Lawrence O'Donnell, Anthony Weiner Rip Joe Wilson For "Idiotic" Health Care Proposal (VIDEO)

Congressman Joe Wilson (R-SC) had an epiphany about health care legislation while he attended a "luncheon" at "Enchilada's Mexican restaurant" with some senior citizens on Hilton Head island. They helped him come to the conclusion that if the Democrats in the House are so enthusiastic about passing a public option, surely they would be rushing to join said plan. And they aren't, so there must be something bad about it.

However, the Congressman does not quite have his facts straight, as "Countdown" guest host Lawrence O'Donnell and Democratic Congressman Anthony Weiner (D-NY) both point out.

O'Donnell notes that members of Congress already have health care that is paid for by the government, and that the public option is for people lacking employer-provided health insurance. He then offered Congressman Wilson some advice: "It's your staff's job to talk you out of introducing idiotic amendments. Try talking to them once in awhile. If this happens again someone's got to be fired, and we know it can't be you, so give your staff fair warning."

Weiner attributed the Wilson's confusion to a bout of schizophrenia that is afflicting the GOP:

He seems to be one taco shy of a combo himself. Congressman Wilson is demonstrating a weird schizophrenia about this. Is he saying that not enough people are getting access to the public option? Does he want to extend it to all six million federal employees? I'm open to that idea! . . . Or is he saying he's against the public option, and therefore when he turns 65 he's not going to accept Medicare. This is part of the schizophrenia that is going on in the Republican party.

WATCH:

Visit msnbc.com for Breaking News, World News, and News about the Economy

Comments

[expired]

Wimpy, wimpy, wimpy dems ride again.

The big House health care vote is tomorrow. So we've launched a new online calling tool to reach out to MoveOn members in key districts and connect them to Capitol Hill. Can you make calls?


Click Here
Tragedy at Fort Hood


MoveOn members mourn the loss of lives at Fort Hood in the tragic shootings. Our prayers go out to the loved ones of those killed and wounded. Find ways to help here and here.

Dear MoveOn member,
After months of build-up, tomorrow is THE big House vote on landmark health care reform. But according to news reports, Democrats don't yet have the votes to win!

This is crunch time. We have to win this vote. Right now, it's all coming down to a key group of moderate Democrats who are on the fence—and we hear they're getting inundated with calls from health care opponents.

They need to hear from progressives now—so we're asking MoveOn members from all around the country to help.

How? We have a great new online tool that lets you call other MoveOn members in these key House districts and connect them directly to their representative's office on Capitol Hill.

Can you drop whatever you're doing and call a few fellow MoveOn members in these crucial districts right now?

Yes, I'll help make calls.

[Judy Buss]

If this is such a good plan, then all government employees s/not have a problem accepting this as
their health care plan and if it's not good enough for them it is not good enough for the rest of
the American population.

[Cye]

I don't understand your post.

The point of the public option is choice. If you're happy with your current healh care provision, then you can keep it. If you're not covered, the public option provides a basic level of affordable coverage (as opposed to none). Why should *all* goverment employees have to accept this as their health care plan? Forcing them onto it would remove choice. This is not the intention behind the public option.

[AllShookUp]

Wilson has an epiphany in a Mexican restaurant - alert The Washington Post!

[psychodog]

Let me preface this by saying I can't stand Joe Wilson...

However, taking his idea into consideration... how much better, and more comprehensive, would the public option be, if those in the Federal government were required to purchase it?

This was an idea I had some time ago... I have the feeling we'd end up with the Medicare +5% rates, and coverage for the majority of the population if those in government knew they were crafting, and voting on, their own healthcare packages.

Plus it would probably get done faster... since the fastest legislation to get through government usually is that which covers provisions for congressional pay raises. This would be almost the same thing.

Please don't beat me up too much... I actually think his idea has some merit, but not his intended consequences.

It could actually work FOR us.

[JRGris]

Joe Wilson lies most of the time so it is always difficult to keep the story straight.

[dobriyden]

Is this the same Weiner who wanted to increase visa's for foreign fashion models by 1000. Hmmmmmm.

