iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

A War Over Water Dries Up Good Will Between Jews, Arabs

First Posted: 06/30/10 06:12 AM ET Updated: 05/25/11 05:20 PM ET

Palestine Water

By Sarah Grooters
Religion News Service

JERUSALEM (RNS) Given the choice, Fatmeh Kawasmi has put her guests ahead of her flowers.

With a limited supply of water, it's comes down to giving a drink to her flowers or serving tea to her guests. So Kawasmi, as a good Middle Eastern host, pours water into the little cups instead of the soil, and hopes her flowers hang on for another week.

"I consider the flowers and plants my friends," said Kawasmi, a 69-year-old grandmother who lives in Qalandia, a West Bank town about 7 miles north of Jerusalem. "I watch them die because of the lack of water."

Kawasmi and about 1,000 other Arabs in her town make daily decisions when it comes to water -- there's just not enough to go around. Kawasmi and her family only have running water one day a week, twice if they're lucky.

"In summer, we stay without water for two weeks. We depend on buying water that is not healthy, and not examined (for contamination). But still it's expensive," she said.

Palestinians are facing a real crisis when it comes to water.

"Israelis have 4.5 times more water than Palestinians," said Dr. David Phillips, a water engineering consultant who's worked in the region for more than 11 years. "Even in the Palestinian community, there's huge variation from top to bottom. The guys at the bottom are thirsty, so thirsty they hurt."

According to Amnesty International, the average Palestinian gets less than 70 liters of water a day. People living in some communities, like Qalandia, get even less. Compare that to the average American, who uses about 380 liters a day, and the average Israeli, who uses 315
liters.

For people like Kawasmi, that means a shower is rare and flowers wither and die.

"Last summer, some villages got running water once a month," Phillips said. "Some villages just get water on Saturdays, and sometimes they just get seasonal water."

While Phillips says the Middle Eastern climate makes it difficult to get and keep water even under the best circumstances, there is no reason for the Palestinian water crisis. In recent years, several nongovernmental organizations like Amnesty International have accused the Israeli government of essentially using water as a weapon. Nowhere is this more pronounced than in Gaza and the West Bank, where Kawasmi lives.

There, Arab villages and Jewish settlers can live only a mile or two apart, but get far different allocations of water. The settlers, who are subsidized by the Israeli government, are encouraged to plant crops and have gardens, while the Palestinians try to collect enough to survive.

"Numbering about 450,000, the (Israeli West Bank) settlers use as much or more water than the Palestinian population of some 2.3 million," according to an Amnesty report from October 2009.

In a statement posted on their website, the Israel Water Authority refutes the claim that they are treating the Palestinians unfairly. They say the Amnesty International report was biased and did not present the facts accurately.

"(T)he information presented in the report is distorted, giving inaccurate and misleading presentations of the water supply situations in the region," said Uri Shani, the director general of the Israel Water Authority.

Phillips, however, says the problem is only getting worse. He claims the Israeli government is causing a systematic water shortage amongst the Palestinians to further weaken their morale and pocketbooks.

When Kawasmi doesn't have enough water, she is forced to buy it from expensive tanker trucks that drive around with water from unknown locations. She says the water tastes bad, and Phillips said most Americans would "spit it out."

Sometimes, residents can see particles floating in the water that shouldn't be there, according to Phillips. But, bad water is better than no water at all, at least in the short term.

"In Gaza, 30 to 40 percent of all disease-related deaths are caused by bad water. Kidney and liver diseases are common there which has to do with salts and minerals in the water. Kids get it worst because adults can build up immunity," Phillips said.

Phillips said the decades-old crisis shows no sign of improving as long as the political situation remains unstable. He added that if the Israelis continue doling out such limited supplies of water, Palestinians will continue to drain aquifers in unsustainable -- and unsafe -- ways. Some Palestinians, he said, pump their own water through illegal wells, with no regulations in place to prevent sewage from seeping into the water source.

