iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Gulf Oil Spill: 'A Whale' Of A Skimmer Offers Up Its Services

First Posted: 06/29/10 04:03 PM ET Updated: 05/25/11 05:55 PM ET

A Whale

A massive, newly-retooled supertanker that its owner claims could skim millions of gallons of oily water a day is now in the Gulf of Mexico, where government and BP officials intend to run tests shortly to see if it actually works.

With residents of four states complaining about the dearth of skimming vessels off their shores, the 10-story tall, 372-yard long Taiwanese-owned behemoth -- called A Whale -- could be an enormous boon to the region.

Or it could be a really, really big disappointment.

Nobu Su, the CEO and founder of Taiwan Maritime Transport (TMT), told reporters in Norfolk on Friday that on account of the special holes he had cut in its sides, his vessel would roll across the Gulf "like a lawn mower cutting the grass."

Though the ship and the process are entirely untested, Su insisted A Whale could ingest and process some 15 million gallons of oily water a day. By comparison, the entire emergency response since BP's Deepwater Horizon rig exploded on April 20 has collected 28 million gallons of oily water.

Over at the unified command center in downtown New Orleans, federal and BP officials are said to be responding with a combination of enthusiasm and caution.

"They're about as excited as you can be about something that you have no idea what it can do," said Kati Walsh, a spokesperson for the disaster's Joint Information Center. "They want to remain in a neutral position about it until after it proves itself," she said. "We don't want to get everybody excited about something that may or may not work."

The next step will be for officials to set up a meeting and test the ship's abilities, Walsh said.

That sounded good to Scott Segal, a lobbyist with Bracewell & Giuliani, the law firm TMT hired to represent its interests in Washington. "Their intention is to coordinate with federal authorities on a test, as soon as possible," Segal said of his clients.

But communication appears to be a problem. Segal didn't know the unified command's intentions until he heard about them from the Huffington Post. And the unified command didn't know the ship was already in the Gulf, which, according to the latitude and longitude Segal provided to HuffPost, it is.

No meeting or test has yet been scheduled because federal and BP officials "haven't determined the what or when or how it will get here," Walsh said.

The ship was built in South Korea, has a Liberian registry and is owned by a Taiwanese company, but Walsh said the Jones Act -- which limits the operation of foreign flagged vessels in U.S. waters -- was not a factor as much as the nature of the ship.

While more traditional "vessels of opportunity" are allowed to start skimming without government pre-approval, this one would not be allowed to do so, she said. "The ship was just built, it hasn't been proven yet, hasn't been officially or formally tested yet."

Even if everything goes according to plan, the ship will suck oily water into its huge tanks for processing, then pump still somewhat polluted water back into the Gulf -- possibly requiring a waiver from normal environmental regulations.

And then of course there's the small matter of money. Even if TMT gets permission to begin operations, just how much will it insist on getting paid?

Frank Maisano, a spokesman for with Bracewell & Giuliani, made it clear this is not a charity operation.

"Mr. Nobu has already sailed the ship around the world and modified it at his own expense," Maisano told HuffPost. "I'm sure that he's looking at least to recover his costs."

WATCH a report from when the ship docked in Norfolk, from WVEC.com:

FOLLOW HUFFPOST GREEN

A massive, newly-retooled supertanker that its owner claims could skim millions of gallons of oily water a day is now in the Gulf of Mexico, where government and BP officials intend to run tests short...
A massive, newly-retooled supertanker that its owner claims could skim millions of gallons of oily water a day is now in the Gulf of Mexico, where government and BP officials intend to run tests short...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 1,738
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (24 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rbenjamin
Rule 5 rules
11:37 AM on 07/09/2010
Another actual "go out and dig up some facts" news story about the A Whale test by that great American Newspaper The Times-Picayune at:

http://www.nola.com/news/gulf-oil-spill/index.ssf/2010/07/a_whale_oil_skimmer_testing_ex.html

It has a good picture of the oil intakes (with sluice gates) protruding into the space between the double hulls. This configuration was used in the tests and it allowed oily water to sluice around freely between the double hulls. The oil intakes are being modified to connect directly to the external slits ("jaws") for the extended test. TMT experimented with turning the ship sideways as "navigational windbreak." No further details about what this means from TMT, but my guess is they mean to let the wind blow sea water into the jaws. I guess they would hold the ship stationary with thrusters or a sea anchor. Seems like a major and desperate change of operational strategy to me.

