More

Bangladesh Trying To Fire Muhammad Yunus, Nobel Laureate, From Microlender Grameen

Muhammad Yunus

FARID HOSSAIN   03/ 2/11 10:36 AM ET   AP

DHAKA, Bangladesh — Bangladesh's government ordered Nobel laureate Muhammad Yunus from his post as head of his microfinance bank Wednesday – a humiliating blow for an activist whose revolutionary idea of giving out small loans lifted many out of poverty. But the Grameen Bank said he remained in charge and that it would fight the decision.

The demand for Yunus' removal as Grameen's managing director capped a string of problems that faced the outspoken government critic, including an apparently politically motivated defamation trial and accusations of an unauthorized bank transfer 15 years ago.

Bangladesh's central bank ordered him out, arguing that he violated the country's retirement laws, A.F.M. Asaduzzaman, an official at Bangladesh Bank, told The Associated Press. Grameen Bank has been notified by letter, Asaduzzaman said, providing no further details. The government owns a 25 percent stake in Grameen, while the remainder of the bank is owned by its borrowers.

In a statement, however, Grameen said Yunus was still holding his post.

Yunus is "continuing his work as the managing director of the bank," said the brief statement signed by Jannat-E-Quanine, general manager of the bank. "Since it's a legal issue, we will fight it legally."

Yunus consulted a lawyer Wednesday.

"The legal process will be followed; the law will determine what happens," he said after emerging from his lawyer's office, without offering more details.

Yunus founded the bank three decades ago, pioneering the concept of reducing poverty by making tiny loans to the poor. His work, which spurred a boom in such lending across the developing world, earned him and the bank the 2006 Nobel Peace Prize.

Recently, Yunus has been under pressure at home. In addition to his legal troubles, Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina has accused Grameen Bank and other microfinance institutions of charging high interest rates and "sucking blood from the poor borrowers."

But he remains a hero to the poor.

Shefali Akter, 25, who has taken out two loans totaling 70,000 takas ($1,000) from Grameen since 2002, called Yunus' removal "bad news."

"The bank is all about him," she told The Associated Press by phone from northern Mymensingh district. "We know he is a respected man. He has brought honor to the country. We all have respect for him."

Efforts to remove Yunus from Grameen intensified in recent weeks, with the central bank claiming that the 70-year-old Yunus violated the country's retirement laws by staying on as the bank's head well past the mandatory retirement age of 60.

Grameen Bank says the normal retirement rule does not apply to it because the bank is run under a special 1983 law. Yunus was appointed managing director of the bank for an indefinite period in 2000, when he reached 60, the bank says.

On Tuesday, Finance Minister Abul Mal Abdul Muhith told reporters he had received a letter from the central bank accusing Yunus of flouting the retirement rules.

Khondoker Muzammel Huq, chairman of Grameen, received a copy of the letter and presented it Monday to the bank's board, but adjourned the meeting without making a decision on it.

Controversy swirled around Yunus after a Norwegian television documentary that screened in December accused him of transferring Norwegian development funds from Grameen Bank to another venture without prior approval in 1996. Pressure by the Norwegian Embassy in Dhaka resulted in the funds being transferred back in 1998, and the Norwegian government has said there was no indication Grameen was engaged in corruption or embezzlement.

In a recent statement, the secretary of the Norwegian Nobel Committee defended the panel's decision to award Yunus the peace prize.

"Without going into detail since there is a 50-year secrecy rule for the entire Nobel system, I can testify to the fact that the vetting process was actually even more thorough than what is normally the case," Geir Lundestad said.

Still, the Bangladesh government set up a committee in January to look into the allegations.

Yunus is also facing a defamation trial in connection with a 2007 interview in which he was quoted as saying, "They (politicians) are only after money. Their politics has nothing to do with ideology."

His lawyers have argued that since his comments were not directed at any specific person, they do not constitute defamation.

At the time of the remarks, Bangladesh was under a state of emergency and many politicians, including Hasina, the current prime minister, were behind bars on charges of corruption. An interim government backed by the country's influential military eventually handed over power to the elected government of Hasina in January 2009.

Grameen Bank, founded in 1983 in Bangladesh, currently has nearly 9 million borrowers, 97 percent of whom are women. Many use their small loans to make ends meet or to start small businesses.

