More

'Free Shane And Josh': New Documentary On Detained Hikers Offers More Evidence Of Their Innocence (VIDEO)

First Posted: 11/04/10 12:42 PM ET Updated: 05/25/11 07:10 PM ET

Hikers Detained

Scroll down to watch the documentary

NEW YORK -- A new documentary about the three American hikers detained by Iran provides new evidence that they were simply tourists and not spies and offers new insights into their lives in prison.

"Free Shane and Josh", produced and directed by Jeff Kaufman, tells the story of Shane Bauer, Sarah Shourd and Josh Fattal, three idealistic Americans who traveled to Kurdistan, the mountainous region of Iraq, in the summer of 2009 to hike and see the sights when they were detained and imprisoned by Iranian soldiers patrolling the border. Iranian authorities accuse them of illegally crossing the border and spying. Shourd was freed on bail in September after nearly 14 months in a Tehran prison but her fiancé, Bauer, and Fattal remain in prison -- their trial was expected to begin on Saturday but it has been postponed.

The trio were visiting Damascus, Syria, when a friend recommended the scenic Kurdistan region as a tourist destination. They traveled there and the film includes footage of the scenic sights they visited, including the Ahmed Awa resort and a waterfall from which they hiked on the trail where they were detained.

Shourd relates the story of their detention, saying that there was no fence or flag or indication of a border of any kind. "We looked up and saw a soldier about 300 meters away from us and holding a big rifle and motioning with his arm for us to go further down the trail and we thought, 'OK, it's just an Iraqi soldier.'

After going down the trail as per the soldier's directions, they were stopped by another Iranian solider. "He said Iran and pointed to the ground where we were standing and he pointed to the trail that we had been on and he said Iraq. So, according to that soldier, we did not enter Iran until he gestured for us to come off the trail into Iran... we wanted to turn around and we tried but he would not let us."

Four days later, they ended up in Tehran, where "even up to the last minute before we came to the doors of Evin prison, they told us we were going to an airport and they were going to put us on a plane and send us back home." Instead, "they blindfolded us and tore us apart and threw us into different cells... that first night I cried and screamed all night long, they had me write pages and pages of what I was doing in Damascus, they would look at it and tear it up... I think it was clear to the people questioning us form the very beginning that we weren't spies."

Another time, Shourd relates, the trio were told that they were being freed and taken to the airport, only to be blindfolded and taken to cells in another part of the prison.

Shourd, who would sometimes pass the time in prison by imagining her fantasy wedding, relates the touching story of how longtime boyfriend Bauer proposed to her in jail. "We were sitting on this blanket, holding hands with our arms around each other and Shane just looked really serious and he said, "Will you marry me?" I was so stunned, and so he said, "Is that a yes? And I said, 'Yes, yes!" So really from that day on, our marriage became a symbol of our future together, and Josh was very much a part of that because Josh will be our best man..."

The documentary, which will be released this week, profiles the trio's humanitarian concerns -- Bauer worked on a documentary about the crisis in Darfur, Shourd worked with indigenous women in the Chiapas region of Mexico and Fattal was the leader of a sustainable living community in Oregon.

WATCH: An excerpt of the film:




WATCH the whole film:


FREE SHANE AND JOSH from Alita Holly on Vimeo.



Bauer and Fattal's mothers, who visited their sons last spring and will soon decide whether they will go back to Tehran, keep waiting for any word on their sons' fates but they've long lost patience.

"It's really terrible," Laura Fattal tells The Huffington Post. "We don't know any more information than the general public."

Fattal, who has sent countless books to her son, says that she emails letters every day to him, which are transmitted through the State Department to the Swiss foreign ministry and eventually delivered to the prison.

"I am an optimistic person, perpetually hopeful that this will end, end in a good way," says Fattal. "I talked about a protracted detention in August 2009 -- and we're on the 16th month."

