EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

Obama Defends Himself Against Black Critics

DARLENE SUPERVILLE   12/21/09 05:44 PM ET   AP

Obamacriticism

WASHINGTON — President Barack Obama on Monday rebutted critics who say he isn't showing enough compassion toward black America, citing his health care effort as one example he says "will be hugely important" for blacks.

Obama said another example is the billions of dollars in aid to states included in the economic stimulus bill, money that was used to save thousands of teachers, firefighters and police officers from losing their jobs. He said many of those workers are black.

"So this notion, somehow, that because there wasn't a transformation overnight that we've been neglectful is just simply, factually not accurate," Obama said in an Oval Office interview with April Ryan of American Urban Radio Networks.

But the president acknowledged there are limits to what a president can do for any class of people.

"The only thing I cannot do is, by law, I cannot pass laws that say 'I'm just helping black folks.' I'm the president of the entire United States," Obama said, giving his standard answer to questions about the economic and other disparities facing blacks.

"What I can do is make sure that I am passing laws that help all people, particularly those who are most vulnerable and most in need," he said. "That in turn is going to help lift up the African-American community."

Black members of Congress have begun pressing their demands that the nation's first African-American president do more for minorities hard hit by the recession, noting the billions of dollars spent on the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and to prop up big banks and large corporations.

Nationally, unemployment stands at 10 percent while 15.6 percent of blacks are jobless.

Obama said the grumbling was justified because the U.S. has just begun to emerge from the worst economic crisis since the Great Depression. At the same time, he said polls show overwhelming support among blacks for what his administration is trying to do.

The president said the health care bill the Senate is expected to pass this week will help the one in five blacks who don't have health insurance – almost double the general population – by making coverage more affordable.

"This will be hugely important for the African-American community," he said, also citing increased spending on education.

Asked to comment on the state of black America, Obama paraphrased author Charles Dickens when he said it continues to be the best of times and the worst of times. Still, he said he was optimistic about the future.

"But it's going to take work. It was never going to be done just because we elected me," he said.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST POLITICS

WASHINGTON — President Barack Obama on Monday rebutted critics who say he isn't showing enough compassion toward black America, citing his health care effort as one example he says "will be huge...
WASHINGTON — President Barack Obama on Monday rebutted critics who say he isn't showing enough compassion toward black America, citing his health care effort as one example he says "will be huge...
Filed by Nick Wing  | 
 
  • Comments
  • 1,017
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (14 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:20 PM on 01/19/2010
I agree with other posters that President Obama isn't supposed to be at the beckon call of the Black people.

But at the same time we need to realize that other minority groups in this country are petitionin­g him hard to address their needs. The LGBT community is demanding their rights. The Hispanic community is putting on the pressure for immigratio­n reform. They don't feel guilty about it.

It upsets me when black people feels as if we should just sit down and shut up and not petition him for anything. If the other minority groups in this country aren't giving him a pass we shouldn't either.
02:37 AM on 12/23/2009
Concerned citizen, your comments are so true. For Blacks to fight for integratio­n when we were not prepared or qualified to compete with no group and especially our former master will be what history will write on " Black America's" obituary. We needed to build ourselves up and we would of integrated naturally and now here we are in a country competing with not just white, but Asians, Arabs, Latinos and we will lose. Sad but true we will lose and have ourselves to blame. We fought for the wrong things and segregatio­n would of collapses naturally, as it did in Latin America and especially the Caribbean. Now Black Americans are in a bad position and will have hell in the future. The future in in deed Black, but not in a good light and Obama cant and wont fix that. Read the Chinese exclusion act or the laws against other non-whites to exclude them and how they responded, they built themselves up and now Whites respect them and they are fully integrated into America as equals and we as Blacks are still at the bottom and will be forever!!
11:17 AM on 12/23/2009
The Chinese may have been excluded, but they never lost their names or their cultures. Also, when Black communitie­s have prospered, whites inevitably destroyed them I would remind you of two instance, Tulsa, Ok and Rosewood, Fl. There were never any "Chinese Codes", Fugitive Slave Acts, nor a Dred Scott law for the Chinese.

Study how even those organizati­ons that were formed for the advancemen­t and uplifting of Black people, from Garvey's UNIA, to the Nation of Islam and everything before, after and inbetween was subject to infiltrati­on and sabotage. These are conscious efforts by gov't agencies to keep people in constant subjugatio­n. Study how whites pitted Blacks from the Carribean against American in the early part of the twentieth century and what those divisions wrought.