[wizegeye]

Rep Weiner is really preoccupied with comparing people to fast food. First he accused Rep Grayson of being "one fry short of a happy meal," and now the taco comment.

[poobah]

Well, when the shoe fits that well......

[wizegeye]

Maybe it's when the bun fits.

[christopherflynn]

"Oh, I wish I were an Anthony Weiner"...no wonder he's always comparing people to fast food... :)

[IndieObama]

A wiener shy of a stadium dog?
Couldn't resist.
I actually agree with just about everything he is promoting, especially Single Payer, HR676.

[VietVet67]

http://countdowntohealthcare.com/

Sign, sign, sign. Pass around!

[sixchair]

This says it all....

Wall Street gets all the H1N1 vaccine it wants while pregnant mothers, children and hospitals stand in line!!!

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/21134540/vp/33651691#33651691

[RoadSkoller]

Mr. Weiner, with a name like yours, I wouldn't suggest you hanging out with Barney Frank. Goggle-Gobble

[ivegotblisteronmefingers]

hey
do not dis Barney Frank!!

[Poiks]

Always elevating the discourse, huh?

[poobah]

The last resort of those with no other rebuttal is a personal attack. Way to go, Sparky.

[myj66]

u kno u wrong. lol

[AllShookUp]

Adolescent

[jsj20002]

Actually, Joe Wilson, as a retired Army colonel, has a much broader array of choices than almost all of the other members of Congress from either party. He can enroll in the taxpayer-subsidized Federal Employees Health Benefits Program and pay about a third of the cost plus the normal co-pays. However, Joe Wilson is, I have heard, currently enrolled in the military's Tri-Care Program that has a much lower cost to the former servicemember and his family than he would have under the FEHBP. Because he has Tri-Care, I doubt he knows much about the FEHBP costs and benefits. And, when he becomes 65 he will automatically get single payer coverage under Medicare Part A. The only downside he may face is that if he chooses to retain his Tri-Care health benefit package after he turns 65, he will also have to enroll in Medicare Part B, which currently costs $96 per month.

[poobah]

You would think that with all those options he could have gotten his wife a swine flu shot.

[gray375]

I can never get enough Weiner

[Elbrando]

choice  /tʃɔɪs/ Show Spelled Pronunciation [chois] Show IPA noun, adjective, choic⋅er, choic⋅est.
Use choice in a Sentence
See web results for choice
See images of choice
–noun 1. an act or instance of choosing; selection: Her choice of a computer was made after months of research. His parents were not happy with his choice of friends.
2. the right, power, or opportunity to choose; option: The child had no choice about going to school.
3. the person or thing chosen or eligible to be chosen: This book is my choice. He is one of many choices for the award.
4. an alternative: There is another choice.
5. an abundance or variety from which to choose: a wide choice of candidates.
6. something that is preferred or preferable to others; the best part of something: Mare's Nest is the choice in the sixth race.
7. a carefully selected supply: This restaurant has a fine choice of wines.
8. a choice grade of beef.


Maybe Mr. Wilson is focusing on the latter definitions regarding food and not the earlier definitions when it comes to the health care bill.
Personally I think that his district needs definition #5 and vote him out.

[ivegotblisteronmefingers]

I think you are right, as he got the idea at a restaurant
btw it must have been the loneliest trip that that particular idea ever took

[ariveria]

lets put it another way. if congress is so happy with their health care lets give it to all americans.

"a lie repeated often enough becomes the truth"
glenn beck
information czar fox news
the view 5/20/09

[escomments]

That would be "Idiotic"

[ariveria]

huh????

"a lie repeated often enough becomes the truth"
glenn beck
information czar fox news
the view 5/20/09

[Reito Hikari]

And you thought the current reform bill costs too much...

[ariveria]

so why would that cost more

"a lie repeated often enough becomes the truth"
glenn beck
information czar fox news
the view 5/20/09

[Yocepuc]

And the po1ntless dr1vel of Joe "1 beer shy of a 6-pack" Wilson continues...

[throwcautiontothewind]

One beer? How about 5 beers shy of a six-pack?