More

Netanyahu: Jerusalem Will Not Be Divided

MARK LAVIE   05/21/09 03:44 PM ET   AP

Mideast Israel Palestinians

JERUSALEM — Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu insisted Thursday that all of Jerusalem will always remain under Israeli sovereignty, taking a hard line on a key Israeli-Palestinian peace issue just hours after his forces removed an unauthorized settlement outpost in the West Bank.

The twin moves came a day after Netanyahu returned from talks in Washington, where President Barack Obama backed creation of a Palestinian state and urged an end to Jewish settlement construction in the West Bank, setting up a potential confrontation between Israel and the U.S.

Netanyahu has refused to endorse Palestinian statehood, and his uncompromising statement about Jerusalem focused attention on another issue that could cause friction between Israel and Obama's administration.

The U.S. has long held that the future of Jerusalem must be decided in negotiations, but Netanyahu offered no flexibility.

"United Jerusalem is Israel's capital," Netanyahu said. "Jerusalem was always ours and will always be ours. It will never again be partitioned and divided."

Netanyahu was speaking at a ceremony marking 42 years since Israel captured east Jerusalem in the 1967 Mideast war.

Before the war, Jordan controlled east Jerusalem, while Israel had the western section. A barbed wire barrier and wall separated the two sides. Shortly after the war, Israel annexed east Jerusalem, a move that no other country has recognized. Israel did not annex other territories, like the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

Previous Israeli governments have indicated willingness to cede Arab neighborhoods to the Palestinians in the framework of peace. Netanyahu, who took office on March 31, has always rejected giving up control of any part of Jerusalem.

Rafik Husseini, an aide to Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, rejected Netanyahu's stand. He said the Palestinians have accepted a two-state solution based on east Jerusalem as the capital of their state.

"Israeli occupation of east Jerusalem is illegal," he told The Associated Press, adding that an Israeli attempt to keep control of east Jerusalem would be a "major obstacle to peace."

Disputes over Jerusalem have torpedoed several peacemaking attempts. The main issue is control over a holy site, where the Al Aqsa Mosque compound sits atop the ruins of the biblical Jewish Temples. Also, Israel has built large Jewish neighborhoods around east Jerusalem, and Palestinians consider them illegal settlements.

Palestinians emphasize halting settlement construction as a key to resuming peace talks.

On Thursday morning, Israeli forces moved on a small West Bank settler outpost and tore it down, but critics charged that the gesture was almost meaningless, and settlers quickly began putting the makeshift buildings back up.

Israeli peace groups say there are at least 100 wildcat outposts in the West Bank, in addition to 121 settlements authorized by the government. For years, Israel has pledged to remove outposts, but little has been done.

More than 280,000 Israelis now live in West Bank settlements, including several thousand in outposts, many of them little more than a a few mobile homes.

About 40 people lived in Maoz Esther, on a hilltop northeast of the Palestinian city of Ramallah.

Twisted metal and household furniture lay in a heap on the ground after the military left. A few teenagers prayed and milled about, while others sifted through the rubble to salvage materials.

Within hours, young settlers were rebuilding the outpost.

"Every time they demolish it, it is rebuilt and that is what comforts me," a resident, Emuna Ben-Yona told The Associated Press. She said her mother was shot and killed by Palestinians nearby six years ago.

The U.S. has long criticized all settlements as obstacles to peace, since they are built on captured land that the Palestinians claim for a future state. At their White House meeting Monday, Obama told Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu that "settlements have to be stopped."

Despite Netanyahu's pledges to remove outposts, he believes that authorized settlements should continue to expand to allow for what Israel calls "natural growth" of the population.

In a television interview, U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton voiced the toughest criticism to date of settlement construction.

"First, we want to see a stop to settlement construction, additions, natural growth, any kind of settlement activity," she told Al-Jazeera this week.

Israeli peace activist Dror Etkes said dismantling Maoz Esther _ one of the newest, smallest outposts _ was a tiny gesture. "It is far, far away from being something significant in changing the reality in the West Bank," he said.

Etkes said the Israeli government had allowed other larger outposts to remain and grow over the last two years in spite of evacuation orders.

