iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Headscarf Martyr Marwa Sherbini Mourned In Egypt

MAGGIE MICHAEL   07/ 6/09 04:06 PM ET   AP

Mideast Egypt Germany

CAIRO — Thousands of Egyptian mourners marched behind the coffin of the "martyr of the head scarf" on Monday _ a pregnant Muslim woman who was stabbed to death in a German courtroom as her young son watched.

Many in her homeland were outraged by the attack and saw the low key response in Germany as an example of racism and anti-Muslim sentiment.

Her husband was critically wounded in the attack Wednesday in Dresden when he tried to intervene and was stabbed by the attacker and accidentally shot by court security.

"There is no god but God and the Germans are the enemies of God," chanted the mourners for 32-year-old Marwa al-Sherbini in her hometown of Alexandria, where her body was buried after being flown back from Germany.

"We will avenge her killing," her brother Tarek el-Sherbini told The Associated Press by telephone from the mosque where prayers were being recited in front of his sister's coffin. "In the West, they don't recognize us. There is racism."

Al-Sherbini, who was about four months pregnant and wore the Islamic head scarf, was involved in a court case against her neighbor for calling her a terrorist and was set to testify against him when he stabbed her 18 times inside the courtroom in front of her 3-year-old son.

Her husband, who was in Germany on a research fellowship, came to her aid and was also stabbed by the neighbor and shot in the leg by a security guard who initially mistook him for the attacker, German prosecutors said. He is now in critical condition in a German hospital, according to al-Sherbini's brother.

"The guards thought that as long as he wasn't blond, he must be the attacker so they shot him," al-Sherbini told an Egyptian television station.

The man, who has only been identified as 28-year-old Alex W., remains in detention and prosecutors have opened an investigation on suspicion of murder.

Christian Avenarius, the prosecutor in Dresden where the incident took place, described the killer as driven by a deep hatred of Muslims. "It was very clearly a xenophobic attack of a fanatical lone wolf."

He added that the attacker was a Russian of German descent who had immigrated to Germany in 2003 and had expressed his contempt for Muslims at the start of the trial.

At its regular news conference on Monday, a German government spokesman Thomas Steg said if the attack was racist, the government "naturally condemns this in the strongest terms."

The killing has dominated Egyptian media for days, while it has received comparatively little coverage in German and Western media.

A German Muslim group criticized government officials and the media for not paying enough attention to the crime.

"The incident in Dresden had anti-Islamic motives. So far, the reactions from politicians and media have been incomprehensibly meager," Aiman Mazyek, the general secretary of the Central Council of Muslims, told Berlin's Tagesspiegel daily.

Egyptian commentators said the incident was an example of how hate crimes against Muslims are overlooked in comparison to those committed by Muslims against Westerners. Many commentators pointed to the uproar that followed the 2004 murder of filmmaker Theo van Gogh by a Dutch-born Islamic fundamentalist angry over one of his films criticizing the treatment of Muslim women.

Abdel Azeem Hamad, chief editor of the independent Egyptian daily el-Shorouk, said that if the victim had been a Jew, there would have been an uproar.

"What we demand is just some attention to be given to the killing of a young innocent mother on the hands of fanatic extremist," he wrote in his column.

An Egyptian blogger Hicham Maged, wrote "let us play the 'What If' game."

"Just imagine if the situation was reversed and the victim was a Westerner who was stabbed anywhere in the world or _ God forbid _ in any Middle Eastern country by Muslim extremists," he said.

The Egyptian Pharmacists' Association called for a boycott of German drugs. The victim was a pharmacist.

According to numerous interviews in Egyptian local papers with el-Sherbini family, the man who stabbed al-Sherbini used to accuse her of being a "terrorist," and in one incident, he tried to take off her head scarf. Mourners at her funeral called her the "martyr of the head scarf."

Laila Shams, al-Sherbini's mother, told the el-Wafd daily that her daughter said she'd difficulty finding a job in Germany because of her head scarf.

"One (employer) suggested she remove her head scarf to get a job. She said no," she said.

Officials from a German Muslim group and the country's main Jewish group made a joint visit Monday to the Dresden hospital where the victim's husband is being treated.

"You don't have to be a Muslim to act against anti-Muslim behavior, and you don't have to be a Jew to act against anti-Semitism," said Stephan Kramer, the general secretary of the Central Council of Jews.

