More

Middle Class No More: New Jersey Family Scrapes By On Half Its Former Income

Agins Family

First Posted: 06/13/10 06:12 AM ET Updated: 05/25/11 05:10 PM ET

As part of our Bearing Witness 2.0 project, the Huffington Post is rounding up local stories of formerly middle-class families who are now struggling to stay afloat. If you or someone you know has a story to tell, please e-mail me at LBassett@huffingtonpost.com.

Two years ago, Ben and Jennifer Agins of Somerset County, New Jersey, thought they were on track to finally purchase their first house. She was making $65,000 a year as a patent administrator for a pharmaceutical company, he was making $55,000 a year as the manager of residential business for Edison Overhead, and they were comfortably supporting their four kids in addition to one foster child.

That dream of homeownership began to slip away in August of 2008 when Jennifer's job was outsourced, leaving Ben to support their family of seven on his salary alone. Adding insult to injury, Agins says he was told that he would not be receiving his 3 to 5 percent salary raise that year or for the next few years, since the tanking economy had put a dent in his business.

"My wife and I used to be middle class," Agins, 38, wrote in an email to HuffPost. "Now we're the 'working poor.' We have 5 children that we are trying to support on my 55k salary, but we have been unable to get any government assistance because we make too much money."

Agins says his wife has been aggressively applying for jobs, everywhere from Quickcheck, the local convenience store, to FedEx, but every job she finds either offers her less money than she receives on unemployment or rejects her for not having the right kind of experience. She has been out of work for almost two years now.

"It's gotten pretty tough," Agins said. "Not only was she making more money than me, but she had the benefits through a major corporation. When she lost that job, I had to pick up the benefits here, which were more than double the cost of what she was paying."

Jennifer is currently training to do medical billing for the New Jersey Department of Labor and Workforce Development, and in the meantime, Ben says, the family is just trying to get by.

"It took her 18 months to get into that program," Agin said. "Somehow we've managed to pay rent every month, although we were late a couple times. We're starting to get used to living on less."

Agins says he doesn't mind the lifestyle changes as much, although he hates having to say no to his kids. His daughter's cheerleading team placed third in a national championship in 2008, but he had to pull her off last year's team because it got too expensive. He says he also had to tell his 15-year-old son that he could no longer attend his favorite summer skateboarding camp.

"They've since gotten over it," he said. "My 18-year-old got lucky -- a friend of the family donated a car when he got his driver's license. I couldn't have given him that."

Despite all of their financial challenges, the Aginses seem to be hopeful about the next few years -- Ben says his wife is one of the top students in her vocational class, and his business is showing signs of picking up.

"We're already seeing people start to spend money a little, fix up their houses," he said. "So we're just holding out until things turn around."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST IMPACT

As part of our Bearing Witness 2.0 project, the Huffington Post is rounding up local stories of formerly middle-class families who are now struggling to stay afloat. If you or someone you know has a s...
As part of our Bearing Witness 2.0 project, the Huffington Post is rounding up local stories of formerly middle-class families who are now struggling to stay afloat. If you or someone you know has a s...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 758
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (13 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Singing Sparrow
retired-government worker
02:41 PM on 04/14/2010
Thank you for your words and thoughts.
This family wanted to buy their own house. That is no longer possible. I feel for them and for so many people caught up in this transfer of wealth from the middle-class to the uber wealthy, the corporations and their owners. I find it sad that people who I would think would be on their side are ready to condemn.
01:32 PM on 04/14/2010
theres nothing wrong with this family, they seem like good people

whats silly is this article acts like a family that "only" makes $55,000 is struggling, and that this is a tragedy (they also get her unemployment, which is approx $22.000)

granted, based on the choices they make, they may have to make adjustments,
but that this author cant see that this family makes a pretty good amount of money (nearly $35,000 over the national average) shows a certain level of being out of touch

of course that this family, making nearly $80,000 a year would have applied for govt assistance makes me wonder about them a little, but at least (rightly so) they didnt qualify

personally i wish them the best,
but this is hardly a family in poverty, even in high tax new jersey
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Singing Sparrow
retired-government worker
02:30 PM on 04/14/2010
Oh!! where do you live?? $55,000 on the East coast for a family of seven is poverty. You need to reread the article especially the sentence regarding the loss of benefits through her job and the doubling of those expenses when he had to pick up through his job.
The unemployment will only go on for six months.
03:30 PM on 04/14/2010
I was asking myself the same question!! Maybe they really can not comprehend the cost of living on the East coast. EVERYONE start using your search engines!
08:08 PM on 04/14/2010
i lived in nyc for nyc for 18 years

so i know east coast

as for unemployment insurance benefits

you can collect them for 99 weeks (almost two years)

not six months

and with her getting more than $22,000 a year in unemployment, on top of his $55,000 they should be able to get by just fine
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StJames
In absentia luci tenebrae vincunt
12:36 PM on 04/14/2010
One last point:

Lower class is now more commonly referred to as the "Working Class" PC in action.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StJames
In absentia luci tenebrae vincunt
12:35 PM on 04/14/2010
In all fairness to those who have not quite understood the point of this article:

HP would be better served by employing writers who actually knew and understood their material and could make their case more clearly. It would help if they also employed headline writers with the same qualification. ;-)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StJames
In absentia luci tenebrae vincunt
12:10 PM on 04/14/2010
I think some of the problem here is that "class" identification issue. And I think perhaps that's due to the fact we are seeing so much income inequality there has been a major shift in these classes. First, it used to be that the "poverty" level translated into the lower, lower class... minimum wage and unskilled labor. Then you had lower class which was semi-skilled labor.

Middle Class had 3 brackets. Lower, middle and upper. As the numbers comprising the middle class were huge the difference in incomes was as well. You lower middle class was skilled labor. Your middle, middle class was low level management and your upper middle class was mid level management and some professionals. The upper middle class income range was enormous....Somewhere between $250K and $300K you crossed over into lower upper class.

I'd like to say again that this article is not about feeling sorry for this family. It's not about poverty vs. wealth or even poverty vs. making it. It's about the destruction of a dream after 18 years of hard work.
It's about what is happening all over America as once prosperous families are reduced to "just making it"

Camp counselors all over the country who will not be able to find employment this summer.
Many of those counselors are teachers and college students who need the extra money to support their families or defray tuition cost. This is a story about how "trickle down" only works in the negative.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OneGirlsOpinion
10:17 AM on 04/14/2010
This article was a missed opportunity to address a significant issue facing millions of Americans. It would've been far more constructive if it were framed in a way that showcased how people need to learn to cut corners and live within their means when household economics change. It comes across as elitist and out-of touch that this family is positioned as some sympathy case because the poor kids can't go to skateboard camp (have we really become that spoiled?) It was irresponsible to try to make members of this family the poster children for the "working poor" when what they are going through is hardly unique, or exemplary of real hardship. I live in NJ and I know that $55K/year doesn't go very far (even with the unemployment benefits they are also receiving) - but it's certainly feasible to live if you can take responsibility for your money. This family is doing the right thing - making changes rather than adding to personal debt (at least that's what I'm assuming), but it's all just hidden beneath an air of entitlement. I really hope this wasn't the goal of the writer or this family and I hope they'll use a little more common sense with future articles in the series because I do believe there are lessons we can all learn from other people forced to make lifestyle changes.
photo
GravitonX
10^300 bosons could care less.
09:13 AM on 04/14/2010
The median household income for whites is $49k, for Latinos and Blacks, $34k and $30k, respectively. $48k/yr. household is technically, mathematically middle middle class.

These people bring home $55k on one salary, and when the husband gets another job they be back in the stratosphere making $120k. Our household income is close to $200k, but even I'm not so out of touch as to say I'm "middle class." Our family has higher expenses but that's because we've chosen it. No one should cry for us if we lose half our income because we could easily downsize, if necessary, and have more money than we know what to do with, relatively speaking.

These people are anything but middle class. I deal with people who live at the median and below, daily. I also deal with this so-called middle class. Trust me, many of the people at the level of this family ("the rich who declare themselves poor" - because they don't "feel" rich) are completely out-of-touch with the true mathematically middle class of this country. They scoff at them from their often homogenous neighborhoods. They thankfully ignore them, consider them lower class and worse, and really don't want them in their neighborhoods or schools.

What you are seeing is that case of "what was over there is now over here" and they are getting a taste of karma.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StJames
In absentia luci tenebrae vincunt
11:53 AM on 04/14/2010
The median and below is not the middle class...never has been.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StJames
In absentia luci tenebrae vincunt
11:56 AM on 04/14/2010
And you household income qualifies you for Upper Middle Class
08:43 AM on 04/14/2010
Call me unsympathetic if you must. These people really don't deserve any.
08:38 AM on 04/14/2010
You people all seem to be skimming over the part where the wife is getting unemployment. That means they're making MORE than $55k per year.

Also, they don't pay taxes on their home because they RENT, so the argument that property taxes are somehow driving them to poverty is ridiculous. At their income level, they don't pay the highest income tax bracket in the state (which isn't that high, anyway). The taxes they DO pay probably add up to all of 1% of their total income (income tax and sales tax).

