Michael Mukasey Slams Liz Cheney's 'Shoddy And Dangerous' Logic In WSJ Op-Ed

First Posted: 03-10-10 01:30 AM   |   Updated: 05- 9-10 05:12 AM

What's Your Reaction?
Mukasey Liz Cheney

Former U.S. Attorney General Michael Mukasey wrote an op-ed in The Wall Street Journal Wednesday attacking Liz Cheney's "Al-Qaida 7" logic as "shoddy and dangerous."

While the former chief of the Bush Justice Department never mentioned Cheney by name, he made it clear that anyone would be wrong to automatically identify DOJ lawyers with the defendants that they represent. Mukasey wrote:

This is all of a piece, and what it is a piece of is something both shoddy and dangerous. A lawyer who represents a party in a contested matter has an ethical obligation to make any and all tenable legal arguments that will help that party. A lawyer in public service, particularly one dealing with sensitive matters of national security, has the obligation to authorize any step or practice the law permits in order to keep the nation and its citizens safe. And a lawyer who undertakes to represent someone whom his neighbors--perhaps rightly--revile as a threat to the public welfare is obligated to bring his talents to bear just as forcefully in favor of that client as he would if he were representing Capt. Alfred Dreyfus, the French artillery officer who in 1895 was found guilty of treason and sent to Devil's Island for little more than being Jewish.

Mukasey is the latest Bush administration official to denounce Cheney's logic, though Some might be disappointed to learn that in the same op-ed, Mukasey also defended John Yoo and Jay Bybee, the authors of the Bush torture memos.

On Monday, 19 prominent Bush administration officials and other lawyers, including Ken Starr, signed a letter denouncing Cheney's ad.

Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.), turned Cheney's logic on its head Tuesday and argued that lawyers who defend "the unpopular" make America safer. Graham told The Cable "...America requires the unpopular to have an advocate and every time a defense lawyer fights to make the government do their job, that defense lawyer has made us all safer."

Get HuffPost Politics On Twitter, Facebook, and Google Buzz! Subscribe to the new HuffPost Hill newsletter!
Former U.S. Attorney General Michael Mukasey wrote an op-ed in The Wall Street Journal Wednesday attacking Liz Cheney's "Al-Qaida 7" logic as "shoddy and dangerous." While the former chief of the B...
Former U.S. Attorney General Michael Mukasey wrote an op-ed in The Wall Street Journal Wednesday attacking Liz Cheney's "Al-Qaida 7" logic as "shoddy and dangerous." While the former chief of the B...
Filed by T.J. Ortenzi  |  Report Corrections
 
Comments
444
Pending Comments
0
View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »   (14 total)
  1 of 1  
COMMUNITY PUNDITS
realpolitic   07:22 AM on 3/10/2010
Liz Cheney has gone way too far. Her fascist tendencies have gotten the best of her. Not only does she want to torture people to get information, she then wants them to have no hearings and get no legal representation. Of course, she would be the first to say government can not do anything right so why give it so much power? When the far right guys like Mukasey and Ken Starr are coming out against her, you  Read More...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Balzac   04:20 PM on 3/17/2010
Wrong again, Liz.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
AyeChart   06:30 PM on 3/10/2010
Mukasey is a fine lawyer, fine judge, did a great job in the Bush administration, but he's off base here.

These were not lawyers hired by the terrorists who simply took the job of representing the terrorists. These were lawyers who gleefully flocked to the terrorists either because they wanted to poke a few sticks in the eyes of the Bush administration or because they actually supported terrorists or terrorism.

Or perhaps just that they were publicity hounds?

