More

Gulf Oil Spill: Criticism Comes To The Obama Administration

Gulf Spill Criticism

First Posted: 05/18/10 09:41 AM ET Updated: 05/25/11 05:30 PM ET

WASHINGTON (AP) -- Last week, it was oil executives who faced the wrath of lawmakers eager to find blame for the massive oil spill spreading in the Gulf of Mexico.

On Tuesday, Interior Secretary Ken Salazar and other federal officials will come under questioning for what the government did - or did not do - to prevent the oil spill, and how they have responded since oil started streaming into the Gulf last month.

Salazar, who oversees the federal agency that monitors offshore drilling, will testify before two Senate committees. Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Lisa Jackson and Coast Guard Commandant Thad Allen also will testify at separate hearings, and oil company executives are back for a second round of questions.

The hearings come amid the first high-level resignation related to the oil spill and a decision by President Barack Obama to name a presidential commission to investigate the cause of the rig explosion that unleashed millions of gallons of oil into the Gulf of Mexico, where engineers are struggling after three weeks to stop the flow.

The presidential panel will be similar to ones that examined the Challenger space shuttle disaster and the Three Mile Island nuclear power plant accident, said a White House official, speaking on condition of anonymity because the decision had not been formally announced.

The commission would be one of nearly a dozen investigations and reviews launched since the April 20 explosion, although it probably would be the most comprehensive.

With BP PLC, the company that owns the well, finally gaining some control over the amount of oil spewing into the gulf, scientists are increasingly worried that huge plumes of crude already spilled could get caught in a current that would carry the mess all the way to the Florida Keys and beyond, damaging coral reefs and killing wildlife.

Scientists said the oil will move into the so-called loop current soon if it hasn't already, though they could not say exactly when or how much there would be. Once it is in the loop, it could take 10 days or longer to reach the Keys.

The U.S. Coast Guard reported that 20 tar balls were found off Key West on Monday, but said a lab analysis would have to determine their origin. The Florida Park Service during a shoreline survey found balls that were about 3 to 8 inches in diameter.

Last week, Obama decried what he called a badly failed offshore drilling system and said failures extended to the federal government and its "cozy" relationship with oil companies. The Minerals Management Service, the federal agency that oversees offshore drilling, has long been criticized for being too close to industry.

On Monday, White House press secretary Robert Gibbs said government failures "certainly" include the Obama administration, which took office in January 2009.

"But my guess is you guys did some stories in the previous decade on what was going on at MMS, which is what caused Secretary Salazar, when he came in, to begin reforming that," Gibbs told reporters.

Salazar, anticipating tough questioning on Capitol Hill, announced Monday he is tightening requirements for onshore oil and gas drilling. The new measures would not apply to oil rigs at sea, and Salazar had outlined the broad outlines of the reforms in January.

Even so, he tried to portray them as more evidence of the Obama administration's aggressive response to the Gulf spill.

"The BP oil spill is a stark reminder of how we must continue to push ahead with the reforms we have been working on and which we know are needed," Salazar said in a statement.

Chris Oynes, associate administrator of the minerals agency, became the first administration official to resign in the wake of the oil spill. Oynes, who was regional director in charge of Gulf offshore oil programs for 13 years before being promoted in 2007 to head all offshore drilling programs, informed colleagues he will retire at the end of the month, according to an e-mail obtained by The Associated Press.

Oynes, like other MMS officials, has come under criticism for being too close to the industry.

A 35-year government employee, Oynes had earlier indicated his plans to retire but decided to accelerate his departure, said an administration official who spoke on condition of anonymity because the issue involved a personnel matter. It was unclear what pressure, if any, was put on him.

Members of Congress, meanwhile, were continuing to focus attention on the Gulf spill.

Sen. Barbara Boxer, D-Calif., and seven other senators asked the Justice Department to determine whether BP made false and misleading claims to the government about its ability to prevent a serious oil spill when it applied for permission last year to drill the Deepwater Horizon well that has unleashed environmental havoc along the Gulf coast.

Boxer, who chairs the environment panel, said BP claimed to have the capability to prevent a serious oil spill in case of a well blowout.

"In the wake of the Deepwater Horizon oil spill ... it does not in any way appear there was 'proven equipment and technology' to respond to the spill" as BP claimed, she and the other senators wrote Attorney General Eric Holder. They asked the Justice Department to determine whether any criminal or civil laws may have been violated as far as misleading the government.

In the month since the oil rig exploded, killing 11 workers, BP has struggled to stop the leak, trying in vain to activate emergency valves and lowering a 100-ton box that got clogged with icy crystals. Over the weekend, the oil company finally succeeded in using a stopper-and-tube combination to siphon some of the gushing oil into a tanker, but millions of gallons are already in the Gulf.

