More

Malawi Villagers Forced To Move For A Madonna School

RAPHAEL TENTHANI   02/12/10 02:08 PM ET   AP

Madonna

BLANTYRE, Malawi — In a land dispute pitting Madonna against African villagers, Malawi's government has sided with the pop star who has pumped millions into this impoverished southern African country and adopted two of its children.

Villagers have been refusing to move from a plot of land near the capital, Lilongwe, where Madonna wants to build a $15 million school for girls. The government, however, says it had originally planned to develop the plot, and only allowed the villagers to live there until a project was identified.

Thursday, Lilongwe District Commissioner Charles Kalemba, accompanied by other government officials and representatives from Madonna's Raising Malawi charity, met with about 200 villagers and told them they would have to move. The villagers have been offered other government land.

"Government allowed you to occupy this land because there was no project yet. But now that Madonna wants to build you a school you have to give way," Kalemba told the villagers. "You are lucky that Madonna has compensated you for your houses, gardens and trees."

Anjimile Mtila-Oponyo, who will be principal of Madonna's school, said the singer paid the villagers more than 16 million kwacha (about $115,000) to compensate them for their houses – mostly mud-and-thatch structures – and improvements such as gardens and trees.

Headman Binson Chinkhota urged residents to move, saying the school would benefit their children. But Amos Mkuyu said the $1,500 in compensation he received from Madonna for mango trees and three homes was not enough. He said his family had been living on his seven-acre (three-hectare) plot for three generations.

The villagers are bitter, he said, but "there is nothing much we can do because government is using threats."

Mtila-Oponyo, the principal, said the school project was going ahead.

"We stalled for some months because of the land dispute," she said. "We are now in full swing and we intend to meet the 2011 deadline we set for ourselves."

According to its master-plan, the Raising Malawi Academy for Girls will be constructed with modern environment-friendly techniques, including solar panels for generating electricity. Mtila-Oponyo said the academy will serve 500 girls, mainly from underprivileged households.

"The academy will have a strong emphasis on sciences because it is the dream of Madonna that Malawi should train its own scientists and doctors to help the vulnerable Malawian girls and women who die needlessly because of lack of local expertise," she said.

Madonna adopted a daughter from Malawi last year and a son in 2008. Her Raising Malawi, a charity founded in 2006 when she first visited the country, helps feed, educate and provide medical care for orphans. In this nation of 12 million, about 500,000 children have lost a parent to AIDS.

Her adoptions raised concern among children's welfare groups, who questioned whether rules meant to protect children were being bent because of Madonna's celebrity, and perhaps out of gratitude for what she has done for Malawi.

While her 2008 adoption went relatively smoothly, a lower court at first rejected her bid to adopt her daughter, saying Madonna had not spent enough time in Malawi.

That case went to the nation's highest court. In June, a three-judge panel that included Chief Justice Lovemore Munlo said the initial rejection was a narrow interpretation based on old laws. The ruling that allowed her to adopt also cited the singer's commitment to helping disadvantaged children.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST ENTERTAINMENT

BLANTYRE, Malawi — In a land dispute pitting Madonna against African villagers, Malawi's government has sided with the pop star who has pumped millions into this impoverished southern African co...
BLANTYRE, Malawi — In a land dispute pitting Madonna against African villagers, Malawi's government has sided with the pop star who has pumped millions into this impoverished southern African co...
Filed by Katherine Thomson  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 107
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
08:23 AM on 02/21/2010
Uhhh how many of you would want to get forced out of your neighborhood... for a school to be built?

And not just your neighborhood... your job. These people are farmers, it's their job. It's like telling you , you have to move your house, and get a new job, because we want to build a school.

i dont understand how this is OK.

besides, the important part of a school is the teachers not the building.
10:30 AM on 02/19/2010
The title of this is unfair. It makes no mention of the fact that the land is going to be used to build a school for girls in a country that treats education of women as a tertiary goal and it also gives the impression that it is Madonna asking the people to move, which it is not, it is the Malawi government. I've never said this before, particularly in defense of a vapid pop star, but, "for shame HuffPo".
photo
GoldStarMom
Reading is Fundamentalism ... in Texas.
04:40 AM on 02/16/2010
Hey, what's the big dea? It's only 200 villagers, so what if many of them had lived there for several generations? Madonna's school will educate 500 girls, maybe even a few from your own village, that'll feel almost like they were back home.

It's not as if there was anyplace else they could have built it, for example the area the government's moving all of you to, after all. She compensated you all, didn't she? $1,500 for a 7 acre mango farm with 3 houses is a fair deal, that's around $200 an acre, what more do you expect.

