iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Gibbs Stands By His 'Professional Left' Critique, Expects Liberals To Vote In 2010

First Posted: 08/11/10 03:25 PM ET Updated: 05/25/11 06:20 PM ET

Obama

Speaking publicly for the first time since he disparaged the "professional left," White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs said he stands by his comments, has no plans to resign and that he fully expects progressive voters to go to the polls in 2010.

"I don't plan on leaving and there is no truth to the rumor that I've added an inflatable exit to my office," the press secretary said during Wednesday's briefing, referencing the recent incident in which a Jet Blue flight attendant bolted his plane in frustration.

Taking the podium after a day off to tend to a sore throat, Gibbs said he has not reached out to any Democrats to discuss his remarks, in which he chastised liberals for wanting to "eliminate the Pentagon" and pursue Canadian-style health care reform. Nor, he added, has he talked to the president about the matter.

Does he stand by the comments? "Yes," he replied.

It was suggested that the remarks may have been part of a cynical strategy to depict the White House as not beholden to the progressive base. But the press secretary insisted that there was nothing underhanded in his interview with The Hill. He had said what he said in a bout of frustration.

"There are many time when I read the transcripts... that I could have said things slightly differently. I watch lot of cable TV and you don't have to watch long to get frustrated by some of what's said."

As for remorse, however, little was offered. Gibbs noted that the president has achieved many of the objectives that he had pledged on the campaign trail, insinuating that he isn't getting enough credit for these accomplishments. The frustration came from there but the sentiments aren't wholly unique.

"I doubt I said anything you haven't already heard before," said Gibbs.

The press secretary did not name names when pressed as to whom he was targeting with his criticism. The professional left was defined by Deputy Press Secretary Bill Burton as primarily cable news pundits. But no one on the TV circuit, let alone in public office, has called for the Pentagon to be eliminated. Gibbs hinted, briefly, that Rep. Dennis Kucinich (D-Ohio) had done as much on the presidential campaign trail, only to have CBS's Chip Reid correct him. Kucinich had promoted a Department of Peace.

A day after the controversy over Gibbs' remarks was seemingly been put to rest by a quick walk-back from the press secretary, Wednesday's briefing seems likely to reignite the debate over the White House's relationship with liberals. But if there was nervousness over base voters not heading to the polls, Gibbs didn't show it:

"I don't think [liberal voters won't show up]," he said, "because I think what's at stake in November is too important to do that."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST POLITICS
Subscribe to the HuffPost Hill newsletter!
Speaking publicly for the first time since he disparaged the "professional left," White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs said he stands by his comments, has no plans to resign and that he fully expe...
Speaking publicly for the first time since he disparaged the "professional left," White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs said he stands by his comments, has no plans to resign and that he fully expe...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 9,120
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (175 total)
08:12 PM on 08/15/2010
Yes, I do plan to vote in 2010. Gibbs may be part of an overall scenario that influences how I vote, but not whether I vote.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bgorden
didn't cause the economic crisis
12:20 PM on 08/13/2010
Dear Mr. Gibbs:

I repent. I admit I have called President Obama "Bush Lite". I have criticized him for going back on his campaign promises and for accepting corporate money and for appointing the people who ruined our economy to be the ones in charge of fixing it. I am doing the only thing possible: I am going to Canada for drug testing. Unfortunately, that means I'll be too busy to vote for Democratic candidates this fall. But don't worry, those centrists and moderates you are courting are sure to prefer you to the Republicans. At least, that's what all the polls say.

By the way, may I call you "Ari Fleischer lite"? You've got a lot to learn about attacking the Left. You didn't even question my loyalty or call me a Communist. Say "Hi" to David Brooks for me, OK?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
VioletDatura
_-*-,,~*~_-*-,,~*~_-*-,,~*~
01:26 PM on 08/13/2010
Nicely put,

#34
avg american
It's about jobs, jobs, jobs...
11:18 AM on 08/13/2010
This is ridiculous.
We didn’t get here overnight and it is not going to be fixed overnight.
Whitehouse team, the left side supported your administration and helped y'all get elected. The derisive tone is not impressive. Humility and gratitude are universal virtues.
Left pundits, He's been in office 20 months. Having to (still)do cleanup duty for the irresponsible bush administration, stopped a crashing economy, got a health care bill passed and is currently working with some unsupportive (in my opinion - pretty childish and unprofessional) folks in congress to help millions of THEIR people on unemployment…over 15 million unemployed people... from all 50 states.
It’s hot and folks are irritated. If y’all need to take a day or two off to cool off and regroup. Do so.
Otherwise………….you’re both pretty……. knock it off and get back to work.

