iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Progressive Groups Turn Sights On Rahm Over Health Care (VIDEO)

First Posted: 03/18/10 06:12 AM ET Updated: 05/25/11 03:55 PM ET

In the latest salvo in an increasingly bitter health care reform debate, progressive groups are targeting White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel, accusing the president's top adviser of abandoning the principles of people in his hometown Chicago.

The Progressive Change Campaign Committee released an ad on Tuesday in which, through the voice of a local Chicagoan, they warn that Emanuel risks support in his own district should he "undermine" the public option for insurance coverage. The spot comes the morning after Ryan Grim of the Huffington Post first reported that the White House chief of staff had urged Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) to get a deal done with centrist Democrats on health care.


Playing off the widely-held belief that Emanuel will eventually return to elected politics, PCCC is set to air the ad solely on Chicago television. But it will run only as many times as fundraising permits. The initial goal is $50,000 worth of spots.

In addition to the new ad, PCCC and another progressive group, Democracy for America, provided polling numbers to the Huffington Post showing fairly healthy skepticism for the Emanuel's performance as chief of staff. Only 36 percent of Americans said they trusted Emanuel with his job. Thirty-five percent said they did not trust him, and 29 percent were not sure.

Taken together, the ad and the decision to poll Emanuel's popularity reflect a widening schism between progressive groups and the chief of staff. Emanuel, for his part, has been quoted in various outlets scoffing at the role played by these groups in the health care debate, even calling their ads "fucking stupid."

But the attacks also suggest the chief of staff is effective at his job. The more the spotlight shines on Emanuel, the less heat the president takes from these same groups. And while White House officials continue to insist that Emanuel did not urge Reid to compromise on health care during their meeting on Sunday night, they also feel confident that should legislation pass, there will be ample time to repair the hurt feelings that the process produced.

Below is the script for the ad, as narrated by Joseph Breitenbucher of Chicago, Illinois :

My family has lived here in Chicago for 30 years. Rahm Emanuel was our congressman. When I had spinal surgery the medical bills were enormous. My insurance company tried to get out of paying bills they clearly were responsible for. That's how they make a profit, by denying people care. Many families in our situation would have gone into bankruptcy. Luckily my wife is a doctor and she knew how to challenge the insurance company. So after months of paper work we got the bills paid. But not everyone has a doctor in the house who knows how to fight back. We need a public health insurance option now. That is the only way to drive competition and keep the insurance companies honest. Anything less is not reform at all.


All of us back home hope Rahm Emanuel is fighting for people like us as White House chief of staff. But if he sides with insurance companies and undermines the public option, well, he won't have many fans in Chicago.


Get HuffPost Politics On Facebook and Twitter!

FOLLOW HUFFPOST POLITICS

In the latest salvo in an increasingly bitter health care reform debate, progressive groups are targeting White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel, accusing the president's top adviser of abandoning th...
In the latest salvo in an increasingly bitter health care reform debate, progressive groups are targeting White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel, accusing the president's top adviser of abandoning th...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 1,238
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (23 total)
03:51 PM on 12/18/2009
Ezekial Emmanuel, M.D., Rahm's brother, has been advising the White House re: health care reform policy. Dr. Emmanuel visited the Commonwealth Club in San Francisco last spring promoting his book's recipe for health care reform. During the Q & A he stated, "the health insurance companies are our friends." Clearly he has had his brother's ear for months and now we all pay the price - and it's a BIG one!
10:19 PM on 12/18/2009
Yeah the insurance companies are our friends and Sarah Palin will be over for dinner tonight reciting who flew over the COO COO NEST.

I and so many others are paying so much for health insurance it is unreal and becoming prohibitive for small business and those that are self employed.

Wake op Mr. Pres I know you understand this who is blowing smoke on you and why are you even listening. I thought you were a man of commonsense please tell us all what are you doing to us and why.

Why have you not taken an aggressive stand to reduce the cost of health care and not by a couple of percent?

