iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Dubai Releases Video Of Alleged Assassins In Hamas Chief Killing (VIDEO)

First Posted: 04/18/10 06:12 AM ET Updated: 05/25/11 04:30 PM ET

(AP) DUBAI, United Arab Emirates — Dubai police appealed for an international manhunt Tuesday after releasing names and photos of an alleged 11-member European hit squad accused of stalking and killing a Hamas commander last month in a plot that mixed cold precision with spy caper disguises such as fake beards and wigs.

The case – as presented by Dubai authorities – rings of clockwork espionage and detailed planning that included suspects riding the same elevator as Mahmoud al-Mabhouh before he was slain in an ambush-style attack in a luxury hotel room that took no more than 10 minutes.

But questions emerged about the list of suspects after Dubai authorities released pictures, names and passport photos identifying them as six Britons, three Irish and one each from France and Germany.

WATCH: Video report with footage from Gulf News


Ireland said the three alleged Irish citizens on the wanted list do not exist. In Germany, officials said the passport number give by Dubai for the lone German suspect is either incomplete or wrong.

Other elements also challenged the narrative presented by Dubai authorities, including how investigators pieced together the evidence pointing to an alleged European assassin team. Or why such an apparently well-planned operation would forget about the country's wide-ranging security cameras.

At least three people who live in Israel share names with suspects identified by Dubai police, Israel's Channel 2 news reported. Another man named as a suspect holds dual British-Israeli citizenship. Those connections are likely to encourage Hamas and others to press their claims that Israel's Mossad secret service masterminded the slaying. Hamas has vowed revenge.

Al-Mabhouh, one of the founders of Hamas' military wings, had been wanted by Israel for his role in the 1989 kidnapping and killing of two Israeli soldiers on leave – something that was acknowledged by Hamas last month.

Days after his body was found on Jan. 20, Israeli officials also pointedly accused al-Mabhouh of helping smuggle rockets into the Gaza Strip, the coastal territory ruled by Hamas.

Officials outside Dubai, however, said at least two Palestinians linked to the case were in Dubai custody, leaving Hamas and its Palestinian rivals trading bitter accusations.

Meanwhile, doubts were raised about some suspects' identities.

In Dublin, Ireland's Department of Foreign Affairs said it could not find the three suspects in passport records and the numbers listed were counterfeit because they have the wrong number of digits and contain no letters. "Ireland has issued no passports in those names," the department said in a statement to The Associated Press.

Germany's Interior Ministry also said the five-digit passport number given for the lone German suspect is too short and lacks the letters that now appear on its passports.

Melvyn Adam Mildiner, 31, one of the men identified by the Dubai police Monday as a suspect, was shocked when an AP reporter reached him on the phone in Israel and read him the information released by Dubai officials.

Mildiner, who said he holds a British and an Israeli passport, confirmed the name and the passport number matched his but said the date of birth was a few days off.

He said he did not know how anybody obtained his U.K. passport, issued in 2001 and never reported lost.

Britain's Foreign Office said in a statement Tuesday that authorities were aware the "holders of six British passports have been named" as suspects in the case but added authorities believe the passports used were fraudulent.

Dubai officials have said they would seek assistance from the global police coordination agency Interpol and press individual nations to hunt down the suspects.

Attorney General Essam al-Hemaydan said Tuesday that international arrest warrants have been issued.

The account presented Monday by Dubai's police chief, Lt. Gen. Dahi Khalfan Tamim, included surveillance video clips from the suspects' airport arrivals to their hasty departures to Europe and Asia before al-Mabhouh's body was found in Room 230 at the Al-Bustan Rotana Hotel near Dubai's international airport.

Tamim said the suspects arrived in Dubai at different times, checked into different hotels and tailed al-Mabhouh from the moment of his arrival in Dubai to when he entered his hotel room. Some suspects even rode in the same elevator as al-Mabhouh to verify his room number and later booked a room across the hall, Tamim said.

They paid for all expenses in cash and used different cell phone cards to avoid being traced, Tamim said.

Surveillance footage shows the female suspect apparently wearing a wig and at times a big hat and sunglasses to blend in as a tourist. Others also were disguised as vacationers, wearing baseball caps or tennis outfits and carrying rackets. Tamim also said some suspects donned fake beards.

He said forensic tests indicated al-Mabhouh died of suffocation, but lab analyses were still under way to pinpoint other possible factors. Hamas initially claimed al-Mabhouh was poisoned and electrocuted, but later a Hamas leader, Mohammed Nazzal, denied that poison was used.

The killing itself took just 10 minutes, Tamim said.

Four assassins later entered his room while he was out, using an electronic device to open the door, and waited in ambush for al-Mabhouh to return.

Tamim said they were careful not to disturb anything in the room and left the door locked from the inside.

The team then headed for the airport, some of them flying to Europe and others to Asia, he said. All left Dubai – one of seven semiautonomous emirates that make up the United Arab Emirates – within 19 hours of their arrival.

