iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Hitler Jewish? DNA Tests Show Dictator May Have 'Had Jewish And African Roots'

First Posted: 08/25/10 03:58 AM ET Updated: 05/25/11 06:25 PM ET

Hitler Jewish African
DNA tests suggest Hitler may have had Jewish and African ancestry.

The story of Adolf Hitler could be the most twisted in all of history. Add one more twist.

Responsible for the slaughter of millions of Jews and a hero only to self-avowed racists, DNA tests apparently show that the Nazi dictator may have had Jewish and African ancestry.

Several media outlets have reported on results published last week in Knack, a magazine in Belgium.

The British newspaper The Daily Telegraph says that saliva samples were collected from 39 Hitler relatives:

A chromosome called Haplogroup E1b1b1 which showed up in their samples is rare in Western Europe and is most commonly found in the Berbers of Morocco, Algeria and Tunisia, as well as among Ashkenazi and Sephardic Jews ...

Haplogroup E1b1b1, which accounts for approximately 18 to 20 per cent of Ashkenazi and 8.6 per cent to 30 per cent of Sephardic Y-chromosomes, appears to be one of the major founding lineages of the Jewish population.

Many victims of Hitler's Holocaust, like Anne Frank, were Ashkenazi.

Another British paper, The Sun, identified more of the people involved and how two of the samples were obtained:

A journalist working for a magazine in Brussels managed to get hold of a sample from Alexander Stuart-Houston, 61, a grand-nephew of Hitler living in America, after picking up a serviette he had dropped.

Reporter Jean-Paul Mulders used the services of historian Marc Vermeeren to find Hitler's Austrian cousin, a farmer called Norbert H, and 39 other distant relatives of the Fuehrer.

Norbert H apparently gave a saliva sample willingly.

"Hitler would not have been happy," said Professor Ronny Decorte in a Google translation of the Knack's web-version of the story. Decorte, a genetics expert from Katholieke Universiteit Leuven (a Flemish research university), says that Hitler apparently wasn't "Aryan" -- what the Nazi would have considered "pure." But the research doesn't seem to be conclusive with respect to which groups Hitler may have descended from.

Hitler's preoccupation with ancestry -- including his own -- has caused speculation for many years. New York Daily News points out that this research could validate a historic myth:

Hitler's heritage has been called into question before, with some suggesting his grandfather was Jewish. But this is the first claim with any scientific data to support it.

Similar reports have been made against Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, who has repeatedly denied the Holocaust occurred and regularly bashes Israel.

Knack says that Russia possesses artifacts from Hitler that would contain his DNA, and that researchers could end the speculation if they were allowed to test those items.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST WORLD

Filed by Adam J. Rose  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 1,436
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (33 total)
09:47 AM on 08/29/2010
I think this article leaves too much open to interpretation. With a few more facts, it might have been more cut and dried. In another article, it is spelled out more decisively. In order to belong to this Haplogroup E1b1b1, which is a marker on the Y (male) chromosome, you have to be in a direct line of males which have the same one. You cannot inherit it from a woman.

