Mass. Hospital Sues Over Cost Of Universal Health Care

The New York Times:

A hospital that serves thousands of indigent Massachusetts residents sued the state on Wednesday, charging that its costly universal health care law is forcing the hospital to cover too much of the expense of caring for the poor.

Read the whole story: The New York Times

Comments

[GoodFeathers]

People who says the universal health insurance will cost a lot. They forget one thing. That is, their cost analysis is based on the current "for-profit" system. As soon as the government takes control of the health insurance, the cost will come down drastically. Government is not in this to make profit. Government is for the people, by the people and to the people.

Please visit this site: http://www.pnhp.org/facts/singlepayer_faq.php

[dali partin]

People who say this also ignore the fact that emergency room care is expensive and that the prices we all pay today already factor in the people that can't pay for their ER visit - and the fact that these people had no access to preventative care.

[PaxEterna]

HP has not once posted a comment I have placed that actually tells the public how it goes down in MA, and how much it costs.

I have tried multiple times to put FACTS up here for the public to judge.

I am under the impression that they don't want the public to know.

If they publish this, I urge all readers to investigate what is happening in MA.

The system is BROKEN, and breaking the backs of middle class workers, small business, and it is a bogus system where the insurance industry controls the entire game and those who pay get something, but those who can't pay (we're talking 20% of your income) get steered to third world hospitals, docs, plans etc.

SINGLE PAYER NOW!

[BlackWidowPilot]

The vaunted "Texas At-Risk Health Pool" is no different here in the Lone Star State. Blue Shield/Blue Cross administers the whole racket, and pockets the profits from an ostensibly state run program.

Premiums and deductibles under this system are simply unsustainable.

Leland R. Erickson

Citizen

[4real]

Take ALL profit out of healthcare. Why should anyone benefit because people get sick? The whole system is twisted.

[Chaimirija]

38 million deficit this year

190 million in reserves

[apoyo]

My kid goes to school in Mass. and is required to buy a health insurance plan each year. We have a health insurance HMO but it won't cover her out of state because it is only for local coverage even though it was bought out by a national health insurance company.

Figure that one out.

When you buy auto insurance are you restricted to your local area or are you able to drive anywhere in the country with full coverage?

As long as health insurance companies control health care it will continue to be costly and rationed.

[DanniD]

So when did Mass. get Universal Health Care?

Come on people. Think! It's not illegal...yet!

[jsgaetano]

> So when did Mass. get Universal Health Care?

A year or two ago. Check The Google.

[NoOneSpecial]

They didn't. MA doesn't have a true universal health care system, nor is it anything close to resembling single-payer. They used mandates and kept the for-profit companies in the plan.

[kitkatborn]

In Alachua County, Fl They have a program called "Choices" which is advertised as being for the working uninsured. I'm not familiar with it, just saying.

[BlackWidowPilot]

We have a system here in Texas, the "Texas At-Risk Health Pool." It is to put it bluntly, a scam that puts high-cost premium payments with high-cost deductibles directly into the coffers of Blue Shield/Blue Cross. At no time does one interact with a Texas state employee once you've been drawn in to this State of Texas sanctioned farce of a program.

The costs were for my family and I simply unsustainable.

I remain one of the 47 million Americans shut out of affordable healthcare.

Clearly what the Blue Shield/Blue Cross broker I spoke to seven years ago said still holds true; I'm "...not profitable enough" for the private insurance racketeers, as I am self-employed and have degenerative arthritis.

Clearly in the eyes of the for-profit insurance racketeers, I remain *expendable.*

Leland R. Erickson

Citizen

[wdw505]

so you want to lower everyone's standard of care to bring yours up......wow

[sandiegoconservative]

And once you get your universal healthcare, don't cry when your tax increase. Or when your other "benefits" decrease, or when the government tells you your ailments fall into their "rationing" strategy. It will come, my friend.

[kitkatborn]

I find it interesting they are paid 64 cents on the dollar as opposed to nothing without this program and they are still complaining?

[jsgaetano]

Typical "fiscal conservatives". No matter how big the handout, it's never big enough.

[Chaimirija]

We agree on something!

[GhostNyc]

I wonder what it would be like if Police officers and Firemen worked along similar principles?

Your home is on fire and the firemen show up and the first question they ask - Do you have insurance? And if you don't have enough- would it be fair to only save a portion of your home?

[katooom]

No. The question should be - "Do you pay taxes", then they decide if they save your home or not.

[wndrwrthg]

There have been reported cases where that exact thing has occurred. Because taxes and fees were not paid, services were withheld, resulting in the loss of property. I cannot give specifics but within the past ten years there have been several instances.

[jsgaetano]

Since conservatives don't want to pay taxes, maybe this plan could work.

Just identify the "fiscal conservatives", and tell the police/fire/ambulance to not respond to them.

[wdw505]

yes if insurance was their only source of funds.........i would be ok with that concept

[Agent420]

You still don't get it. Nobody cares what you think, little boy. A word of advice, stay away from priests.

[ResistanceisFutile]

In Wisconsin I carry auto insurance protection from the uninsured driver and the under insured driver. Auto insurance isn't even mandatory in this backward state.

I'll be forced to carry insurance under Obama's plan and if I don't I'll be fined $2,500. The only health insurance I can get is through the State of Wisconsin at a yearly cost of $20,000.

I am more concerned with someone injuring me in an auto accident and not having enough medical coverage then with falling ill due to disease.

The point of the comment is that anyway my elected representatives try to help they will and have, in fact, hurt me financially.

[Chaimirija]

Couple other points about WI: at any given time 20% of the drivers on the road are intoxicated...why? you might ask? Because you can get up to...4?...and it is still not a big deal...

[thegreatgiginthesky]

Mandating people to buy private health insurance is not Universal healthcare.

[Chaimirija]

well, Obama said his goal now is universal COVERAGE....

[PWM]

He has to start somewhere.

[thegreatgiginthesky]

This is where State run hospitals come in handy. India has a system where you have private hospitals and government run facilities. People who are poor go to the government run hospitals and the people who can afford private care go to the private hospitals. No harm no foul.

[Sam1234567]

Yeah lets model ourselves after a country that has cast systems, and rampant poverty.

[ywcachieve]

That sounds like the US.

[PWM]

Like the US

[Dynamohum]

Oh that sounds real fair.....NOT!! This if foul and is HARM. Good luck to you if you ever lose a job and are forced into government care!!

[mergina]

The 1st of many. Why is Obama cutting his political throat on this?

[mharg11]

72% of citizens favor revamping the health care system. I don't think that is cutting ones throat. Maybe you would like for it to be, but that will never happen once the health care bill passes.

[wdw505]

not 72% of the voters.......

[sandiegoconservative]

Revamping is different than what is being proposed. I would say 72% of the slobs who don't want to work to take care of themselves would love someone to pay for their healthcare . . .

[GhostNyc]

Are the doctors complaining or the HMO that controls the hospital?

The health care debates over who is covered, who is not, who makes money, who spends it...is all avoiding the main question...how much is your life worth to you? or how much is the life of your child worth to you? Enough to go bankrupt a hundred times over?

Its not health care its extortion.

[jackbauer05]

I meant forced to buy, sorry.