__

Associated Press Writer Geir Moulson in Berlin contributed to this report.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST WORLD

CAIRO — Thousands of Egyptian mourners marched behind the coffin of the "martyr of the head scarf" on Monday _ a pregnant Muslim woman who was stabbed to death in a German courtroom as her young...
CAIRO — Thousands of Egyptian mourners marched behind the coffin of the "martyr of the head scarf" on Monday _ a pregnant Muslim woman who was stabbed to death in a German courtroom as her young...
Filed by Stuart Whatley  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 110
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
01:49 PM on 07/10/2009
i cant accept it when you say the police accidentally shot the husband?think of thar poor pregnant lady?think of the child?the suffering the kid went through?can he have a normal life again after seeing her mother stabbed in front of his own eyes?wake up people we are all human beings.there is plenty of everything on earth for all of us.why should we hate or fight with each other?she had head scarf,ok, let her have it, but give her the choice to choose what seems right to her.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FCBarca
Anther wrld is not only pssible, she is on her way
02:10 AM on 07/09/2009
Tragic...Islamophobia, fueled by W and perpetuated the world over by more ignorant people.

Still, the muted response is astonishing...Not only at the murder but the initial hate crime attack in the first place that led Marwa to have to go to court in the first place...Had this occurred to a Jewish woman?...Honestly, this would've never happened.

We seem to be disengaged from the suffering of some people while based on their religion...And on the flip side of that spectrum, rushing to support suffering of other religions.

We're all the same
08:42 AM on 07/07/2009
Marwa el-Sherbini's tragic murder reveals the uglier side of Islamophobia and should've got more attention in the Western media. But likewise, we should also ask ourselves why doesn't the prejudice and discrimination against non-hijabed women and converts to Christianity in Egypt and other Muslim countries not stir up more outrage in the Egyptian media?

Here's a piece I wrote on the issue: http://chronikler.com/middle-east/egypt/hijab-and-dagger/
01:16 PM on 07/07/2009
Back to reality.
This murder doesn't reveal anything.
It only reveals actions of one man who was universally condemned and is awaiting trial.
Lemme guess, there will be a few McDonalds burned in Egypt today. Encouraged by irresponsible statements from know-it-alls who would have trouble finding Dresden on the map.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:25 PM on 07/07/2009
"It only reveals actions of one man who was universally condemned and is awaiting trial."

Would've a massacre made a better point? Isn't that what has been happening for centuries to that group of people?
10:24 PM on 07/06/2009
Clearly the guards were complicit. How do you get stabbed 18 times in a court room!? Poor Marwa and her unborn, and her husband.
10:11 AM on 07/09/2009
There were no guards - this kind of thing is simply not expected in a German courtroom; uniformed security is absent except in exceptional cases (defendant is on remand; people present who have a history of violence/organized crime/terrorism. According to http://www.fr-online.de/in_und_ausland/politik/aktuell/1827814_Landgericht-Dresden-Messerattacke-gibt-Raetsel-auf.html the only people in the room were: three judges, the prosecutor, the defendant, the defendant's lawyer, Mrs. Sherbini, her husband and her three-year old son. The murderer's lawyer threw a chair at him and the victim's husband grappled with him - then the policeman (who waited to testify in another case) arrived, saw two men fighting...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
emmeaki
05:37 PM on 07/17/2009
"Clearly the guards were complicit. How do you get stabbed 18 times in a court room!? Poor Marwa and her unborn, and her husband."

Or even get close enough to stab her in the first place?
09:45 PM on 07/06/2009
Has any of you realized that an innocent young women died because of pure racism?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
longtimegone
my micro-bio remains empty
11:22 PM on 07/06/2009
Many times as I've tried to make that point; one wonders why the moderator won't allow that simple truth to be voiced.
09:40 AM on 07/07/2009
This innocent young woman died because of the action of one individual. Killing regardless of motivation, be it greed, hatred or simple indifference for human life is wrong and should be punished the same way.
03:30 PM on 07/13/2009
Yeah, one individual who was not motivated by culture or media at all. Nope, he grew up in a Skinner Box, completely closed off from the racism of other human beings.
09:08 PM on 07/06/2009
What else can be expected form Germans?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:23 PM on 07/06/2009
Any specific reason for this urge to be so anti-German?
01:19 AM on 07/07/2009
Take a lot the comments from your fellows.

Also take a look at the history of Germany.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:20 PM on 07/06/2009
Well, that comment is pure racism.
01:19 AM on 07/07/2009
What happened to your last account?
06:17 AM on 07/07/2009
"An Islam is not a 'race' the last time I checked."

German is not a 'race' the last time I checked.

;)
09:02 PM on 07/06/2009
""One (employer) suggested she remove her head scarf to get a job. She said no,"

What would happen to a Western woman if she appeared without a head scarf in many Muslim countries, say Iran or Saudi Arabia?
01:22 AM on 07/07/2009
Western women in Saudi Arabia don't take scarf. Westerners works in some oil fields in SA and over there they carry their own lifestyle.