Dubai police claimed that four members of the alleged cell carried out the killing. Five others, including the woman, were used as spotters and in other planning roles, police said. The mastermind was a man identified as French.

The consul general of France in Dubai, Nada Yafi, declined to comment.

A former high-ranking Mossad official, Rami Igra, told Israel Army Radio that the assassin "does look professional" as described by Dubai police. But Igra said it "doesn't look like an Israeli operation" because of the apparent shortcuts, such as allowing members to be videotaped by security cameras.

Igra declined to speculate on who could have carried out the slaying, but noted that al-Mabhouh has many enemies and was at the center of bloody Palestinian feuds.

"He was not new to terror ... and he had many contacts with people who had good reason to want him dead," he said.

The two detained Palestinians were Hamas operatives, said West Bank police spokesman Adnan Damiri, citing sources familiar with the investigation.

Hamas, however, claimed the suspects were linked to the rival Fatah movement of Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas as part of alleged clandestine links with Israeli intelligence.

In Amman, Jordan, government spokesman Nabil Sharif told the AP that Jordan turned the two Palestinians over to the United Arab Emirates "a few days ago." He declined to give their names or further details.

Top Hamas figures have denied reports that al-Mabhouh was en route to Iran, a major Hamas backer. But the group has not given clear reasons for his presence in Dubai.

Besides Mildiner, the other suspects were identified by Dubai police as Michael Lawrence Barney, James Leonard Clarke, Jonathan Louis Graham, Paul John Keeley and Stephen Daniel Hodes of Britain; Gail Folliard, Evan Dennings and Kevin Daveron of Ireland; Peter Elvinger of France and Michael Bodenheimer of Germany.

___

Associated Press Writers Mohammed Daraghmeh in Ramallah, West Bank, Jamal Halaby in Amman, Jordan, Amy Teibel in Jerusalem, Dave Rising in Berlin, Shawn Pogatchnik in Dublin and Raphael Satter in London contributed to this report.

(This version CORRECTS ADDS three people in Israel share names with suspects; corrects name of former Mossad agent to Igra sted Yigal; ADDS video.)

FOLLOW HUFFPOST WORLD

(AP) DUBAI, United Arab Emirates — Dubai police appealed for an international manhunt Tuesday after releasing names and photos of an alleged 11-member European hit squad accused of stalking and ...
(AP) DUBAI, United Arab Emirates — Dubai police appealed for an international manhunt Tuesday after releasing names and photos of an alleged 11-member European hit squad accused of stalking and ...
Filed by Nicholas Sabloff  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 399
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (9 total)
01:53 PM on 02/22/2010
I retract my initial statements.... this was a job done by Oceans 11. Goerge Clooney, Brad Pit, Julia Roberts, et al.
photo
flashfyre
Honore de Balzac
11:04 PM on 02/21/2010
My guess is Israel felt it was worth exposing these agents not only because they took out the primary arms negotiator for Hamas but (more importantly) obtained all his documents for the arms meetings he was travelling to in China. Those documents are a huge political bargaining chip for Israel because the official party line in China is non-interference with other nations.
06:22 PM on 02/18/2010
I believe this was an operation by the CIA rather than Mossad, and knew that being video taped would throw confusion and finger pointing into the investigation. Interpol will never know who did this and neither will Dubai Officials. Good work who ever did this, Great Showmanship.
photo
skialethia
αω vs military might
01:25 AM on 02/26/2010
The CIA is now resorting to stealing Israeli identities, right?? Try again.
05:15 PM on 02/18/2010
Gail smiled to the video camera at the end of the operation, they knew they would be movie stars. I like it.
06:54 AM on 02/18/2010
Why on earth would Israel leave clues that incriminate her own citizens? Couldn't possibly be a set-up by one of her enemies, could it?
photo
skialethia
αω vs military might
01:27 AM on 02/26/2010
Nope. Did you see their pictures? Cam on!
10:52 PM on 02/17/2010
I guess I probably won't get the answer here...but in a world where facial recognition, voice, finger print, coupled with widespread CCTV + centralized image storage using Ethernet, computer&internet records, credit card, e-passport & digitalized travel records, proxy cards & door locks (as noted in the video), not to mention phone&cell phone record....how is it possible to not use same agents for assassination in a city environment, like Dubai?

Some ways I thought of are - make up & plastic surgery, use of "rubber finger" for fingerprints, use of relay for phone calls, but internet seems to be off limit since it leaves too much traces. Also wouldn't any single hair dropped, even scraped arm leave behind DNA evidences?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Archie1955
04:14 PM on 02/17/2010
Hamas should learn that the best revenge is eaten cold. Let Dubai's investigation conclude, they are not going to let this rest until they either have the assassins or know who they are. That is the time for evenge and i don't mean more killing, that is not revenge it's just suicidal. No, what you want is true revenge, to hold up to the light of day the parties that did this evil deed and whichever country is behind it. Then you ask the countries whose passports have been compromised what they are going to do about it. Keep rattling the cage and you will get results. You want to make sure this kind of egregious behaviour is prevented as much as possible from happening again so you lobby for the complicit country to be ostracized from association with civilized countries. Let them suffer the inability to meet in any other country, let their leaders be prevented from leaving their country, let their exports be boycotted, let their airline industry lose all landing rights in the rest of the world. Such a country may have one foreign supporter which follows the same kind of egregious behaviour and which will allow the citizens of that country to travel to it as before but at least the rest of the world will then know that any further assassinations using this modus operandi will be emanating from this third country and that they are totally complicit in it.
02:55 PM on 02/17/2010
Uh, oh. Israel just opened up a whole new front. A lot like the IRA drumming up incidents to get more money from silly Irish "Republicans" abroad. This is gonna get ugly!
01:14 PM on 02/17/2010
Great work by Dubai Police to publish pics of 11 suspects so soon... Wow!. ..
Now, big question is who is covering up who for not doing their job properly....

