iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Richard Hoover, NASA Scientist, Claims Extraterrestrial Life Evidence Found In Meteorites

Extraterrestrial Life

The Huffington Post   First Posted: 03/07/11 10:58 AM ET Updated: 05/25/11 07:35 PM ET

Evidence that there is life from beyond Earth has allegedly come hurtling through the sky.

Richard Hoover, a NASA scientist, recently reported in the Journal of Cosmology that rare meteorites on Earth contain what appear to be tiny fossils of extraterrestrial life. According to a report in The Guardian, the remains lack nitrogen, necessary for life on Earth, which led Hoover to his conclusions. As Hoover explains in the journal, the filaments “found embedded in freshly fractured interior surfaces of [certain meteorites] are interpreted as the fossilized remains of prokaryotic microorganisms that grew in liquid regimes on the parent body of the meteorites before they entered the Earth’s atmosphere.”

If Hoover’s claims are true, his findings will support a theory called “panspermia.” Panspermia suggests that space rocks spread life to different planets. The theory doesn’t necessarily explain how all of life began -- as a recent Scientific American piece states, “panspermia theories merely push the problem of life's origin into outer space.”

Recently, a meteorite in Antarctica was revealed to contain nitrogen, an element required for life on Earth. Many scientists believe that Earth initially did not have the molecules necessary for primitive life, and thus it is possible that a meteorite brought the elements necessary for life to begin.

Not everyone is convinced that Hoover’s findings are valid. He has reportedly made similar claims in the past, and no remains have been confirmed as structures of alien life. Rudy Schild, the journal’s editor, has invited 100 scientists to comment on the research in order to show all points of view on the subject.

UPDATE:
NASA has distanced itself from and disputed Hoover's claims.

From the AP:

"There has been no one in the scientific community, certainly no one in the meteorite analysis community, that has supported these conclusions," NASA Astrobiology Institute Director Carl Pilcher told The Associated Press Monday. "The simplest explanation for Mr. Hoover's measurements is that he's measuring microbes from Earth. They're contamination."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST GREEN

Evidence that there is life from beyond Earth has allegedly come hurtling through the sky. Richard Hoover, a NASA scientist, recently reported in the Journal of Cosmology that rare meteorites on Ea...
Evidence that there is life from beyond Earth has allegedly come hurtling through the sky. Richard Hoover, a NASA scientist, recently reported in the Journal of Cosmology that rare meteorites on Ea...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 153
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TC Ragstix
just a songwriter
04:52 AM on 03/12/2011
As much as I like Huffpo, the science coverage here is sometimes like the Art Bell show. How many of these sensational claims have appeared here before peer review fleshes out, only to disappear and never be heard from again?
photo
funserious
I have not yet BEGUN to procrastinate
08:39 PM on 03/11/2011
Extraterrestrial life = GOP sent to destroy America.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
doctordoubt
It is never too late to try.
07:21 PM on 03/11/2011
Can't even imagine the ego it takes to think we are the only intellignet life form out there
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
proudtohaveserved
10:40 AM on 03/12/2011
doc. ARE WE INTELLIGENT?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
doctordoubt
It is never too late to try.
10:49 AM on 03/12/2011
Given what has been happening here, maybe not so much. But I am hopeful.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:51 PM on 03/11/2011
I think those who think extraterrestrial life doesn't exist are idiotic.

But don't be fooled.

I'd bet any discretionary money I have that this claim IS WRONG.

Why?

Because the odds of finding direct "in your hands" extra-solar, exo-biological evidence are staggeringly remote.

I.e., a simple back of the envelope calculation will tell you that the odds of a fist-sized meteorite from beyond our solar system reaching Earth, even from a nearby star is many orders of magnitude below unity because the odds of hitting Earth are astronomically small. I.e., the solid angle that Earth subtends compared to the void of its surrounding empty space is nearly zero. And though more distant stars increase in number roughly as the square of distance, so does the area of space subtended. So, the multiplicity of stars argument won't wash.

In fact, even if all rocky planets have or have had life forms, a simplistic estimate based on 20 light years to the nearest rocky/Earth-sized planet sets

the odds of a fist-sized meteorite evidencing signs of life, actually intercepting the Earth, at

~ 1 x 10 to the MINUS 17 or less - a very very small number.