"I've faced this problem for 30 years since I moved into this home, and each year, it's getting worse year by year," said Kawasmi. "Imagine what it's like when you have guests over and you don't have water in your bathroom."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST RELIGION

Filed by Clay Chiles  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 294
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
09:07 AM on 05/06/2010
This article doesn't make sense! Flowers or tea??? Flowers can be watered with dishwater, bathwater, cooking water, even urine in limited amounts. Laundry and personal hygiene can certainly be a problem if water is scarce, flowers are not.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JustMeInNY
Live and Learn.
04:56 PM on 05/06/2010
LOL!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
INTUITE
10:41 PM on 05/05/2010
The greatest war this world will ever experience, will be world wide and it will be for water.
06:39 AM on 05/04/2010
water means life all over the world and in the Middle East water is even more precious . . . make no mistake the israeli's have been working hard to deprive the Palestinians of their land and water . . . it is more than time that the US stop being complicent in israel's crimes against the Palestinians . . .

http://www.waronwant.org/campaigns/fighting-occupation-in-palestine
03:29 AM on 05/04/2010
Who gets control of the Jordan river was pointed out nearly a decade ago (as I recall) as a major but unacknowledged factor of conflict between Jews and Palestinians. Failing resources have since contributed to the ethnic cleansing in Darfur. Expect shortages of basic necessities to heat up many more simmering conflicts that will be reported as "ethnic" and "religious." According to a lengthy study ordered by the Pentagon, blowback from climate change could result in major wars between countries like Pakistan and India that already have hostile relations on other grounds.
08:16 PM on 05/03/2010
According to Amnesty International, the average Palestinian gets less than 70 liters of water a day.

This figure doesn't ring true. I would doubt that my family of 5 uses 70 liters of water in a day. Not every day.
09:07 PM on 05/05/2010
Really?

The average water consumption per person, per day, in Washington is 265 litres.

http://www.wsscwater.com/service/waterusagechart.cfm
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cbzd
05:11 PM on 05/03/2010
This article is way short on research as to the reasons this situation exists. I am left with the thought that it is obviously Israel that is to blame, again, for the plight of the Palestinians and the lack of water in Gaza. Do some research and see what happened in the days after Gaza was handed back, see what became of the greenhouses, infrastructure and even the houses that were built by the Israelis. It is possible that Hamas could spend some of their weaponry money on getting the water utility up to snuff, but somehow those thoughts don't quite resonate as well as pulling a water usage number out of a hat and comparing it to Gaza. Heck we could do the same with Haiti, I am sure that is the Israelis fault too.
07:50 PM on 05/03/2010
http://www.oxfam.org/en/policy/failing-gaza-no-rebuilding-no-recovery-no-more-excuses

Download and, more importantly, actually read the report.

It is very well researched.

See what happened during Cast Lead.

See what became of farmlands, greenhouses and the infrastructure.

See how impossible it is for any realistic reconstruction to take place.

And, while you are about it go search back to the Israeli withdrawal from Gaza and look at the evidence for Israel destroying everything huge amounts, specially houses built for Israelis, of what they "left behind". There were newscasts at the time which showed Israelis being forcibly removed from the housing you mention as the Israeli bulldozers approached to demolish them.

The current situation with regard to the water shortages being suffered by Palestinians is entirely at the door of the Israeli government.
03:50 AM on 05/04/2010
"The current situation with regard to the water shortages being suffered by Palestinians is entirely at the door of the Israeli government."

Blind assumptions so to vilify Israel. Unless you can with 100% prove your claim, it will remain an example of propaganda. That's what happens when someone makes exclusive, simplistic attacks like you made on such intricate matters. You should of left out the word "entirely" if you wanted to be a taken at all, seriously.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:18 AM on 05/04/2010
I remember when the Jewish settler's left. And they blew up or burned down
most of what was there, out of pure hatred and spite !!!

As a US citizen who has helped Pay for ALL of that I feel this was
incredibly stupid and wasteful.
Just wondering, do right wing settler's have to take courses in
religious egomaniacal extremism ?
Because it sure seems like it ....
03:32 PM on 05/03/2010
The Palestinians should not expect Israel to take care of them after all the suicide bombers and rockets they sent to murder innocent civilians. If the Palestinians want something from Israel, they should stop being hostile.
04:30 PM on 05/03/2010
lightningbolt,
I'm sorry but collective punishment is still not an option it is a war crime.
04:40 PM on 05/03/2010
This is not collective punishment. If the Palestinians want to be an independent nation, then they should learn to feed themselves. If they cannot feed themselves, then they shouldn't kill the citizens of the nation they want to be fed by. Why aren't Arab nations sending them water? Would you consider that collective punishment? Arab nations are the ones responsible for the occupation in the first place.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JustMeInNY
Live and Learn.
02:05 PM on 05/06/2010
**I'm sorry but collective punishment is still not an option it is a war crime. **