___

Associated Press writer Karl Ritter contributed to this report from Stockholm.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST WORLD

DHAKA, Bangladesh — Bangladesh's government ordered Nobel laureate Muhammad Yunus from his post as head of his microfinance bank Wednesday – a humiliating blow for an activist whose revolu...
DHAKA, Bangladesh — Bangladesh's government ordered Nobel laureate Muhammad Yunus from his post as head of his microfinance bank Wednesday – a humiliating blow for an activist whose revolu...
Filed by Mark Hanrahan  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 191
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ndem
04:40 PM on 03/03/2011
This is from a Bengali man (whom I’m Facebook friends with) who is asking for our help:

YOU CAN NEVER FEEL HOW A MAN LIKE ME FEELS WHEN HIS NOBEL LAUREATE PROFESSOR MUHAMMAD YUNUS IS ATTENDING COURT PHYSICALLY WHEN EVERYBODY KNOWS THE NAUGHTY DEED TO THE GREAT MAN !
MY HEART IS BLEEDING.......!!
PLEASE SHARE IT EVERYWHERE.....!!!

He has been emailing me talking privately about the oppression in the newspaper and the media smear campaign going on. That he posted this on my wall when he has been censored in the past is because it is that bad there.

I’m forwarding the petition again on his behalf...
http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/letmicrocreditflourish

Holly

Holly Mosher
Filmmaker for Change
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ndem
05:52 AM on 03/03/2011
Pres Obamaknows a lot about Dr Yunus and Microcredit and even awarded the highest honor the US gives to Dr Yunus...Obama's mother,Ann Dunham's most lasting professional legacy was to help build the microfinance program in Indonesia, which she did from 1988 to '92—before the practice of granting tiny loans to credit-poor entrepreneurs was an established success story. Her anthropological research into how real people worked helped inform the policies set by the Bank Rakyat Indonesia, says Patten, an economist who worked there. "I would say her work had a lot to do with the success of the program," he says. Today Indonesia's microfinance program is No. 1 in the world in terms of savers, with 31 million members, according to Microfinance Information eXchange Inc., a microfinance-tracking outfit.
— While his mother was helping poor people in Indonesia, Obama was trying to do something similar 7,000 miles (about 11,300 km) away in Chicago, as a community organizer. Ann's friends say she was delighted by his career move.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ndem
05:50 AM on 03/03/2011
Another writ petition filed challenging govt decision

Star Online Report - The Daily Star Mar 3, 2011

Nine directors of Grameen Bank on Thursday filed another writ petition with the High Court challenging the legality of Bangladesh Bank’s decision to remove Dr Muhammad Yunus from the office of managing director of Grameen.

The writ petitioners are Rahima Begum, Nasima Begum, Jyostna Begum, Anwara Begum, Rozina Begum, Zulekha Begum, Sajeda Begum, Sundari Begum and Sathia Begum.

They are all directors elected by the Grameen Bank.

The bench of Justice Momtaz Uddin Ahmed and Justice Gobinda Chandra Tagore is expected hear the petition later in the day.
05:30 AM on 03/03/2011
Both Pres. Obama and Sec Clinton deeply understand Yunus' good work and have known him for decades. Sec Clinton heard about him while still living in Arkansas and seeing so much rural poverty brought him there. Pres Obama's mother, Stanley Ann Dunham was an inspiration and a pioneer in microcredit.

— Ann's most lasting professional legacy was to help build the microfinance program in Indonesia, which she did from 1988 to '92—before the practice of granting tiny loans to credit-poor entrepreneurs was an established success story. Her anthropological research into how real people worked helped inform the policies set by the Bank Rakyat Indonesia, says Patten, an economist who worked there. "I would say her work had a lot to do with the success of the program," he says. Today Indonesia's microfinance program is No. 1 in the world in terms of savers, with 31 million members, according to Microfinance Information eXchange Inc., a microfinance-tracking outfit. While his mother was helping poor people in Indonesia, Obama was trying to do something similar 7,000 miles (about 11,300 km) away in Chicago, as a community organizer. Ann's friends say she was delighted by his career move.

Pres Obama and Sec Clinton have spoken out in support of Yunus. Sec Geithner's father also worked with Microcredit issues while at the Ford Fdn. Grameen America and Grameen Fdn in US are doing good work based on this sustainable model.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ndem
05:04 AM on 03/03/2011
The hacker who hacked into Zuckerberg's Facebook page referred to media as a social business as described by yunus. The message called for the site to become a social business with investment for the users and used Mr Zuckerberg name and read,”Let the hacking begin. If Facebook needs money , instead of going to banks , why doesn’t Facebook let its users invest in Facebook in a social way? Why not transform Facebook into a social business the way Nobel Prize winner Muhammad Yunus described it?”
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ndem
05:03 AM on 03/03/2011
Yunus said media business should be social business, otherwise the space will be taken up by the owners' news. "I have got offer from India and the US to launch a TV (television) and a global networking media respectively," he said. But he did not say whether he is going to get involved in the media business.

The message called for the site to become a social business with investment for the users and used Mr Zuckerberg name and read,”Let the hacking begin. If Facebook needs money , instead of going to banks , why doesn’t Facebook let its users invest in Facebook in a social way? Why not transform Facebook into a social business the way Nobel Prize winner Muhammad Yunus described it?”