And this doesn't even include the very low odds of a) a meteorite surviving its encounter with our atmosphere, b) the ridiculously low odds of any scientist accessing said rock, and c) contamination by terrestrial life forms.

So, yes, not impossible, but OF EXTREMELY LOW LIKELIHOOD.
07:31 PM on 03/10/2011
clear this post. it has been widely criticized and hoovers findings were turned down by other scientific journals and his findings have not been properly scrutinized. At this point this is not science.

Cool as it may be, science has a method and it has not been followed in this instance yet.
03:38 PM on 03/10/2011
Not sure I buy this, but is is very interesting and exciting to think about.

That there are fossils in meteorites does not necessarily mean that the life was active in those fossils of transferred to the Earth, does it? That is what the panspermia hypothesis is all about. Even if it was so, the distances involved in this and the slow speeds and random collisions seem to me to peg this as very unlikely and infinitesimally infrequent.
09:16 PM on 03/09/2011
Sarah Palin, Michelle Bachman, Jan Brewer , Beck,are just a few real examples of Extraterrestrial life
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
doctordoubt
It is never too late to try.
07:18 PM on 03/11/2011
Yeah but, one would hope they were smarter than us, right?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steve Rockett
01:04 AM on 03/09/2011
..and then Jan Brewer asked this scientist if the little illegals aliens had their little papers? He looked baffled, so she pulled out a laser and zapped his a*s.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steve Rockett
01:02 AM on 03/09/2011
Hey, I knew it. Remember when I told you that? We were at that Star Trek convention and you were hitting the Southern Comfort pretty hard. I said, I think that life exists in meteorites and we laughed, because it was like a meeting of the minds. And then we did this mind meld thingy. Yep, we should get credit for this. Hey, what is NASA anyway?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NebDem78
Basai Master
01:04 AM on 03/09/2011
Star Trek is awesome!
01:58 AM on 03/09/2011
Sorry to be so serious Steve, but my friend's father was an Air New Zealand long haul pilot for over thirty years and he said some of the things he has seen have no rational explanation. This guy is no flake and doesn't really believe in extraterrestials but stands by his opinion.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steve Rockett
11:24 AM on 03/09/2011
Hey, Chris, how are you? I tried to respond to an earlier post, but it wasn't there. Silly, because what you said was not offensive at all. Thank you. I am honored by your comment. I passed by 4th dan (blackbelt) in Aikido. Your comment raised the bar for me in my comments. You rat! Now I have to avoid nasty sniping, thanks to you. Oh well, I respect your posts too. Regarding the above comment: When I read something that is beyond me, I make up a little story acting like I knew that and wanting to take credit. I believe that this is a real scientific breakthrough and validates our connection to the universe. Take care and enjoy your summer. I live in SoCal and we have spring and summer and rarely anything else.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
proudtohaveserved
10:48 AM on 03/12/2011
how can we be so arrogant as to believe that we are the only ones in the universe? We are not even TAT GOOD to each other. The MAN must be very dissappinted the way we have turned out
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dblan9
.
01:53 PM on 03/08/2011
Can we stop looking at Meteor fossils and start looking at the Stargate in Peru? I think that holds more answers.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
sillyfrog
Pastafarian and UU student
04:29 PM on 03/08/2011
Yes!
01:47 PM on 03/08/2011
Illegal aliens are taking over our meteorites!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
situationcritical
SuperMegaUltraUberLiberal
01:25 PM on 03/08/2011
Meteorite skeletons are scooby snacks for giant aliens.
12:11 PM on 03/08/2011
Well OF COURSE NASA has distanced themselves from this! Any word of alien and it actually being true and they go under investigation for all of the other things they've been missing (or knew about and never reported) from all these years! STOP HIDING THE TRUTH!!!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jujubees
starch, gum and corn syrup, bees extra
11:47 AM on 03/08/2011
What, again? Doesn't this story in one flavor or another pop up about every month?
pharmmajor
proud Libertarian.
10:58 AM on 03/08/2011
I'm pleased to see people here advocating skepticism, yet it baffles me that people on this site are skeptical about the claim of alien life but buy into anti-vac.cine hysteria no questions asked.