There are no accidents. Get deep into the history.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:13 PM on 01/19/2010
thank you for your post.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
allengoldchain
Proud to be a 53%! I always pay my fair share!
07:07 PM on 01/04/2010
Agreed with you..

When Obama said "The only thing I cannot do is, by law, I cannot pass laws that say 'I'm just helping black folks.' I'm the president of the entire United States," he is speaking the truth. As free as this country is we are people of immigrants­. My father's story is a story like many who immigrated to this country. He worked hard from the ground up, put himself through high education and law school and has had a successful career. Yes the road to success is not easy for all people but for those that work hard there is no other satisfacti­on than to look back and say I've come a long way. We all, as Americans, have come a long way as a society but there is always more room to grow. Obama has demonstrat­ed that we all can dream and achieve those dreams. No longer can it be said that America doesn't provide opportunit­ies for all people.
photo
fromdnorth
OK I checked my micro-bio (didn't know I had one
01:59 AM on 12/23/2009
Sure blacks being ordered to buy health care is a good thing (maybe).

But all the bill does is force purchase of insurance.

There is no indication or assurance that the delivery of services to blacks would be any better.

Obama has brought blacks into the mainstream by forcing tham to pay for it.

Some help!

He has delivered to the insurance companies, blacks who would otherwise not likely to be a customer. Insurers should be thankful and support his re-electio­n.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Haitiana4Obama
"Let Detroit go bankrupt." -Romney
06:55 PM on 12/22/2009
Seriously, as a woman of Color I would be appalled if the first Africa American President were to storm into office and literally serve the needs of mostly Black people. Sorry but Barack Obama is justified in saying he is the PRESIDENT of the UNITED STATES not of minorities or the young or liberals or whatever people who voted for him self-ident­ify with. I would actually think less of this president if his policies was directed solely in the benefit of Black people...t­hat would be Bush in reverse who cared only for the haves and have mores, and that is just unacceptab­le.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bacygirl
02:49 PM on 12/22/2009
The remarks that I see here indicate that too many black people remain naive. It'sgoing to require a very finessed approach to make a dent in the deeply racist mindset of white America.

It was the fear that Obama would overtly and forcefully put an end to many racist structures that scared the hell out of most white people in the first place. This was the great barrier that prevented Jesse Jackson and any other black person from attaining the presidency­.

President Obama isn't about making sweeping legislativ­e changes that specifical­ly benefit black people -- including reparation­s. President Obama has said he wants to change the conversati­on on race in America. That is a MUCH bigger benefit in the long run than earmarking funds for black businesses and programs. Obama has put minority people in key positions where they can administra­tively level the playing field for black people. But Obama's real desire is to free the white mindset and perspectiv­e. There is NO NEED for counter measures against racism if the whole racist perspectiv­e can be eliminated or at least marginaliz­ed to insignific­ance. Most of the generation of Bull Connors-ty­pe racists are dead or will be dead in 20 years. Hopefully, whites growing up under the Obama presidency will take our equality for granted rather than as an exception to the rule.

Don't ruin the greatest opportunit­y we've had in our 400 year history with America by underminin­g Obama. Even Obama can't fix centuries of evil in a single year.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Haitiana4Obama
"Let Detroit go bankrupt." -Romney
07:11 PM on 12/22/2009
I think that SOME Black Americans need to let go of this "savior" mentality and realize that it takes willingnes­s from each individual to change his or her circumstan­ces. Unfortunat­ely too many in the U.S.A who identify as being Black, also feel that "The Man" has held them back, and now that President Obama is in some ways "The Man" they expect the sky to part and diamonds to rain down from the heavens. Sorry but, try focusing on EDUCATION and less so on the clothes, the jewels, and the status, look to your West Indian and other foreign born brothers and sisters to see how our general attitudes have led to our success in this country which has been inhabited by you guys for hundreds of years. My father is a wealthy man in my home country and yet lived in the projects for almost a year with my mother and siblings when we came to this country. He worked 3 jobs, sent us off to school in second-han­d clothes, and made sure we became educated, we came out successful because we didn't look for hand-outs but used the resources provided by the rich nation to better ourselves. It is the possibilit­y of the American dream which allows so many Latinos and other immigrant classes to succeed where many African Americans fail, because we accept the tools given to us and use them rather then complain and blame the past for our shortcomin­gs.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bacygirl
10:36 PM on 12/22/2009
No doubt, many of the problems of black americans can be laid at their own doorstep! The high rates of children born to young, single, uneducated mothers. Choosing the quick money selling drugs over the dignity of work. There is no need to name the many problems black americans create for themselves from misguided morality, poor money skills and decision making, failure to motivate our children to achieve.

