More

Hezbollah Resigns: Lebanese Government Collapses As Political Party Pulls Out

ELIZABETH A. KENNEDY and BASSEM MROUE   01/12/11 03:50 PM ET   AP

Hezbollah Resigns

BEIRUT — Lebanon's government collapsed Wednesday after Hezbollah and its allies resigned from the Cabinet in a dispute with Western-backed factions over upcoming indictments in the 2005 assassination of former Prime Minister Rafik Hariri.

A U.N.-backed tribunal investigating the truck bombing that killed Hariri and 22 others is widely expected to name members of the Shiite militant group, which many fear could re-ignite sectarian violence that has erupted repeatedly in the tiny nation.

Hezbollah's walkout ushers in the country's worst political crisis since 2008 in one of the most volatile corners of the Middle East.

Lebanon's 14-month-old government was an uneasy coalition linking bitter rivals: a Western-backed bloc led by Hariri's son Saad and Hezbollah, which is supported by Syria and Iran and maintains an arsenal that far outweighs that of the national army.

Disputes over the tribunal have paralyzed the government for months, with Hezbollah denouncing the court as a conspiracy by the U.S. and Israel and urging the prime minister to reject any of its findings. But Hariri has refused to break cooperation with the Netherlands-based tribunal.

Now, the chasm between the two sides is deepening with Hezbollah accusing Hariri's bloc of bowing to the West. Hezbollah's ministers timed their resignations to coincide with Hariri's meeting with President Barack Obama in Washington, forcing him to meet the American president as a caretaker prime minister.

Western governments have worked to strengthen the central government since Israel and Hezbollah fought a devastating 34-day war in 2006, but they also have expressed concern about the balance of power with the heavily armed militant group.

The U.S. classifies Hezbollah as a terrorist organization.

A White House statement said Obama commended Hariri for his "steadfast leadership and efforts to reach peace, stability and consensus in Lebanon under difficult circumstances."

U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton said Hezbollah's actions are "a transparent effort ... to subvert justice and to undermine Lebanon's sovereignty and independence."

"No country should be forced to choose between justice and stability," Clinton said while traveling in Doha, Qatar. "The Lebanese people deserve both."

Hariri's office had no immediate comment on the walkout that brought down his government, but they said he was heading to France to meet French President Sarkozy before heading back to Beirut. France, Lebanon's former colonial power, is a major player in Lebanese politics.

The immediate trigger for the Hezbollah withdrawal was the failure of talks between Syria and Saudi Arabia, a Hariri ally, to try to find a compromise over the tribunal.

There had been few details about the direction of the Syrian-Saudi initiative, but the talks were lauded as a potential Arab breakthrough, rather than a solution offered by Western powers.

"This Cabinet has become a burden on the Lebanese, unable to do its work," Jibran Bassil, who is resigning his post as energy minister, said at a news conference, flanked by the other Hezbollah-allied ministers who are stepping down. "We are giving a chance for another government to take over."

Bassil said the ministers decided to resign after Hariri "succumbed to foreign and American pressures" and turned his back on the Syrian-Saudi efforts.

Calls to the tribunal seeking comment Wednesday were not immediately returned.

U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon "is monitoring closely developments in Lebanon, where the situation is fast evolving," U.N. spokesman Martin Nesirky said.

Hariri formed the current national unity government in November 2009 after his bloc narrowly defeated the Hezbollah-led opposition in elections. But it has struggled to function, and in the past two months it has met only for a few minutes because of the dispute over the tribunal.

Violence has been a major concern as tensions rise in Lebanon, where Shiites, Sunnis and Christians each make up about a third of the country's 4 million people. In 2008, sectarian clashes killed 81 people and nearly plunged Lebanon into another civil war.

Rami Khouri, director of the Issam Fares Institute of Public Policy and International Affairs at the American University of Beirut, said he does not expect any immediate widescale violence, particularly after the destruction seen in 2008.

"I would think that the fears of sectarian violence are less now than they might have been a few years ago ... People are working overtime to avoid violence," he said.

Rafik Hariri's assassination in a massive truck bombings both stunned and polarized Lebanese. He was Lebanon's most prominent politician in the years after Lebanon's 1975-1990 civil war – a Sunni who was a hero to his own community and backed by many Christians who sympathized with his efforts in the last few months of his life to reduce Syrian influence in the country.

A string of assassinations of anti-Syrian politicians and public figures followed, which U.N. investigators have said may have been connected to the Hariri killing.