Once again, i agree, BDS is a war crime!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:50 PM on 05/03/2010
Lightningbolt, you have no idea what you are talking about. Go and educate yourself first before posting a one sided comment like this.
04:54 PM on 05/03/2010
If you can't make an argument with substance to counter my comment, then it is you who appears as the uneducated one. What facts do you have to back up your argument?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JustMeInNY
Live and Learn.
04:59 PM on 05/03/2010
Well now, why don't you present a counter argument instead of spewing unsubstantiated accusations?
01:31 PM on 05/03/2010
I'd like to address Sarah Gooters directly.
Is it possible for outsiders such as myself to help alleviate the situation for Palestinians, without prejudice?
What I had in mind would be subsidizing delivery of clean water, building ecologically-responsible wells, low-tech methods of conserving water and optimizing it use.
I ask this in the hope that the Israeli authorities do not, in fact, wish to deliberately injure the non-Jewish population of the West Bank.
I will leave out the situation in blockaded Gaza where Israeli actions speak very loudly, indeed.
11:09 AM on 05/03/2010
The Palestinians are avoiding treatment of wastewater and reuse of the treated effluents for irrigation, a move that would free large quantities of fresh water for domestic use, while also preventing contamination of groundwater and environmental pollution. At times, this is explained on the basis of a religious prohibition, which is puzzling as neighbouring Arab countries treat wastewater and use the effluent for irrigation of agricultural lands. It also appears that for tactical reasons of negotiation, the Palestinians do not wish to discuss desalination as a concrete solution (for the West Bank) or regional schemes. This Palestinian position may be summed up as follows: "Give us (Israel to the Palestinians) all the fresh water we need for the present and the future, take (Israel from the Palestinians) the wastewater that we generate, and desalinate seawater in place of the water we are taking from you."

IWA 2008
11:47 AM on 05/03/2010
What is "IWA 2008"? The 2008 report of the Israel Water Authority, perhaps?
Where does "Uri Shani, the director general of the Israel Water Authority" figure in this situation.
Which Palestians have the authority to influence distribution of water in the occupied territories and precisely which puts them in the position to be "avoiding treatment of wastewater and reuse of the treated effluents for irrigation"
Considering that Israel is a belligerent occupying power it seems strange that IWA 2008 should imply that Israel has "full and untremalled ownership" of Palistinian aquifers and the Palestinians no rights. Israel has assumed [stolen] full authority over Palestinian water reserves, how unreasonable is the Palestinian position in light of that fact.
mackdee, you are pretty despicable to try to pass off this "special pleading" as neutral commentary.
01:00 PM on 05/03/2010
Where do you get this notion that Palestinians have no water rights??? They can influence a lot of water resources, by construction a desalinization plant, built all the wells that have been approved, and proceed accordingly to access water as stated in the Water agreement of 1995. Where does the IWA say it owns all the aquifers??? Where has Israel stolen water reserves??? Please supply credible links. Where have they broken the Water agreement???

Nothing despicable about my post, just because you don't like the factual content, don't shoot the messenger. Why don't you prove, what I posted as inaccurate instead of Ad Hominem attacks.

There was no "special pleading" that's your personal response, and what do you call neutral commentary??? The one's who profess you side of the argument [vilifying Israel] with "unbiased"links from: Al Manor? Mondoweiss? MJ Rosenberg blogs?, Al Jazeera?Amnesty Int'l LMAO

SO according to you, Israeli sources can't be credible, for one reason or another [you HP posters will dig up dirt on someone, whether true or not], therefore can't present it's side of the argument!!! Get real.
08:20 PM on 05/03/2010
Fine.

http://www.amnesty.org/en/news-and-updates/report/israel-rations-palestinians-trickle-water-20091027

Though I have little conviction that you might digest it.
03:58 AM on 05/04/2010
I responded to this down below, you linked it at least 3 times. And i had read it before you linked it on this blog. I'm not a grazing farm animal that simply digests what's offered, i can analyze it and form my own opinions. I think I'm entitled.
11:01 AM on 05/03/2010
a. Israel has met all its obligations according to the Water Agreement, in terms of the
additional quantities of water to the Palestinians, and has, indeed, even exceeded the
requirements.
b. The Palestinians are seriously defaulting on their obligations according to the
Water Agreement primarily on two important items:
1) Drilling of Unauthorized "Pirate" Wells – the Palestinians drill water wells
without the approval of the JWC, principally in the northern West Bank; to
date, more than 250 unapproved wells have been drilled.
2) Failure to treat wastewater – the Palestinians are not constructing wastewater
treatment plants and discharge their wastewater to streams, contaminating the
environment and the groundwater. Some of the wastewater flows into Israeli
territory.
c. The Palestinians are not developing and using, quite deliberately, the groundwater
resources in the eastern aquifer that were made available to them in the Water
Agreement.

