iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Gates Takes On Woodward Book Charges

ANNE GEARAN   09/24/10 12:55 AM ET   AP

Gates Woodward

WASHINGTON — Defense Secretary Robert Gates said Thursday that the Obama administration's redrawn Afghanistan war strategy is sound, answering claims in a new book that the plan was a politically driven hodgepodge.

Once President Barack Obama announced the plan his entire administration and the military swung behind it, Gates said during a Pentagon news conference. The Pentagon chief also predicted no big shifts as the war moves into its 10th year.

Obama overrode some close advisers last December after months of debate, when he added about 30,000 forces and shifted battlefield priorities. Neither did he satisfy his generals. The resulting divisions and bureaucratic backbiting are laid out in Washington Post writer Bob Woodward's book "Obama's Wars."

Gates shrugged off those divisions.

"Conflict sells," Gates said.

The Obama administration sought a new counterinsurgency strategy to blunt the momentum of the resurgent Taliban. The homegrown Afghan insurgency was defeated in the 2001 invasion but allowed to regroup during several years of what Obama and his advisers call inattention by the Bush administration.

The book suggests the final strategy was fashioned by committee and was partly driven by anti-war politics within the Democratic Party.

The White House will conduct a long-planned review of its Afghan strategy at the end of this year, and some Democrats had hoped that Obama would use the opportunity to signal a swift end to the protracted and costly conflict.

Gates said the Afghan war may have dragged on for years, but the Obama plan to address it is new and only beginning to bear fruit.

He predicted that the administration might order "adjustments and tweaks" to its war plan, but no major shift in policy. The current plan calls for some forces to come home next summer but presumes that the war will go on far longer.

Gates said relationships within the Obama administration were as harmonious as he has seen in his long government tenure. He refused comment on the book's claim that he had chewed out a White House colleague for airing his dissenting views on the war too prominently.

Asked whether he held any reservations about the compromise war strategy that emerged from an unusually long and fractious debate, Gates said no.

"I wouldn't sign the deployment orders if I didn't believe," the policy is sound, Gates said.

Adm. Mike Mullen, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, told reporters that he, too, had faith in the current strategy.

"We're starting to see some signs of progress," Mullen said. "With the right strategy and the right resources and the right leadership, you know, we're starting to move forward."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST POLITICS
Subscribe to the HuffPost Hill newsletter!
WASHINGTON — Defense Secretary Robert Gates said Thursday that the Obama administration's redrawn Afghanistan war strategy is sound, answering claims in a new book that the plan was a politicall...
WASHINGTON — Defense Secretary Robert Gates said Thursday that the Obama administration's redrawn Afghanistan war strategy is sound, answering claims in a new book that the plan was a politicall...
Filed by Jeff Muskus  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 105
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MyHO
Speaking Truth to Power
08:32 AM on 09/27/2010
That potentially many thousands more should die or be wounded just to preserve a politically acceptable withdraw is criminal insanity. The harsh reality is whether we withdraw now or 10 years from now, this region of the world will be in turmoil and the training ground for terrorists. However, the extent to which terrorists can harm Americans is miniscule compared to one of our enemies acquiring nuclear weaponry.
04:59 PM on 09/25/2010
Obama makes one comment about "losing the Democrats" and all of a sudden all of his decisions on Afghanistan are politically driven. He only uttered the words. W on the other hand, blatantly invaded Iraq purely for political reasons, trying to take advantage of America's taste for revenge on anybody for 9-11, and on behalf of the oil industry, with "national defense" coming in a distant third. Blatant as hell. I'm sure the same Boehn-heads that are crying now were cheering then.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Blackorpheus
the decisive blows are always struck left-handed
10:43 AM on 09/25/2010
Woodward is right: the Obama-Gates Afghan strategy is a "politically driven hodgepodge."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Michael Valentine
Retired SEIU Member
02:06 PM on 09/24/2010
Gates is the biggest failure in Washington.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Kevin Atlanta
Active Citizen 54
01:06 PM on 09/24/2010
From Gates' own mouth:  "Conflict sells," Gates said.


The Holy Republican TEA Party Cults of Jesus Inc's agenda in two words.  


Thank you Chairman Gates.


