'Slumdog' Child Star's HOME Torn Down By Authorities

digg Share this on Facebook Huffpost - 'Slumdog' Child Star's HOME Torn Down By Authorities stumble reddit del.ico.us RSS

ERIKA KINETZ | 05/14/09 04:01 PM | AP

What's Your Reaction?
"Slumdog Millionaire" child star Azharuddin Mohammed Ismail, right, drives a bicycle past demolished shanties in his neighborhood in Mumbai, India, Thursday, May 14, 2009. City workers bulldozed the home of Azharuddin Thursday as part of the demolition of dozens of shanties in a Mumbai slum.(AP Photo/Gautam Singh)

MUMBAI, India — The 10-year-old child star of "Slumdog Millionaire" was awakened Thursday by a policeman wielding a bamboo stick and ordered out of his home. Minutes later it was bulldozed along with dozens of other shanties in the Mumbai slum he calls home.

"I was frightened," said Azharuddin Mohammed Ismail, who lost his pet kittens in the chaos.

"Where is my chicken?" he asked forlornly, picking through the shamble of broken wood and twisted metal sheeting in search of the family hen.

Eight Oscars and $326 million in box office receipts have done little so far to improve the lives of the two impoverished child stars plucked from obscurity to star in the blockbuster. They have been showered with gifts and brief bursts of fame, but their day-to-day lives in the Garib Nagar slum _ the "city of the poor" _ are little changed.

After the latest misfortune, Azhar and his family will be spending the night on the muddy ground surrounded by the rubble of their shack. His 9-year-old co-star Rubina Ali has fared no better: her family's shanty was flooded for days last month with sewage water from a backed-up drain.

For Azhar's family, the latest problem began at 11 a.m. Thursday, when a bulldozer and about 100 men descended on the slum to tear down 30 illegally built homes _ a common occurrence in India's chaotic cities, where officials struggle to keep crowding under control.

The result is a cycle of destruction and debt few can escape.

U.D. Mistry, an official with the city's Bombay Municipal Corporation, said the latest razing was part of a "pre-monsoon demolition drive."

Story continues below
advertisement

He said only illegally built shanties _ not homes that were legally owned _ were bulldozed.

"They were removed. That is the principle," he said, adding he was not aware the young "Slumdog" star lived in the slum.

Mistry said shanty dwellers who can prove they have lived there more than 15 years _ which would include Azhar's family _ will be resettled elsewhere in government housing. Such promises often come to nothing, though, and even when slum-dwellers are given housing, it is often in poor-quality buildings on the outskirts of cities, far from jobs.

Residents of Garib Nagar vowed Thursday to rebuild, though many have yet to pay off the loans they took out _ at 20 percent monthly interest _ to reconstruct the shanties they lost when the city tore them down last year.

Azhar's mother sat despondently Thursday afternoon on the stack of belongings the family managed to save. Nearby, Azhar dodged piles of metal sheeting and debris as he rode through his destroyed neighborhood on a shiny new bike given to him by a fan from Britain, a fancy black-and-red helmet on his head.

Azhar wants to move. "I am fed up," he said.

Behind him a wrinkled movie poster of "Slumdog Millionaire" waved in the breeze. Scrawled in black marker was a message from the movie's director, Danny Boyle: "Azhar, with love and thanks, Danny Boyle."

"Slumdog" filmmakers say they've done their best to help the young stars. They set up a trust to ensure the children get proper homes, a good education and a nest egg when they finish high school. They also donated $747,500 to a charity to help slum kids in Mumbai.

Producer Christian Colson has described the trust as substantial, but won't tell anyone how much it contains _ not even the children's parents _ for fear of making the youngsters vulnerable to exploitation.

Trustee Noshir Dadrawala told the Associated Press Thursday that the families were offered temporary rental apartments last week until permanent homes can be found, but they turned them down.

Azhar's parents say the filmmakers have budgeted $30,000 to get them a new apartment _ an amount they insist is inadequate in Mumbai's pricey real estate market.

"I don't want to take a house where life will be like a slum again," said Azhar's mother, Shameem Ismail.

