president helped rush the bill through parliament in a bid...
Filed by Hanna Ingber Win  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 273
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (9 total)
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Emerald1943
10:25 AM on 04/03/2009
This is sad. Not so long ago, we were celebrating the fact that more women could go to school and find employment there.

I cannot believe that any religion would condone this and I do not blame Islam. However, the religious zealots seem to have the power and do nothing to elevate Islam to the rest of the world. Karzai is obviously pandering to his "base".....sound familiar??

I have mixed feelings about helping Afghanistan because of this but if we walk away and do not help, there is no hope for many people there to live better lives. Karzai needs to go....but who (or what) will replace him? Democracy can be scary!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dynamohum
11:20 AM on 04/03/2009
Well, one must consider the fact that Karzai was brought to power by the BUSHCO administration and one get's what one pays for. kARZAI HAS TO GO.
10:21 AM on 04/03/2009
NOTHING JUSTIFIES RAPE. NOTHING.
10:10 AM on 04/03/2009
"What's the use of getting sober, when you know you'd be drunk again?"

Trinidad and Tobago's greatest calypsonian, The Mighty Sparrow, sang that in one of his earlier calypsoes.

Guess it's safe to ask, "What's the use of getting married, when you could get hit with a rape charge by the woman to whom you're married?"
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Emerald1943
10:29 AM on 04/03/2009
If a man does not force himself on a woman, he has nothing to worry about. Rape, in any context, is wrong!!!!!
12:29 PM on 04/03/2009
I will agree a husband and wife need to have the understanding that they both have needs and not to step out of the relationship. Even that sometimes husbands and wives have to sometime please their other even when they aren't in the mood. But lets be honest here, this law has nothing to do with well ... "i asked my wife to make love and she denied me for 8 years so now i want out of this marriage i am not happy"... its more "... i told her i want now 4 mins ago and she said she didn't feel well and she had been working all day so i knocked her upside the head and took it". That is rape, some of these women are trying to kill themselves to get out of these marriages. Their husbands are beating them, their mother-in-law is beating them depending on the wives age the older children are beating on them. This is unjustifiable and, and these women are now faced with the terror and horror of men who are manipulating Islam to fit their unjust and deplorable ways. This is not the true Islam but now the world will never know it because these men who were born and bread under the height of ignorance are still in power
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:44 AM on 04/03/2009
Thanks for your insight shaista. Its significant to point out Karzai 's own culpability in distorting and manipulating for political powr.
11:58 PM on 04/01/2009
Hamed Karzai will do anything to stay in power at the expense of innocent Afghans. Yet, America continues to support him. Do you know that he has a $100 MILLION dollar budget to run his campaign? Ask yourselves.....WHERE DOES HE AND HIS FAMILY GET THIS KIND OF MONEY????

American taxpayers are spending millions if not billions and sending their sons and daughters to get killed.....to support another dictatorship! How can the U.S. say they are there to rid the country of the Taliban and defend women's rights when the very thing they are doing is supporting a Taliban-like government that oppresses women?

Why is it that the U.S. is already saying that there aren't other qualified candidates to run the country...when there are? Why are they already saying that Karzai may win again when the campaigning hasn't even started????? Is this part of a master plan?

So before you start blaming Islam and bashing the religion....ask why the U.S. time and time again supports the most corrupt leaders in order to create instablity in a region, and ultimately a need to occupy. Ask yourself the deeper questions because not everything is black and white.
11:57 PM on 04/01/2009
Afghans who speak against the Karzais gets punished behind the curtains in some way. Afghans around the world are speaking against them but many are fearful of what could happen to them if they do. They are hard line extremists in disguise who use the West in public but behind the scenes, laugh at the Americans. My brother worked for them so I know all of this firsthand. Karzai himself will not allow his wife to go out in public. Secretly he has a Taliban mentality yet acts as if he is so pro-democracy and West in the public eye. He makes deals with the devils to stay in power. He fired the former Minister of Womens Affairs because she was trying to bring positive change for women and he feared she might gain popularity.He abuses the constitution to benefit himself. He dominates the media and will not let other candidates have proper airtime to run against him let alone speak against him. It's BULLSHIT that he claims he only has $10K in his bank account. His clothing budget is ten times that. He owns property in Dubai and has millions stashed in bank accounts across the world. All Afghans know this so it is sickening to hear that he went on the record saying he doesn't have money...what a liar!
11:57 PM on 04/01/2009
Let me break it down for all of you since we Afghans have the inside scoop. First, let's put your religious intolerance aside because these problems have nothing to do with Islam and has everything to do with a bunch of power hungry men who are abusing laws for their own benefit....and America is doing nothing to stop it when they can.

The Karzais are a bunch of greedy thieves who have sucked the blood of the Afghan people, and now the wallets of the American taxpayers. Mahmoud Karzai was once a cab driver in the U.S. and has gone on to become the richest man in Afghanistan. The other brother Wali is Afghanistan's biggest drug dealer. Karzai's nephew Hekmat used to be a bouncer at a club and now is leading some Institute for Peace, for which he received millions in funding, meanwhile he abuses his status to harrass those who dare to speak against the corruption in their family.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Emerald1943
10:35 AM on 04/03/2009
Just a thought....can you just imagine the public outrage we would see if it was found out that our president's brother was a major drug dealer??? Do the people of Afghanistan know about their leader and his corrupt family?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:53 AM on 04/01/2009
Why don't the haters show how the religion of Islam is the cause of the problems in Afghanistan. America supported war in Afghanistan for 10 years and ignored the postwar reconstruction (sound familiar?).
Afghanistan is a failed state and collapsed society that needs strong families.
Karzai appears to be trying to strengthen the role of the family. His problem is codification. Will a woman be found guilty of a crime if she doesn't have sex with her husband every 4 days?