But this is non of your problem. You frustration lies somewhere else.
09:25 AM on 07/07/2009
Women can not hold that many jobs in Saudi Arabia so that is an asinine question.
08:57 PM on 07/06/2009
""Just imagine if the situation was reversed and the victim was a Westerner who was stabbed anywhere in the world or _ God forbid _ in any Middle Eastern country by Muslim extremists," he said.

You do not have to imagine it. What about the busload of European tourists killed in Egypt.

While I would very much like to see Egypt's antiquities, as a Westerner and Christian I would not feel safe in Egypt.
09:37 AM on 07/07/2009
I am still waiting for the muslim protest for that tragedy.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:42 PM on 07/07/2009
Why are you waiting for exactly a Muslim protest? It should be Christian, Jewish, Buddhist, etc. protest of anyone who cares about human rights.
08:45 PM on 07/06/2009
""The guards thought that as long as he wasn't blond, he must be the attacker so they shot him," al-Sherbini told an Egyptian television station."

What nonesense. The majority of Germans are not blond.
09:20 PM on 07/06/2009
Hilarious!

How you come back over and over and dig some sentences to spin according to your frustration.

LMAO!
photo
LMPE
I connect the most dissimilar things
06:38 PM on 07/06/2009
Gee, Germany. Can't you ever avoid this stuff?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:44 PM on 07/06/2009
What do officials mean if the attack was racist? Ya think when he has been hating on Muslims for a long time. They should send the perpetrator to Egypt and let them take car of him.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ergon
Man From Atlan
05:09 PM on 07/06/2009
If Theo Van Gogh had been wearing a burqa when he was stabbed the silence would have been deafening..
12:42 PM on 07/07/2009
Clueless as always.
03:25 PM on 07/13/2009
Were you talking about yourself?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:35 PM on 07/06/2009
Don't forget that the attacker was Russian--German, not just "European" or "Westener," and that currently in Russia there is a rise in neo-Nazism.
09:00 PM on 07/06/2009
LOL

You really don't know what the Issue is. Read the article carefully.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:21 PM on 07/06/2009
And you do? Quote from the article: "He added that the attacker was a Russian of German descent who had immigrated to Germany in 2003 and had expressed his contempt for Muslims at the start of the trial."
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:26 PM on 07/06/2009
Quote from the article: "He added that the attacker was a Russian of German descent who had immigrated to Germany in 2003 and had expressed his contempt for Muslims at the start of the trial."
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:39 PM on 07/06/2009
An Egyptian blogger Hicham Maged, wrote "let us play the 'What If' game."

"Just imagine if the situation was reversed and the victim was a Westerner who was stabbed anywhere in the world or _ God forbid _ in any Middle Eastern country by Muslim extremists," he said.

We don't have to play the what if game, there are thousands of examples of Muslim attackers against Europeans and their brothers. 911, the London bomb!ngs, the dutch filmmaker, Daniel Pearl, and thousands of other Europeans and Americans that have been tortured and murdered by Muslim Extremists. Then there are all the murders and crimes of Muslim immigrants into European countries, don't even get me started on that one.
04:53 PM on 07/06/2009
Oh no you didn't! Lets look at the millions of middle Easterners who have suffered because of European greed start with the crusades, colonization after WWI, the British mandates that established Israel and the murdered and tortured Palestinians, Egyptians and other Arabs, The French colonists who tortured the citizens of Algeria.And that is just to begin with. How about the establishment of the Saudi Monarchs so they can suppress and torture their own people in order to please their European masters. How about The Shah and his role in thwarting Democracy in Iran with the help of Europe. You want more How about that law of physics that says, " Every action has a reaction equal in force and opposite in direction" better known as KARMA. Europe reaps what it sows so learn to live with the rest of the world in peace and stop your whining when your imperialist plans go awry.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:21 PM on 07/06/2009
Do you want "start with the crusades" because prior to that were centuries of unprovoked Islamic aggression against Christians, Hindus, Chinese and other groups?

Or do you have some other explanation of Muslim armies in France in the 800's, two centuries before the first Crusade?

Or how about the centuries of Ottoman occupation of their fellow Muslims, the Greeks, Bulgarians, Serbs and others?
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
pfrogger
06:23 PM on 07/06/2009
well said.
nailed it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
davidwayneosedach
03:36 PM on 07/06/2009
This is not a good time with blond hair and blue eyes to visit Egypt.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
LiberTLover
04:00 PM on 07/06/2009
But if you did, I'll bet they won't say no to your money for hotels, restaurants, souvenirs and sightseeing.