Roxana Saberi Is No Spy, Says Obama

The Hill:

Roxana Saberi, a 31-year old American journalist sentenced to eight years in prison in Iran last week, was not "engaging in any sort of espionage," President Obama said Sunday.

Obama, talking to reporters at a press conference at the Summit of the Americas in Trinidad and Tobago, said that he is "gravely concerned with her safety and well-being."

Read the whole story: The Hill

Comments

[Dan Stewart]

Why assume Roxanne Saberi is not a spy? Is there a reason to presume she was not engaged in espionage? I simply don’ know either way.

Objectively speaking, there’s plenty of precedence for the possibility and it seems rather naïve to cursorily accept she’s not a spy.

The CIA certainly deploys spies, both intelligence officers and agents. It would be surprising if the US hasn’t done so in Iran, a country it (until recently) has publically threatened with bombardment and has marked for regime change. If she were an officer or agent of the CIA, the US certainly wouldn’t admit it.

Apparently, she has been well treated, and not tortured. And she was given a trial (albeit inadequate and probably unfair) and has the right to appeal. The forgoing is not something the US would avail to an unfortunate Iranian in the same position. More than likely his fate would be “illegal non-combatant” status, Bagram prison, and multiple sessions with a waterboard.

And, much like the four Iranian diplomats current held by the US in prisons in Iraq, there would be no charges, no lawyers, no trials, no appeals, and certainly no good treatment.

[Don Klinestiver]

There can be no real discussion unless Isreal can get an equal number of agents on thes posts. Anything to do with Iran is just a posterboard for the Iranian Revolutionary Guards.

J'acuse Hass, Baghooli, jamilk99, Snuffleupagus who have no bio no picture to turn on thier webcams or publish a bio and show us which ministry they work in.

[canfemlib]

Well, we should expect the Iranians to use the same moral compass as the Americans and waterboard the girl 180 times.

[DLBSR]

And exactly how many times did KSM himself waterboard Dani*el Pea*rle before he de*cap*itat*ed him and recorded the gris*sly event for the whole world to witness. Or do you even care? You think Iran's moral compass with respect to torture is higher than the US? It is not, both countries practice this abhorent form of interrogation. Mr. Pea*rle may have prefered the waterboarding if given the option.

· Torture In Iran - CBS News Video
Apr 5, 2009 ... Posted by NimaNas at 8:24 AM : Apr 12, 2009: + report abuse + permalink .... this barbaric regime under Islamic law torturing Iranians for ...
www.cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=4920609n - 74k

· How Ahmad Batebi Survived Torture In Iran - CBS News
Posted by TonyPic at 8:03 AM : Apr 15, 2009: + report abuse + permalink. Anderson Cooper asked: "What the purpose of torture in Iran is" let me explain on ...
www.cbsnews.com/stories/2009/04/03/60minu... - 123k - Similar pages
[ More results from www.cbsnews.com ]
· iranian torture - Tehran's Evin prison - Marie Claire
In 2001, 20-year-old Iranian Zarah Ghahramani spent 29 days in Tehran's Evin prison for participating in student protests against her country's ...
www.marieclaire.com/world-reports/news/internati... - 65k

· Iran: Government Report Acknowledges Torture In Prisons - ...
Exiled Iranians in Germany demonstrating this month against execution and torture in IranIran's hard-line judiciary has acknowledged in an unprecedented ...
www.rferl.org/content/Article/1060161.html - 38k -

[Estevan Benson]

why is she so beautiful?

[SFkid]

So she's not a spy and maybe should be let go. On another note the US has detained many men for 7 freakin years from Iraq that are accused for being terrorist with absolutely no proof or trial. What does this say about the US?

[WorkingClass]

Iran should send this girl home even if she is a spy. Holding her will cost them dearly.

[writerjohnny]

If it was Rush Limbaugh or Dan Rather being held there would be saber rattling and calls for special ops to go in and kick a little Iranian butt. Of course Rush would never put himself anywhere close to an actual war zone which Dan Rather did for extended periods during the Viet Nam conflict.

[CAP6]

In addition to his reporting from Nam, Rather also made at least one trip through the mountains from Pakistan into Afghanistan with Afghani Resistance during the war with the Russians where he witnessed combat between the two groups.

[Hank10303]

Just thnk they were once our friends but republican foreign policy made them our enemy - that party has a very long history of failure that has gone ignored for far to long.

[MideastDove]

The Iran government was never our friend....it was our puppet.

[AbeMartin]

How do we know she isn't a spy? Perhaps she is spying for a different government, other than the U.S.
Or maybe she is an undercover op.

Julia Child was a spy. Valerie Plame was a spy. Heddy Lamar was a spy. Moe Berg was a spy. Just because a man or woman is attractive, athletic and has a career cover doesn't mean that they are not working covertly. The fact that someone has an outside career which eclipses their intelligence gathering seems to be a pretty reason for their recruitment.

[Horst]

Are you suggesting that your President Obama is lying?

[MideastDove]

"I have complete confidence...."
Is not a denial.

[freshnotbitter]

Spying on what? Was she passing secret falafel recipes? The country we are talking about is not much farther advanced than the 8th century. It is hard for me to accept that I live in a world as backwards as the one I read about on these posts.

[wsb25]

How about if Iran follows USA government legal
precedents and waterboards her to find the truth?
Wouldn't that be fair?

[Horst]

They do a lot worse in Evin Prison.....

[MideastDove]

Interested. Got any verified info?

[katekid]

If she's not a spy than shame on her for putting herself and the US in this position.
Iranian citizen, no press credentials and in Iran for 6 years, c'mon.

[Horst]

Absolutely correct... a minor league "journalist"/beauty queen who wants a big story and book deal.

[cole b]

Minor league journalist? How about a respected correspondent for BBC and National Public Radio. How about a woman with masters from both Cambridge and Northwestern and was studying in Iran, which was one reason she was still living there. I know Roxana and she is more than Miss North Dakota. In fact, that might be the least interesting and accomplished thing about her. Please learn more about her before you make such broad, sweeping ignorant assumptions.

[ladydragon]

She's no spy? well then what the hell was she doing over there? Obama wants Cuba to allow travel there, that don't mean that I should go traipsing around over there,

[laxfamily]

The Iranian gov't may also use "enhanced interogation techniques" on her similiar to what the US did since Bush and his buddies have said it ins't torture. Will Fox News be the first to raise ire when she is tortured? Will they be outraged?

[katekid]

I did hear she may have confessed.

[hu.man]

My guess is that she asked too many questions, may be even on the nuclear issue and caught the attention of wrong folks in Iran. The international community should keep the relentless pressure to have Iran either release Saberi or produce some hard evidence on the spying case.

Iranians will respond to pressure from abroad. The legal system there is chaotic and influenced by vying interest groups. These are inherent risks in reporting from a closed nation like Iran. That is why you are not seeing too many reporters roaming there or spending a significant amount of time on location. Saberi is paying the price of being somewhat ignorant of these facts.

[MideastDove]

"The legal system there is chaotic and influenced by vying interest groups."

Like ours.

[Ranta]

Two TV pundits were talking via telephone to Saberi's father . He is currently in Tehran. After the call, lady pundit said, " you know this phone call is probably being listened to". Did she mean by the Iranians or our government or both?

[postman606]

Possibly by any, and everyone.