___

Associated Press writer Dalia Nammari contributed to this report.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST WORLD

JERUSALEM — Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu insisted Thursday that all of Jerusalem will always remain under Israeli sovereignty, taking a hard line on a key Israeli-Palestinian peace ...
JERUSALEM — Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu insisted Thursday that all of Jerusalem will always remain under Israeli sovereignty, taking a hard line on a key Israeli-Palestinian peace ...
Filed by Stuart Whatley  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 352
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BLUEBIRD1234
A POLITICAL ANALYST
01:18 PM on 05/30/2009
For the first time breath fresh air and believes that they would be getting back to seat in UNO
With dignity and safe from humiliation by a audacious arrogant and ill-mannered state in the name of being the best friend the only ally of USA. Not only that this state violated UNO resolutions and used USA in its entire wrong doings that brought defamed USA throughout the world. To the extent, when USA's Ex-President was called a devil in front of hundreds of delegation attending the UNO's General Session in New York. We gulped the insult and now time has come we can and should no more be allowed ourselves be insulted for others audacious criminal acts and no faults of ours but for only such continuous horrendous deeds of others which is unacceptable to the international body.

We realize the horrifying days the Palestinians confronted and are still facing these inhuman acts of Israel. It is shocking as to how this Israel evaded its horrifying activities all these past years and dared use the armaments given by our country it for its self defense and it took the liberty of using the same for inhuman activities.
I am confident President OBAMA will by the grace of the Almighty GOD be able to bring an end to this long outstanding problem. And ensure permanent stoppage of human slaughtering by neighboring country Israel and Hamas however, more or less they kill.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
omobob
left coast, usa
10:42 AM on 05/28/2009
Historically Jerusalem has always been a meeting place for Christian, Jew and Moslem. As long as free access was granted to all worshippers, Jerusalem has remained fairly peaceful. However when one religious power denies access, people tend to get bent out of shape. Why should the Arabs make peace? If I was an Arab leader I would never make terms with Israel. That is natural: we have taken their country." – David Ben Gurion, 1956
04:29 PM on 05/26/2009
Right now people from every religion can go worship at the holy site of their choosing because Israel has freedom of religion. If the eastern half of Jerusalem is given to the Palestinians, they will only allow Muslims to go to the holy sites. The most important thing in the holy city of 3 religions is freedom of religion, and the only party who will enforce it is Israel. The Palestinians have neither the will nor the ability to enforce freedom of religion, so it is better for everyone if Israel continues to rule over all of Jerusalem.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
omobob
left coast, usa
11:25 AM on 05/28/2009
Please don’t make it sound like the Israelis are doing the Jerusalem worshipping world a favor while they keep their boots on the necks of the Palestinians. Never forget Israel is the result of mass illegal immigration and a Jewish campaign of terror bombings and killings against the British Government.
photo
jwcmass
I dream of things that never were and ask Why not
12:38 AM on 05/29/2009
The exception you son't mention is the Palestinians in Gaza and from the West Bank (and those living in refugee camps outside Israel and the Occupied Territories.

They are not allowed into Jerusalem at all. I know someone will say that this is because of past acts of terrorism, but then I would have to reply that this is an act of collective punishment.

Also, the above statement is simply NOT FACTUALLY TRUE.

As far as a solution, I would suggest the Palestinian state govern Palestinian East Jerusalem, and the two states JOINTLY govern the OLD CITY --which is where the religious sites are located.
12:29 AM on 05/24/2009
Relevant International Ruling:
UN Resolution 478
Affirms that the enactment of the "basic law" by Israel constitutes a violation of international law and does not affect the continued application of the Fourth Geneva Convention of 12 August 1949 Relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War in the Palestinian and other Arab territories occupied since June 1967, including Jerusalem;
http://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Foreign%20Relations/Israels%20Foreign%20Relations%20since%201947/1979-1980/117%20Security%20Council%20Resolution%20478%20-1980-%20on%20Jeru
BubbaC33
Jimmy Buffett is the greatest American
11:01 AM on 05/24/2009
The UN can pass whatever it wants, but that does not change the fact that Jerusalem is our eternal and indivisible capital.
11:14 AM on 05/24/2009
Unqualified Statement:
Israel is openly violating the Geneva Conventions.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Freenation
04:26 PM on 05/22/2009
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/1087483.html

"France: Jerusalem should be capital of two states"
BubbaC33
Jimmy Buffett is the greatest American
05:25 PM on 05/22/2009
Quoting Haaretz is about the same as quoting Matt Drudge, neither is very accurate.
06:53 AM on 05/25/2009
French President Nicolas Sarkozy had told Israeli lawmakers this in a speech last year.