Immigration incompetence for not checking passports properly or trainors not training immigration staff to detect forged passports or both following policy of not scutinizing thoroughly passports of white Europeans. Only keep asians under hammer & keep rhetoric of great work done by all when they catch one asian with a flawed document.

This will continue & increase till white Europeans including Mafia groups enter Dubai unchecked without a proper visa document issued thru sponsor resident in Dubai... Similarly what is applied to asians to enter Dubai. Unless this is also applied to these Europeans this drama of catch em, find em, forget em, find new ones and chase asians out will be great game of the day and good photo ops for all & sundry who matter in newspapers.

It is time Dubai reconsiders its policy for white Eurpeans entry visa requirements. Give better training to immigration staff to change their mindset that white Eurpoeans can also be crooks, thieves, killers, and contraband pushers. It is not asians only who are the sorts. One wonders when will this change come... when it does, Dubai government will be proud of themselves & hold head higher than what is now... Dubai has done a lot for its people & expatriates, but needs to apply its rules to all (including white Europeans) evenly..
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
02:40 PM on 02/17/2010
Yeah right, brilliant investigation: round up the usual security footage and make snapshots of everyone wearing western clothes and a hat.

Move over Sherlock - Dr bin Watson reporting for duty.
03:02 PM on 02/17/2010
Yes and profiling every Arab that comes to the US should be done as well....
12:57 PM on 02/24/2010
They've already been doing that for years.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nym22
10:46 AM on 02/17/2010
This video needs music. Maybe the theme from the Benny Hill Show?
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
05:47 PM on 02/17/2010
I fought the law and the law won?
10:40 AM on 02/17/2010
just in Israeli community leaders blame Mossad.New high tech passports make trans -international hits much more difficult its seems.
http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSTRE61G2PF20100217
09:30 AM on 02/17/2010
An eye for a eye again infinitem ...c.i.a-mossad job who knows?!will TMZ expose the truth?ha

.It makes me laugh though,when people say oh Mossad wouldnt let themselves be photographed.
Read up;the target never left Syria of late, so his one off trip to Dubai was their only option to "do him " Dubai has the highest tech airport,you would be a red light if you were seen scuffling sideways past security cams!.
Also the assassins would've been bonused a healthy sum to take the risks.The yanks had a bounty of US12.5mill on him.do the math.
Also between standard disguises- fake teeth /wigs/contact lenses and more modern cosmetic procedures i.e Botox and Restalyne implants( thats injectable facial putty)They wouldve been able to alter the look of there facial structures(think wildenstein!.)After the jobs done they can disappear -burn passports/dissolve the Restalyne(with hyaluronidase acid injection)What a strange world we live in...
04:16 PM on 02/17/2010
Indeed! The Israelis are doing just what the IRA used to do, They have to drum up drama in order for cynical "Israel Firsters" (AIPAC) in our Congress to funnel money to Israel through foreign aid and Swiss bank transfers. It is just another such effort to appear relevant. I hope Americans wake up soon and realize how they are being played for SUCKERS.
08:42 AM on 02/17/2010
I took the time to watch the whole video and read the whole piece...

Nice video, but am not sold yet....until they answer one nagging question...

How did the suspects leave the room with the latches on and the door locked from inside?...

The article or the video did not explain that, until that is proven and despite the nice video documentary, it is plausible that the guy died of natural causes.
04:17 PM on 02/17/2010
Indeed! The Israelis are doing just what the IRA used to do. They have to drum up drama in order for cynical "Israel Firsters" (AIPAC) in our Congress to funnel money to Israel through foreign aid and Swiss bank transfers. It is just another such effort to appear relevant. I hope Americans wake up soon and realize how they are being played for SUCKERS.
08:31 AM on 02/17/2010
No one knows who did this...certainly not the keyboard commandos here. It is interesting that today Jordan, which has one of the world's best intelligence services, extradited two Palestinians from Dubai as part of an investigation into Mabhouh's assassination.
photo
future primitive
Voice in the Wilderness
08:23 AM on 02/17/2010
Who knows what their real identities are. I don't. But when they ran photos yesterday, you could tell who was was gonna be ops and who was communications/surveillance. Amazing to see the four guys in ball caps take the same elevator out. Casual. Another day at the office.