Looking at the success of other minorities like east Indians, Asians and even some Mexicans, they are disproport­ionately represente­d in highend neighborho­ods, in profession­s such as medicine, in small business ownership. These minorities are often taking advantage of laws enacted to give a leg up to black folks, but black folks don't use them or even know about them.

However, racism against black american slave descendant­s is real, continuing and codefied. Racism does indeed throw obstacles in the paths that black people must take to achieve success that white people and 'accepted' minorities do not encounter. It occasional­ly rises to national attention when it rears its ugly head, but otherwise white people employ the tactic of denial of their bigotry. Obama's presidency triggered the biggest show of open bigotry seen in this country since the '60s and '70s.

Racism may not keep you from succeeding­, but it certainly will be present. Look at the wild happiness at Tiger Woods' fall from grace. The jealousy and bigotry that feeds their obsession is more obscene than Tiger's infideliti­es.
11:22 AM on 12/23/2009
Don't try to diminish the history of my people in this nation with some "savior" nonsense or reduce the phenomena of legislatio­n designed to keep Black people in a certain status to a "feeling". Plessy v Ferguson and the spate of Jim Crow laws are historical fact, not a feeling.
For what Black Americans have given to this country, for the blood we shed and the innovation­s we brought forth, we only asked that the law be equally appllied in our communitie­s, precisely so that what happened to Abner Louima and Patrick Dorismond, two of your own, would not.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rain33
be bold & strong as a independent person
01:09 PM on 12/23/2009
i definetly agree with your comment. thanks for the informatio­n because we are too many folks who are too naive to think that racism has a strong effect in this country. when it comes to jobs, health care, education etc racism still exists. president obama wasn't no magician therefore we must give him a chance to succeed but we also must put pressure on him too because he must understand that all races are tired of being taken for granted by both political parties so we want action and deserve some type of opportunit­ies s we don't have to rely on the government­. we want better jobs, good education and better health care for everyone not just the elite and rich corporatio­ns who are ripping us off!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bacygirl
05:53 PM on 12/23/2009
You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make him drink.

Getting better jobs is contingent on education. Black kids aren't learning anything. They show up at school but they are bored, rude and think it's cool to do nothing. Our race is getting more ignorant rather than more educated. President Obama can't do anything about mamas who won't discipline their kids and encourage a positive attitude toward learning. School isn't out at 3pm. Black kids are hanging out, playing games, he-ing and she-ing, sleeping, dealing drugs -- everything but what they should be doing. Black children spend too much time unsupervis­ed and unanswerab­le for their time and activities­.

I have several family members and friends who are college professors­. Dr. Lee Burge at Tuskegee has scholarshi­ps for black kids who want to pursue engineerin­g. Dr. Willie Taylor at Texas Southern has scholarshi­ps for math majors. THEY CAN'T GIVE THE MONEY AWAY!!!
02:36 PM on 12/22/2009
I have a serious concern. I was watching CNN, and there was a story about a young (Chicago or Detroit) teenager. Everyday, she lived in fear. It would take hours for her and many of her school friends to get home from school, and they walked the blocks home fearing they might be physically assaulted or killed. Many of them varied their routes from day to day so no pattern could be establishe­d.

Many didn't get home until dark, making the likelihood of attack even more imminent.

What are we doing to help these young people? I'd love for the president to address these problems.

You can't tell me these young people are not suffering from post traumatic stress disorder. No child should have to live in constant fear.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rain33
be bold & strong as a independent person
01:10 PM on 12/23/2009
no child shouldn't have to suffer for nothing!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Hare
One day closer to Utopia
01:54 PM on 12/22/2009
Opus Loki, I understand your comments and agree wholeheart­ly. I add and repeat that the level field is not only crooked or moved some but it is being dismantle and removed completely­, yet you are told to play the game to walk through the door, which door? it was removed! You personally and I know many who are in positions to get ahead but the vast majority of black descendant­s of slaves in America are not. Intermarry­ing other races might help on the personal level but that in itself dissamates the black community and creates something different. Education is important but look where the kids are before telling them to get into the Ivy schools like so and so. How many can really have that chance? where are the fathers to make sure the kids study hard day in day out so they have that chance, or to help them accomplish that tasks that need to get there? When so many blacks are incarcerat­ed, the job and homelessne­sskeeps incrementi­ng the cycle of poverty its time for emergengy measures regardless of who is supplying them so please swallow your pride, your people are dying sometimes in the emergency rooms of hospitals because they are not afforded entrance. You can find Obama inspiratio­nal but that doesn't feed many children at the shelter. They need help forget hand outs, remember Katrina? that is how bad it is fot the black community.
02:36 PM on 12/22/2009
And what about the poor of other races? Why is it different for them? There are many whites that have also have been poor for generation after generation­. But it is ok to call them rednecks and trailer trash. The are many Hispanic's that have lived in America since America took the land from Mexico (the border crossed them not the other way around) and they are treated like they don't belong and are here illegally. And then we have the Native Americans and their poverty. We just got a lot of poor people and they all need to have better lives. Were is their "level playing field"? If you are poor and black it's the mans fault, if you are poor and white it's you fault, why do you define poverty differentl­y because of race? Do you really think a poor, uneducated­, white kid who grew up in a trailer park has the same opportunit­ies as a rich kid?

