Gulf Oil Spill: BP To Keep Cap Closed Until Relief Well Is Complete

First Posted: 07/18/10 01:31 PM ET Updated: 05/25/11 06:05 PM ET

Gulf Oil Spill

NEW ORLEANS — BP hopes to keep using its giant stopper to block oil from reaching the Gulf of Mexico until they plug the blown out well permanently, the company said Sunday.

"No one associated with this whole activity ... wants to see any more oil flow into the Gulf of Mexico," said Doug Suttles, BP's chief operating officer. "Right now we don't have a target to return the well to flow."

Retired U.S. Coast Guard Adm. Thad Allen outlined a different plan on Saturday, saying that after the test was complete, the cap would be hooked up through nearly a mile of pipes stretching to ships on the surface that will collect the oil.

But that would mean oil would have to be released back into the Gulf for three days to release pressure from the well, Suttles said. The oil giant hopes to instead keep the oil shut in until its permanent measure is completed, although Suttles said BP was taking it day by day.

It wasn't immediately clear if the plan had changed, or if BP and the government disagreed about the next move. Allen will make the ultimate decision.

Both Allen and BP have said they don't know how long the trial run – initially set to end Saturday – will continue. Allen has extended it to Sunday afternoon, and could extend it again.

Unimpeded, the well spewed as much as 2.5 million gallons a day, according to the government's worst-case estimates. It's possible the oil has been depleted, and that's why pressure readings from the cap have been lower than anticipated, BP has said.

Scientists still aren't sure whether the shut-in is causing oil to leak into the bedrock surrounding the well, which could make the seabed unstable. That's why pumping the oil up to four ships on the surface and containing it there may be a safer option.

But to do that, millions of gallons of oil could spew into the water when the cap is initially reopened, an image both BP and the federal government would like to avoid.

BP is drilling two relief wells, one of them as a backup. The company said work on the first one was far enough along that officials expect to reach the broken well's casing, or pipes, deep underground by late this month. Then the job of jamming it with mud and cement could take "a number of days through a few weeks."

The cap, which on Thursday stopped the crude for the first time since the April 20 explosion unleashed the spill, lets BP shut in the oil, which would be important if a hurricane were to hit the Gulf and force ships to leave the area.

Pressure in the well cap continues to rise, and scientists are still monitoring for any signs of a leak, but the news still seems to be good, Suttles said. The oil giant is hoping to keep evaluating even after the extended monitoring period it was given by the government, which expires Sunday afternoon.

"We're not seeing any problems at this point with the shut-in," Suttles said at a Sunday morning briefing.

It will take months, or possibly years for the Gulf to recover. But there were signs that people were trying to get life – or at least a small part of it – back to normal.

The public beach at Gulf Shores, Ala., had its busiest day in weeks on Saturday despite oil-stained sand and a dark line of tar balls left by high tide.

Darryl Allen of Fairhope, Ala., and Pat Carrasco of Baton Rouge, La., came to the beach to throw a Frisbee just like they've been doing for the past 30 years. With oil on people's minds more than the weather, Allen asked what's become a common question since the well integrity test began: "How's the pressure? I hope it's going up," he said. "You don't want to be too optimistic after all that's happened."

People also were fishing again, off piers and in boats, after most of the recreational waters in Louisiana were reopened late this week. More than a third of federal waters are still closed and off-limits to commercial fishermen.

"I love to fish," said Brittany Lawson, hanging her line off a pier beside the Grand Isle Bridge. "I love to come out here."

And even though it has been only days since the oil was turned off, the naked eye could spot improvements on the water. The crude appeared to be dissipating quickly on the surface of the Gulf around the Deepwater Horizon site.

Members of a Coast Guard crew that flew over the wellhead Saturday said far less oil was visible than a day earlier. Only a colorful sheen and a few long streams of rust-colored, weathered oil were apparent in an area covered weeks earlier by huge patches of black crude. Somewhere between 94 million and 184 million gallons have spilled into the Gulf, according to government estimates.