IWA 2008
03:39 AM on 05/04/2010
I replied to this already , down below. Amnesty report, doesn't refute what i quoted, nor is it a analysis of serious reporting. It's heavily based on someone's opinion critical of Israel, and then makes a video for sensationalistic purposes, something a laymen could do with media player editor from his basement and then post on You Tube.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:52 AM on 05/04/2010
Let's see, "exceeding it's requirements." Does that include the IDF and
nutty settler's destroying Arab rainwater and other systems ???

That is nothing less than hate and meanness, something I might
only expect from a wild 12 year old hillbilly.

I've read a lot of history, and military history. I could probably tell
most of you more about the Israeli military's strategy and tactics
in the 67 and 73 war's than you or friends know. They were
the aggressor in 67 and pretty much therefore they were attacked
in 73. They had quite a time fighting the new anti-aircraft
missiles and the suitcase anti-tank rockets from Russia.

I had a lot of respect for the bravery and ability of the IDF for years.
But I can see now that the IDF has been a cruel and practically
fascist force for years. It dishonors the Jews of Israel. Unless
it can change.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
omobob
left coast, usa
10:40 AM on 05/03/2010
It is noted that Israel uses water as well as food, fuel and medicine as hold out essentials to deny the Palestinians for what Israel decides is proper behavior or reasons for denial. At the mercy of the Israelis, those in Gaza are forced to smuggle what they can to survive. Meanwhile Israelis punish all Palestinians for the actions of a few.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
eileenflemingWAWA
http://www.wearewideawake.org/
09:10 AM on 05/03/2010
When a map of the so called holy land is superimposed upon the aquifers, it is clear to all how The Wall is about grabbing those resources.

I have been to I-P 7 times since June 2005 and it is a most Orwellian world. In the 6+ decades old refugee camps in Bethlehem and Jerusalem there are no green areas, but a short walk away to the illegal settlements one will view acres of landscaping and Olympic sized pools.

Eileen Fleming,
Founder of WeAreWideAwake.org
A Feature Correspondent for Arabisto.com
Author of "Keep Hope Alive" and "Memoirs of a Nice Irish American 'Girl's' Life in Occupied Territory"
Producer "30 Minutes with Vanunu" and "13 Minutes with Vanunu"
http://www.youtube.com/user/eileenfleming
10:18 AM on 05/03/2010
There are many public pools in Arab Neighborhoods in West Bank as well.
03:00 PM on 05/03/2010
Please give us a reference.
Unsupported claims on either side are counterproductive.
04:40 PM on 05/03/2010
Then if you know so much about the area, since you've been there so many times, you would know there's a pool for reserved for woman and a Olympic pool in the Arab city of Nablus. And Ramallah has more then 10 pools.

http://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/news/w-bank-swimming-pools-help-palestinians-brave-the-heat-1.227078
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JustMeInNY
Live and Learn.
04:48 PM on 05/03/2010
Isn't it amazing how much propaganda the Palestinians are able to get through even though they are supposedly under siege?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:01 AM on 05/04/2010
Gee, after what this article and the links posted here tell us, that means
that the Israeli swimming pools only outnumber the Arab ones by
about 100 to 1 !!!! Or is it more ?

I bet some Iranians in Los Angles have at least 200 pools, are you
going to count them in the Arab number also ?

Funny that so many of you with utterly blind support for
RIGHT WING ISRAEL are so afraid of admitting
hardly any of it's crimes, aggression, or inhumanity.

You are afraid that a small crack in the shell will break it.
To admit to some crimes may tick off some of your
friends in Israel, or the US ?
It might give a little sympathy to the Arabs, heaven forbid !

Your hard line makes your case all the weaker, it
shows you are Afraid. Afraid of any truth that dares
to expose right wing Israel.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
helen1
03:58 AM on 05/03/2010
So the Aparthied system extends even to water.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
eileenflemingWAWA
http://www.wearewideawake.org/
09:27 AM on 05/03/2010
YES indeed and racism is even visible on every car, for Palestinian license plates are a different color from Israelis and VIP's.

CASE IN POINT: While viewing CNN's series on "God's Warriors" I was struck more by the lack of coverage than what was covered regarding "God's Jewish Warriors."

Christiane Amanpour and her Israeli license plated driver were taped rolling through one of over fifty checkpoints in the West Bank, but no film documented the thousands of Palestinians who daily wait hours at checkpoints and who may even be denied the right to move on.

In addition, Israel blocks access to main roads with various physical obstacles such as dirt piles, concrete blocks, iron gates, and trenches. The number of staffed checkpoints is fairly constant, while the number of physical obstacles often changes depending on the political and security situation.

In the beginning of 2006, there were about 470 physical obstacles blocking roads-there are over 600 now!