Do not act naive here because we all know you are street smart . We know you cannot deliver everything but how about reducing the cost on everyones health insurance.

Instead you are forcing those many people who will not be able to afford and will not get the government support they need to there knees.

Yes, we need to start somewhere but when the people are going to see what you are allowing to pass they will be angry and you may never have enough support to run again and win.

You opened up your mouth when you ran and said we will have a real reform for health care are you kidding. .Stand up and be heard and please tell me and others in a simple dialogue what this joke of a bill will
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JohnTalbutt
01:48 PM on 12/18/2009
Obama must ditch Rahm. He is too proud of being a bully.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mystic01
Proudly pro-union
10:50 AM on 12/18/2009
Rahm must go. Bad choice from the start.
08:38 AM on 12/17/2009
BO gave Rahm a job and Howard the boot. BO made the wrong choice from the get go. Howard would have gotten this thing done for the citizenry and not for the health insurance corps.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jimfl
09:24 PM on 12/16/2009
Rahm is not serving the president he is serving Lieberman.
01:32 PM on 12/18/2009
and they both serve israel
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jimfl
04:29 PM on 12/18/2009
And thats the truth israel before you and me.
04:32 PM on 12/16/2009
Probably a good idea to fire Emmanuel after the failure on health care reform. His lukewarm support to the process has not served the nation well.
06:38 PM on 12/16/2009
Agreed and well said....
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
sviolette
Hug a vet!!!
06:45 PM on 12/16/2009
He serves the president. He must be doing what the president wants him to do or he would be fired donchathink?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Joseph Palermo
Huffington Post Blogger/Author/Professor
01:11 PM on 12/16/2009
Rahm obviously learned nothing from 1994 -- they should read George Lakoff's books.
12:18 PM on 12/16/2009
I like the "no more pre-existing conditions" and I like the "no more health benefits max out" but all insurance companies have to do to counter is refuse coverage or outprice it. There's NO attempt to slow the rise of cost. NO public option, NO medicare expansion, NO drug importation, NO anti-trust amendment.....NO CHANGE! Just telling 30 million people (who can't afford it already) that now they HAVE to afford it. How is this not an absolute GIFT to insurance companies and big pharma? Was Leiberman elected president? Where was the pressure from the White House to make these jerk-offs in the Senate get behind real reform? I don't know if I like the idea of killing this bill only because i fear that if they do there won't be a bill but I know this.....if this bill passes I've seen enough. It will have taken just 12 months for me to go from being an ardently enthusiastic Obama supporter to losing all hope. This bill passes, he loses my vote in 2012 not for what he did but for what he didn't do. I drove to South Carolina and listened as he promised to stand up to corporate lobbyists. He's done the EXACT opposite. I can forgive the loss of a hard fought battle but I CANNOT AND WILL NOT forgive him for blatantly LYING as I sent money to his campaign! As this bill passes, he fails!
05:15 PM on 12/18/2009
I think we should just put cream on our collective butts and start thinking about electing someone like Howard Dean in 2012. I have been so thoroughly disappointed by an administration which cannot pass even a watered down version of the HC reform bill that I have lost all hope for the remainder of this term.
Our first goal should be to elect a more progressive congress and the first order of business for that congress should be campaign reform (public funding-let's face it, we'll pay for it either from our pocket, or by being ripped off by corporate interests, which one would you choose?), and then work on REAL Health Care Reform.
I know this sounds like an impossible enterprise, but what choices do we have? No matter what legislative reform is introduced in congress, it's blocked and/or killed by moneyed interests...the congress simply has ceased to function as a body that represents the interests of the American people, although I am sure you many of us refuse to believe that...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alak0926
12:15 PM on 12/16/2009
Money saved by averting financial collapse caused by Bush and the Right: $500 trillion
Lives saved over the next ten years because of new healthcare legislation: 150,000
Families able to avoid bankruptcy after FULL STIMULUS is implemented: Millions
Damage caused when right wingers take back the Congress: The richest 2% will own 95% of the tea baggers wealth!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Changeizgood
04:41 PM on 12/18/2009
That's what they get for watching Fox and believing the rich who supported their tea parties while turning the financial screws on "real healthcare reform.