The tribunal has not said who it will indict, but Hezbollah leader Sheik Hassan Nasrallah has said he has information that members of his group will be named.

Now that the government has fallen, President Michel Suleiman will likely hold a meeting with the parliament speaker marking the beginning of consultations with lawmakers to name a prime minister-designate.

It is possible that Saad Hariri will get the largest numbers of backers given that he heads the largest bloc in parliament, but he could not build a coalition again without appealing to Hezbollah and its allies.

"Politics is a game of negotiations," Khouri said. "Whoever gets the best deal wins."

___

Associated Press writers Zeina Karam in Beirut, Matthew Lee in Doha, Qatar, and Robert Burns in Washington contributed to this report.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST WORLD

BEIRUT — Lebanon's government collapsed Wednesday after Hezbollah and its allies resigned from the Cabinet in a dispute with Western-backed factions over upcoming indictments in the 2005 assassi...
BEIRUT — Lebanon's government collapsed Wednesday after Hezbollah and its allies resigned from the Cabinet in a dispute with Western-backed factions over upcoming indictments in the 2005 assassi...
Filed by Cara Parks  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 1,757
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (15 total)
photo
skialethia
αω vs military might
09:09 AM on 01/14/2011
While other leaders have been assassinated, example Pakistan, no one petitioned the U.N. to set up a Tribunal to investigate who was responsible. You have to ask yourselves who stands to gain from the division that this was create in Lebanon? All you have to do is research who's funding this Tribunal and who’s pushing behind the scenes and even providing false intelligence to this Tribunal to get the "desired" results. My answer: the U.S. and Israel.

A couple of weeks ago someone leaked a fake story to a Christian Lebanese paper which alleged that the "disappeared" Iranian general, Asgari, who the U.S. and Israel claim "defected", miraculously re-appeared before the Tribunal to testify against Hezbollah. Just one problem, the general is nowhere to be seen. It was alleged his family defected with him in 2006, but no such luck. His wife, ex-wife and kids are all in Iran demanding Turkey investigate his disappearance since they believe he was kidnapped in Turkey. So how come when Iran asked the U.N. to investigate his disappearance last week, no one produced a video proving he's alive and in fact appeared before the investigative committee? Probably, because the story was fake, just like a bunch of other fake witnesses long since discredited. There are strong suspicions that Asgari was kidnapped, interrogated under torture and killed perhaps in Israel (see "Prisoner X"), and this Tribunal is a means of resurrecting animosity and inciting war so that Israel can invade Lebanon AGAIN.
photo
skialethia
αω vs military might
09:20 AM on 01/14/2011
corr. You have to ask yourselves who stands to gain from the division that this WILL create in Lebanon?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ergon
Man From Atlan
10:42 AM on 01/14/2011
Correction: The division was created when the Hariri assassination was blamed on Syria (even though car bombs are a Mossad/Falangist m.o.)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StCuthbert
Anytime the mods are ready...
10:09 AM on 01/14/2011
Whoa, so now you care about UN bias? I thought justice was your primary concern.
photo
karim banned
A fool's mind is at the mercy of his tongue and a
04:20 PM on 01/14/2011
That's the point no Justice with a bias.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Shingo
09:21 PM on 01/14/2011
How is justice cerved when 11 countries refuse to provide evidence or testimony to the tribunal? Among those 11 states that are refusing are Germany (the head of STL happens to be German), Israel, the US, the UAE and the Czech Republic.
photo
SeptimusDSX
Always question the obvious.
08:36 AM on 01/14/2011
Syria, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Iraq, US...there seem to be far too many international players for things to settle down. What do the people of Lebanon want?
01:37 PM on 01/14/2011
Most of the smart ones emigrated long ago...
photo
realitycitizen
Proud American, Proud Gentile
01:17 AM on 01/14/2011
Hezbollah is the the #1 military and #1 political power in Lebanon. They never needed to cut a deal with the weak opposition.

And yet Hezbollah showed up to the table in good faith, allowed the opposition to share power in the government, and refused to exercise their military power.

And how does the opposition repay them? By opening up a witchhunt and trying to have all of Hezbollah tried in absentia and arrested for the assassination of Hariri in a kangaroo court.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Shingo
01:43 AM on 01/14/2011
"And yet Hezbollah showed up to the table in good faith, allowed the opposition to share power in the government­, and refused to exercise their military power. "

That's a little extreme. The March 8 block didn't win the election.

The collapse of the Hariri government comes as no surprise. World leaders, especially Israel's, have been predicting it for quite some time.
photo
realitycitizen
Proud American, Proud Gentile
02:11 AM on 01/14/2011
The March 14th coalition has no real legitimacy in Lebanon.