Eileen Fleming,
Founder of WeAreWideAwake.org
A Feature Correspondent for Arabisto.com
Author of "Keep Hope Alive" and "Memoirs of a Nice Irish American 'Girl's' Life in Occupied Territory"
Producer "30 Minutes with Vanunu" and "13 Minutes with Vanunu"
http://www.youtube.com/user/eileenfleming
10:23 AM on 05/03/2010
The road checks and Security Wall, Which was a response to the flood of suicide attackers, has become the most successful deterrent to prevent suicide terrorist attacks from Palestinians. Opps. some context into the reality.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StCuthbert
Anytime the mods are ready...
01:59 PM on 05/03/2010
"for Palestinian license plates are a different color from Israelis and VIP's"

...Palestinians are not citizens of Israel. Why shouldn't their license plates be different colors?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:05 AM on 05/03/2010
Disputes over scarce water, caused primarily by the fact the humans do not seem able to stop breeding like rats, is only going to escalate all over the globe in the coming decades.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JustMeInNY
Live and Learn.
04:49 PM on 05/03/2010
And the Palestinians are doing just that!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:28 AM on 05/04/2010
Since you insist on taking his comment that way I must offer a counter...

" And the Orthodox Jews are doing just that !"

And of course some mostly far right zealot Christians like that
TV family that has what, about 17 kids and counting...
Is this some sort of breeding like cows contest ?
08:40 PM on 05/03/2010
If the global warming body is correct, wars over water will likely be the cause of wars all over the planet.

Perhaps those wars will reduce the overpopulation to a sustainable level, since sure as eggs is eggs, humans will not govern their propensity for over production.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Rabbi Irwin Kula
11:54 PM on 05/02/2010
This is simply one more facet of an issue that unless everyone outside the region steps back and stops simply reflexively siding with whatever side they side with there will be no chance of a solution. The two sides are locked in trauma induced battle in which each side can only see the worst aspects of the other. Only outside intervention by people who start with a fierce compassion for both sides that holds each side accountable rather than what we have now which is reflexive defense or attack of one side or the other. Both sides are locked into a position n which they are no longer creating the conflict rather the conflict, the relationship, is creating the combatants. In other words, there is no way for the combatants to make peace because they would literally lose their identity. The war relationship creates their identity> so every time we with anger and vehemence back one side and demonize and blame the other (even if we happen to be right regarding some specific critique or another, we are actually contributing to solidifying the war-like relationship which is creating the combatants identities.
01:09 AM on 05/03/2010
Yes, there is no time for partisanship on this issue. Israel and the Palestine Authority must work this out, in a fair and balanced approach.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:28 AM on 05/03/2010
Rabbi, first please use paragraphs, easier to read. I'd say at least 3 for this post.

You sound moderate and fair. But I'd like to hear more Jews and their leader's admit
to the crimes and daily oppression by the IDF and extremist settlers. Just as it
was the duty of Christians to attack the extreme's of our nations like Germany.
Maybe your job or other concerns make this unwise or even dangerous if
you even recognize the Arab pov [with more specifics].

And as far as "outside intervention" that sounds like asking the US, and
England, the UN, etc., to help find peace around Israel. I used to believe
this too, for many years, but with right wing Israel's latest insult to the
US, and coming to American and rubbing it in at AIPAC, I think we
should get out and stay out.

No more money for the region, no advice that gets us spit on; no
dealing with those who seek to interfer in US politics like Bibi.

We get blamed no matter what. We have enough on our plate
here, let the Mideast figure it out or not.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
eileenflemingWAWA
http://www.wearewideawake.org/
09:21 AM on 05/03/2010
WE the people are culpable where our 'leaders' lay our money down!

America is the worlds largest arms supplier to Israel and under a Bush negotiated deal which Obama upheld with Israel, we the people who pay taxes will also provide an extra $30 billion in military aid to Israel over the next decade on top of the $30 billion we already provide annually that supports the 43 years of military occupation of Palestine as well as $1.5 million more per mile to erect the illegal wall/fence where ever it does not follow the Green Line-which is most everywhere!

CONTACT President Obama:
The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Avenue NW
Washington, DC 20500

E-mail: http://www.whitehouse.gov/contact/

White House Comment Line: (202) 456-1111

Fax: (202) 456-2461

Secretary of State Hillary Clinton
Department of State
Washington, DC 20520
State Department Public Information Line:
(202) 647-6575
photo
Marcus047
given up on HP
09:53 AM on 05/03/2010
Yeah, no one gets to interfer in Us politics. America, on the other hand, has a right, even a duty to interfer in the politics of all other states.