Dadrawala said the trustees wrote to Boyle and Colson last week to see if they could get more money, but haven't heard back.

Azhar's neighbors have less to look forward to. Homeless mothers nursed their babies Thursday in what little shade they could find in the 100-degree heat. Nearby, a 98-year old woman lay listless on a metal bed frame scattered with rags. A pregnant woman carried two large jugs of water, trying not to trip. A man on crutches hobbled through rubble littered with stuffed animals and children's shoes.

Some sang "Jai Ho," the Oscar-winning song from "Slumdog Millionaire." Others tried to cook. Children struggled with unwieldy bundles of clothes tied together with old sheets.

Many in the neighborhood had clung to Azhar's fame, hoping it would save their homes from destruction; now they have nowhere to go.

Rickshaw driver Ramdas Ambadas Gaikwad took out a $100 loan from a local moneylender four months ago, built a shack across from Azhar's and moved his wife and five children out of the crawl space under a road where they had lived for years.

He really doesn't want to go back there.

Two of his sons have crusty sores covering their faces and scalps. "It's from the heat," the 35-year-old Gaikwad said.

Still, life is far better than it was in the tunnel, he said. Rats used to bite them every night. Now he only gets bitten every other day, he said, fingering a fresh puncture on his big toe.

___

Associated Press writer Rajesh Shah contributed to this report.

Report Corrections
 
Comments
121
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: 1 2 3 4 Next › Last » (4 pages total)
- Ohioan730 I'm a Fan of Ohioan730 134 fans permalink
photo

As poor as I was growing up in urban America with numerous siblings and a single mother, I have never been through what the poorest of the poor have been through in this country and around the globe. I honestly don't know how they remain sane with all the blows they take from life.

There is obviously not much birth control available. There are so many people, there isn't enough housing to support them and employment and education opportunities are scarce to non-existent so the cycle continues. There is no family privacy because they literally live a few feet from each other and have sheets for walls in some cases. There is filth, vermin, rats and stray animals to contend with constantly, not to mention sickness, petulance and god-knows-­what-else.

How bad can it get for certain societies before some serious action is taken? At this point, its better to live on a desert island than be part of some of these cities. These places are breeding grounds for crime and all sorts of societal menaces and disease. These problems have a way of trickling up and meeting us in a dark alley. Help the children.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:57 PM on 05/14/2009
- danusgram I'm a Fan of danusgram 15 fans permalink
photo

Here is the problem folks $30000.00 is a lot of money in India. That argument does not fly. There is something wrong here its like he said she said.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:19 PM on 05/14/2009
- AN2009 I'm a Fan of AN2009 4 fans permalink

For all their complaints about exploitation, I don't see the Indians doing anything to help these "Oscar children." They claim that India is the "next superpower" -- even better than China -- but they don't lift a finger to help their own child stars. Where are all the Indian billionaires willing to give a few bucks to help these kids out? Where's the Indian government on this? Oh, that's right, they don't care. They just want foreigners to give a bunch of aid, but they don't want to pitch in as well.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:22 PM on 05/14/2009

The filmmakers should have just hired actors instead. With all the negative publicity they are now paying the price for exploiting these children. If they were so concern about the plight of these children they could have simply donated to various charlies in India and be done with it. I'm sure they will think twice about trying to save money by hiring non actors next time.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:26 PM on 05/14/2009

They aren't paying the price, they already won their Oscars, had their box office take, and DVD has come out, and most who want the movie have bought it. As for the next movie, they will just pick upper class kids.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:16 AM on 05/15/2009

A trust fund for this child requires he live to get it. Unless the owner of the film provided for his education, even if it's a boarding school, he can't pass classes he is not taking. Why couldn't the family have been moved to permanent housing by the film company. That would have cost less than hiring a u.s. child actor. They even brought these young children here for an award show and then sent them back to squalor. How they must have felt. Even without a contract, they need current help. I know it's unlikely anyone will try to find the kids involved and save them. I searched and have not found a site trying to help them. But their faces will not be forgotten by me.
This is outsourcing to cut costs. This project made money. I know it won't matter, but I don't want to be a part of this and therefore won't be seeing this project or any other by the people who did this. It will always remind me of the children who helped make the profit.
Who is the next Slumlord Millionaire? Someone seeking intellectual property with extreme profit in the lowest cost places with the lowest cost people. Who knows, this horror story could be someones next project? For those who know the whole story, this project will not make friends abroad and it will influence some people not to respect us.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:28 PM on 05/14/2009