---

AP writers H. Josef Hebert and Erica Werner contributed to this report.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST GREEN

WASHINGTON (AP) -- Last week, it was oil executives who faced the wrath of lawmakers eager to find blame for the massive oil spill spreading in the Gulf of Mexico. On Tuesday, Interior Secretary Ken...
WASHINGTON (AP) -- Last week, it was oil executives who faced the wrath of lawmakers eager to find blame for the massive oil spill spreading in the Gulf of Mexico. On Tuesday, Interior Secretary Ken...
Filed by Katherine Goldstein  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 171
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nicole473
Because Republicans are a threat to this democracy
06:34 PM on 05/19/2010
I think it's a lot worse than we've been told.

"This is not a system in stasis.  This is an out of control volcano of oil spewing up with 70,000 psi behind it, from a reservoir nearly the size of the Gulf, with an estimated trillions of barrels of oil and gas tucked away.  It is this deposit that has me reminding people of what the Shell geologist told me about the deposit. This was the quote, "Energy shortage..., We are afraid of running out of air to burn." The deposit is very large. It covers an area off shore something like 25,000 square miles. Natural Gas and Oil is leaking out of the deposit as far inland as Central Alabama and way over into Florida and even over to Louisiana almost as far as Texas.

What we are seeing now could be small compared to what may yet unfold if things break apart, as they can do under such circumstances.  If this thing blew, it could be like the Yellowstone Caldera, except from below a mile of sea, with a 1/4-mile opening, with up to 150,000 psi of oil and natural gas behind it.

That would be an extinction event.

It is not likely to happen, but it is within the realm of possibilities.

That's the kind of stuff we're playing with here."

http://www.examiner.com/x-8199-Breakthrough-Energy-Examiner~y2010m5d13-A-volcano-of-oil-erupting
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Artemis34
Women can vote against the GOP or against their ow
11:21 AM on 05/19/2010
Those who have been saying all these years that all regulation does is hold business back, that they can police themselves, that the "invisible hand of the market" will fix everything are here blaming the government (that they dismantled) and every over scapegoat including the Sierra Club, but not business itself or the market.

The invisible butt of the market is cr@pping all over the gulf and the invisible hand of the market can't even wipe!

All this proves is that regulation, real regulation by real public servants, is required. That your deregulation approach does not work.
08:56 AM on 05/19/2010
Gas Leak 3000 Times Worse Than Oil
By innereye
5-18-10

There is 3000 times more natural gas coming out of the leak than oil. The damage of the massive amounts of Gas being released into the gulf is worse than the oil.
http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5gIX
WYBTpLtSayJtg41LKXpxSxVPAD9FO07J00

Oxygen levels in some areas have dropped 30 percent, and should continue to drop, Joye said.
"It could take years, possibly decades, for the system to recover from an infusion of this quantity of oil and gas," Joye said. "We've never seen anything like this before. It's impossible to fathom the impact."



The Federal Minerals Management Service (MMS) contracted a study to see how badly a deep water drilling oil spill would deplete the gulf of oxygen. this study underestimated the current leak by a factor of 26. It was NOT peer reviewed and did not consider that the damage would occur at depth greater than 700 meters. In other words, the determination of the potential impact of deep water drilling on the ecosystem by the federal agency that regulates these activities was a TOTAL SHAM.

The Gulf oxygen depletion zone or "Dead Zone" has been documented by environmentalists over the last 20 years....
http://rense.com/general90/gasleak.htm
03:59 AM on 05/19/2010
This is catastrophic genocide of the ocean and all the sea life that is being killed by BP's Greed.
Does any body remember the old Spirit song Nature's Way? "It's Nature's Way of telling you something's wrong...." It is time to revisit that song as it relates to this horrible tragedy with no end in sight.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A81kQGx4710
12:26 AM on 05/19/2010
Millions of gallons are continuing to spill into the Gulf, with the siphon. Don't forget to mention that every day, too, please.
07:03 PM on 05/18/2010
Big Oil (Exxon, Shell, BP, Chevron, etc.) only control 5% of the worlds oil reserves.