Stick a fork in it, I think testing is about to wind down.

Phase 2: Use it to process and bunker oil collected by other means? A fascinating, if somewhat bizarre chapter in the annals of marine engineering.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
skibum49
03:37 AM on 07/04/2010
The guy who owns the A Whale apparantly is crazy like a fox. Turns out that per maritime salvage law whatever they "salvage" in the way of crude oil from the gulf becomes their property. So if this ship really can separate 500000 barrels of oil a day that turns out to be a nice little $35 Million dollars gross revenue in crude oil at current market prices per day. That combined with whatever they can get BP to pay them per day for being a 'big a**" cleanup ship and this could be one very profitable piece of environmental altruism. Leave it to the Taiwanese to come up with such a beautiful little plan.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ipanemagirl
progressive
06:21 PM on 07/03/2010
anything that helps the clean up of oil should be used and charged to BP.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
William Kolek
04:33 PM on 07/02/2010
"Most elementary school students know that oil floats on top of water. It is relatively easy to seperate the two into individual containers. Why is this hugh oil skimming ship not immediately being used to clean up oil in the Gulf of Mexico? Federal bureaucracy and redtape are delaying the skimming of 15 million gallons of oil and water a day, seperating it and returning clean water to the gulf. BP, we are told, must first approve it. Do we really trust BP to do anything correct in this entire fiasco?
05:38 AM on 07/02/2010
A Taiwanese-flagged vessel, named "A Whale," which is 3 1/2 football fields long and looms 10 stories high - outfitted with 12 vents on either side of its bow, which experts hope will be able to suck up as many as 21 million gallons of oil-tainted water each day in the Gulf of Mexico oil disaster – has offered its services in the attempted clean up.

So will the President Kick Ass and get the permissions needed expediated?

http://just-me-in-t.blogspot.com/2010/07/just-who-makes-decisions.html
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:30 PM on 07/01/2010
if it works great, at this point maybe they can harpoon Tony Hayward.
01:51 PM on 07/01/2010
This ship really is enormous. This AP video footage of the ship puts its size in perspective. Maybe it's fitting, since the oil spill is enormous.

http://www.newslook.com/videos/225695-world-s-largest-oil-skimmer-moves-into-gulf
01:35 PM on 07/01/2010
Thank you Mr. Nobu. Can we afford NOT to at least try the Whale in the gulf?
01:14 PM on 07/01/2010
Shouldn't we build/retrofit 50-100 or so of these ships? We could maintain the fleet to be used for future spills. There seems to be a need for large volume oil skimming once every 8-10 years or so (Itox I, Persian Gulf War, Valdez, etc). The fleet could reside in a spot where it could be used as a tourist attraction (Louisiana, Florida, Texas, etc). A consortium of the world's oil companies could fund it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rbenjamin
Rule 5 rules
11:54 AM on 07/01/2010
A quick back-of-the-envelop analysis suggests A Whale is more about publicity or perhaps oil salvage value than practical remediation.

A Whale would be booking to do 30 km/hr. Assuming it can clear a swath of oil 100 meters wide that works out to 3 km sq per hr or 72 km sq per day. The slick has been estimated by various methods to cover 6500 to 24000 km sq, so a VERY! generous upper estimate of A Whales time to cover all that ocean surface is 90 to 330 days, top cruise speed, with no stops for offloading, resupply or repairs. The surface slick is growing and moves with the winds and tides, so multiple passes would be required. It's not like mowing your lawn.