The other article stated that Hitler's grandmother, Fraulein Schickelgruber, had a liaison with a named Jewish man (whose name I forget). Her illegitimate son from that union (I don't know if they had more children) was Hitler's father. If you tested the other male-descended relatives of Hitler (any uncles and nephews) who came from this union, you would find the same Y-chromosomes with only minor changes over such a short period of time. This is how the case has been made, through mostly voluntary testing and not from snatching napkins from diners in restaurants. If you say it is all about the napkin snatch, then the story is easily apocryphal. After all the reproduction rate in Europe isn't great (hence their fear of more rapidly multiplying immigrants), so the story might easily die out. Hitler's body has probably not been preserved either.
11:38 PM on 08/28/2010
Jesus Christ, so now..the Jews are also responsible for Hitler, next to killing Jesus and Communism.
This is not a good thing at all.
.
photo
southingtonian
"I'm a Capricorn and you can't make me do sh*t.."
04:15 AM on 08/28/2010
We ALL have African roots.
01:29 PM on 09/30/2010
Although, he didnt believe it. Which makes it so much more tragic, considering what he did and the fact that his own paternal ancestors were some of the last people to leave that continent.
12:56 AM on 08/28/2010
J.Edgar Hoover could pass for Italian or Hispanic. He clearly has some black in him, yet he was one of the most anti-black leadership racists around. Some of these racists would have to commit suicide if their purity proclamations were taken to their final conclusions.
12:43 AM on 08/28/2010
Former President Dwight Eisenhower was not pure white. In fact his mother was mulatto. If you look at some color photos of him you could see that he was not pure.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:45 AM on 08/29/2010
Pure???? I can't believe I'm hearing this on a lefty American site!!! We're all mutts!!! This stuff is OVER!
As for Ike, it's that smile and heart I love. Who cares about the hybrid vigor his mother demonstrated so well...handing out pacifist leaflets when he was at West Point! Go mutts!

Pure??? Didn't that end with Pandora or the Garden of Eden???
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MisterCee
The Ruler's back!
11:21 PM on 08/27/2010
Uh uh...We have enough problems, don't push Hitler on us too!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheColouredEuropean
Government is not evil, REPUB government is evil
04:20 PM on 08/27/2010
TeaBaggers are already spinning this as some sorta "proof" that since Hitler was black, Obama is actually Hitler, so all of their fingerpainting on that subject is accurate.
To which I say:

1. Wait, he was, according to this info, THREE times more Jewish than Black, but more importantly he was 235 (TWO HUNDRED AND THIRTHY FIVE) times more WHITE than Jewish and African ... combined!

2. Any implication that Hitler was North African and therefor linked to Obama, is a stretch, since it was the North African Sefardic Arabs who enslaved the black, Middle-Africans. So ...

3. You have MUCH MORE of a point saying that Obama is half WHITE, so he must be like Hitler, who was completely white ... Oh wait, that goes much more for the whole of the Teabagger crazies, since they are 99.8% white!!! (yes, we do allow for that poor Atlanta woman with mental health problems. Extreme case of Stockhom syndrome after being gangraped by the KKK ... Sad.)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:51 PM on 08/27/2010
so what... humans migrated out of africa, so we're all a % African, even the moronic "white" supremacists.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheColouredEuropean
Government is not evil, REPUB government is evil
04:21 PM on 08/27/2010
that's right, the only sensible thing to say about this, is that there's no such thing as a pure race ... this is even more the case for so-called white americans ...
photo
Renee27
The Most Censored Commenter on HuffPo
02:56 AM on 08/27/2010
I know black folks are not going to want to hear this but I think that J Edgar Hoover may have been black too. This is just my theory.

Take a REALLY good look at these pictures -

Young Hoover -

http://moviesmedia.ign.com/movies/image/article/108/1081150/hoover1_1270069155.jpg

http://www.old-picture.com/american-legacy/000/pictures/Hoover-Edgar-J-002.jpg -

http://johndenugent.com/jdn/wp-content/uploads/2010/01/Hoover-Edgar-J-young.jpg

http://history.sandiego.edu/cdr2/WW2Pics4/07252.jpg

What's up with people who commit hate crimes against people of their own ethnic group (and sexual orientation) ?
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
maiali
05:16 PM on 08/27/2010
A few years ago, an African-American woman wrote about Hoover and his black ancestry. She was related to Hoover. If I can find the link to the book, I'll post it.
11:50 PM on 08/27/2010
In fact, it's old news in Europe.
photo
Renee27
The Most Censored Commenter on HuffPo
02:39 AM on 08/27/2010
He!! no, yuck

..but everyone has African ancestry in our DNA
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
afrodesia
04:57 PM on 08/27/2010
Aw Rene. Don't us for being Black & Beautiful.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wwoody
Retired fishing for the truth.
12:00 AM on 08/27/2010
This still don't explain why he turn his back on Jesse Owen .
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bruce vain
11:19 PM on 08/26/2010
Okay as an African AMERICAN...yall can have him..PERIOD
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
afrodesia
04:57 PM on 08/27/2010
& Rene27 too!
10:26 PM on 08/26/2010
This article is major BS!
photo
billbb
Just the facts
12:06 AM on 08/27/2010
This is not exactly a new allegation, and Hitler went to considerable pains to erase any possible proof.

