Families Stream Into NYC 9/11 Ceremony

digg Share this on Facebook Huffpost - Families Stream Into NYC 9/11 Ceremony stumble reddit del.ico.us RSS

SUZANNE MA | 09/11/09 11:49 PM | AP

I Like ItI Don’t Like It
A woman is comforted as friends and relatives of the victims of the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks gather for a commemoration ceremony at Zuccotti Park, adjacent to ground zero, on the eighth anniversary of the terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center, Friday, Sept. 11, 2009 in New York. (AP Photo/Jason DeCrow)

NEW YORK — The selfless spirit that helped mend a stricken nation eight years ago was renewed. Volunteers marked 9/11 Friday by tilling gardens, writing letters to soldiers, setting out flags – and, at ground zero, by joining the somber ritual of reading the names of the lost.

President Barack Obama, who observed his first Sept. 11 as president by declaring it a national day of service, laid a wreath Friday at the Pentagon and, with wife Michelle, helped paint the living room of a Habitat for Humanity house in Washington.

"We honor all those who gave their lives so that others might live, and all the survivors who battled burns and wounds and helped each other rebuild their lives," Obama said. He said the day was meant also as a tribute to the "service of a new generation."

Memorials in New York, at the Pentagon and at the crash site of United Airlines Flight 93 in Pennsylvania all took place under gray skies. A chilly rain fell in lower Manhattan, and those reading names at the World Trade Center site spoke under tents.

"We miss you. Life will never be the same without you," said Vladimir Boyarsky, whose son, Gennady Boyarsky, was killed. "This is not the rain. This is the tears."

In the hours after the attack and for weeks afterward, volunteers responded to New York City's needs, sending emergency workers to help with the recovery, cards to victims' families, and boxes of supplies.

"Each act was a link in a continuous chain that stopped us from falling into cynicism and despair," said New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg.

Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton received a standing ovation from Sept. 11 family members and volunteers at a tribute to the first National Day of Service and Remembrance at Manhattan's Beacon Theatre on Friday night.

Story continues below
advertisement

"September 11 will always be a day that represents humanity at its worst and humanity at its best," Clinton said as she thanked the audience for ushering in a new era of service.

In an annual tradition, two bright blue beams of light rose from lower Manhattan in memory of the fallen towers on Friday night.

Across the country, Americans marked the anniversary with service projects.

Volunteers in Boston stuffed packages for military personnel overseas. In Tennessee and West Virginia, they distributed donated food for the needy. Community volunteers in Maine worked on a garden and picnic area for families transitioning out of homelessness.

In Chicago, they tilled community gardens, cooked lunch for residents of a shelter and packed food for mothers and babies. And on the lawn of the Ohio Statehouse, volunteers arranged nearly 3,000 small American flags, in a pattern reminiscent of the trade center's twin towers. At the top was an open space in the shape of a pentagon.

"It's different than just seeing numbers on a paper, when you actually see the flags. It's a visual impact of those lives," said Nikki Marlette, 62, of the Los Angeles suburb of Palos Verdes Estates, visiting Columbus for Saturday's Ohio State-Southern California football game.

At a plaza adjacent to the World Trade Center site, volunteers – from soup kitchens, advocacy groups, the Red Cross, the United Way – joined relatives of the lost to read the names of those killed in the twin towers.

"I ask that you honor my son and all those who perished eight years ago ... by volunteering, by making some kind of act of kindness in their memory," said one of the readers, Gloria Russin, who lost her son, Steven Harris Russin.

Renewing what has become a poignant tradition, some relatives called out greetings and messages of remembrances when they reached the names of their own loved ones.

"We love you, Dad, and we miss you," said Philip Hayes Jr., whose father, long retired from the Fire Department, rushed to the site that 2001 morning and ultimately gave his life.

Theresa Mullan, who lost her firefighter son, Michael, wore a poncho and shivered in the rain as she waited for her son's name to be called. She said she couldn't dream of being anywhere else.

"It's a small inconvenience," she said of the weather. "My son is the one who ran into a burning building."

Moments of silence were observed at 8:46, 9:03, 9:59 and 10:29 a.m. – the precise times that jetliners struck the north and south towers of the trade center and that each tower fell.

At ground zero in lower Manhattan, relatives and friends of victims visited a partially built, street-level Sept. 11 memorial plaza that had not been there a year ago.

The memorial, to be partially complete by the 10th anniversary in 2011, will ultimately include two square pools evoking the towers' footprints, with victims' names surrounding them and waterfalls cascading down the sides.

On Friday, William Weaver placed a single red rose in a temporary reflecting pool at the plaza, a photograph of his son, policeman Walter E. Weaver, pinned to his jacket. He said the memorial was taking too long and he did not like it. "It should have been a graveyard-type of thing," Weaver said.

In Shanksville, Pa., bells tolled for the 40 victims of the fourth hijacked jetliner that crashed there.