Sounds like a damn good idea look at joindiaspora.com open source and no selling private info!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ndem
05:01 AM on 03/03/2011
Muhammad Yunus defended microcredit as an effective tool in cutting down poverty but criticised the abuse and over-commercialisation of microcredit by SKS, India's largest for-profit micro financier.

"But it doesn't mean the original concept of microcredit is flawed." Microcredit is meant to help the poor with loans, he added.

The comment came after his attention was drawn to SKS that staged a highly successful initial share offer in India in August.

It came at a time when analysts fear India's seven-billion-dollar micro-finance industry could be thrown into crisis by a bill that seeks to regulate lending to the poor more tightly.

The legislation, slated to be taken up Tuesday by lawmakers in southern Andhra Pradesh state--hub of India's microcredit activities, sets new rules aimed at cracking down on aggressive lending and recovery practices.

There are a LOT of Westerners and others who see a lucrative loan sharking market here and Yunus speaks out against them! Of Course they are going to be behind trying to bring him down!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ndem
04:43 AM on 03/03/2011
Keep up the good fight Dr Yunus!

As of today, the United Nations estimates that over 100 million people have been pulled out
of poverty thanks to microcredit, and that the living conditions of over 200 million people have
substantially increased even if they still are inferior to national poverty benchmarks. These
statistics are surely impressive, but Dr. Yunus trusts that this is only the beginning. Indeed,
over 1 billion men and women are still living with less than a dollar a day. Dr. Yunus
accepted a movie about his life to be made as he is convinced it can help in the fight against
poverty as microcredit and the idea of “Social Business” are promoted.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atif Ahmed Choudhury
02:28 AM on 03/03/2011
This is a 100% politically motivated move...the current government has begrudged Dr. Yunus since 2006 when he tried to establish a new political party. If a reality show were made about Bangladeshi politics, it would blow Jersey Shore out of the water in ridiculous drama.
12:43 AM on 03/03/2011
that would be too bad if Bangladesh tried that because he has been a noble personality all his life !
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ronju01
Live and let Live
03:07 PM on 03/02/2011
Grameen Bank is a non-profit organization and now for-profit Banks are getting into Micro-financing. He must have ruffled somebody's feathers.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atif Ahmed Choudhury
02:30 AM on 03/03/2011
No this is a purely political move...the current government has held a grudge against Dr. Yunus since he tried to form a political party in 2006. So sad...
photo
brooklyncitizen
Quaerite primum regnum dei
02:24 PM on 03/02/2011
Some people are just braver than most of us. I hope he is safe.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atif Ahmed Choudhury
02:31 AM on 03/03/2011
I appreciate your concern but I don't think Prof. Yunus is in any physical danger...for all of its problems (overcrowding, arsenic poisoning, climate change, etc.) fortunately Bangladesh is not in the least a failed state :-)
photo
brooklyncitizen
Quaerite primum regnum dei
11:43 AM on 03/03/2011
I know Bangledash is not a failed state, but corruption has a way of shutting people up.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ndem
04:44 AM on 03/03/2011
I had an email from him this morning and he is safe and asks us to keep up the fight. This is insane that a person who has dedicated many decades of his life, never profited from this and truly believes in the power of people to create a better world, is being treated this way!

Everyone needs to show their outrage!!!
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
photo
Pandoras Folly
This Micro-bio is of legendary quality
01:56 PM on 03/02/2011
As i understood the Grameen system they basically loan out a small amount, sometimes in the double digit ranges, then you are put together with other local borrowers to talk about and support each others projects, and the interest rate is really really really low a couple of percentage points a year. did i get anything wrong? what is this about ruinous rates, blood sucking even?
03:20 PM on 03/02/2011
It's about him actually trying to help the poor and telling the truth about political corruption. The biggest charge against him is not retiring at 60. C'mon.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:46 PM on 03/02/2011
Bangladesh is the problem here. Their government is so corrupt and despotic..... kind of like Iran, Yemen, etc.

Everything brought against this man is a political vendetta. I hope the UN steps in........
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atif Ahmed Choudhury
02:34 AM on 03/03/2011
I'm certainly no fan of the corruption in Bangladesh, but for all of its flaws the country IS a democracy (AND with a female head-of-state to boot)...so yes this sacking is absolutely ridiculous (as is the current government's long-standing feud with the honorable Dr. Yunus) but please don't hate on one of the only genuine democracies in the Muslim world (and the ONLY one to currently have a woman at the helm).
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ndem
01:44 PM on 03/02/2011
Here's the official press release from the Grameen Bank detailing what really happened---not ousted at all?

http://globalspin.blogs.time.com/2011/03/02/a-twist-in-grameen-bank-founders-ouster-not-fired-after-all/