NYR iOS app Android app More

5 Meanest Book Reviews Ever: Franzen, Foer, Larsson And More (PHOTOS)

First Posted: 09/24/10 10:01 AM ET   Updated: 05/25/11 06:50 PM ET

It has been said that any publicity is good publicity. But when someone describes your writing as "like reading a bad newspaper or a bad piece in a magazine. It makes you wince," as John Irving said of Tom Wolfe's "A Man In Full," that credo loses a bit of credibility.

Book reviewers, generally speaking, tend to keep their heads when assessing a book's worth. They are, after all, charged with the task of objectively analyzing a work. Sometimes, however, professionalism and decorum give way to vitriol and downright disgust. The words in these hateful reviews are less letters on a page and more the transcript of a critic's frenzied ravings.

So, here are the worst of the worst, the most dispiriting, and the meanest. But what did we leave out? What are the meanest reviews you've ever read?

Disclaimer: We apologize if you are the author of one of these books.

"Dirty, Sexy Politics" by Meghan McCain
1 of 6
Review by Leon H. Wolf:

"It is impossible to read 'Dirty, Sexy Politics' and come away with the impression that you have read anything other than the completely unedited ramblings of an idiot."
Total comments: 190 | Post a Comment
1 of 6
This Review
Love Tap
Slap To The Face

  • 1

  • 2

  • 3

  • 4

  • 5

  • 6

  • 7

  • 8

  • 9

  • 10
Top 5 Reviews
Users who voted on this slide


Filed by Sammy Perlmutter  |