Bauer's mother, Cindy Hickey, says her patience is being tested. "The unfairness of this and the inhumanity is starting to take its toll," she says, explaining that she closed the doors to her longtime business, her daughters are both suffering physically and emotionally and Shane's father is working around the clock to keep things up financially.

She hopes that the documentary will have an impact -- "that people all over the world, including Iran, will look at this, it really explains what we've gone through." Hickey, an avid hiker, says that she would have joined the trio if she had been there at the time.

Around this time of year, with Thanksgiving and the holidays approaching, she often thinks of Shane. "I was walking through my property thinking, this is the second fall and my son is not home... People ask me, 'What are you doing for Thanksgiving?' I'm hoping to have my son home around my table with my family. I've got wild cranberries in my freezer waiting for the special event."

Here are links to:

Free The Hikers Website

Free The Hikers Facebook page

Free the Hikers blog

FOLLOW HUFFPOST WORLD

Scroll down to watch the documentary NEW YORK -- A new documentary about the three American hikers detained by Iran provides new evidence that they were simply tourists and not spies and offers new i...
Scroll down to watch the documentary NEW YORK -- A new documentary about the three American hikers detained by Iran provides new evidence that they were simply tourists and not spies and offers new i...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 780
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (12 total)
04:23 PM on 12/08/2010
Want to see the way the spin works? check out this clowns latest act of verbal running off at the mouth and see the great posts left for her to read on her CNN interview, truth bites at least they do not remove posts as you do here on Huff post .99 % smell a rat.
04:01 AM on 12/07/2010
See my comments have been removed, Nice work in keeping the story slanted in they way you want it to show.So much for opionion to differ from the media spin here
JacksonJones
Absit iniuria verbis!
04:32 PM on 11/12/2010
One wonders at the silence of the international community with respect to the kidnapping of these people by Iran. This is not some band of pirates plying the Somalian waters for ransom booty, this is a sovereign UN member acting this way.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
05:47 PM on 11/10/2010
two points:

1) on its own, the assessment is sloppy, presumptive and contradictory: "The lack of coordination on the part of these hikers, particularly after being forewarned, indicates an intent to agitate and create publicity regarding international policies on Iran."

2) no objective reporting substantiates any of the opinions raised in the assessment. it is a completely subjective, political statement.

re-read the document and explain to me how you can possibly view the "assessment" as credible and objective: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/world/iraq-war-logs.html#report/D2430687-FCE7-C5BB-ED19F523FE225046
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
General Armchair
What, me worry?
10:22 AM on 11/09/2010
I am a bit concerned that the WikiLeaks document on this matter includes the following quote:

"The lack of co-ordination on the part of these hikers, particularly after being forewarned, indicates an intent to agitate and create publicity regarding international policies on Iran."

Sarah Shourd claims to have no idea why this statement is in the WikiLeaks-released US military document ( http://www.nytimes.com/2010/11/01/world/middleeast/01shourd.html?_r=1 ), and the film (produced before the WikiLeaks document dump) makes no mention of any warning, and in fact goes to some lengths to establish that the hikers did NOT have any foreknowledge of potential danger.

So this is a discrepancy. It would be great if we could clear this up.
01:40 PM on 11/08/2010
thanks, No War With Iran. i had previous comments in mind too when deciding it's finally time to jump into the agitation of online debate about this. the outrageous indifference and i'll say it again and underscore it - racism against Muslim people - projected onto the trouble my friends have found themselves in, has permeated online discussions. it has been this way from the beginning.

intellectual, compassionate debate here seems practically impossible here. so many great, supportive comments and then so many sickening commando responses alongside the "serves them right" crowd. i can't believe the immaturity of the latter two. is this a sampling of politicization and polarization in the U.S.?

ill will and indifference are the same thing in the current, collective state of violent affairs our country is deeply entrenched in. i believe both ill intention and indifference are the result of racist fantasies of "what might happen to one when traveling inside a Muslim country or any country of color." so we hear thinly veiled, dehumanizing remarks such as the Middle East is a "lion's den" or "a noose". Iran IS North Korea IS hell on earth... these horrific fantasies that the mainstream dishes out for consumption around the clock which show a sliver of the population and lived experience in the Middle East.