95% of the known oil reserves are controlled by state oil companies (owned by foreign governments).
04:47 PM on 05/18/2010
I'm not worried about the spill anymore because the Obama Administration is creating a panel to determine what caused the event. Oh brother!!! Cap that Well...cap it quick...put a 25 ton lid on it if you have to but get it stopped now! This is beyond belief....putting a little pipe i a big pipe capturing 20 percent and claiming success is nothing but propaganda...knock off the crap talk and get it done!!! Your killing off everything in the Gulf!
06:59 PM on 05/18/2010
Yeah, those panels usually work pretty quickly don't they.
12:32 AM on 05/19/2010
Argh! this is so huge and the administration is proving so inept. I can almost begin to understand ecote**o*ists at times like this.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Artemis34
Women can vote against the GOP or against their ow
04:20 PM on 05/18/2010
Can't believe droog1 would blame Jimmy "I'm putty solar panels on the White House" Carter!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Artemis34
Women can vote against the GOP or against their ow
04:22 PM on 05/18/2010
Obviously "putting"
05:25 PM on 05/18/2010
Remember Jimmy was in office when the Saudi's embargoed us and he put into effect massive incentives to spur new drilling to help lower the cost of crude. He probably put the solar panels on the White House because energy costs went through the roof.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CherokeeGirl
one pissed off Indian.
04:09 PM on 05/18/2010
MMS under "criticizm"? They should have been under investigation and cleaned out a year ago when it was reported on Rachel Maddow that the MMS had been having sex orgies on the riggs with the oil execs snorting meth off of a toaster. And they are just getting to this now?

Buck stops with Obama on this one. Can't blame Bush for this one. Obama needs to clean out all of the empty suits leftover by the Bush Administration, especially in the DOJ and Interior.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Artemis34
Women can vote against the GOP or against their ow
04:21 PM on 05/18/2010
DOJ should have been on day one.
05:26 PM on 05/18/2010
The MMS "orgies" were in Denver. That office regulates onshore activity.

Can you really snort meth?
photo
janie@atthelake
Keep Austin Weird
03:23 PM on 05/18/2010
CNN report: 1/5 of the oil has been caught from the pipe inserted

The rest still going into the Gulf.
If they could put Cheney in jail for 1 day for this..............I'd never ask for another Christmas or Birthday present.
photo
DaveInWheaton
Corporatism Destroys All - both here & abroad
03:44 PM on 05/18/2010
they refuse to prosecute him for war crimes - why would they prosecute him for this?
photo
janie@atthelake
Keep Austin Weird
04:47 PM on 05/18/2010
....Former Vice President...let it go.

But, I wish they would. Maybe it would be better to support this ad. to go forward. Cheney...its just a wish that he would go to jail.
Hey! Who knows? Maybe he will shoot someone again????
03:46 PM on 05/18/2010
I don't particularly care for Cheney, but how is he involved in this? Did he call the Halliburton crew and tell them to pump a crappy cement job? Did he call the MMS inspectors and ask them not to inspect the rig as often as they are supposed to?
photo
janie@atthelake
Keep Austin Weird
04:34 PM on 05/18/2010
With all respect droog1 ...many of us feel (and I do have a college BA, that during the Bush ad. it was all about following his father's footsteps...but his father's footsteps were in oil.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/11/15/AR2005111501842.html
Cheney is one of the owners of Haliburton--the no bid contract company. They win...and to hell with us & the enviroment. In a nutshell...enter Sarah Palin.
Bush retired.
Cheney still rages....He is the ..(hope so) last member of the Trilateralism Commision.
Cheney is PO'd. and he rages.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Artemis34
Women can vote against the GOP or against their ow
11:14 AM on 05/19/2010
They say "the fish rots from the head," that is that corruption starts at the top.

C h e n e y sent the message that there was no rule that could not be broken, no moral like that could not be crossed in the pursuit of profits. Seems everyone in Halliburton took his message to heart.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Oonagh
Old sins have long shadows
02:32 PM on 05/18/2010
I know who is blame, the MMS for giving them the permit to drill a mile down and then not following up on inspections, Halliburton, Transocean and BP..
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Artemis34
Women can vote against the GOP or against their ow
02:41 PM on 05/18/2010
If I get a permit to build a house, then build it shoddily, it is my fault, not the fault of the permit issuer.
02:47 PM on 05/18/2010
That's partly true, but it is also the responsibility of the permit grantor to inspect your work and make sure it is up to code. Same goes for the MMS; there was no reason for them not to grant BP the permit to drill as long as they satisfied the requirements for the permit application. There has been a lot of discussion over BP's alleged failure to provide an environmental impact statement that was specific to this well; the reality is that those are frequently waived by the MMS if they already have one on file for a nearby well that is in the same general environmental conditions as the well being permitted. I doubt there are endangered species living only in the immediate are of this well but not in the area around the next well over. That is a red herring.

