iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Effort To Grow Broccoli On East Coast Gets $5 Million Investment

STEVE SZKOTAK   02/21/11 03:15 AM ET   AP

RICHMOND, Va. — A cool microclimate in the shadow of the Blue Ridge Mountains has allowed farmer James Light to grow broccoli in quantity enough to supply a small chain of supermarkets.

Along most of the East Coast, however, the broccoli piled up in produce crispers has traveled thousands of miles from the West Coast in refrigerated trucks, typically at a cost of $6,000 a tractor load.

A team of researchers and agricultural agents hopes to take a bite out of the West Coast's $1 billion broccoli monopoly with new strains of the vegetable designed to withstand the East Coast's heat and humidity. They've received a $3.2 million grant from the U.S. Department of Agriculture and $1.7 million in matching private contributions to create a broccoli corridor running from northern Florida to Maine.

Their work has been driven by the rising cost of fuel to ship crates of broccoli from California fields to East Coast grocery coolers, the "eat local" movement and concerns about creating a sustainable, diversified food network.

U.S. consumption of broccoli has nearly doubled in the past 25 years, with Americans now eating 8.5 pounds annually of the vegetable celebrated for its high levels of vitamin C, fiber and antioxidants. Nearly all of that comes from California, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture.

"And they do an excellent job," said Thomas Bjorkman, one of the lead researchers and associate professor of horticulture at Cornell University. "But with the demand for locally grown and rising transportation costs, that really creates an opportunity for Eastern production."

East Coast proponents aim to capture a $100 million share of the broccoli market in five to 10 years.

"We're not attempting to put California out of business. We just want a piece of the action," said J. Powell Smith, a South Carolina extension agent who is lining up growers in his state. South Carolina farmers currently devote about 1,000 acres to broccoli.

But Smith said it won't be easy to compete with established, proven growers in California, as well as Arizona.

"In order to do so, we want to produce a product that is equal in quality if not superior," he said.

Broccoli suffers under constant hot temperatures and humidity common to the Southeast, developing "cateye" – a polka-dot pattern of discolored buds. Stores reject batches of broccoli that aren't properly shaped or a deeply colored green, and they want a reliable supply system.

"If you cannot deliver year-round, you're going to be a bit player," Bjorkman said. "It's really going to take improved varieties to stretch the season."

The West Coast dominates because it has the cooler nighttime temperatures and climates broccoli needs and vast areas of farmland to keep the vegetable growing all year.

"A long stretch of California, from the north-central valley to the desert has been able to produce broccoli year-round by shifting production north and south," said Mark H. Farnham, a broccoli breeder in South Carolina. "We believe it can be done up and down the East Coast."

Miguel Gomez, an assistant professor of applied economics and management at Cornell University, has been helping put together an East Coast network of farmers and retailers. Along with saving money, Gomez said creating second major production center for broccoli provides a hedge against threats such as drought, disease and bioterrorism.

"When you look at a food system that depends on a single area, that is extremely risky," he said. "It's good to diversify."

It also saves money. Shipping 10 tons of broccoli from Salinas, Calif., for instance, runs about $6,000 and adds 20 cents to 25 cents per pound to the vegetable's cost, Bjorkman said.

The Western Growers Association, which represents growers in California and Arizona, declined an Associated Press request to comment on the East Coast initiative.

While researchers expect the East Coast network to include areas where broccoli is already grown on a small scale, they also hope to grow new varieties in places broccoli hasn't been planted before. They've been recruiting farmers to test the new varieties at the same time they're trying to convince current growers to increase their acres and developing regional distribution hubs.

They're working with farmers like Light and retailers like Kevin Semones, manager of the Southwest Virginia Farmers Market in Hillsville, where Light sells his vegetables.

Light, whose family has farmed in the Blue Ridge Mountains for generations, devotes about half of his 100 acres of vegetables to broccoli in an area where its cousin, cabbage, was once king. When summer temperatures may reach triple digits in Richmond, it is 30 degrees cooler in the mountains along the Blue Ridge Parkway where his fields are located.

Light said it makes sense to devote more acres to a crop that now travels thousands of miles to reach dinner tables.

"It will be a week fresher when it goes into stores," he said.