Hezbollah is to the March 8th coalition what the “National Army” is to the March 14th coalition.

And during Israel's attack on Lebanon in 2006 the National Army and its political benefactors chose to back regime change from abroad by Israel. They lost, leaving Hezbollah to fill the vacuum as Lebanon's military and establishment.

To fit this into the American context, this is why liberals will never win on economic and military issues. The right wingers in the US control the real state, just like Hezbollah controls the real state in Lebanon.

The March 14th coalition is simply better at politics than the March 8th coalition. March 14th coalition receives the best political engineering the west has to offer. They currently have a small majority in the congress. Yet the March 8th coalition is comfortable resigning from the government and walking away.

Technically the opposition just won big. But in reality they are panicking.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hassanista
12:13 PM on 01/14/2011
Israel has been expecting the collapse of their government because they've been doing their best to make it happen.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Json
Cynical dreamer, sarcastic idealist...
09:21 AM on 01/15/2011
So you don't even consider it possible that hezbollah was responsible?
12:47 PM on 02/16/2011
Why would hezbollah do su ch a stupid thing? Whoever did it did it to start trouble.
photo
realitycitizen
Proud American, Proud Gentile
01:05 AM on 01/14/2011
Looks like Hezbollah is forming a coalition government with the Christians, and cutting out the US/Israel backed Sunni extremists.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hassanista
12:13 PM on 01/14/2011
I hope so.
10:06 PM on 01/13/2011
I read the same crap in all western media, here is a message to all so-called journalists covering this: 11 ministers quit the government in Lebanon. Just two of them were from Hezbollah! 2!!!

To now write that "Hezbollah and their political allies" brought the government down is factually correct, but an outrageously inaccurate representation of the actual events. Especially for the American reader it would be interesting to hear that FPM, the largest Christian (!!!) party in the Lebanese parliament and the second largest party overall (both according to the seats won in the last election) is

a) one of the allies of Hezbollah

and

b) has fully supported the course that lead to this.

And if you wonder why some non-Islamists might do this, I got news for you that might for some shatter your view of the world: The STL has actually done a lot to warrant mistrust in it.
photo
karim banned
A fool's mind is at the mercy of his tongue and a
11:07 PM on 01/13/2011
F&F
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bill Sampson
Truth is the most valuable thing we have!
02:04 AM on 01/15/2011
F&F as well
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mr MOTO
Three Strikes And You're Not Out!
08:47 PM on 01/13/2011
"tensions between Lebanese Sunnis, which include the Hariri clan, and the Shiites who compose Hezbollah’s base are so high that Lebanon’s current prime minister — Rafiq Hariri’s son, Saad — has publicly considered asking the UN to cancel the tribunal for the good of the country. His choice, in other words, is either to risk a new civil war with Iran’s most lethal proxy army or to keep the peace by exonerating his own father’s murderers. It’s Greek tragedy in an Arab setting."

Repost of Allahpundit
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DavidET
Earth has no sides
08:29 PM on 01/13/2011
A terrorist organization and governing do not mix. It goes against their goals.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Shingo
09:59 PM on 01/13/2011
"A terrorist organizati­on and governing do not mix. It goes against their goals. "

Good point. We should stop doing it.
10:55 PM on 01/13/2011
Good thing that Hezbollah is not a terrorist organisation then.
photo
GraphicMatt
Somebody make me a sandwich!
01:26 PM on 01/14/2011
When did they cease being a terrorist organization?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
streetmagik
You can't fight in here this is the war room!!
08:17 PM on 01/13/2011
It is bizarre to watch Nasrallah try to rewrite history at the point of a sword. He offers no rebuttal evidence beyond trying to deflect the blame toward Israel with unsubstantiated and shrill accusations.

He is not even really trying to prove Hezbullah's innocence, it is almost as if he wants them declared innocent by decree.

They are basically saying to Hariri, yes there is all this evidence that we killed your father, but if you do not declare that we are an innocent peace loving people then we will plunge the country into chaos.

They are literally trying to force Hariri to ignore evidence as to his own father's murder - if there is no evidence linking them to the assassination (and a dozen more which followed it) then why is he willing to topple the country to avoid trial?

Me thinks he doth protest way way too much.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Shingo
09:58 PM on 01/13/2011
"He offers no rebuttal evidence beyond.."

Actually he did. He produced video footage from an Israel drone that was tracking Hariri's motorcade when it was hit. Even Saad Hariri said that Israel should be investigated for it's involvement.