I am sure by now… everyone caught that piece about the folks in Atlanta trying to get an application for section8 housing? The homelessness and poverty are part of the continuing fall-out of our economy and it needs to be addressed maturely. PDQ too, winter is coming.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jerome Henehan
04:43 PM on 08/13/2010
I wish you would run. I'll perhaps vote this fall.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dr. Jonathan David Farley
mathematician
07:41 PM on 08/13/2010
In October 2012 you'll be saying, "Obama's only had 3 years and 9 months. It takes time."
02:31 AM on 08/14/2010
How about the President's doing quite well considering the great support he's gotten from half of the 'left' and nod-da from the 'right!
!8 months? You guy's will be dang lucky if the man decides to ever run again.
If not, heaven help ya!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bob Gort
07:51 AM on 08/13/2010
Is it possible to send e-mail to good-old Gibbsy? I don't see any way to do it on the White House Web site.
photo
blinkthink
Tax Wall Street Trades Now
07:06 PM on 08/13/2010
White House switchboard is all I know of.
12:52 AM on 08/13/2010
"I don't think [liberal voters won't show up] because I think what's at stake in November is too important to do that."

Don't count on it, Gibbs. A lot of us will hold our nose and vote for Obama and other so-called Democrats because we'll do anything to keep the Republicans out of office. Probably not enough of us, though.

The thing is, if we do this, we are "enablers", in addiction parlance. We will never get the representation we want if we continue to re-elect people who betray us. There's no penalty, nothing to keep them from selling out over and over.

I really don't know what I will do come 2012. For now, I guess I'll hope Obama redeems himself by then. But I'm just cynical enough to know that's probably not gonna happen.
09:38 AM on 08/13/2010
Well, then you've just handed conservatives the win. Congratulations, you gutless cowards. You capitulated at the final moment; at the time of reckoning; at the behest of the time of resurrections. You have done us all proud, fools that you are, and added us yet another Republican president that will shred any hopes dashed by Obama to pieces. What has Obama done? Well, for starters, he has opened to the door to universal health care. Oh, but does that matter? Of course not. Your aims are too high. You want it all!

Fools like you I suffer daily in this party, and I'm sick of it. If Obama does not win come 2012, I will never vote for the Democratic party again. Liberals are whiny. You support you candidate, that's what you do. That's what the Right does.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dr. Jonathan David Farley
mathematician
07:43 PM on 08/13/2010
You're delusional: If Obama had wanted to "open the door to universal health care," he would have let people testify about universal health care. Keep hoping.
photo
AaronO
Radio Show Host, 97.3 The Rock Radio FM
11:04 PM on 08/12/2010
I think people misunderstood Gibbs. Gibbs is a guy who shoots from the hip and he's going to say some things that will make people say, "Wow, did he actually say that?" I think his frustration stems from the lack of understanding from people who believe that he's going to specifically pursue the liberal agenda when the current political climate prohibits him from doing so.

As a Democrat, I'm frustrated with the president as much as everyone else here -- except I understand (even when I voted for him on November 4, 2008) that he's not going to please everyone. When my liberal colleagues pushed for universal health care, I stood by their side but when he wasn't able to achieve that, I understood why. Congress did not have enough votes to enact such revolutionary legislation. We're talking about a congress that includes a handful of fiscally conservative "blue dog" Democrats and Republicans who made it perfectly clear that they're going to rubber stamp, "NO!" on progressive initiatives.

When the "professional left" comes out and says, "How dare you, Mr. President for not doing what we want you to do," I have to put myself in Obama's shoes. Once I do, I'm able to see this monumental, fringe right-wing opposition that blocks everything that the "professional left" wants. Gibbs is just frustrated that his administration cannot realistically advance the agenda of his leftist base.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dr. Jonathan David Farley
mathematician
07:44 PM on 08/13/2010
You think that if Obama had pushed for universal health care, that there's a substantial group of Democratic voters who would have been displeased?
photo
AaronO
Radio Show Host, 97.3 The Rock Radio FM
08:39 PM on 08/13/2010
Including myself, plenty of Democratic voters would be supportive if Obama pushed for universal health care, but the problem -- unfortunately -- is that Democratic voter support is not recognized by the GOP in Congress. The GOP has leverage because of their virtually unanimous "no" voting block and support from conservative Democrats like Senators Max Baucus, Evan Bayh, and 11 others who were against the inclusion of the public option.