Eight years after 2,976 perished in the attacks, Obama vowed at the Pentagon that the United States "will never falter" in pursuit of al-Qaida. "Let us renew our resolve against those who perpetrated this barbaric act and who plot against us still," he said.

On a day already fraught with emotion, the Coast Guard massed vessels in the Potomac River in a training exercise, causing confusion. The exercise took place near the bridge where Obama's motorcade had passed earlier. As a precaution, departures from Reagan National Airport were halted for about 22 minutes at midmorning.

Initial, mistaken reports on two cable news channels said the Coast Guard was firing shots on the river. A group for military families expressed outrage that the Coast Guard exercise was held while families of 9/11 victims were gathered at the Pentagon.

George W. Bush, whose presidency was defined in part by that day, had no public appearances planned. A spokesman said he would be working in his office. In a statement, he said he and his wife, Laura, were thinking of the victims and their families.

___

Associated Press writers Verena Dobnik and Virginia Byrne in New York, Nancy Benac in Washington and Dan Nephin in Pittsburgh contributed to this report.

NEW YORK — The selfless spirit that helped mend a stricken nation eight years ago was renewed. Volunteers marked 9/11 Friday by tilling gardens, writing letters to soldiers, setting out flags &n...
NEW YORK — The selfless spirit that helped mend a stricken nation eight years ago was renewed. Volunteers marked 9/11 Friday by tilling gardens, writing letters to soldiers, setting out flags &n...
Report Corrections
 
Comments
123
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: 1 2 3 4 Next › Last » (4 pages total)
photo

I wrote poetry on that day and resurrected it today:

On That Day

Spotless Blue,

Brilliant Orange

Stunned cries

Silenced.

by janet walker

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:40 PM on 09/11/2009
photo

I wrote poetry on that day and resurrected it on this:

On That Day

Spotless Blue,

Brilliant Orange;

Stunned cries

by janet walker

Silenced.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:38 PM on 09/11/2009
- LaHenche I'm a Fan of LaHenche 7 fans permalink

Have you ever seen satellite images of The WTC on 9/11? Pretty awe inspiring. Kinda puts the suffering of that day, over the things that we hold dear, into a universal perspective.

Read what you want to read into that statement.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:51 PM on 09/11/2009
- LaHenche I'm a Fan of LaHenche 7 fans permalink

A few things:

Just consider that there is no video or photographs of the attack at the Pentagon. NONE. The most secure and highly guarded place on earth and no video or photos? Has anyone ever seen any aircraft wreckage?

How about the wreckage in that field in Pennsylvania? NONE.

I'm just saying.

Ok, back to our regularly scheduled 9/11 programming.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:48 PM on 09/11/2009

I would like to see public debates, discussing all three collapses, between NIST scientists and some of the more prominent members of Architects and Engineers for 911 Truth.

Then maybe the public would understand that there are many renowned architects, engineers and scientists who know that the official story couldn't possibly be true - for scientific reasons, not political ones. Arianna Huffington and people like her should be more than happy to request such a debate, if for no other reason than to prove us wrong.

As a matter of fact, I'm challenging HuffPost right now to request such a debate. It won't be so easy to dismiss everyone who questions the official story as a "truther" if such a debate actually takes place.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:13 PM on 09/11/2009
- otto756 I'm a Fan of otto756 9 fans permalink

Excellent idea. The NIST report is a complete scientific fraud. I would love to see such a debate.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:35 PM on 09/11/2009
- otto756 I'm a Fan of otto756 9 fans permalink

Building 7, people. Building 7. The official story completely falls apart if you do even five minutes of serious research into that ridiculously improbable collapse. Don't take my word for it. Look into it and it's plain to see.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:37 PM on 09/11/2009
- otto756 I'm a Fan of otto756 9 fans permalink

The only way to honor the victims is to have an independent investigation. The official story defies the laws of physics. Every day more scientists, engineers, first responders, and concerned citizens see the inconsistencies, omissions, and lies and realize that we are not being told the truth.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:34 PM on 09/11/2009
- otto756 I'm a Fan of otto756 9 fans permalink

Why is no one talking about the bogus call that solicitor general Ted Olson "alledgedly" got from his wife who was on flt.77? Even the FBI admits it never happened. Without that call, we would never have known about the box cutters. Why did Ted Olson make that up? Does anyone find that suspicious?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:27 PM on 09/11/2009
- Alethea I'm a Fan of Alethea 64 fans permalink
photo

If there is one lesson that I wish we had learned from 9/11 is how to resist the psychological effects of terrorism.

I mean, the whole point of the attack was to make us lash out in fear and behave irrationally. Which is precisely what we did when we attacked Iraq. Hundreds of thousands of Iraqi's died as a result and we effectively destroyed what little bit of good will that we still had left in the Middle East.

Our fear-driven actions gave Osama Bin Laden exactly what he wanted.

