iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Righteous Among the Nations: Muslims Who Saved Jews from Holocaust

First Posted: 11/01/10 09:27 PM ET Updated: 05/25/11 07:10 PM ET

Muslim Righteous Among Nations

By Tim Townsend
St. Louis Post-Dispatch

ST. LOUIS (RNS) In 2003, Norman Gershman was looking for some of the righteous.

What he found astonished the investment banker-turned-photographer, and led him toward a project now on display in a St. Louis synagogue.

The Righteous Among Nations are gentile rescuers who make up "a small minority who mustered extraordinary courage to uphold human values," according to Yad Vashem, Israel's Holocaust memorial museum.

They are, the museum says, "the few who helped Jews in the darkest time in their history."

Gershman's story begins during the Holocaust and involves Albanian Muslims -- villagers, peasants and farmers -- who risked their lives and the lives of their families to shelter Jews fleeing Nazi Germany.

Italy invaded Albania in 1939 and occupied the country until the overthrow of Benito Mussolini in 1943. Germany then took over the Albanian occupation. Before the war, Gershman estimates from his research, only about 200 Jews lived in Albania, a country that is about 70 percent Muslim.

During the years of occupation, 10 times as many Jews streamed into Albania to escape persecution from Poland, Yugoslavia, Czechoslovakia, Greece and Italy. Gershman says it was the only country in Europe where the Jewish population grew by the end of the war.

Most of the hidden Jews either fled to Israel or back to their native countries after the war. Albania's postwar communist regime made it impossible for the Jews who had been hidden to stay in touch with the Albanian Muslims who had provided shelter.

In 2003, New Jersey native Gershman heard hints of the story and began doing research, eventually traveling to Albania to begin interviewing those Muslims who took part and who were still alive. Gershman said it wasn't just Muslim families who shielded Jews from the Nazis, but also Orthodox and Catholic families.

All of them were motivated by an Albanian code of honor called "besa," a concept that can be translated into "keeping the promise," Gershman says. The Albanian villagers were motivated to risk their lives by the simple concept of helping one's neighbor.

"We chose to focus on the Muslims because, who ever heard of Muslims saving Jews?" Gershman said in a telephone interview from Israel, where he is at work on his next project.

Gershman's research eventually led to an exhibit of his photographs, "Besa: A Code to Live By," which opened recently at Congregation Temple Emanuel, and a book, Besa: Muslims Who Saved Jews in World War II.

The exhibit makes the case that the Muslim Albanian villagers who sheltered Jews from deportation to concentration camps did so from a sense of religious obligation.

"Besa is a cultural idea, but for the Muslims in Albania it was ingrained in their faith as well," Gershman said.

Ahmet Karamustafa, professor of history and religious studies at Washington University, said saving a life is a universally acknowledged Muslim value.

Protecting a life, Karamustafa said, "has always ranked at the very top of moral and legal categories articulated by legal and theological scholars in Islam."

The exhibit has been traveling the world since 2006, opening in Yad Vashem in Israel, the United Nations in New York, and synagogues, mosques, college campuses and Holocaust museums from Turkey to El Paso, Texas.

The exhibit of 30 photographs includes one of Lime Balla, born in 1910, who told Gershman that a group of 17 Jews came from the capital city of Tirana to her village of Gjergi in 1943 during the holy month of Ramadan.

"We divided them amongst the villagers," Balla said, according to Gershman. "We were poor. We had no dining table, but we didn't allow them to pay for food or shelter. We grew vegetables for all to eat. For 15 months, we dressed them as farmers like us. Even the local police knew."

David Sherman, president of Temple Emanuel, said the synagogue "decided it could be an opportunity to educate the public about this piece of history that was a model of dialogue and tolerance."

The synagogue's rabbi, Justin Kerber, said one of the Reform congregation's goals with the exhibit is to combat a common depiction of the modern relationship between Jews and Muslims.

"There's so much coverage about Muslim-Jewish strife and conflict," Kerber said. "It's important to tell people that's not the whole story, and these are examples of Muslim-Jewish respect, tolerance and love. This was a good opportunity for us to be part of that conversation."