__

Weber reported from Houston.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST GREEN

NEW ORLEANS — BP hopes to keep using its giant stopper to block oil from reaching the Gulf of Mexico until they plug the blown out well permanently, the company said Sunday. "No one associated ...
NEW ORLEANS — BP hopes to keep using its giant stopper to block oil from reaching the Gulf of Mexico until they plug the blown out well permanently, the company said Sunday. "No one associated ...
Filed by Alexander Belenky  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 81
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
10:42 PM on 07/20/2010
Meanwhile, back at the sea floor . . . http://bpspillsolutions.com/BPspill/main003.asp?postref=329320241196168&postid=38
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
M Miles
05:54 AM on 07/19/2010
From your article . . .
"No one associated with this whole activity ... wants to see any more oil flow into the Gulf of Mexico," said Doug Suttles, BP's chief operating officer

From another article, see link . . .
Doug Shuttles, British Petroleum’s chief operating officer, went on the Today show Wednesday to deny government claims that massive oil plumes were polluting the ocean a thousand meters below the surface dozens of kilometers around the Gulf spill.

http://www2.macleans.ca/2010/06/09/bp-exec-denies-oil-plumes/

Doug I guess you could cover your eyes?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jmad
10:27 PM on 07/18/2010
The prime reason for BP to not re-open the well is that they do not want any real estimate of the actual flow so as to minimize any potential fines for their misdeed.
The potential fines could amount to tens of billions.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Enock Zamora
KARMA
09:42 PM on 07/18/2010
The well is like a bad date. Mark it up as a learning lesson.
06:11 PM on 07/18/2010
CRAP!!!! I refuse to eat Bp's and the governments crap on this keep it capped reporting. The last thing BP wants is to flow that well or we will all find out what the true volume of this spill really is. Now it sounds like the government is falling for their lame reason to keep it capped also. There shouldn't be one drop of oil spilled hooking up the flow lines to the surface much less three day's worth of spillage to get the well flowing. Do any of you turn on the water spigot before you try to hook up your garden hose??? If you saw the pictures of the new wellhead there are valves that can be turned on or off at will so here is a bit of info for you BP, hook up the flow lines before you open the valves. Letting the pressure continue to increase while they admittingly are concearned about weakness in the well bore below the seabed is assinine at the least. They seem to be waiting, and BP is actually probably hoping for a blow out below the sea bed so no one will ever know what the true scope of this spill actually is. Then they can save the day with their offset drilling and cement the bore in and no volume will ever be known as to the size of the spill.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Someone Said
Watching this movie in a front row seat.
04:54 PM on 07/18/2010
I think the "cat is out of the bag" already, watch this video to see what has happened to the water in the Gulf.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SekmdPCAQ0U

Stand back non-believers...
10:48 PM on 07/20/2010
Embed and post this with a short description at the new independent clearinghouse site
http://bpspillsolutions.com/BPspill/default.asp
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Texan POd
04:01 PM on 07/18/2010
Duhhhh, IT'S NOT LEAKING..... Leave it alone .... Get Obama the hell away from it.....
05:00 PM on 07/18/2010
I'm sure the Presidential advisory panel was instrumental in the capping of this blowout. The cause of the blowout seems clearly to be negligence on the part of BP. Even Anadarko Petroleum, one of BP's partners in the rig stated that BP was reckless and negligent. BP seems clearly to be facing negligent homicide charges regarding then incineration of the 11 rig workers. The facts and eye witness testimony are piling up regardless of anyone's inability to see or understand the truth. The Coast Guard, of course, was also instrumental in the remediation efforts regarding the blowout and continues to be so. Thad Allen probably deserves a Presidential Medal for his work.
06:28 PM on 07/18/2010
considering that your nametag implies urination it's odd for you to comment on the lack of leakage.
photo
MichaelMcKLA
I'm moving to Pandora.
03:28 PM on 07/18/2010
Leave it shut.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
HLL
Women, their rights & nothing less ~ SusanBAnthony
04:46 PM on 07/18/2010
Co-sign
06:42 PM on 07/18/2010
let's just say hypothethcally the under seafloor piping is damaged and bursts open uncontollably with the added pressure. Why should I not expect the armchair scientists like yourself to just as likely whine about how precautions were not taken and why did we not use the option of capturing the oil to relieve the pressure. .

I would prefer to leave the decision to the real scientists and engineers who are currently working on this problem.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
HLL
Women, their rights & nothing less ~ SusanBAnthony
03:11 PM on 07/18/2010
My friends,
This is an extraordinary full-lenth film about the Earth. It is free. Whenever you have time :)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jqxENMKaeCU

"We are living in exceptional times. Scientists tell us that we have 10 years to change the way we live, avert the depletion of natural resources and the catastrophic evolution of the Earth's climate.

The stakes are high for us and our children. Everyone should take part in the effort, and HOME has been conceived to take a message of mobilization out to every human being.

For this purpose, HOME needs to be free. A patron, the PPR Group, made this possible. EuropaCorp, the distributor, also pledged not to make any profit because Home is a non-profit film.

HOME has been made for you : share it! And act for the planet. ~ Yann Arthus-Bertrand"
photo
MichaelMcKLA
I'm moving to Pandora.
03:36 PM on 07/18/2010
In around 250 years, summer temps in some places will top 140 degrees (projected figure based on estimated future incremental warming). Oh, our descendants are gonna have a hot time! And they won't think kindly of us. We traded our inconvenience for their scorching world.