"Actions such as the destruction of Palestinian homes or the transformation of Arab districts risk provoking an escalation in violence. They are unacceptable and contrary to international law,"
RTIII
Poster of over 0.0135% of all HufPost comments
09:44 AM on 05/22/2009
To make this statement is ALSO to make the statement that _something_ will be divided - or at least is on the table for discussion.
.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Khirad
09:16 AM on 05/22/2009
Major 'duh' factor:

Mideast 'extremists' have found their best possible ally in Netanyahu
http://www.dailystar.com.lb/article.asp?edition_id=10&categ_id=17&article_id=102157
08:45 AM on 05/22/2009
"FOR months we have been suffering under the torture of a problem which the Versailles Diktat created-a problem which has deteriorated until it becomes intolerable for us. Danzig was and is a German city. The Corridor was and is German. Both these territories owe their cultural development exclusively to the German people. Danzig was separated from us, the Corridor was annexed by Poland. As in other German territories of the East, all German minorities living there have been ill-treated in the most distressing manner. More than 1,000,000 people of German blood had in the years 1919-20 to leave their homeland."
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Khirad
09:00 AM on 05/22/2009
Königsberg as well.
BubbaC33
Jimmy Buffett is the greatest American
11:29 AM on 05/23/2009
This has nothing to do with the current situation in Israel.
06:13 AM on 05/22/2009
East Jerusalem was captured in a defensive war from Jordan, not from the Palestinians. From 1948 to 1967, the city was ruled by the Jordanians, and it never occurred to them to make it a capital of a Palestinian state. (BTW, if the so called Palestinians wanted to create their state, they had this chance in 1948 - by the UN partition plan; last time I checked, they blew this opportunity.)
BubbaC33
Jimmy Buffett is the greatest American
02:39 PM on 05/22/2009
Be careful, using facts on this site will certainly bring down the wrath of the uninformed on you.
03:50 PM on 05/22/2009
The uninformed have brought much wrath upon my comments.
11:16 AM on 05/23/2009
Did you expect in 1948 the Palestinians to jump up and down with joy, and to welcome the Jews to take their land and homes? The establishment of Israel within the territorial confines of how we, the British and French did it , under the aegis of UN Resolution, made it, under international law, a legal entity, without question. But by the same legal principle, international law rrecognizes the rights of Palestinians in the rest of the land. Since that time Israel has done everything to enlarge itself, and to further purge the land of Palestinians. It's time for all three countries to return the thumbed noses given to them by Israel, and particularly the US which bankrolled deveolopment of Israel. How naive we were to expect gratitude from the Israelis and to expect them not to connive an enlargement at the loss of Palestinian life and land from state terrorism practiced toward the Palestinians from Israel's Day One. It's time to get forceful with Israel. For starters there is always the possibiility of an economic embargo, followed by a boycott in the US of Gentiles refusing to buy goods from Jewish owned stores. The tide will turn when the screws really turn. Let's face it: The AJC has put the screws to us through the maneuvers of AIPAC. AIPAC should be required to register itself as an agent of a foreign country; donations to it and Israel directly should not be allowed as a tax write-off.
BubbaC33
Jimmy Buffett is the greatest American
11:46 AM on 05/23/2009
What an amazingly foolish posting kirby has offered, one that is absolutely wrong in fact and in conclusions. Added to that is the illegal and unethical suggestion made by the poster, one which should be condemned by any thinking, reasonable person.
In 1947 Israel accepted the UN partition plan, the Arabs did not. Which means the Arabs cannot seek redress under the terms of that agreement. Without an acceptance of the partition plan, a contract, the Arabs cannot seek to make claims provided by the contract. Given the attacks on Israel in 1947-49 the Arabs also forfeited any claim to land taken by Israel in its defense.
In 1947 as soon as Israel accepted the partition plan the Arabs bgan an attack. Some of these attacks were undertaken under the watchful eyes of the Brit authorities. The fact of the matter is kirby has terribly misstated the attacks that started in 1947. Israel was attacked, we did not start the conflict.
The worst parts of the kirby posting arre his suggestions that are clearly anti-Semitic and illegal under US law, not to mention in violation of UN sanctions against an embargo against Israel. The idea that goyim should boycott a business simply because it is Jewish-owned is despicable. The idea that contributions to Israeli charities should be removed from tax-write-offs is just as despicable.
Kirby is wrong.
11:52 AM on 05/23/2009
1. The question was why the Arabs didn't take the opportunity to create their own state, as decided by the UN in 1948? You do not mention even a word about that failure (and no, Israel didn't prevent them from doing this, and yes, they attacked Israel).