"He is not even really trying to prove Hezbullah'­s innocence..."

Guilty until proven innocent?

"They are basically saying to Hariri, yes there is all this evidence that we killed your father "

On the contrary. The evidence is being covered up.

After 4 years of insisting that it had solid evidence that Syria did it, the STL last year dropped all pending accusations against Syria and declared that the 1o witnesses for the prosecution on whose testimony Syria was being investigated were false witnesses and put Hizbullah in its sights. This happened at just about the time Syria was taken out of the doghouse by the US after they made some deal or other on Iraq and the US announced that it would be sending an ambassador to Syria. The STL is refusing to put the 10 false witnesses on trial or to provide any information relative to their false testimonies. These 10 witnesses are currently under the protection of the court.

11 countries have refused to collaborate with the STL or provide any information to the Hariri investigation.

These countries includes the US, the UAE, Israel, Germany (who ironically is running the STL) and the Czechs.

Yet, everyone is asking why Hezbollah is not participating.
04:10 PM on 01/13/2011
People commenting on this post keep on pretending that this has nothing to do with Israel.
As a matter of fact, it's mostly about Israel, essentially an incompetent, bungled attempt to discredit Hezbollah on Israel's behalf which has backfired big time:


"In case no one has noticed, the Obama administration just gifted Lebanon to Iran. Washington earlier presented Iraq, Afghanistan, the Gulf, and Pakistan. Could it be more clear that Iran’s strategic trump card is America’s subservience to Israel? For Iran, Israel’s strangle hold on the US government is the gift that keeps on giving.”

Lebanese Human Rights Ambassador Ali Khalil

http://www.veteranstoday.com/2011/01/13/franklin-lamb-why-hezbollah-walked/
photo
blutopie
maui ono
04:43 PM on 01/13/2011
"Could it be more clear that Iran’s strategic trump card is America’s subservien­ce to Israel?"

....great line

A big anti-Apartheid crow is it's winging it's way home to Israel to roost now - and there's nothing the US can do about it. It's as if the Israeli Lobby used it's useful patsy for so long they just eventually gave Israel enough rope to really do itself in
05:03 PM on 01/13/2011
Oh, especially now. I have mixed feelings about this- as an American, I'm really sorry that my government's actions have caused so much chaos and loss of life, and, due in part to its unconditional support of Israel, becoming more and more an international pariah.
As the quote (spuriously attributed to Alex De Toqueville) says: "America is great, because America is good. If America ceases to be good, America will cease to be great."
A true patriot loves his or her country, but works for its betterment, and this includes protesting unjust and unwise policies, foreign and domestic.
On the other hand, perhaps this will signal to Israel that it can no longer control events in the Middle East using its superpower patron as a combination bodyguard and cash cow.
Perhaps the more rational people in Tel Aviv will realize that there has to be a drastic change in Israeli policy.
Of course, this is not likely, but anything is possible.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Shingo
05:16 PM on 01/13/2011
Right on the money Mulegino,

The very existence of the tribunal is a ruse for the sake of Israel. More important people than Hariri were assassinated, and there was no such tribunal set up to investigate.
05:33 PM on 01/13/2011
You're absolutely right-look at Benazir Bhutto's assassination- now that was an internal matter for Pakistan.
When the Tribunal couldn't find enough fabricated evidence to push the blame on Syria, they decided to discredity Hezbollah and fracture Lebanese unity.
It's just an application of "Game Theory" but this time it has boomeranged big time.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:20 PM on 01/13/2011
You're right, Shingo, the secular government of Lebanon has no interest in its own survival.

Come on.

Hezbollah is a deranged neo-nazi menace. Their flag is a black mushroom cloud. Are you really going to support such a force?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:16 PM on 01/13/2011
Perfect example of why politics and religious beliefs being integrated together in government will continue to do nothing good but many will die in the fight to be "better" than the other guy.
photo
blutopie
maui ono
02:21 PM on 01/13/2011
It sounds like the UN Tribunal needs a few months to cool it's heels before the report is released.

I've got a great idea - since they're already all assembled lets give the UN Tribunal the '2008 Cast Lead Crime against Humanity' dossier and have them investigate that for a couple of weeks (they already have Goldstone and most of the facts already organized) - then maybe they could release that simultaneously with the Hariri report.

Nasrallah would probably read the Hariri indictments himself if he could read the 'Cast Lead' indictments for Olmert, Ashkenazi, and the rest of the Israeli war criminals at the same forum.