Tim Townsend writes for The St. Louis Post-Dispatch in St. Louis, Mo.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST RELIGION

By Tim Townsend St. Louis Post-Dispatch ST. LOUIS (RNS) In 2003, Norman Gershman was looking for some of the righteous. What he found astonished the investment banker-turned-photographer, and led...
By Tim Townsend St. Louis Post-Dispatch ST. LOUIS (RNS) In 2003, Norman Gershman was looking for some of the righteous. What he found astonished the investment banker-turned-photographer, and led...
Filed by Josh Fleet  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 332
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (7 total)
09:57 AM on 11/15/2010
The story is nice; it's just sad that they have to lie about others to promote it: "Gershman says it was the only country in Europe where the Jewish population grew by the end of the war." That simply isn't true!

Sweden's Jewish population grew considerably, as we took in about 8.000 Danish and Norwegian Jews during the main part of the war, and another 10.000 or so from Ravensbruck and other concentration camps during the last weeks before, and the first weeks after, the end of the war.

And I presume Switzerland's Jewish population grew as well, as did Spain's, and probably Portugal's.

Even if that statement was to be changed to 'OCCUPIED Europe', it still wouldn't be entirely true. There was at least one more occupied country where the Jewish population grew, and far more than in Albania: the Vatican City State. Thousands of Jews hid in the Vatican itself and its various buildings around Rome.
photo
Left of Right
Want to default your country? Default your job!
05:19 PM on 11/09/2010
As a Baha'i, the governments in many Muslim countries have persecuted us since the beginning, and still do. But the Muslim people themselves are most often friends and defend us.

I champion the goodness in them and am not surprised to see that they protected those that were unlike themselves.

All too often, too many paint an entire people with a broad brush and you have racism and discord.

I defend my Muslim brothers whenever I hear anyone at all try to lump the entire population of Islam with the radical, extreme few.
photo
StephenBP
What's he building in there?
02:20 PM on 11/09/2010
Beautiful.
09:26 PM on 11/07/2010
I am Albanian, and although I was told this story years ago by my parents, reading it on here still put a smile on my face. After having read a few other articles about all the things that are going wrong in the world, arriving at this article was like a breath of fresh air. I would beg the media if I could, to please please provide us with some uplifting stories once in a while. All is not wrong with the world, there is good out there too! Do so because it restores our strength, our faith in humanity and it gives us the will to get through a very depressing hour of the 10 o'clock news.
05:56 PM on 11/07/2010
It's an interesting story, but it's also kind of stupid in the way the author wants people to get surprised by the fact Muslims helped Jews, like "wow, I'd never have expected that"... Lol. I understand why he does that, but if people were less stupid he wouldn't have too.
It's sad but now many people seem to think that Muslims and Jews have always hated each other, as if it was written like that, and as if it's when it's otherwise that it's weird. But if you look more closely at history (I'm talking about older stuff than this story) you see things haven't always been like that.
02:52 PM on 11/07/2010
A great story. hopefully it provides a seed of love between all three Abrahamic religions. we don't have to be agree with everything, I think it is okay to disagree on some issues but when it comes to humanity, we all share the same human values and same teachings. Love for all hatered for none. go to www.alislam.org for true teachings of Islam and muslimsforpeace.org
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Raphi
07:19 AM on 11/07/2010
Terrific reminder about the all too human habit of seeing difference as a monolithic "they."

As in "they" attacked ____. (Fill in the blank.)
Or "they" are unAmerican. Intolerant. ___.
Against our religion. Against our way of law. Against our ___.

There are too many comments on this thread doing essentially that.
ALL of "them"? Everywhere and at all times? Even little old ladies and tiny babies?


Nor can we progressives exempt ourselves. Go over to the various political articles. Read the many obviously aggressive retorts or oh-so-clever put-downs of right-wing comments. Sure, uninformed trolls are annoying. Sure, the equation of progressive with communist is silly and probably meant to elicit anger.

But if anger, fear, division, and hatred are the only ways we approach each other, then those negatives become everything. Because there will be no other ways, no other mental frames, by which to understand reality.
12:58 AM on 11/06/2010
Why it is surprising that Muslims were saving Jews during Holocaust? They are not Europeans after all.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Anne Mccormick
02:17 PM on 11/05/2010
these were good people who risked their own lives to safe others. the fact that they were Muslim is secondary.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bintalshamsa
Disability rights activist, multi-ethnic, polyglot
08:50 PM on 11/08/2010
I don't think you can break up identity as simplistically as you're doing here. The fact that they were Muslim seems to have been a large part of what motivated them to take human rights so seriously. In other words, it's what made them into what you and I both would consider to be good people. Many people derive their views about the inherent worth of all lives from their particular faith tradition. We don't need to separate parts of these people's identity in order to commend them for doing what so many others in the world would not.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
uansari1
10:12 AM on 11/05/2010
No disrespect meant, but I'm surprised at the ignorance of the author. First, numerous Muslim nations assisted Jews in escaping from European countries by giving them passports and visas to flee to Muslim countries via their embassies in Europe...this includes **gasp** Iran!