And the biggest tragedy, to me, is that in the few months following 9/11 we had an unprecedented opportunity to make tremendous good out of a horrible incident. Virtually every country in the world, (including Iran) gave us their full hearted condolences. It was a once in a lifetime chance to build real, lasting bridges with countries that we previously regarded as enemies. But we just couldn't see past our own anger to do anything about it.

They reached out to us in sympathy, and we rejected them out of a need for vengeance That squandered opportunity, is the single most painful betrayal from our government in my lifetime.

Let us never forget the pure tragedy of 9/11 and especially the tragedy that followed it. Terrorism can never be allowed to affect us like that again.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:35 PM on 09/11/2009

As an engineer, and an expert in physics, statics, dynamics, vibrations, heat transfer and thermodynamics, I can state with confidence that the planes that struck the twin towers did not cause them to collapse. There is absolutely no possibility that either the collisions, the explosions or the fires caused those buildings to collapse in free fall, directly into their own footprints. Each of those buildings contained over 180,000,000 pounds of steel; they were some of the largest heat sinks ever built. The idea that the heat from these localized fires brought the buildings down in free fall should be preposterous to any engineer or scientist.

The NIST report, by the way, was not valid science. That's why they're unwilling to debate the issues in public. It would be embarrassing (or, more accurately, shameful) for them to reveal their procedures to the world's engineers, architects and scientists.

Arianna Huffington would simply call someone like myself a "truther", with a dismissive wave of the hand. It's too bad she has absolutely no valid scientific analysis on which to base her assessment.

Ideally, we would all like to know the truth about what happened that day. But, the moment one begins to analyze the events of 9/11, one is dismissed by everyone in the media, including those who run HuffPost. Sad.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:32 PM on 09/11/2009
- otto756 I'm a Fan of otto756 9 fans permalink

Bravo. Well put and perfectly true.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:32 PM on 09/11/2009
- Catriona I'm a Fan of Catriona 4 fans permalink

But are you a structural engineer?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:58 PM on 09/11/2009

I am a Mechanical Engineer. On top of the above-mentioned physics, statics, dynamics, vibrations, heat transfer and thermodynamics, I have also studied finite element analysis, modal analysis, computational fluid dynamics, mechanics of materials and metallurgy. I have experience as a research and development engineer, manufacturing engineer and project engineer.

Don't take my word for it, though, there are hundreds of renowned structural engineers calling for a new investigation into the collapses of the three WTC buildings. Just check out Architects and Engineers for 911 Truth if you don't believe me. These are not drug-addled hippie conspiracy theorists, they are some of the most logical, rational, intellectual members of our society.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:10 PM on 09/14/2009
- PilotZ27 I'm a Fan of PilotZ27 2 fans permalink

It would be a great relief to the families of the September 11, 2001 victims, if the USA government finally admitted that Osama bin Laden was killed in December of 2001.

The French reported that he was wounded in mid-to-late December 2001 by a "bunker-buster" bomb, and he has never been seen, in anything but a doctored video-tape, since that time.

I realize that for the Bush Administration, keeping Osama "alive" was a convenient mechanism to direct America's hate toward this extreme Muslim on the forefront. But it is high time the world knows that bin Laden died in 2001.

Osama bin Laden is dead.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:07 PM on 09/11/2009
- GeorgeP922 I'm a Fan of GeorgeP922 108 fans permalink
photo

I wish Obama would step in and end this foolishness over a fake tower.

Rebuilt the towers bigger and better, America deserves it.
We are not a people to compromise and cave, no matter how much congress relishes in it.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:58 PM on 09/11/2009
- JustinST I'm a Fan of JustinST 5 fans permalink

It feels terribly odd to see the towers again on the front page. Please let this be a quiet remembrance.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:54 PM on 09/11/2009
- Alethea I'm a Fan of Alethea 64 fans permalink
photo

I think calling 9/11 a Day of Service is an excellent idea. It's a way to turn feelings of helplessness into feelings of usefulness.

Which feels a whole lot better to me than just staying home, walllowing in grief and feeling like a victim.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:52 PM on 09/11/2009
- RexOzone I'm a Fan of RexOzone 28 fans permalink
photo

The tragedy might have been avoided.
It's possibility might have been ignored.
If the details of an attack were left apparently unnoticed or ignored on the desk of Condolezza Rice and the President admonished an aide who brought his attention to Al Qiada before he took his extremely long and irresponsible vacation what on earth would having more info on Atta or the "hijackers" have achieved in avoiding this tragedy...one that looks handy for a government needing shock to obtain its objectives...invading Iraq, Syria, Iran and paving the way for energy companies and oil interests (all brought together by Cheney as a first and secret order of business) to control the world.
The people who were sacrificed on this day (and subsequently due to inadequate analysis of the environmental hazards present) were victims of greed, ideology and a sociopathic disregard for human life, any life. That fits the corporate model as we know it today.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:52 PM on 09/11/2009
Page: 1 2 3 4 Next › Last » (4 pages total)
Comments are closed for this entry

 You must be logged in to comment. Log in  or connect with 

Connect