Everybody happy yet?
03:16 PM on 01/13/2011
Idiotic. The two things have no relation to each other.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Shingo
05:14 PM on 01/13/2011
Great suggestion. After all, isn't the refusal of Israel to participate in the Golstone Report proof of their guilt?
photo
blutopie
maui ono
02:07 PM on 01/13/2011
How come the Neocons and Israelis are spitting up their coffee over this? - oh, because they see the last vestiges of Israeli-puppeteering in Lebanon going down the drain. Anytime one of the Neocons expresses the slightest concern for Lebanon just know it for what it is - crocodile tears - the same kind they always shed over Iran.

What's good for Lebanon is to finally be capable of defending itself from Israel. That Israel doesn't like that is tough luck.

The UN investigation of the Hariri killing was at the behest of Israel and the US - NOT Lebanon. The first order of business for Hezbollah needs to get rid of the Lebanese Defense Minister Elias Murr who was exposed on Wikileaks colluding with the Americans (and Israelis) against it's own people.

Maybe Murr and Abbas can share a retirement villa in Tel Aviv - the days of Israeli-American puppeteering in Lebanon and Palestine are thankfully over
03:20 PM on 01/13/2011
How come the anti-Israelis keep bringing up unrelated events with regards to Israel. Because that's their standard response when Israel is discussed. Let's talk about the Armenian genocide and Turkey and Israel's culpability in that event. How about the Janjaweed Arab militia and it's attacks and rape in Darfur. How is Israel involved in those atrocities?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Shingo
05:17 PM on 01/13/2011
"How come the anti-Israe­lis keep bringing up unrelated events with regards to Israel. "

Because the events are not unrelated.
11:01 PM on 01/13/2011
The Hariri-government was more of "capitalist-puppeteering" though. Not so much Israel, but providing nice real estate opportunities...... which kinda is the same thing though, in a way.
12:50 PM on 01/13/2011
Mass Hezbollah Resignations Collapse Lebanese Government
Lebanon's national unity government has collapsed after Hezbollah ministers and their allies resigned over a UN-backed tribunal investigating the assassination of former prime minister Rafik Harir. http://www.newslook.com/videos/283311-mass-hezbollah-resignations-collapse-lebanese-government?autoplay=true
11:02 PM on 01/13/2011
"mass hezbollah" - bullcrap, they just had 2 ministers out of 20.
12:44 PM on 01/13/2011
It looks like nothing will ever be solved in that region.
photo
blutopie
maui ono
04:50 PM on 01/13/2011
That's what you always say when Israel is losing bigtime...

Israel used to dominate a prostrate Lebanon - now there's Hezbollah
Israel ethnic cleansed Palestine - now the world is calling her an Apartheid state
Israel has been trying to gin up an attack on Iran for years to cover her atrocity in Palestine - and now Mossad has called the Israeli government liars.
Iran is ascendant in the Middle East despite the now hollow Israeli threats - without firing a shot


Yep - I'd call that losing control over her dreams of Middle East hegonomy as well as her own destiny.

What is getting solved is 'Israel' -
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:22 PM on 01/13/2011
I don't even know what you're saying anymore....do you?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nader Ghazi Hobballah
12:14 PM on 01/13/2011
How anyone can take the Tribunal seriously is beyond me?

First everyone was set on Syria, then we find out Syria had nothing to do with the assasination, and then the blame began to shift to Hezbollah.

All the while, we had leaks coming out, well-respected middle east experts (such as Joshua Landis and Juan Cole) bash the Tribunal for being a political tool rather than an engine of investigation and justice, and yet still, people put faith in it.

Goes to show you that when it comes to ideology and politics, ignorance is bliss!
02:12 PM on 01/13/2011
What "people" apart from Israel and the US put faith in this tribunal?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nader Ghazi Hobballah
02:24 PM on 01/13/2011
The hardcore maronites, sunnis, and those who'd hope the tribunal would be a mechanism to curb hezbollah.

There's no 'justice' to be found in the tribunal. It's just another tool in the power play that's going on the middle east.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Shingo
05:21 PM on 01/13/2011
"How anyone can take the Tribunal seriously is beyond me?"

It's purely a blunt instrument, just like the sanctions against Iran. In either case, there is no concern for the facts, just political expediency.

"First everyone was set on Syria, then we find out Syria had nothing to do with the assasinati­on, and then the blame began to shift to Hezbollah."

Actually, it goes like this. First everyone was set on Syria, then Syria helsp the US out in Iraq, so the blame is shifted to Hezbollah