In any case, it is fair to question WHY they were so eager, so GD eager, to fly to Guantanamo and defend terrorists.
photo
Flokk   05:38 PM on 3/10/2010
Is anything this woman says important or relevant enough to warrant this kind of reaction? Not even close. The media built her up because she's polarizing and helps draw viewers, that's all.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Economike   05:50 PM on 3/10/2010
Unfortunaley she in common with someone like Joseph McCarty has to potential to damage many lives.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
deeppeace   04:34 PM on 3/10/2010
I'm not "disappointed to learn that in the same op-ed, Mukasey also defended John Yoo and Jay Bybee" at all--

Even though I disagree with him, at least it proves that Mukasey put thought into his observations and didn't just paint with a broad brush. And man, Liz is worse than Yoo and Bybee? Whew!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
KevinFitzz   04:31 PM on 3/10/2010
Quite a dangerous duo, that daddy and daughter. So dangerous in fact, they should be arrested.
photo
hyjanks   04:13 PM on 3/10/2010
Looks like Jihad Liz is going to join Jihad Jane in her infamy.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
flossophy   04:07 PM on 3/10/2010
Mukasey is right on this one... Liz should retract it.

I still think she should be veep.

Condi / Liz 2012
ZiloRS   04:11 PM on 3/10/2010
Then the world really would end in 2012.
photo
Bogey907   04:19 PM on 3/10/2010
LOL, that's a good one.

I thought you were serious for a moment.
photo
Exexecution   04:33 PM on 3/10/2010
I think you should be commited
reed-er   11:14 PM on 3/12/2010
How about Cheney-Palin 2012!
photo
ladbrady   04:03 PM on 3/10/2010
How's your SEEEESter Liz?
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
KriTiKiT   03:47 PM on 3/10/2010
I wanna know who she has defended. Just to prove a point.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Ed and Deb Shapiro   03:45 PM on 3/10/2010
Liz Liz - arrogance can get you nowhere

You can fool some of the people some of the time but not all of the time

Liz has had her say and is becoming more and more the one who will bring down the Cheney mob once and for all! what a relief!

Does anyone agree?

Ed
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Dosadi   04:34 PM on 3/10/2010
I hope so. It is impossible for a person to say the rediculous things she is saying without it coming back to bite her.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Economike   05:49 PM on 3/10/2010
We can only hope.
photo
robphilnz   03:40 PM on 3/10/2010
The Cheney name becomes more tarnished with every passing day. It's like reverse alchemy, with time : degrading the gilding to show the base element of who and what they are.

Of course, I suppose that she could be a Democrat double agent involved in a conspiracy to make the GOP look even more stupid! If so, she's doing a great job.
photo
rjvg50   03:25 PM on 3/10/2010
It's tragic that this thread only harpoons Liz Cheney - her partner is crime BILL KRISTOL must pay the price for his treason as well.

Boycott any show that has Bill Kristol as a regular commentator.

Can someone start a "Color of Change" sponsor bail-out of Bill Kristol's numerous, regular gigs?
photo
Exexecution   04:34 PM on 3/10/2010
William Kristol---he who has yet to be right, even once.
bbmill37   02:59 PM on 3/10/2010
I'd like to hear nothing more from this woman unless it's on the witness stand at the Hague, trying to defend her daddy and his boss.
simonbollocks   04:43 PM on 3/10/2010
word.
photo
quintus   02:50 PM on 3/10/2010
Gosh, she seems to have evaporated into thin air recently. Why isn't she out there defending her position?
Petey131   02:51 PM on 3/10/2010
She's back at the cave getting further advice from daddy.
edtheengineer   05:19 PM on 3/10/2010
Lizzie Borden Chainee is awaiting delivery of a shipment of new axes. Her current ones have become chipped and dull.
photo
panamarine   11:12 AM on 3/16/2010
Because her position is indefensable! That's why. And she has been reprimanded and now is ashamed and went into hiding with a red face. That's why.
ethearch   02:40 PM on 3/10/2010
Something tells me we won't be hearing from Dark Vadress any time soon.
maumeeone   02:53 PM on 3/10/2010
Don't bet on it.She has no shame...Or apparently morals, for that matter.

Twitter Edition