2. There was no political movement to establish a Palestinian state till after the '67 war - until then, Gaza and the West Bank were administerred by Jordan and Egypt. So no Palestinian cared to ask for establishment of their own state on territories under Arab administration - but as soon as Israel captured those territories in a war, they readily began to claim their state rights, skipping the fact, that those lands were Jordanian and Egyptian, not "Palestinian".

3. When you choose to reply, do reply, do not spin.
01:33 AM on 05/22/2009
This Israeli administration is populated by settlers and settler supporters who believe they are entitled to commit acts of ethnic cleansing and maintain a system of apartheid until the ethnic cleansing is complete. Both former president Carter, a man who did more for middle east peace than any other president, and bishop TuTu have said that what is happening in the ocupied territories is WORSE than apartheid.

3/4 of our elected officials in Washington, in a letter sent to Obama in order to undermine his efforts and support the policies of a foreign government, have seen fit to give cover to this brutal system and allow it the latitude necessary to expand settlements by insisting on terms that make peace nearly unachievable, and therefore putting US citizens and interests at danger by allowing this ongoing, despicable system to inspire more blow back terror against the US.

I can only attribute such behavior to cowardice, greed, and pathological self involvement.
01:49 AM on 05/22/2009
And the PC Palestinians want to inter- marry and live in harmony with ALL races, creeds and cultures.
Especially the Jews.
02:21 AM on 05/22/2009
Natalieonine, please attempt to know what you talking about when you make remarks like the above.
It is Jews who are dismayed by intermarriage. At the base of Judeaism is a fervent desire for "purity", if you don't believe me go read Nehemiah and Ezra.
Google the terms Jewish and Assimilation and read the angst filled articles that come up, moslems are much more tolerant of "the other" than are either Christians or Jews.
02:33 AM on 05/22/2009
Israel removed all the settlers in Sinai. Then Israel removed all the settlers in Gaza. Israel offered to remove the settlers in the West Bank in return for a peace agreement and a two state solution at the Camp David meetings hosted by President Clinton. The Palestinians rejected the offer and launched an illegal war killing thousands on both sides. Jimmy Carter will go down in history as one of the biggest failures, especially in his post presidency. If the Palestinians have their way, all Jews will be ethnically cleansed----it is what they say in their mosques, their media, and government.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hdaryl01
02:42 AM on 05/22/2009
Isreal currently illegally occupies Palestinian land in Gaza, East Jerusalem, and the West Bank. Isreali settlements in these areas is in direct contravention of UN Resolution 242 from 1967.

Isreal is the aggressor-illegal occupying country. The Palestinians are defending, and asserting their rights, as recognized by the UN over 40 years ago.

The Camp David offer would have preserved Isreali settlements, given the Palestinians no control of their borders, ceded airspace rights to isrealis, and..........
\
A BS false offer.
photo
jwcmass
I dream of things that never were and ask Why not
02:57 AM on 05/22/2009
You have omitted a few critical items in your history review.

First, Jimmy Carter. Israel oews a great deal to him, for by securing peace with Egypt, he essentially protected Israel's entire Southern Front, and made it much easier to protect herself. That peace accord has held through all the turmoil that has followed since, and Egypt was, far and away, Israel's biggest threat.

Think how differently Israel might have fared during the Leabanon Wars and the Intefadas if it also had to deal with Egypt (and likely Syria also) interfering. There might be a lot more people alive today who otherwise would not be because of that peace agreement and Jimmy Carter.

As for the Palestinians, I would remind you of the words of Thomas Jefferson in the Declaration of Independence-- "we hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their creator with certain unienable rights.. among these life, liberty, pursuit of happiness."

He went on to say that if a government became destructive of these rights --if if became tyrannical, then the people had not only a right, but a DUTY to alter or abolish it.

Israel IS, without due process, oppressing the natural rights of the Palestinians. Israel must live with the consequences. The longer this goes on, the worse, not better it will get.
01:15 AM on 05/22/2009
Jerusalem is the capital of Israel. Arabs live there. Christians live there and Jews live there. But it is and will be administered by Israel. Israel took it from Jordan, and is not giving it back to Jordan or anyone else. Palestinian Arabs are now managing Temple Mount. That is more than enough.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hdaryl01
01:36 AM on 05/22/2009
According to who? Isreal can dictate policy to the world, and act according to its twisted logic, as soon as it starts to pay its own freight, and isn't subsidized by the US to the tune of $6 Billion per year, or over $100 Billion since 1949. Isreal has, for the last 40 plus years, been the single largest recipient per capita of US aid on the planet (except Iraq).