But it is the responsibility of the regulatory agency to perform inspections to ensure compliance. It's BP's fault if they didn't comply, but it's the governments fault for not performing the inspection to ensure compliance.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
DorianCorso
Mammal who wears pants.
02:54 PM on 05/18/2010
Most permits require INSPECTIONS as part of the building process.
Electrical, Plumbing ,Framing ,Gas . If you pull the municipal permit the inspections MUST be completed prior to each stage of construction and the issuance of a certificate of occupancy.

Let's say your house were to burn down and it was discovered that the inspections never took place. You could ,theoretically, sue the municipality who issued the permit and failed to provide the inspections, even if the shoddy building is your fault. The inspectors job is to shut your project down unless or until it is code compliant.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:27 PM on 05/18/2010
does anybody know anything about the idea of dynamiting the wellhead to stop the gusher? would it be likely to work? if so, why didn't bp do it a month ago?
02:30 PM on 05/18/2010
That would probably make things worse. Plus, does dynamite work at those pressures? My guess is that a detonation would just open it up more and cause a huge shock wave that would kill any marine life for miles around.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:34 PM on 05/18/2010
i don't know the physics of it, but a detonation would be a lot less damaging to marine life than the long, slow poisoning process we have that continues to add more poison.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:13 PM on 05/18/2010
"You do not throw explosives on it, or bomb it, a crater that leaks 1000 times more oil will be your result. Explosives are primarily used to use up the oxygen, disperse heat and finally kill a fire."

"You do not drill beside it and place explosives to crimp it, been there, done that, and it does not work, what this does do is fracture the rock enough so that the now increased oil flow follows the fissures and you have the sea-floor puking oil from a bunch more spots over a wide area. If you are to do this you need precisely shaped charges set at hyper-accurate positions surrounding the pipe that are tuned to the precise density of the material around them. When your working at 5000 feet below the sea this is all but impossible in an expedited manner with slim odds of working even at the best of conditions."
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
04:31 PM on 05/18/2010
thank you, techcafe. i was seeking a knowledgeable answer.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:08 PM on 05/18/2010
I also blame the people who upheld and continue to obstruct Obama's admin appointments.
02:32 PM on 05/18/2010
Obama apponted Salazar as Secretary of Interior, and he appointed the current MMS Director Liz Birnbaum.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:56 PM on 05/18/2010
That's true but I don't know anyone who has come into the middle of a large corporate situation and 'got it right' within a few months. I can't imagine what a fustercluck things are in government but the BS obstructions haven't helped, neither have the Bush/Cheney appointed 'landmines' and don't think for a moment that klan wasn't klever enough to place them strategically to mess things up for the current admin. for them it's politics, power and wealth creation, for everybody else it's basic survival.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hedgewytch
01:15 PM on 05/18/2010
"Oynes, like other MMS officials, has come under criticism for being too close to the industry.
A 35-year government employee, Oynes had earlier indicated his plans to retire but decided to accelerate his departure, said an administration official who spoke on condition of anonymity because the issue involved a personnel matter."

Yeah, that little personnel matter of you being a criminal and should be investigated and prosecuted by the Justice Department.
01:57 PM on 05/18/2010
The government just doesn't investigate their own. He will fade quietly into retirement.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Oonagh
Old sins have long shadows
02:34 PM on 05/18/2010
He is a coward, he did not want to face the music... he is running for cover
12:54 PM on 05/18/2010
I really don't want to sound disagreeable … but "WE ARE TO BLAME." We've been unwilling to pay for the true cost of energy production for a century, and when domestic oil companies attempt to deliver a product at a rate competitive with global production, we get what we pay for. Salazar and the Obama administration have to now come clean on these economic and market pressures on the industry and about the real challenges that face us in meeting our domestic energy goals. Obama had it spot on in his Press Conference in the Rose Garden, there is enough blame to go around, and it's time we STOP ducking responsibility and START making the tough choices that will leave us with better, more efficient, and cheaper alternative sources of energy in the future.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tom95134
01:14 PM on 05/18/2010
!00% right on. We The People are do addicted to oil that until we become more realistic about a conversion to renewable resources these kind of incidents will continue to occur.

I can already hear the Republicans on these Committees grilling Slazar and other agency officials. These Republicans will be struck by a convenient loss of memory that many of the people who were suppose to be overseeing companies like BP were appointed under the Bush/Cheney Oil administration. This is combined with the fact that those same Republicans that will scream the loudest have been blocking President Obama's attempts to appoint new people to run these agencies.
02:33 PM on 05/18/2010
The director of the MMS was appointed by Secretary Salazar who was appointed by Obama. The other MMS employees are just plain old government employees; they're not appointed.
01:15 PM on 05/18/2010
Let's agree to index that "cheaper" portion with todays cost of driving a mile or burning a btu of fuel. Making gasoline more expensive to make something else cheaper in comparison isn't what we should do.