In Southern California's San Fernando Valley, where a very hot day can reach 110...well, 140 will mean you wear insulated clothing or don't live here. Or don't live at all.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
HLL
Women, their rights & nothing less ~ SusanBAnthony
03:43 PM on 07/18/2010
I think we're at that possibility - "or don't live at all...."

But we can change. We must. I keep hope alive in my heart! This catastrophic tragedy in the Gulf of Mexico must be the wake-up call that we cannot keep gouging holes into our planet and expect her to keep yielding her gifts in such a harsh and destructive way. Peace, compassion, kindness, harmony, solar, wind, wave - these are the ways of the future. Starting now. Enjoy the film.

Fan #320
TheBear
I still believe but I'm getting tired
04:53 PM on 07/18/2010
How many people will read in "250 years" and not give a hoot? Wish we could make this more urgent to people. I don't understand why many are not willing to make even small sacrifices for the good of the planet?
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Starling5
Not an Earthling...
04:08 PM on 07/18/2010
Thankyou HLL for this wonderful gift.
I am posting very little on HP these days because I'm spending all my energy on breathing light onto the wound that was inflicted on Gaia's flesh and to join with all of you to send our healing energy in unison.
I am also beaming that light-energy onto all the critters in that area, as well as those who are about to land there, in order to guide them away from the whole area.
I am accutely attuned to the Earth at this time and am anticipating a further sudden event to occur around the end of this month.
In this current heightened mode of intuition, I am able to beam right through every single word spoken by BP and US Gov and can see nothing but lies, lies, lies and how they have been fashioned to obscure a very nasty secret known about the deed they have done in the GoM.

Please all raise your Yin healing energy levels as we approach the end of this month. This is something very nasty that is set to occur then, but it also brings with it the urgency of transformation that is needed by the Human mind-waves.

All Together Now.....
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
HLL
Women, their rights & nothing less ~ SusanBAnthony
04:14 PM on 07/18/2010
Fan #40.

We are on the same wave-length, Starling. Thank you for breathing light into the Earth. I've been sending prayers and blessings to the Gulf of Mexico. I received a wonderful Email some weeks ago that you will, I feel, deeply appreciate, emphasizing how important it is to send love to the ocean:

There is a Japanese Scientist, Dr. Masaru Emoto, whose research revealed that water physically responds to emotions.

He sent out an Email, and I received a fwd. He wrote: "Please participate in this prayer and set an intention of love and healing that is so large, so overwhelming, that we can perform a miracle in the Gulf of Mexico.

We are not powerless. We are powerful. Our united energy, speaking this prayer daily... multiple times daily.... can literally shift the balance of destruction that is happening. We don't have to know how...... we just have to recognize that the power of love is greater than any power active in the Universe today.

Healing Prayer: I send the energy of love and gratitude to the water and all the living creatures in the Gulf of Mexico and its surroundings. To the whales, dolphins, pelicans, turtles, fish, shellfish, planktons, corals, algae and all living creatures..... I am sorry. Please forgive me. Thank you. I love you.'"

Peace.
03:04 PM on 07/18/2010
Thad Allen is the only one cautious and he's right. The scientists better not mention, they have done this to measure the pressure. This would be bad gambling. However, even if there's a leak and the pressure low as it is, the gas probably freezes in the rock and the oil forms hydrocarbonats. Perhaps sometimes a bit gas or oil releases through the seabed until it's plugged, but not as a huge flow or blow out.
bp should pay for air injections into the dead zones. In the moment there's a 30000 horse power pump available as I remember. Nothings worse and more expensive than unused equipment.
photo
GeorgeMilquetoast
Striving for a mediocre amount of mediocrity
02:59 AM on 07/19/2010
Total agree about the need to oxygenate the gulf. That action might significantly speed up the microbial breakdown of oil and also dramatically shorten the temporal duration of the dead zones.
02:54 PM on 07/18/2010
Concrete Slabs to crush vents and pipes??? Who would have guarateed that it was going to work? That is a pretty risky way of dealing with that problem. Just by crushing the pipes would not have stopped all of the Leaks. I think BP wanted to stop that oil from coming out as much as all of us did. It was not in their best Interest to prolong this Agony.
photo
GeorgeMilquetoast
Striving for a mediocre amount of mediocrity
04:12 PM on 07/18/2010
A repeat of what I posted below:

Concrete slabs, no matter how massive, would have failed to contain the leak. You cannot know that a crushed pipe is sealed, and in all likelihood it will leak due to the damage of crushing. If the oil is at 6000 to 8000 psi at the sea bed, even a pinhole leak looks terrible. 6000 to 8000 psi with a pinhole stream will cut through most materials. And then you'll have lateral erosion beneath the concrete slab, followed by an uncontrolled release around the slab perimeter.