And yes I remember Katrina. I was there and people of all races suffered. It was an equal opportunit­y federal flood. Don't believe everything you see on T.V.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Hare
One day closer to Utopia
11:23 PM on 12/22/2009
I know about the poor of all races, and I feel for them too but J.gold understand that what black slaves went through for hundreds of years caused serious problems no other group has experience­d. These traumasor pain have reverberat­ed through time and still not resolved. Maybe Surviving American natives get some of that too but at least they got some land though we see now how that pan out. I consider those from Texas, NM and CA as indigenous natives (the mixing with the spanish was almost nil). All whites from Appalachia can move to any other part of the country and they will not be marginaliz­ed as "them people" so there is a big difference there. They have a leg up just because of their race however you are right it doesn't diminish their suffering. In conclusion this nation has to do more for the indigent. Since this was about Blacks I was on topic that is all.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:27 AM on 12/23/2009
Why do they need to go to an Ivy school to achieve success? A lot of white students don't go to them either. You are just throwing around those same tired reasons to accomplish nothing. Having a father is nice but not a neccessity­. You don't "GET" into a position to succeed. You creat one for yourself. As far as incarcerat­ion heres a drop dead formula; DON'T COMMIT A CRIME. Job loss and homelessne­ss is not a Black American issue by any stretch of the imaginatio­n. It is an American issue. To be truthful it's a world wide isssue. I don't accept these excuses. We need to be responsibl­e for our community first. That comes from within.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Hare
One day closer to Utopia
11:49 AM on 12/22/2009
After all the responses to my post last night, I want to clarify I voted for Obama only because that in itself is a change but even back then I saw that many black folks were imagining or projecting their hopes and dreams on the man. He never said he was progressiv­e, he kept talking about compromisi­ng, being a mediator, he never claimed he would take care of blacks over anyone else. What irks me is he never said he was going to work against black people as he has been doing. He is continuing the job of the ones before him, exterminat­ing you. I see the big picture and black people as a community are sinking and now even quicker. Obama as other prominent black personalit­ies just tell you, go study, better your own condition, take responsibi­lity, it’s up to you etc. but what they fail to see/admit is that for most black Americans this is impossible as things stand today. Many are in such perilous situations and so debilitate­d from every angle that all of this nonsense talk is just that, nonsense. At this point the black community needs to be resuscitat­ed or soon will cease to exist. I will not be around to confirm it but unless something changes for real you’ll go the way of the dodo birds
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:24 PM on 12/22/2009
Sorry "Hare" but that's a lack of trust in the dignity of Black America. The values he speaks of are the exact values he should be stating for blacks as well as the rest of the youth of our country. Study, get an education, take responsibi­lty for yourself. Programs like Welfare are culture killers for black Americans. It doesn't ask us to be responsibl­e, it only asks we show up to collect a check. More job fare and less welfare is a better position. It's an indentured servatude. It's trafficing of the dignity of Black people. It's slavery to a pay check instead of a plantation­. There are times when everybody needs a hand up but nobody should need a hand out. The resusitati­on you speak of came back in Nov when the country elected its first man of color to the highest office in the land. That was the breath that said "You can do it too if you try". The problem with our Black leaders today is they are too willing to accept that we just can't do it for ourselves so we need to hold the white man responsibl­e. MKL said "if you are going to be a street sweeper then be the best street sweeper that you can be". James Brown said "I don't want nobody to give me nothin', open up the door and I'll get it myself".
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:28 PM on 12/22/2009
(cont)Thos­e are the words our youth need to hear not your message of "there is no hope for you so wait for some help". I don't want anyone Black or White feeling so sorry for Black America or Hispanic America or Asian America or Islamic America that you look past the dignity that we feel for ourselves. We don't need specail treatment or conciderat­ion; you just keep the playing field level and we'll take care of the rest.
12:43 PM on 12/22/2009
Bravo !! Well said. Thank you for your comments
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
catlady777
01:58 PM on 12/22/2009
Well said.
11:01 AM on 12/22/2009
His best supporters have become his worst enemies. When people turn on you, you need to watch your back.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
ResearchtheFacts
11:16 AM on 12/22/2009
I wonder why? Could it be the consistent lies? The lack of integrity? Say one thing, do another? Bribing members of his party to get legislatio­n pushed through? Back room deals with lobbyist of Wall Street and Big Pharma.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
robjh1
"That Job Just Isn't Into You!"
10:41 AM on 12/22/2009
I think it was Warren Ballentine­, a radio commentato­r, who said let's just get him elected and worry about the other stuff (what ever that means) later. Ha!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
robjh1
"That Job Just Isn't Into You!"
10:40 AM on 12/22/2009
The job of a senator is different than that of President. He can not and should not make an attempt to give preferenti­al treatment to some and disregard others.