IIRC, they've been provided new housing - a place they really own. But in at least one case, the family doesn't wish to move there. Don't know if that's this case or not.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:15 PM on 05/14/2009
- FlippyO I'm a Fan of FlippyO 9 fans permalink
photo

OMG, did you NOT read the article??? They've TRIED to help the kids! You've searched for a site to try to help the kids, yet couldn't be bothered to read the article that tells you that money HAS been given to the families. That the families have rejected the temporary apartments, that the mother says that whatever amount wasn't enough, blah, blah, blah. I feel badly for the kids, but the "Slumdog Millionaire" people have clearly tried to help them and they're up against greedy families, greedy neighbors, and either a greedy or incompetent government. They can't just keep throwing money at the problem when money isn't solving the problem. The kids have trust funds for when they grow up and are able to leave the community (or heck, country) on their own. Right now, they're at the mercy of people in India. And, if you'd just read THIS article, you'd see what the producers/director are up against.

I can't believe that anyone would think that the movie company would hire local kids to "save money", as if they needed the pocket change that it might save. I'm sure they were trying to both get local flavor in the movie AND help some poor kids. Right about now, I'm sure they probably wish they'd hired actors, because of people like you and people like the kids' greedy families.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:47 AM on 05/15/2009

I do not have the resources to do it but can anybody here able to do so please adopt just this one kid. It would be a huge symbolic gesture to the entire world!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:51 PM on 05/14/2009
- ywcachieve I'm a Fan of ywcachieve 107 fans permalink

The child is not up for adoption.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:10 PM on 05/14/2009

They have a family.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:13 PM on 05/14/2009
- Sarijj I'm a Fan of Sarijj 4 fans permalink
photo

What kind of parents turn down housing? I feel sad for this kid and his siblings,

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:04 PM on 05/14/2009

I really wish this movie was never made. Then I wouldn't have to hear an update about these people every friggin' week.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:38 PM on 05/14/2009
- rkg I'm a Fan of rkg permalink

Or you could be happy that the poverty in India (or anywhere really) is getting some reaction, albeit as pablum. The problem in the first place is that everyone wants to forget such things and not be bothered. So look past the presentation, and the media's attempt at cliche sensationalism, and remember the people who are really living this.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:17 PM on 05/14/2009
- ywcachieve I'm a Fan of ywcachieve 107 fans permalink

SwingingFr­omCenter..­.I hear ya. I am so tired of hearing about these people. They have made many movies in Africa, and I have never seen them obsessed with the African actors or extras.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:59 PM on 05/14/2009
- Logout I'm a Fan of Logout 3 fans permalink

At least he has a helmet and a bicycle. That's something!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:35 PM on 05/14/2009
photo

oh, yeah. that is much better than a home with a roof over your head.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:26 PM on 05/15/2009
- Rangergirl I'm a Fan of Rangergirl 18 fans permalink

What happened to the apartment they were supposed to be getting? Supposedly they were getting an apartment that the produces paid for. I feel so bad for the kids...The­ir parents seem to be using them for gain of there own....Sad­....I do believe that is their culture.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:34 PM on 05/14/2009
photo

It's their circumstance more than "their culture"..­..remember Oliver Twist?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:14 PM on 05/14/2009

For at least one of the kids, the parents didn't wish to move, preferred the slum to the apartment. I don't know if that's this one or not.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:16 PM on 05/14/2009
- psbintl I'm a Fan of psbintl 19 fans permalink
photo

So they have to wait until after they get out of high school to be helped?

They could be dead before then from starvation, disease or crime inflicted upon them!

I am almost sorry now I gave money to see this film if this is how the child stars are treated!