President Obama; now is the time to end this prosperity vacuum, put the Military into it's proper place.  "Peaceful Readiness" is the ONLY position the United States Military is Constitutionally mandated to maintain.  End the Fraud of Wars.  Nation-build America first!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
softvoice
keep your eye on the prize
01:02 PM on 09/24/2010
Bob Woodward is trying to relive his success from years ago. This new book is not going to help in Afghanistan or anywhere else. It has the potential to do harm to the progress that is being made. Books like this should wait until the Presidency is over.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MyHO
Speaking Truth to Power
08:22 AM on 09/27/2010
...... and thousands more are dead or wounded. I don't think so!
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Cacey
Ignore rudeness, honor discussion
12:38 PM on 09/24/2010
Fox News host Meghan Kelly with her infinate knowledge and wisdom yesterday blasted the President for having fired McCrystal and disagreeing with Petraeus on some issues, adding that he (the President) has already fired one commanding general and may fire another.  How many, she added, is the President going to fire before he learns something.  I suggest she read up on Lincoln and the Civil War and get her answer to that.  Unfortunately, her viewers will not and like all Fox viewers remain biased and uninformed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Francois Bergeron
seeking sense
01:02 PM on 09/24/2010
Cool. I just sort of said that... We agree completely.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
calindi
12:14 PM on 09/24/2010
We'll see.  I always read his books knowing I'm reading from his perspective.
That said....I always read his books. 
11:51 AM on 09/24/2010
I don't like this Article. It is like somehow the Administration is Screwing Up and they are fighting about it.
It is easy to wag your tongue and point your finger but these people have a very tough job.
Americans would not admit this for the sake of their own lives.
The age of the Raging Ego is slipping into the Age of Arrogance and it is Painful to Watch.
Everyone was there when this War was started, Everyone was there when the Economy Ballooned beyond reason, Everyone was there when Bush and Cheney kicked the Constitution to the Curb. Blah, Blah, Blah.
Now Everyone wants to Blame Someone else.
On top of that the Media plays the same old Game of selling Indignation to us and we buy it without even asking why.
The Administration Cannot Do Anything Right, The Conservatives are doing exactly the same things they did during the last Democratic Administration and Everyone is is taking it the same way they did previously.
Everyone is playing an Absurd Game the playground is full and no one is paying Attention. Everyone is not represented by the Politicians. Nothing is Being Done about Immigration Reform, Nothing is Being Done about Campaign Financing, Nothing is being done about Term Limits.
Everyone knows that we need to break up the Status Quo in Washington but issues such as infighting in the Administration are sold to us because we enjoy our indignation and it is Profitable.
And Everyone is responsible.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
AussieEconomist
"Curiosity is the lust of the mind." Hobbes
11:15 AM on 09/24/2010
This is nothing new for Mr Gates. I seem to remember him being deputy director of the CIA during Iran Contra....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Michael Valentine
Retired SEIU Member
02:08 PM on 09/24/2010
Failed and promoted.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:58 AM on 09/24/2010
Cro magnon man would pick up a rock to dash out the brains of his adversary trying to steal his partner or food source, or he would chuck a spear. Today, there are much advanced means of delivery with gunpowder projected lead or DU pellets, or even drone-launched hellfire missiles to assure incineration of targets, whether they are combatants or not.
Mankind has evolved very little in the thoughts that allow for this type of behavior, but now profits are also a motivating factor.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TEHelms
Still learning....
10:39 AM on 09/24/2010
I don't think anyone likes this situation, not the Pres, not the SOD and not the country. I think overall Afghanistan is a mission for fools...but, having said that, we have the fact Bin Laden, the murderer, is still likely in Pakistan, the fact Pakistan has the bomb, is unstable and Al Qaeda would like nothing better than to have either country to operate out of at will. I wish we could contribute to the political stablity of either or both but the task may be beyond the patience of the country given the fact we dallied with real progress having been taken from the task by the stupidity of the Bush administration in Iraq. Oh, well...when have we not paid the price for the stupidity of our leaders?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:25 AM on 09/24/2010
It's a stretch to think that a country like Afganistan, with generations of full time, hardened combat veterans, will ever give up. It is of recent note, that they routed the Russians, who were in for the full dollar and not ten cents.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
AussieEconomist
"Curiosity is the lust of the mind." Hobbes
11:16 AM on 09/24/2010
With U.S. money, training and weapons.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:27 AM on 09/24/2010
Kind of like the lend lease Ford trucks broke and captured twenty German divisions at Stalingrad? Except for Grenada invasion, the US has grossly underestimated the determination and resourcefulness of it's opponents for sixty years.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
noaxe397
10:14 AM on 09/24/2010
"The book suggests the final strategy was fashioned by committee and was partly driven by anti-war politics within the Democratic Party"

I'd like to hear from veterans, conservatives and teabaggers:


Do you think this is a better way for the C in C to determine war strategy or should he go with his "gut instinct" as the previous C in C said he did?
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
ProfessorDuh
09:54 AM on 09/24/2010
I hear no more old, loudmouth warmongers defending America's disastrous, cruel and suicidal military occupations in the Mideast. So much for the great neocon Republican dream of world domination. All the pretty colors ran.