The best fix is the to inject high-density drilling-mud into the base of the well-casing, allow the controlled upward flow of oil to be collected by surface vessels, and to allow the natural pressure of the well to carry the high-density drilling mud upward with the oil. Once enough high-density drilling mud fills the well-bore, the downward force due to all the mud weight will overcome the natural well pressure, and flow to the surface ships will essentially halt. Then they will inject concrete into the base of the well-bore, and it will harden to form a plug. The well will then no longer be a threat, and the cap will be shut off.

This is the only realistic long-term solution. Period.
05:19 PM on 07/18/2010
With the 6000-8000 psi, you forget 2300 psi counterpressure from water.
Also in the moment, this should be almost a gas well than an oil well. That's why the pressure is still slowly increasing, because the gas raises inside the well.
These pseudo-scientists are from gullivers travels.
05:37 PM on 07/18/2010
... and when the new mini-BOP is opened, there could be a giant ice column inside the well, because the temperture decreases in time. Perhaps these -surprised by miracles- scientists finally discovered the meaning of a triplepoint at wikipedia.

Just kidding, it's too easy to say they are idiots. If I try to understand the intentions of this actual BP-effort-commercial, I think very bad of them. Nonetheless the leak is closed for now.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
mrJJ
02:37 PM on 07/18/2010
snip

More than a week has passed since Alabama’s beaches have seen significant oil… [S]ome swimmers are taking their chances.

News Five collected samples of water and sand from Orange Beach, Gulf Shores, Katrina Key and Dauphin Island. To our eyes, the samples appeared normal…

http://www.floridaoilspilllaw.com/shock-water-sample-exploded-when-chemist-tested-for-oil-most-likely-methane-or-corexit
02:35 PM on 07/18/2010
Just because the oil cap is holding for the moment, don't think this is over. Keep a close watch on the oil cam. Especially the pressure gauges when they are being shown. Which by the way is not happening now. Anyone know why the pressure levels are no longer being shown to us: http://www.gulfoilcam.info
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Vegasyankee
Making Energy for a Strong America!
02:43 PM on 07/18/2010
I haven't watched any of the cam work for sometime but you check here to see if any of the other ROVs are following it.

http://www.bp.com/sectionbodycopy.do?categoryId=9034366&contentId=7063636

I believe they've pretty well proven that they have full integrity on the well as of now. the pressure had climbed a little over 6,700 psi and that was all they were looking for. I believe they are doing some more sea floor surveys and will soon be starting back up the relief well operations. 4' of formation and then they begin to penetrate the 9-5/8" casing.
02:12 PM on 07/18/2010
BP has a cap in place, and the proof existing that had they fashioned concrete slabs on Day 2 of the spill, permanently sealing the well by crushing the valves and pipes, the Gulf might have survived. What we need is a domestic terror trial, and every one of those greedy BP decision makers locked away incommunicado for the rest of their lives. How dare they opt for a solution to maximize profits over preventing literally millions of people to lose their livelihoods, destroy the Gulf, and jeopardize the planet's ecosystem?! Arrests for these domestic terrorists can't happen too soon. And, my boycott of their stations will be permanent.
photo
GeorgeMilquetoast
Striving for a mediocre amount of mediocrity
04:11 PM on 07/18/2010
Concrete slabs, no matter how massive, would have failed to contain the leak. You cannot know that a crushed pipe is sealed, and in all likelihood it will leak due to the damage of crushing. If the oil is at 6000 to 8000 psi at the sea bed, even a pinhole leak looks terrible. 6000 to 8000 psi with a pinhole stream will cut through most materials. And then you'll have lateral erosion beneath the concrete slab, followed by an uncontrolled release around the slab perimeter.

The best fix is the to inject high-density drilling-mud into the base of the well-casing, allow the controlled upward flow of oil to be collected by surface vessels, and to allow the natural pressure of the well to carry the high-density drilling mud upward with the oil. Once enough high-density drilling mud fills the well-bore, the downward force due to all the mud weight will overcome the natural well pressure, and flow to the surface ships will essentially halt. Then they will inject concrete into the base of the well-bore, and it will harden to form a plug. The well will then no longer be a threat, and the cap will be shut off.

This is the only realistic long-term solution. Period.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:04 PM on 07/18/2010
Fantastic idea. Maybe BP does have some people actually thinking about the damage and not their greed?