public outreach has proven most people to be supportive of Shane, Josh and Sarah. LET'S FREE ALL THREE! thanks woody, huffpost and wereeverywhere, friends everywhere for having their backs.
01:06 AM on 11/07/2010
These kids think they are so smart and worldly, yet they didn't think to buy a GPS? Yes, they work in Iraq.
Any experienced hiker would tell you to invest in one, even if you go to some place as benign as Yellowstone.
They knew they were walking a fine line and were probably laughing about it the whole time. Then reality hit them like a ton of bricks and the American government now has something else to worry about.
No compassion. If you want to see Iraq or North Korea, join the service. But these kids probably think they are too good for that.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
valhalladad
Justice went out of style too soon
10:03 PM on 11/06/2010
Here's a spy story for you. If only America were a little more forthright and cautious.

http://redactednews.blogspot.com/2010/11/when-is-leak-hacking-hacking-leak-and.html
05:38 PM on 11/05/2010
To pick a place like Iraq I do think you need your head examined. Why not Jordan?Right next door to Syria where you were. World famous climbing and hiking.. You pushed the envelope and lost.
03:25 PM on 11/05/2010
i cannot explain how hurtful so many of these comments are to me, as a friend and fellow solidarity activist of Shane and Sarah's. hurtful not only because so many people are kneejerk reactionists when it comes to any news regarding Iran or any other Muslim country and not just because i think that the place where your provocations of violence against my friends is coming from is a place of deep-seated hatred and racism. but even more hurtful that, after seeing such intimate, honest and intentional portraits of my friends and their families, you could still wish harm to them. how is that possible? could it be that you have feel no compassion or relation to Sarah, Shane and Josh because you can not imagine yourself taking any risk whatsoever - intellectually or in the real world - to challenge the unforgiving, violent perceptions ingrained in your heads by a war-driven media, society and economy. can you even make an effort to think beyond the constraints of sabotage and war and towards reconciliation? because it is not only the fate of our friends that depend on this paradigm shift but also the possibility of world peace that hangs in the balance. you decide.
10:50 PM on 11/05/2010
Nicely put. And don't let the various clowns who substitute their ideology for logic get you down. I hope your friends are out soon.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
mytwocents02
my micro-bio does not meet guidelines
02:23 PM on 11/06/2010
x2
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wwoody
Retired fishing for the truth.
08:46 AM on 11/06/2010
Fan.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
mytwocents02
my micro-bio does not meet guidelines
01:46 AM on 11/05/2010
I'm still trying to understand the vitriol being spewed at the three Americans who found themselves in the wrong place at the wrong time, but criticisms were subdued for the Americans who found themselves in North Korean prisons and required two of our former Presidents to rescue them. Why the disparity?

Israel is almost always at war with one group or another, but Americans visiting the country are not being accused of stupidity or being spies. Safaris are wildly popular even though some African countries are considered dangerous. Even luxurious and relatively safe cruise ships are not impervious to pirate attacks. Heck, even getting on a plane today is scary, just ask Juan Williams.

There are always risks involved in travels to foreign countries, but one should not let fear or ignorance keep one at home. Granted, one can choose the well-beaten path, but please refrain from criticizing the adventurous ones who choose the road less traveled.
05:42 PM on 11/05/2010
A war zone on the border of Ira and Iran??? Adventure is one thing ..Stupidity is something else.
This was just plain DUMB!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Richard Pearce
Atheistic-agnostic Canadian polymath
02:03 PM on 11/06/2010
Read the vitriol that was spewed about the Iranian who was kidnapped to the US, and denounce that. Then your complaint might seem more than a case of 'us good, them bad' style 'debating'.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
mytwocents02
my micro-bio does not meet guidelines
02:14 PM on 11/06/2010
I was talking about people being judgmental of others and I was pleading for tolerance. Who's complaining and judging?
photo
karim banned
A fool's mind is at the mercy of his tongue and a
08:51 PM on 11/04/2010
Tit for tat.