Of course, much of the slick is deep underwater (all those dispersants) and the draft of A Whale is on the order of 25 m. A large fraction of the oil is going to end up on the sea bed or washed up on land.There may be unforeseen downsides to churning a surface slick with a super tanker wake, so I would monitor the operation carefully - and well out of the way.
11:17 PM on 07/07/2010
I think that many are using the hyperbole to make incorrect conclusions as to it's effectiveness. In earlier statements Mr. Nobu said that it would be most effective near the spill collecting oil as it surfaces. This would be an effective use of the mass approach. Not after it has spread over the gulf. Also Mr. Nobu is presently outfitting two other vessels which would make the lawn mower numbers better.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rbenjamin
Rule 5 rules
10:03 AM on 07/08/2010
Much of the hyperbole seems to be coming straight from TMT, fanned by a public desperate for a magic bullet solution.

The area near the spill is already crowded with vessels supporting the relief wells (the last best hope for actually stopping the gusher) and the collection of oil from the well head. Running such a huge vessel back and forth, with its large turning circle and poor acceleration, near this fleet endangers the primary missions for what seems a very small return. The biggest virtue I can see to the A Whale is it's sheer bulk. Might make some sense to hook A Whale into the top hat so that less of the collected oil has to be burned.
11:49 AM on 07/01/2010
Bushes Fault....Get out of the Bushes...Yeah
09:17 PM on 06/30/2010
Try to stop the flow-deal with the oil on the water-clean it up after it gets on shore-find the truth about why this happened-have meetings with oil companies as to what can happen if this happens again-ask if more regulations are needed or did we not enforce the regulations we currently have-ask all oil companies to help build or fund equipment to respond if event happens again- we need to drill-we will need oil for a long time-drill what we can which creates jobs and brings in revenues to the government
photo
DrBlunt
Telling it like it is....
03:57 AM on 07/01/2010
You had me until:

"we need to drill-we will need oil for a long time-drill what we can which creates jobs and brings in revenues to the government"

Then you lost me... BUT QUICK!
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
mrJJ
如果你不投票,你不能抱怨
08:16 PM on 06/30/2010
OT: Via TPM

Exclusive: BP Bills Anadarko $272 Million In Gulf Spill Response

Texas-based Anadarko owes BP more than $272 million for its share of cleanup and response costs in the Gulf, according to a bill that was sent by BP and obtained by TPMMuckraker.

Anadarko owns a 25 percent stake in BP's Deepwater Horizon, and BP wants Anadarko to pay for 25 percent of costs. Those costs include money BP has spent to drill the relief wells and stage other spill response efforts, plus reimbursements to the federal government, damages to equipment and claims paid to those hurt by the leak.

http://tpmmuckraker.talkingpointsmemo.com/2010/06/exclusive_bp_bills_anadarko_272_million_for_gulf_s.php?ref=fpb

Actual Invoice

http://www.talkingpointsmemo.com/documents/2010/06/bps-invoice-to-anadarko-for-response-costs-may-2010.php?page=1

GoBP Barton's Largest Contributor Andadarko .. http://www.opensecrets.org/politicians/summary.php?cycle=Career&cid=N00005656
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Peter Wu
07:05 PM on 06/30/2010
The Coast Guard should buy the tanker and do the clean up. Bill BP for it too. The oil that is harvested would probably more than pay for the cost of the tanker.
04:52 PM on 06/30/2010
So far as I can find, BP has signed up A Whale to skim and the Coast Guard is willing to test them out. It has been determined they are no subject to the Jones Act. The only non-responder has been the EPA Headquarters

Call Now 202-564-4700
email Jackson.LisaP@epa.gov

Ask for the status on A Whale for the Gulf!!!!
04:54 PM on 06/30/2010
That email is: Jackson.LisaP@epa.gov
04:56 PM on 06/30/2010
try jackson dot LisaP at epa dot gov