When their rolling in the grocery isle, from a stroke convulsion, then they will get it. WE did the math for the last 30years since insurance companies hit the markets and it comes to 1,760,000 people.

IS THIS THE WALL STREET HALOCAUST?

YOU BETCHA!
11:55 AM on 12/16/2009
Introducing Rahm Emanuel, the Dick Cheney of the Obama Administration.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
sviolette
Hug a vet!!!
06:56 PM on 12/16/2009
I don't think he has started any fires in his office yet trying to destroy documents. I would classify him more like Rumsfeld.
04:56 PM on 12/18/2009
Rahm is the Karl Rove of this administration
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:31 AM on 12/16/2009
Obama has surrounded himself with the worst and dumbest. His first year in office has been a series of capitulations and reversals and a too easy forgetting of any principles he was elected for.This is not the president most of us voted for and next election the democrats will suffer a huge slap. His chief of staff is a complete failure. By then it probably will be too late to rescue him from a 1 term presidency.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
formerroadie
I am a liberal and proud of it!
12:18 PM on 12/16/2009
We can't blame everything congress does on the president. Also, it would be stupid for progressives to stay home on election day. We need to vote in more progressives, not give this over to the republicans. If liberals stay home, they show how really weak they are and how much the conservatives have truly won.
06:40 PM on 12/16/2009
Absolutely right well said!!!

no more stupid giving up and letting the Condems and Rips reap the benefits....
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:46 PM on 12/16/2009
Exactly! If we don't focus on those Republican seats that can be taken by a progressive Dem, we will be in this stalemate for the next 12 years. I don't think the country can stand it. Hopefully, Reid will be replaced by another Dem who has some street fighter in him/her.
11:25 AM on 12/16/2009
Wake up people. He works for Obama. He does not do anything without prior approval. Put the blame squarely where it belongs, on his boss. Guess who that might be?
06:42 PM on 12/16/2009
Probably only half right-Rahm probably exerts a lot of pressure and has a lot of clout, I can smell the difference between Obama moves and Rahm moves, can't you?
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
sviolette
Hug a vet!!!
06:58 PM on 12/16/2009
You have one of those new fangled scratch and sniff monitors?
04:10 AM on 12/17/2009
I agree.

Rahm is no evil puppet-master controlling the president. Quite the contrary, he does exactly what he's told.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:08 AM on 12/16/2009
He is to rich for the job
04:44 AM on 12/16/2009
Cost of a taxpayer funded trip to Europe to get an Olympic bid: $750K

Cost of a taxpayer funded useless stimulus: 1 TRILLION.

Cost of finally seeing Obama supporters realizing he is not a leader and questioning his decisions and abilities: Priceless.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:24 AM on 12/16/2009
Cost of 8 years of George W. Bush, the ra pe of our treasury, the loss of confidence in US foreign policy, the needless bl_ood of our soldiers in Iraq.
01:32 PM on 12/16/2009
Don't forget all of the three years spent on taxpayer funded vacations at the ranch!
01:35 PM on 12/16/2009
What is your idea of leadership? Letting a Nazi VP like Cheney tell you what to do ...who loves power so much he is willing to put innocent lives in danger and purposefly lie about WMD? Is leadership spending all your time at the ranch letting the country work itself up to the abyss of depression and doing nothing?
03:46 AM on 12/16/2009
Ever bought a car from a used car salesman?
If so you have an excuse for being bamboozled by this administration.
If not, stop complaining.
This was so obvious long before the primaries happened.
All it took was looking at his past, his associates, his political acccomplishments, and it was so so so so obvious.
But, you bought the car while kicking Hillary to the curb.
And now we are stuck.
02:09 PM on 12/16/2009
Ha ha, Hillary ? the one who sat on the board of Wall Mart and thought Iraq was a good idea?