Not to mention there are obviously at least TWO able-bodied teenagers of employable age in the family who can certainly contribute SOMETHING to the household income.

Cry me a river, seriously. This is NOT a sad story. Not compared to a lot of what's been happening in this country for the past few years. There are people who are freaking homeless and completely jobless and moneyless, and you guys want to cry for a family who is doing better than over 50% of the nation?

The kids can't go to camp? Who cares?! This is not a tragedy! I'm insulted that the author titled the story "Middle Class No More". These folks are still middle class! They aren't living in poverty, far from it! When the oldest child has to drop out of school to go to work and help pay the bills, let me know. I could probably manage some sympathy then.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OneGirlsOpinion
09:13 AM on 04/14/2010
I agree with you on all this. But one thing - someone owns the apartment they rent...that property tax is built it, so while they don't pay property tax, they are still paying. Rent ain't cheap in Jersey.
photo
GravitonX
10^300 bosons could care less.
09:19 AM on 04/14/2010
Here's the other thing people missed. They get PAID for the foster child. This among other forms of "welfare" are common, like the HUGE number of people playing the disability scam that's rampant in this country. But, America associates the welfare stigma with only "particular" types of people.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OneGirlsOpinion
09:33 AM on 04/14/2010
If I'm interpreting the picture correctly, they adopted the foster child. I don't think they get the subsidy anymore. Though I could be wrong there.
07:43 AM on 04/14/2010
Actually NJ is a very expensive state. $55,000 a year doesn't go as far as it might in other states. Besides, I don't berate them for having several children since they were making the money to support them. I'm more upset that her job was outsourced, that's the real problem.
photo
GravitonX
10^300 bosons could care less.
09:28 AM on 04/14/2010
I think you have absolutely no idea what it means to truly struggle. The people who live on the median live in what you call "rundown" neighborhoods, where incomes don't move and the cost of living, e.g. rent has been stagnant for decades - because they don't have any money. They're typically dotted with trailers or near the ghetto. That's America.
07:38 AM on 04/14/2010
04:58 AM on 04/14/2010
Come on huff po. I don't consider this scraping by. Scraping by is having a can of Beneful for dinner. But I can sympathize with this family and it sucks living pay check to pay check. A lot of people have gotten poorer this family is just one example.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
floodberg
Attorney (ret.)
04:44 AM on 04/14/2010
ATTENTION HP AUTHORS AND EDITORS:

If HP is going to attempt to develop original content to a posted article, an editor needs to frame the article, clearly state the issue and its importance, break down the logical argument that relates the issue to the personal story, and specify additional background information that will illustrate both the issue and the relationship.

Undoubtedly this family came forward with the intent to facilitate the discussion of a critically important trend in American society, the middle class slipping into lower economic brackets. That message was totally lost. This is only a 'story' about some people from NJ, which has cruelly resulted in the family being ripped apart and analyzed in 12 pages of comments made by anonymous bloggers.

No media outlet, even on the internet, should ever make a mistake like this, especially when using a family who has volunteered to be the subject. If the authors have any integrity, they will post an apology on HP for this debacle.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OneGirlsOpinion
09:21 AM on 04/14/2010
Totally agree. The point was completely missed. It should've been framed that people need to learn to cut corners and live within their means when household economics change. It was irresponsible of HuffPo to try to make this family the poster children for the "working poor" when what they are going through is hardly unique, or exemplary of real hardship. It comes across as highly elitist and out-of touch that they position as some sympathy case because the poor kids can't go to skateboarding camp. I really hope this wasn't the goal of the writer or this family and I hope they'll use a little more common sense with future articles in the series because I do believe there are lessons we can all learn from other people forced to make lifestyle changes.
07:46 PM on 04/14/2010
Great point. Some of us have been trying to keep people on the issue intended. Yet, people are still focusing on the family.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kingofthenet
Where is Your GOD, Now?
01:47 AM on 04/14/2010
Medical Billing and coding...What a JOKE! I also took a course directed by Unemployment at CPLC(Computer Professional Learning Center) what a WORTHLESS course, not only were ther no books provided, but the teacher was so substandard as to be criminal..Good Luck finding a job!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lhsouthern1988
01:34 AM on 04/14/2010
So what! We live on 2000.00 a month take home from my husbands salary as a teacher.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
belyeu
04:16 AM on 04/14/2010
"So what! We live on 2000.00 a month take home from my husbands salary as a teacher."

Are there 7 of you?
03:49 PM on 04/14/2010
my thoughts exactly