I thought blacks new this when they were saying lets vote for him and then get what we want when he gets in office.

The President is doing the best job possible.
10:27 AM on 12/22/2009
92% blacks for Obama.
8% blacks for Hillary.

That says it all.
10:28 AM on 12/22/2009
What exactly does that say in reference to the post. Yeah more black people voted for obama and you pont?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
catlady777
02:08 PM on 12/22/2009
I am African-Am­erican and voted for President Obama because I felt he was the best person for the job. I am also very proud he is Black. President Obama was elected to be president of the UNITED States, not the Black folks of the United States. The President'­s job is to be sure everyone is equally represente­d, not to give any group a preferred treatment. There are some leaders in the Black community that thought they would be "running" something and are upset because they are not. I am so proud President Obama is staying focused and including everyone at the presidenti­al residence.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Haitiana4Obama
"Let Detroit go bankrupt." -Romney
07:04 PM on 12/22/2009
THANK YOU!
09:46 AM on 12/22/2009
As a black person I have to say Obama is representi­ng the black race poorly. I remember him as a Senator in Chicago and how he fought for laws that he cared for. I see none of that fight in him now. It now seems he only cared about becoming the first black president and now he's done. Job over. What is really frustratin­g is seeing his speeches about what he wants done and then seeing his actions which are contrary to what he says. Nobody wants a flip flopper and straight up liar representi­ng them whether they be black, white or Hispanic. In this aspect he is doing a disservice to the black race. I wish he would stand up and become the fighter of the people we all elected.
10:13 AM on 12/22/2009
America has got to be the dumbest nation on the planet. Do you really think he knew what he was up against when he ran for the office? Of course not! We, the people, and the Media can sit here and speculate and make idiot comments on how we THINK things should be and what we THINK is going on, but NONE of us know what or who is really running the show. If you actually pay attention to him, you can see that his demeanor has changed. He knows things about the way this nation is run that he was not privvy to before. You wish he would become the figher the people wanted...h­ow do you know he hasnt tried to be? How do you know he wasnt stopped at every attempt? You and everyone else in the country are living in a fairy tale world if you think that holding that office means you run the show. Grow up and learn that cash rules everything around you.
10:18 AM on 12/22/2009
Awsome comment. The fight in him is gone. It's all about appeasing the right of the Democratic party that is controlled buy corporate america
09:42 AM on 12/22/2009
Obama is a total fabricatio­n of false hope designed and controlled by the corporate puppet masters. He will lead all of lower and middle class americans, regardless of race, back into slavery or at the very least indentured servitude.
09:45 AM on 12/22/2009
Are you referring to "Big Brother" or "The One World Government­"?
09:52 AM on 12/22/2009
Big Brother is already under way thanks to the Patriot Act.

There will be no One World Government till the US Empire falls.
09:35 AM on 12/22/2009
The President is very much aware of the plight of African Americans. However, he also knows exactly how we are. It is in our nature to complain about everything­. As my father use to say; we will have piece of bread in our mouth and still complain that we don't have any food.
10:22 AM on 12/22/2009
Thas has nothing to do with our nature. Next your going to say all we like is fried chicken and watermelon
12:32 PM on 12/22/2009
Come on als 360. When does telling the truth constitute turning against your own race? The truth is the truth regardless as to how much it hurts. If the truth stings . . . say OUCH and try to do better.

The President is everyone's President not just African Americans. We have to stop expecting him to solve all of our issues on the basis that he is AA. We need to stop complainin­g and get off our duff and work with him and our local government to solve our problems.