Democratic voter support for progressive measures is very important -- and I'm not undermining that -- and as Gibbs said today, Obama wants that pressure from the left. The problem is that Obama faces tremendous opposition from those who worship the status quo in this country and he's not going to get what he wants unless he negotiates for votes. Sadly, when he does that, progressive legislation gets watered down and we're left to accept the "better than nothing" rationale when bills are passed.
10:35 PM on 08/12/2010
I wasn't one to be fooled by Obama the first time and having seen proof of what I expected of him as president there is no chance he'll have my vote in 2012. Democrats hardly deserve the majority they have now, so I am one "professional left' voter that will be staying home. Good call Mr. Gibbs.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ladywolf55
Independent Secular Progressive
11:49 PM on 08/12/2010
Agreed. We Progressives are perfectly capable of voting with our feet!
11:58 PM on 08/12/2010
Ah, the genius of the foot-voter! And I bet you were very happy and never complained about the way things were before Obama took office, huh?
09:37 AM on 08/13/2010
What?

If you don't vote, the Tea Partiers will win. You think you punish Obama by this?

You merely punish yourselves!
Jack Canuckski
Canadian Observer of the passing scene
09:56 PM on 08/12/2010
Gibbs is right about 1 thing. The liberals and progressives will turn out to vote because they are the ones who are the most acutely aware of the consequences of a major Republican victory in November. But fewer will go out and enthusiastically work to elect Democrats, because a good many will simply give up, become cynical about the whole thing and decide that they're all the same, so it doesn't matter who wins, as they did back in 2000 after the election was stolen from them from under their noses.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
VioletDatura
_-*-,,~*~_-*-,,~*~_-*-,,~*~
01:31 PM on 08/13/2010
FAnned and faved. Despite expressing my disapproval of Obama, whose presidency I had great hopes for, I will vote for him again although reluctantly.

What the "My President Right Or Wrong" crowd doesn't seem to understand is that without high expectations from the "professional left", Obama - or any politician - has no compelling reason to remember we exist.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dr. Jonathan David Farley
mathematician
07:50 PM on 08/13/2010
Yes, if the Republicans win in November, we won't have universal health care, Guantanamo will stay open, we will still have tens of thousands of troops in Iraq and Afghanistan, we'll have more off-shore drilling, nuclear power, no prosecutions for torture, a government that reserves the right to assassinate U.S. citizens without trial anywhere in the world...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alamantra
09:04 PM on 08/12/2010
I stand with Gibbs and his comments about how it makes him feel to watch the cable news as well as Pres. Obama's comments about 24 hr. cable chatter. It's an odd position for the corporate fueled "left wing" media to say that when they criticize the White House its a contribution to a legitimate debate, but when the White House points out media banality, lack of civility, arrogance, selective reporting and/or editing, etc.. that such criticisms are out of bounds and then react with steaming piles of self-inflated, crapulous indignation. How about some basic media responsibility and a little less raw arrogance? ..I realize that they are run by & for corporations ...but after all, it is the PUBLIC airwaves that they are using to make their money. We have reached a bad place when the comedy channel's news satires are more intellectually honest than the actual news media that they parody. It's really hard to assess what is happening when the first duty of the news is to keep their corporate handlers and advertisers happier than the people that they are supposedly reporting the "news" to.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dr. Jonathan David Farley
mathematician
09:24 PM on 08/12/2010
Please specify exactly which criticism of the White House is illegitimate.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Joseph Furtenbacher
No one you know...
08:25 AM on 08/13/2010
In my book, criticism by people who don't even care about themselves is illegitimate - that would seem to include most Americans. Also criticism by people who are afraid to reveal their income, let alone try to justify it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
VioletDatura
_-*-,,~*~_-*-,,~*~_-*-,,~*~
06:37 PM on 08/12/2010
I'd take you more seriously, Gibbs, if you hadn't made that preposterous comment about lefties wanting to abolish the Pentagon. Is that your exact equivalent to wanting to end this war? How about we end the war, but keep the Pentagon? Can you continue to make arguments without resorting to the Straw Man argument?
09:39 AM on 08/13/2010
Yes, yes! Bash your party's representatives! Conservatives are laughing right now!