The facts are this: Hitler's father Alois was illegitimate, born in 1837 when Granny Schicklgruber was working as a maid in Graz. Her employers were said to be a Jewish family named Frankenberger, who had a 19-year-old son. Supposedly, Alois was his kid, though a late-in-the-day coverup changed Al's birth certificate in 1876, declaring that Alois's stepfather J.G. Hiedler was in fact his real father. J.G. already being dead, there doesn't seem to be much reason for the switch, save to hide the Jewish connection. This would make him 1/4 Jewish, if true. Hitler's attorney claimed that, around 1930, some member of the clan Hitler was trying to blackmailer Der Fuhrer about his supposed Jewish ancestry. No evidence for this has ever been uncovered, and some historians believe that there were no Jews in Graz at the time.

Another possibility for Hitler's paternal line is no less weird: Klara Poelzl (Hitler's mom) was the granddaughter of one Johann Nepomuk Hiedler, brother of J.G Hiedler and next most likely suspect as the true father of Alois. Having his maternal and paternal grandfather be the same guy might explain loads about Hitler's insanity. Whether the Jewish rumors were true or not, Hitler went to extreme lengths to destroy the area around the town of his birth in order to make tracing his ancestry impossible.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
E-Nation
I don't like the taste of right wings
09:57 PM on 08/26/2010
This has been common knowledge for a while now
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:50 PM on 08/26/2010
I thought this was already generally known knowledge. Hitler represented the Barbarian side of Germany in contrast to the neo-classical. The German people never abandoned some of their Barbarian roots and the brutes lived on and were the ones who committed the Holocasut and persecuted not only all of its direct victims, but the rest of Germany that did not realize these cavemen were stilla round until they had all the power. For me, this is the great tragedy and absurdity of World War 2. Barbarians don't know how to govern. They are from a bygone era and Hitler knew and related this to people, ultimately hoping that Germans would return to a neo-paganism where they would worship multiple non-existent Gods and there are more fools out there today that still believe in him. The brutes are still with us in many circles.
I used to be quite ignorant about Germany, but I now see the real people of Germany to be victims of the Nazi's as much as those that died in the camps. Hitler not only had an unparalleled hatred for Jews, gays, blacks, Slavs and Gypsies, but also the real Germans that were responsible, essentially for making Germany well... Germany.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hulagirrrl
11:12 PM on 08/26/2010
I think you are still quite ignorant about Germany, I can not agree with you on anything you wrote here, sorry.
photo
Tinki - bot
Be excellent to each other!
05:23 AM on 08/27/2010
Hmmm, ok, where to start?

I was born in Germany, lived there until my late teens; I am half German and half hispanic American, a grandchild of the post war presence of the Allies. ( I am currently living in Australia, I have family in CA)
So, in a nutshell, I was German born and bred, yet an outsider, due to my dark skin and curly black locks.
This gives me a somewhat unique insight into the issue of race, ethnicity and discrimination in German society, having had a foot in both camps, so to speak.

So please, let me assure you, none of what you wrote bears any resemblance to the reality of Germany's history, or indeed the present.

I am sure most readers would have come to the same conclusion half - way through your post, but I had to respond either way.

I do agree with you on one point, many Germans were a victim of the Nazis as well. Some honestly believed they were serving their country, performing their patriotic duties....


So please excuse me when I feel a chill going down my spine when I hear those same, noble sentiments exploited by the shrill voices of the conservatives.