This is shameful! They should have immediately been rewarded with a proper home to live in along with their families!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:43 PM on 05/14/2009
photo

yeah...I don't get why they didn't do that.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:15 PM on 05/14/2009

Apparently that's not where the millions of dollars made at the box office went. It goes to people who want more but should have less.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:18 PM on 05/14/2009
- FlippyO I'm a Fan of FlippyO 9 fans permalink
photo

C'mon, read the article. Money HAS been sent to help the kids - they haven't just set up a trust fund, but a fund to try to help them now. Blame their families and/or the Indian government.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:49 AM on 05/15/2009
- dcjdjay I'm a Fan of dcjdjay 23 fans permalink

Look, slums in Mumbai have sprouted on land worth hundreds of billions of dollars, and the city can no longer serve as de facto slum for the millions of poor who arrive each day from India's Northern impoverished states of UP and Bihar. For decades, slumlords, greedy politicians, corrupt cops, and the thuggishly greedy Indian bureaucracy have exploited slum dwellers with repeated threats of removal, only to forego those threats after being paid by the slum residents. However, in recent years, some civic-minded citizens have regrouped to insist on adequate housing and re-settlement for slum residents. In part, the slum dwellers had really nowhere to go, but in recent times even when they are offered apartments (for free) by the government, they refuse to leave. Their argument is that the homes are too far away and that their commutes to the city on commuter trains would take too long. Some even rent out their government provided homes, and then move back to the slum, essentially becoming illegal landlords. Unfortunately, Mumbai's middle class tax-paying citizens are fed up of being exploited not only by government bodies who provide only 5 cents in services to each dollar the city pays out in taxes, but also by slum residents (harsh as it may sound). It's easy for Westerners to cluck in disapproval, but if you lived in Mumbai I bet you'd lose patience too. The real story is often much more complicated than the "Gee Whiz, Sally Struthers" version.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:10 PM on 05/14/2009
- voltage356 I'm a Fan of voltage356 17 fans permalink
photo

What's going on here? I thought the studio had them living in a apartment buildin,and had move them out of the slums.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:47 PM on 05/14/2009

Danny Boyle stated, these children can't touch the the money unless "they pass all their exams and finish school". I'm thinking these kids are hungry and homeless today. Face it these kids were exploited. Just like the Afghani actors in the Kite Runner who were paid the equivelant of about $17,500. Westerners (white Brits and Americans) have doing this for ages, nothing new.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:35 PM on 05/14/2009

oh!poorCladakin,how naive you can get.Pl, feel free to call on me,I will drop you to the nearest airport for free.Are you so lost that you can nothelp by mouthing off.It require decades of hard accountable goverance,which India has not achieved in 65 years,75% of people do not drinking water,pepsi makes more money making drinking water.Idio­tic charity,worthless compassion or meaningless sympathy do not pay.I did not say this,the great Budha said it.Work hard,make your own luck,life is nothing but pain& suffering.­It comes in all shades and color.If you are not poor it pure sheer chance and luck.I do not think it will sink in many minds.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:34 PM on 05/14/2009

One cannot *possibly* imagine the depths of poverty the average Indian lives in unless you've visited the country or grew up there. My husband and I traveled to India for the first time early last year and I was totally taken aback by the shanty communities like the one Azharuddin Mohammed Ismail's there in Mumbai. Houses are constructed from any materials the residents can find, which range from dirty tarps to spare pieces of moldy lumber. And of course, indoor plumbing is completely lacking.

It's hard to imagine anyone anywhere wanting to live under such conditions but I question whether the right thing to do regarding this child star 's situation is to take him from his parents, as some here have suggested. Undoubtedly, there has been some attempted exploitation of the young "Slumdog" actors by their families but what can one expect? When people are as poor as these people, children become a commodity, girls even more so than boys.

I'm not sure what the right answer is here but it certainly is a sad situation. Of course we should also remember that Azharuddin represents literally millions of less talented/lucky Indian children forced to live in substandard conditions and lacking opportunity and education.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:10 PM on 05/14/2009
Page: 1 2 3 4 Next › Last » (4 pages total)
Comments are closed for this entry

 You must be logged in to comment. Log in  or connect with 

Connect


svn