Keep dashing your hopes, you godd*amn fools.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
VioletDatura
_-*-,,~*~_-*-,,~*~_-*-,,~*~
01:19 PM on 08/13/2010
We're not allowed to disagree, Zombie?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
blueollie
nerd from Illinois
04:37 PM on 08/12/2010
This remark won't hurt the Democrats in 2010. Reason: progressives have power in blue districts, and House members in these districts will score political points by bashing Gibbs (e. .g, the way that Rep. Grayson did). The House Democrats that are in trouble in 2010 are mostly the blue dogs in purple districts, and these remarks won't hurt there.
By 2012, either the economy will be recovering or the Republicans will run Palin (in which case Obama wins easily) or the economy will be in free fall and Obama won't stand much of a chance. I predict the former..but 2 years is a long time. In a year, no one will even remember.
07:10 PM on 08/12/2010
Grayson is not in blue district. It has elected Repubs. He is betting
strength and clarity will keep independents and win enough
repubs. He is so forceful, unlike most Dems, some Repubs and Indes thought he was a
Repub, according to some internal polls.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
blueollie
nerd from Illinois
11:08 PM on 08/15/2010
Thank you for the correction! :-)
03:03 PM on 08/12/2010
Yeah, Gibbs is right. Liberal voters will show up to vote, BUT they will not necessarily vote for the Democrats. They will do what they did back in 2000 - they will vote for someone like Ralph Nader - and the again the country will go to the right wingers. And you can thank Gibbs and the White House for it. They drove us to this with their arrogance.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
VioletDatura
_-*-,,~*~_-*-,,~*~_-*-,,~*~
06:34 PM on 08/12/2010
I hate that I almost agree with you.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ladywolf55
Independent Secular Progressive
11:55 PM on 08/12/2010
Did you ever consider that they're all in it together and Obama was put there to be a "placeholder" until the Repubs could get back in good graces (or their twisted version of good graces)? They're all Corporate w.h.o.r.e.s
12:33 AM on 08/13/2010
That would explain a lot....
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
flossophy
the unfamous anti-establishment classical liberal
02:09 PM on 08/12/2010
The Democrats know you'll never vote for Republicans... that's why they treat you this way.

You disillusioned lefties should start your own tea party to get your masters to pay more attention to you.

They're taking you for granted.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
JonBFertippton
07:41 PM on 08/12/2010
re: flossophy - Progressive should start a teabag party like the Reps

So you think that, in the long and short runs, the teabaggers have been a success for the Republicans? Let's look at this and have a discussion after the mid-terms.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dr. Jonathan David Farley
mathematician
09:24 PM on 08/12/2010
Yes, they changed the course of the health care non-debate.
12:07 PM on 08/12/2010
Robert Gibbs comments were highly unprofessional. If he'd had made these comments as a Congressional press secretary, he would have be fired.

Also, it dismisses a very valid frustration about the admin's tepid attitude. Yes, Congress and Obama have gotten things done. Great. But that doesn't mean Obama's representing a style of leadership that's inspirational or aspirational. He came out strong but his leadership image fading away.

Finally, why NOT make some bold decisions? The opportunity is there. It would certainly allow Blue Dog Dems to safely distance themselves pre-Nov. The RW is giving the administration the finger. It's the perfect opportunity to go left (and actually do what's right).

But it's not happening. Instead, the Snarkmaster 2010 (Gibbs) is wagging his finger at Democratic supporters. That, to me, makes no sense.
photo
blinkthink
Tax Wall Street Trades Now
09:43 AM on 08/13/2010
I have no problem with Obama's style. He should be based on policy, not posturing.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:43 AM on 08/12/2010
The "Professional Liberals" speaks - everything you need to know in one place.

http://www.salon.com/news/opinion/glenn_greenwald/2010/08/10/gibbs/index.html
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ladywolf55
Independent Secular Progressive
12:00 AM on 08/13/2010
Gotta love Glenn Greenwald. At least the man has a brain between his ears instead of swiss cheese like Gibbs.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
VioletDatura
_-*-,,~*~_-*-,,~*~_-*-,,~*~
05:02 PM on 08/13/2010
Agreed!