Meanwhile, illiteracy in Afghanistan is around 60% for men and 80% for women. Afghanistan cannot allow prostitution, sex trafficking to increase there otherwise the women will suffer more, given they are illiterate and without many options. Marriage and family can lift men and women out of their desperate condition. "Free sex" values of the West will not.


America and the West decriminalized sex outside of marriage, making sex "free". Prostitution is legal and growing in almost every European country with the exception of Sweden and a few others. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostitution_in_Europe#Prostitution_in_Germany

Prostitution is now a major global entreprise thanks to the 'free' sex values of the West and capitalism. Thanks to America's occupation of Iraq, 'free' sexual values have now exponentially elevated prostitution and sex trafficking to Iraq when before it was almost nonexistant.
MSNBC reported unemployed women r seeking employment at strip clubs. Prostitution via the internet is now widespread and brothels in Nevada have 1000s of applications.
11:16 AM on 04/03/2009
"Free sex?" I'm sorry but sex is a highly personal and individual activity for ALL and humans and is inherently a fundamental human right. For you to be obsessed with other people's sex lives suggest more about how weirdly perverted you are than it says about anyone else.

Love and sex must be a freedom for all people of any culture in the world! Other people's love lives should be none of your concern and I quite frankly can't understand why you are concerned about it. Please enlighten us.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Solja
03:37 AM on 04/01/2009
The women of the world need to stand up and cry foul over this! It is a known fact that the Afghanistan government is corrupt. Our government needs to not play nice with them and not give them a damn thing until they make some serious corrections within human rights, especially for women. What the hell is going on in that country that was allowed to go on over the last 8 years?

Our President needs to do something about this right here!
12:10 AM on 04/01/2009
Brutal. Religion is just brutal.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Solja
03:40 AM on 04/01/2009
I agree, and I'm a Christian. It seems to me that every major war is over religion in some shape or form.

I won't pass judgment but the middle east doesn't reflect good morals or values, at least in my western way of thinking. Maybe it's just the news that I read about them, but this is not a story that makes me think this is a good place on earth. It makes me think these people are savages.
01:02 PM on 04/01/2009
The news reports are almost invariably like this -- very negative about the people who live in that region. The truth is that most people there, like here, just want to work hard and raise their families in peace. Which shouldn't be too much to hope for or expect. The problem comes from the extremists. Here our extremists bloviate on the news channels; there, they blow things up. It's still press.

For a much different take on "average" folks in central asia, I strongly (and persistently) urge people to read Three Cups of Tea about Greg Mortenson's work there in the last 15 years.
10:56 AM on 04/01/2009
A lot of religious ideology (a la the Bible and the Koran) is actually sensible and loving. But it gets warped and twisted into something ugly by people who use whatever text they subscribe to as a weapon. What they've just passed actually goes against the Koran.

It's not about Islam ... or Christianity.

It's about men controlling women.
11:00 AM on 04/03/2009
Yeah, but in the end these religions were created by men who at the time, women were property! We don't need guidance from people living 2000 years ago because I'm pretty sure a lot has changed since then. i don't know why the world is so beholden to the deep past when we are free from those seemingly dark times where even a heavy rainstorm was probably terrifying to people who made stuff up to explain the rainstorm.
09:42 PM on 03/31/2009
Rape is the ultimate denial of human rights and liberty; it's apart of those unalienable rights which all people are born with.

I also say, these rights trump religion and geopolitics. Some say we as Westerners have no right to superimpose our values upon another culture because we once condoned slavery; but clearly rape is equal to slavery and equally ought not be tolerated by any society on Earth.

If this report is correct, the President of Afghanistan should be condemned by the rest of the world.
photo
goodog
Honk if you believe in a public editor.
09:14 PM on 03/31/2009
Sharia courts are now allowed in Great Britain, and it's only a matter of time before freedom of religion in America requires we allow Sharia courts here too.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
naschkatze
A free man creates himself.
09:30 AM on 04/01/2009
If I'm not mistaken, the sharia courts in Britain are civil not criminal.
photo
goodog
Honk if you believe in a public editor.
05:13 PM on 04/01/2009
You might notice the court being discussed here is Family Court, not criminal court. The rights of women are being infringed upon as a matter of family law.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
dimplesmile7
08:37 PM on 03/31/2009
If Islam is about love, then we need to see more of it. It seems like everything we see about it is negative. I am sure the news about it is bias, but are there any one that can really lead by example in a positive way when it comes down to Islam?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
peskime
Patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel
08:35 PM on 03/31/2009
What do you expect from a man who's brother is Afghanistan's biggest drug dealer?
Disgusting.
08:31 PM on 03/31/2009
What a total crap-hole of a country.
Why are we there? Why? Why? Why?
and don't tell me it's to "fight Them there so we don't have to fight Them here"
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Solja
03:35 AM on 04/01/2009
We are there because the animals that orchestrated the attacks on our World Trade Centers and the Pentagon are there plotting more attacks on us. Face the facts because that's why we are there.
07:03 PM on 04/01/2009
You are so funny!! hahahah