Semones said he's added more cooling equipment to store locally grown broccoli as acreage increases.

"Most people tell me it's sweeter and crisper," he said of Virginia-grown broccoli. "It has to be fresher."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST FOOD

Filed by Colin Sterling  |  Report Corrections
 
 
  • Comments
  • 27
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Linda from Deerfield
Paying attention
06:59 PM on 02/24/2011
I wonder what New York's Torrey Family Farms have to say about that? The Torrey's apparently are indeed a family, but their truck farm is 10,000 acres -- absolutely monstrous, as truck farms go -- and they testified before Congress about the severe hardship they endure by not being able to hire illegal immigrants. A grant to help eastern vegetable growers is a bit ironic, considering. I don't know whether broccoli is one of the Torreys' crops, but let us hope that this new undertaking is not destined to create another giant family to dominate a region and cry about needing their underpaid and ill housed illegals. I love farmers, but the Torrey's test me.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:46 AM on 02/25/2011
Maureen Torrey provided an answer to your question in the Buffalo News. http://www.buffalonews.com/life/taste/article247049.ece
In essence, she is concerned that they will not be able to get the labor to harvest the crop.
Labor is indeed a big issue, but we are finding farms where the broccoli harvest time comes when there is a little slack from harvesting other crops. Profitability hinges on getting all these details right, so it's not a trivial undertaking to build the right producer networks.
The current H2A rules for legal immigrant labor gives you an idea of what broccoli harvesting jobs might pay. The hourly wage is about $10 per hour plus housing, plus airfare to and from the US, plus daily transportation to and from work. US workers have first dibs on these positions. In the rural communities where vegetables are grown, that pay compares favorably to entry-level jobs in retail and services. There is no question that it is very hard work, so you have to decide what the wage really means.
There is definitely an irony here. In today's political environment where job creation is such a high priority, the potential jobs created by this development is seen as a problem! But that dilemma is too big for this project team to tackle.
Thomas Bjorkman, project leader
Linda from Deerfield
Paying attention
09:57 AM on 02/25/2011
Thank you! My nephew, a Midwestern farmer's son, earned his college tuition working for a small, local vegetable grower, carrying on a long tradition of young people putting up buildings and bins, roofing, painting, seed corn detasseling, or whatever hot, dirty, good paying hard work they can find. These summer opportunities have become as rare as the ever thinning rural population. Subsidies for vegetables seem to be curiously absent, but it may well be that the subsidizing of commodity crops has made farms enormous, destroyed rural businesses, ruined farming profitability south of the border, and created immigrant desperation to fill those niches. The oft repeated laziness of Americans is untrue and unfair as a cause for the missing labor.

I could be accused of unrealistic romanticism, but we see that people in business for themselves will do most anything to succeed, and I see spotty evidence that the small, multi-crop farmer, working in cooperation with others, may still have a place, if only we could seek and find the right policies to defend rather than destroy. Think what it would do for dying rural towns. Whether it is inevitable that they succumb to the Torrey's and a few other big survivors ought not to be off limits for discussion, in my opinion. Best of luck in your endeavors.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sue Bryant
07:30 PM on 02/22/2011
When I lived in New York, I was amazed at the produce in a regular supermarket, the quality was terrible to what I was used to, living on the west coast.
06:52 PM on 02/22/2011
I lived on the East Coast for a bit and all I can say is Broccoli was never as fresh and crisp and tasty as it is in my home town in California. I bought Broccoli at every kind of store you can think of, huge supermarket chains, Whole Foods, small family run markets and all the rest.

