Ruth Madoff Sued For $44.8 Million 'Clawback' By Trustee
NEW YORK — The trustee overseeing the liquidation of Bernard Madoff's assets sued the disgraced money manager's wife on Wednesday, asking for nearly $45 million that he says was spent on "a life of splendor."
Trustee Irving H. Picard spelled out his claims in a lawsuit against Ruth Madoff in U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Manhattan. Ruth Madoff several weeks ago moved out of a $7 million Manhattan penthouse where she and her husband had lived during their 49-year marriage.
Ruth Madoff's lawyer, Peter Chavkin, said in a statement that Picard's action was "wrong as a matter of law and fairness."
He said the lawsuit was "particularly perplexing and totally unjustified" because his client has already forfeited to the federal prosecutor's office nearly all of the assets described in the lawsuit.
"At the same time, after a thorough and comprehensive investigation, the U.S. Attorney's office determined that Ruth Madoff was entitled to keep property of $2.5 million because that property could not be linked to the fraud," Chavkin said.
Although the U.S. government agreed not to contest Ruth Madoff's claim to $2.5 million, the agreement did not protect her from lawsuits to recover additional money by Picard or investors.
Picard said Ruth Madoff for decades lived "a life of splendor" using money that belonged to customers of her husband's investment firm.
He said she had received tens of millions of dollars from Madoff's business in the last six years while the business received no corresponding benefit or value in return.
He said she had pocketed $23.7 million from the business in the last two years, including $1.1 million to pay personal expenses charged to Mrs. Madoff's American Express card and $2.7 million in 2007 to pay for her yacht. He said some or all of the money was subsequently transferred to family members or affiliated entities.
Picard said the court should award to the trustee for distribution to victims no less than $44.8 million that Ruth Madoff knew or should have known belonged to the business and its customers as well as other unspecified compensatory and punitive damages.
He said she had no good-faith basis to believe she was entitled to the money, whether she knew of the fraud or not. He noted that she was a controller at Madoff Securities International Limited, a related British company, and she had business responsibilities for account reconciliation within the company's Investment Advisory Business.
"While Madoff's crimes have left many investors impoverished and some charities decimated, Mrs. Madoff remains a person of substantial means," Picard said. "The inequity between Mrs. Madoff's continuing financial advantages and the economic distress of Madoff's customers compels the trustee to bring this action."
The 71-year-old Bernard Madoff is serving a 150-year sentence after admitting he squandered tens of billions of dollars in investors' money. His wife has not been charged with any crime.
Two lawyers for investors who lost millions of dollars in the fraud visited him Tuesday at the Butner Federal Correctional Complex, about 45 miles northwest of Raleigh, N.C. They said he apologized repeatedly for the harm he had caused victims but did not know where any money might be found that was not already identified by Picard and others.
Loading comments…
LARRY NEUMEISTER | 07/29/09 02:37 PM |