As for the universality of saving lives in Islam, the Qur'an clearly says that saving the life of even one innocent person is like saving all of humanity. A Muslim is obligated even to protect his enemy during a time of war or otherwise if that person stops fighting and asks for safe-passage.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Catch 22
Plan for Mid to Long Term.
10:05 AM on 11/05/2010
I am always fascinated by stories of this kind, where the human spirit trumps the herd mentality and personal safety. This is actually my concept of what America was all about. We seem to be fast losing that. The Muslims, Orthodox and Catholics who risked their lives to protect Jews, The Hutus and Tutsis who hid each other, and even here at home, the Whites who lost their lives, working to Register Blacks in the Deep South. They must all be commended. We are in a place now where we are pressured to do what is morally wrong, and quite frankly, some Religions are not helpful in this respect.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Regenleif Ali
We promote peace.
10:27 PM on 11/03/2010
its a shame tht people only see differences tht divde us...if they were to look with more love then they would realize wht we have in common and half the conflicts in this world would disappear...
Carroll27
Nature's own nice conservative
08:52 PM on 11/03/2010
Last week, some muslims killed over 40 Catholics who were worshipping in a church in Iraq. Right after that, mail bombs started coming out of Yemen. And speaking of Yemen, in September, a Yemeni chess team refused to play a world wide tournament because their first opponents were from Israel.

Someone got the script. Muslims were looking bad. It was time to dig into the archives and show muslims in a positive light.

I'm for mercy, and I'm very very glad these muslims acted so righteously during the Holocaust. But doesn't it strike you as odd that muslims doing good makes the news? I mean, THAT's the news story here. Muslims did good things for jews. Wow.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jim Elkins
09:55 PM on 11/03/2010
They had to go back 70 years to get the story...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bintalshamsa
Disability rights activist, multi-ethnic, polyglot
09:02 PM on 11/08/2010
Do you really need us to try to figure out the stats behind how many Christians killed people last week? And you really don't want to discuss bombs. How many of those daisy-cutters that have shredded innocent children throughout Afghanistan and Iraq were dropped by our military which is supposedly chock-full of Christians? The chess tournament comment is just ridiculous when you compare that to the apartheid system in Israel that doesn't even allow Israeli Muslims to go to school with Jewish children and refuses to issue marriage licenses to couples where one person is a Muslim and the other a Jew. I could go on and on.

With all of the ignorant people like you in the world, it doesn't strike me as odd that a story about Muslims behaving righteously made the news. Now, perhaps if you picked up a book or two and educated yourself, you'd realize that what you see as a lone incident of mercy is actually the norm throughout the world. Now please take your big Conspiracy Theory about scripts and go find Mel Gibson.
07:31 PM on 11/03/2010
I am extremely glad to see that somehow one religion and the other are finding ways to get along. I find it extremely important to show this and bring it out into the public eye. For the most part many only see the negative side to Islam. Mostly because all that is publicized is that of the horrors committed by extremists. There are more moderate Muslims that the extremists, but they don't come to speak out most of the time. People also fail to see that these extremists even attack and kill other Muslims for being moderate or not sharing their beliefs. Don't think that the terror is just against the "West", because there are always bombings, be-headings and dismemberments against other Muslims.

Alhamdullilah, that these were good and ideal Muslims that chose to save lives than end them.
Carroll27
Nature's own nice conservative
08:52 PM on 11/03/2010
Muslims killing muslims. What does it say about Islam? I mean, this isn't 1600.
06:42 PM on 11/03/2010
Great story, it should be told throughout the Middle East and especially in the Palestinian territories, Iran, Lybia, and Egypt.
07:25 PM on 11/03/2010
I think you failed to see the whole picture. You only indicated Islamic countries. As far as I know, Iran has a very large Jewish community living there. As far as I know, the problem between those Muslims are the Zionists and I know that the problem with the the world and those Muslims is terrorism. But you are only looking at those. They are not the majority and many do not practice what is taught. You should maybe look a little deeper into it the background first. I take neither side.

---Former Catholic, now Muslim convert

themuslimbutterfly.blogspot.com