Heck, she's planning to spend 15 million to build the school and the government's happy about that, they even cut through the laws and red tape when she adopted 2 of your orphans. How much more is a wealthy foreign celebrity supposed to sacrifice?

*turning off sarcasm now*
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Michael Ludin
Child advocate
08:19 PM on 02/15/2010
Who really cares about intentions. The results are fabulous--- education for girls who are otherwise marginalized and left to marry and birth more kids.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Michael Ludin
Child advocate
08:18 PM on 02/15/2010
What do y'all think. I believe anything is better then nothing whether well intentioned or not, the already too marginalized kids are getting the long end of the stick for a change!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LindyK
02:36 AM on 02/15/2010
I side with Madonna on this one. She's doing a very nice thing.
03:53 PM on 02/14/2010
Unfortunately, this has been an issue in Afghanistan as well where I am from.

NGOs have routinely paid Afghan villagers “compensation” for changing their location. This compensation has only been for the houses in which they lived. What capital can compensate the right of sovereignty? What capital can substitute the love for the particular piece of land where people have raised livestock, children and built places of worship?

The truth of the matter is, Americans are very simple-minded people. Such understanding is very esoteric for the average Madonna lover.
photo
GoldStarMom
Reading is Fundamentalism ... in Texas.
04:43 AM on 02/16/2010
That's the American way to deal with things. Shove enough money at it until you get your way.
09:53 AM on 02/14/2010
Some people here haven't read the article....

The people knew the land was going to be used for a project before-hand, and they are being given compensation and new land......

At the end of the day, even if she does it for PR reasons, who cares? She is building a school that will help educate hundreds and help improve their lives greatly.
08:21 AM on 02/14/2010
Americans making the natives happy. Thanks Madonna.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stylembe
Visual artist living in San
01:24 AM on 02/14/2010
Creepy.

http://bit.ly/9c4viI
07:11 PM on 02/13/2010
I sincerely hope these people have a place to move to - where it does not cost them anything in the process. I think this is very wrong, and Madonna can find another location that will not disrupt the lives of these people.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
marignymitch
E pluribus unum percent
04:01 PM on 02/13/2010
What Vadge wants ...
04:53 PM on 02/13/2010
Oooh you called her Vadge. Wow. What intellect. I chuckle everytime I see a Madonna headline on here just knowing you are going to lose your head over it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
marignymitch
E pluribus unum percent
06:15 PM on 02/13/2010
Happy I can be of service.
07:13 PM on 02/13/2010
...Ina gets. ( Sorry.)
11:15 AM on 02/13/2010
The government selected the site! Do you really think Madonna arranged it all. She is just bringing the money and the intentions to build and help.
01:08 AM on 02/13/2010
I know there is a lot of outrage over the fact that people will be uprooted, but people need to get some perspective. The school will uproot about 200 villagers, but the school will help more than 500 girls, which will no doubt have a lasting positive affect on Malawi, a place where over 2 million children are orphaned by AIDS. She doesn't sound that evil to me.
photo
GoldStarMom
Reading is Fundamentalism ... in Texas.
04:48 AM on 02/16/2010
The article says 500,000. Not like that's a small number, but it is 1/4 of the figure you mentioned.
11:45 PM on 02/12/2010
There is no need to uproot villagers to build one school. I think it's wonderful that she's building a school but this tactic is so poorly thought out. The school can be built elsewhere. It's like imperialism 2.0. People always embroil themselves in Africa without educating themselves beforehand. Africans are not objects to be mindlessly moved around. Smh.
02:42 AM on 02/13/2010
Well said.
03:25 PM on 02/13/2010
Thank you for the thoughtful post. You don't see many of those around here.

Here is my take- we don't know all the details. Was there other land available? This may have been the only suitable site. We don't know. It is government land, the villagers did not own it. It was always going to be developed eventually, according to reports.

If you watched Madonna documentary on this you would know she is well aware foreigners cannot solve Malawi's problems. They must come from Malawians. She wants to build this school to mold future leaders to empower their own people. Right now, that will never happen without education. Frankly I am shocked they are allowing her to attempt to provide education to the people as education is a direct threat to those in power. Africa has a long history of those in power keeping the people down by keeping them from being educated.

This has been a PR disaster for her yet she is sticking to it when she could have just said forget it and walked away. She was also savaged for her support of gays and lesbians and AIDS awareness but history has shown her to be on the right side of things. Make no mistake, Madonna hasn't always been known as the most lovable person but when it comes to the downtrodden, the weak, the neglected, the powerless she has shown to always have the biggest heart for them.