Isreal is pretty confident, considering it has never been autonomous, and self supporting...............

Many in the US, including me, are losing patience with Isreal, and are tired of being lied to about Isreali perpetrated atrocities against the Palestinians, Syrians, Lebanese, and Egyptians. We no longer support unequivocal support of, and acquisence to Isreali arrogance.
BubbaC33
Jimmy Buffett is the greatest American
09:03 AM on 05/23/2009
Jerusalem is the historic capital of Israel, nothing can change that fact. Until 1967 we were prohibited from worshipping at some of the holiest sites of the Jewish faith. So, we will not give up Jerusalem.
About your patience. I spoke with Bibi and told him he replied that he had already lost patience with you so it was a push.
photo
MajorKong
If the pilot's good, see, I mean if he's reeeally
01:44 AM on 05/22/2009
Ah, the old "we took it" argument.

Then by that logic I guess the Russians should still control Eastern Europe. After all, they took it in a defensive war after being attacked.
OpposingViewpoint
Sometimes you get and sometimes you get got
01:59 AM on 05/22/2009
The old "we took it" logic is alive and well in the US as well. The southwest from Mexico and much of the remaining US real estate from the Native Americans. Uhhh.....we never gave it back.
BubbaC33
Jimmy Buffett is the greatest American
05:30 PM on 05/22/2009
No, your analogy is wrong and not appilcable. The Russians were not attacked by the nations of eastern Europe, but by Nazi Germany. IN the armistice argeement ownership of land was resolved. And the war ended. Egypt and Jordan have signed peace treaties with Israel, but other Arab nations are still technically at war with Israel.
12:27 AM on 05/22/2009
Look at these fools in the middle east. They can't hold a functioning country together because they're all busy fighting each other over which GOD is the TRUE GOD. The US needs to stop supporting Israel when they are clearly a stubborn, pushy country. They really believe that they are the chosen people. They are not the chosen people. If the US wants to intervene in other countries wars and ways then they need to do it right. Palestine has a border. Israel has a border. They are TWO states. Israels thieving of Palestinian land is criminal and needs to be stopped. WE FUND ISRAEL. WE CAN CHOSE NOT TO.
12:16 AM on 05/22/2009
The last time Jerusalem was divided was between 1948 and 1967. In 1948 Jordan expelled all the Jews of East Jerusalem, without property, on 24 hours notice. These people and their decendants had lived there for centuries. East Jerusalem had been majority Jewish since 1860. These people had committed no crime, did not attempt to fight against the Jordanians and did not seek to become a part of Israel. After they were ethnically cleansed, Jordan destroyed 52 synagogues, Jewish cultural centers, and grave yards. In 1967, they had announced plans to destroy the western wall, sacred to Jews everywhere. To say that somehow East Jerusalem is Palestinian makes no sense to me given the history of the city.
07:11 PM on 05/25/2009
Hmm; so Jordan had the power to expell all the Jews, yet unlike the Jews at Deir Yassin and many other Palestinian villages, they did not resort to the massacre of the population, interestling. And of course the Jewish forces, in violation of the secrect agreement between Jordan and Israel that kept the army of Jordan out of the war (and since Jordan was also given control of the Iragi forces those were also kept out of most of the fighting) did attack and try to take Jerusalem. Maybe you should strudy some history besides what is taught (mostly propaganda) in the Israeli school system, that still teaches that the Arab nations told the Palestilnians to leave their homes.
11:48 PM on 05/21/2009
Isreal wants to do to the Palenstinians what America did to the Native Americans. They want to commit genocide on the natives who have been there for thousands of years. They will not compromise or negotiate for a true two party state. Isreal want to be a Jewish state period. They want the Palenstinians to move to other surrounding muslim states. Period. Who will stop Isreal-no ONe
OpposingViewpoint
Sometimes you get and sometimes you get got
11:55 PM on 05/21/2009
Who stopped the early settlers in America in their cru*sade against the Native Americans? Nobody!!!!! There was no compromise and little or no meaningful negotiation. Where is your post demanding the return of all sovereign lands in this country to the Native Americans? Who will stop you?
07:14 PM on 05/25/2009
I'm just wondering OV why you seem to be so pissed off that the Native American lands were taken but at the same time take the opposite view that it's OK the Israelies to take the land that belonged to the Palestinians.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:38 AM on 05/22/2009
Interesting, you're an expert on this subject (laugh) yet the proper spelling of Israel is beyond your grasp.