Iran has already freed one American.

It is US turn to do the same.

http://edi­tion.press­tv.ir/deta­il/149384.­html
photo
karim banned
A fool's mind is at the mercy of his tongue and a
08:54 PM on 11/04/2010
Something wrong with previous link.

http://edition.presstv.ir/detail/149384.html
10:13 PM on 11/04/2010
The US government DID release Amiri, before the release of Sarah Shourd, and we did not charge a ransom of $500,000.
If governments respond strictly tit for tat, will that encourage Iran to go out and kidnap OTHER American tourists or reporters or teachers wherever they find them in the world? These people are absolutely innocent of any wrongdoing or any crime (I know two of them personally).
The US should indeed open up an investigation, regardless of this case, into whether the charges are truly warranted against the Iranians in American prisons, and American citizens should protest cases in which they are held for political reasons only, as the two hikers are. However, reciprocal kidnapping hardly is the correct political policy, it definitely weakens Iran's case to round up Americans wherever they can find them and hold them for ransom.
photo
karim banned
A fool's mind is at the mercy of his tongue and a
02:04 AM on 11/05/2010
If I accept your argument, it means US should accept that Amiri came here against his will and was kidnapped.

But US does not accept that narrative.

US says that Amiri was in US for higher eduction studies and was free from begining to leave US.

So you accept that US goverment was guilty of kidnaping an innocent Iranian citizen and bring him to US.

I am almost sure if US goverment is ready to accept this fact and put it in writing them the "tit for tac" argument can continue by Iran releasing another American.

Also US has 11 Iranian citizens in its jail, releasing one American should cause several Iranians to be released.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Odojas
07:26 PM on 11/04/2010
My friend is is friends with these people in Berkley. I told him that I thought it was naive of them to hike near the Iran border in Iraq in today's political climate. He defended them saying they were just hiking and were not in the wrong. I agree they aren't in the wrong. But, Not only would I not got to Iraq, I would not go anywhere near the border of Iran. No matter how beautiful the nature is. It a wisdom check. And they failed it.

That being said, these people do not deserve this. I hope they all get out and are over this nightmare.
photo
Amryxx
politeness rules, but with sharpened edges
07:26 PM on 11/04/2010
"It a wisdom check"
Maybe they're using it as a dump stat.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Odojas
07:34 PM on 11/04/2010
A stat that gets sacrificed for gain in other areas. Used in role playing games generically.
Strippers - what happens when god uses int as his dump stat.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Odojas
07:36 PM on 11/04/2010
Heh. You gamers.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:07 PM on 11/04/2010
I hope you don't visit your friends in Berkley, because I think it's very naive to hike near Oakland in today's political climate. Do you have any idea how many people get robbed, raped, and bashed around there? I agree you aren't in the wrong to travel to this region. I would not go anywhere near San Francisco. No matter how great the marijuana is. It's just common sense if you look at the statistics.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
persianadvocate
07:07 PM on 11/04/2010
The wikileaks reveals that the Iranians actually caught a net positive value asset. These hikers should be ashamed of putting the US in this position where we now have to bargain with the Mullahs. ESPECIALLY after the US Army is shown in the files as telling these hikers to get out of the area and NOTED they were likely trying to start trouble between the US and Iran. These are leaked files from our military telling us this!

The Iranian people would also like to heartily thank them for giving this glorious public relations moment for the regime that is cruelly oppressing them.

Truly stupid, stupid people, who will not be harmed in any way, but will continue to try to worsen the relations between the Iran and the US. Do these people want our troops to have to go to harms way to get them after they did something so stupid? The rescuers don't have families that don't want them going into Iran after you? No one ever thinks of these things.