Broccoli Rules California... I bet people on the East Coast will disagree, but I have been lucky enough to get my food very fresh and it most cases picked just the day before.
05:49 PM on 02/22/2011
Been growing broccoli commercially in Northern Maine for decades.....It freezes really well if you get it fresh and blanch it for a few minutes.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:59 AM on 02/25/2011
When you look at the most recent agriculture census, you see that about 3/4 of east coast broccoli production is the northernmost county. Broccoli likes it up there, and the growers in that county do a really good job with it. Hats off to you!
Easterners eat an amazing amount of broccoli (about 800,000,000 pounds a year and growing). To meet a little more of that massive demand, and to supply when the Maine growing season ends, it will have to be raised in many more eastern counties. They'll need new varieties that can handle the vagaries of their weather.
Thomas Bjorkman, project leader
05:07 PM on 02/22/2011
3.7 million dollars is ridiculous. I agree with Palitra Patania, we don't have to have broccoli year round. Look at tomatos, when you buy them out of season they have no taste. This is why we have a bazillion dollar deficit.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thepoliticalcat
Eradicate your microbioflora
03:57 PM on 02/22/2011
This is good. CA will adapt, there's no shortage of crops they can grow or industries they can create. But shipping "fresh" produce thousands of miles is simply idiotic. There are plenty of other fruits and vegetables that will grow in hotter climates as well, including "summer spinach" crops like pasilla, or basella, and NZ spinach, portulaca, etc., that are green, edible, hardy, not likely to bolt, heat-tolerant, and high in vitamins and nutrients.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mssreader
eat, read, sleep, read and be happy
03:28 PM on 02/22/2011
Good heavens! They could have hired the master east coast, Vermont, all year round organic gardener and author, Eliot Coleman, to advise on this at a fraction of the cost. He's my all year round organic gardening guru.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:25 AM on 02/25/2011
Mr. Coleman is a great inventor and educator, but we are going way beyond what he does. Most if the project is to develop broccoli that is hardy to eastern conditions. Current material is too risky for growers to make the investment. That is a really big undertaking, but we have breeders who have made some really cool advances to tease that hardiness out of the existing base, and the commitment of seed companies to actually sell new hardy varieties to eastern growers.

You'll be please to know that we also have five people that are playing a similar role to Mr. Coleman. They are great educators and are already trusted and respected part of the farming communities in the different production areas of the east.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mssreader
eat, read, sleep, read and be happy
12:26 PM on 02/25/2011
T Bjorkman, thanks for the info. I've great respect for Eliot Coleman but if you really are going beyond him then that's another matter.

fanned for replying in a polite manner.
02:21 PM on 02/22/2011
Food should be in the season. Everything else is not real food. So to modify food to match the environment does not do it. People need to get used that there are seasons. http://www.palitra-pitania.ru/aboutus_eng/?lang=en
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:51 AM on 02/25/2011
If you want to supply produce to a supermarket, they require a year round supply. That's one of the rules of the marketplace, probably because people who get their food in supermarkets want to have broccoli available all the time. It is not a phenomenon we can fight.
However, what this project can do is to have east coast markets carry broccoli that was raised in the closest place where it is in season. It's a different way to get at your goal. You get the environmental and quality benefits of working with nature to raise a crop in season, and you get the benefits of having a considerably more local product.
Thomas Bjorkman, project leader
photo
catcancook
Going Forward 2013-2016
02:18 PM on 02/22/2011
I'm in Va. Broccoli seems to be limp and expensive here but I only buy organic which does cost more. The organic broccoli probably comes from CA as well. I'm disappointed this Va. grower James Light will not be growing an organic product.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cabinetmaniac
Think for yourself. Question authority.
10:22 AM on 02/26/2011
I grow broccoli. If I pick it in the morning it is much crisper than if I pick it in the evening.

I put it in cold/ice water for a few minutes. It crisps right back up.

☮
photo
catcancook
Going Forward 2013-2016
11:24 AM on 02/27/2011
Should I be putting my grocery store broccoli in cold water when I bring it home or before I cook it? It is pretty limp for being so expensive. Thanks.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tomstedham
Troubled old white guy....
11:13 AM on 02/22/2011
I wonder if this succeeds, in a few years the USDA will give a grant to California to help its broccoli compete with the NC broccoli...

You know that will happen!
01:55 PM on 02/22/2011
Not to worry. We will ship California cooking oil to the East so that they can deep fry broccoli.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JTWallace
10:26 AM on 02/22/2011
Go Farmers! Just keep out the Unions and illegals.
photo
Talking The Wolf
I support the right to arm bears.
12:17 PM on 02/22/2011
And Monsanto.
01:53 PM on 02/22/2011
Yes, because the last things you want to do is pay fair wages for decent hours in safe working conditions.