iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Buying Legitimacy: How A Group Of California Executives Built An Online College Empire


First Posted: 03/09/11 07:38 PM ET Updated: 05/25/11 07:35 PM ET

CLINTON, Iowa -- Inside the red brick campus of Ashford University, perched on a bluff above the Mississippi River, the door marked "President's Office" remains perpetually shut. Telephone calls to the university's head are swiftly transferred to a corporate office some 2,000 miles away, in San Diego.

A new, 500-seat football stadium adorns the campus, and is featured prominently in Ashford's promotional literature, though the university has no football team. Signs around campus proudly read "Founded 1918" and "90 Years Strong," despite the fact that Ashford -- one of the nation's fastest-growing for-profit colleges -- has existed for less than a decade.

The perplexing campus landscape here in Iowa amounts to an elaborate stage set for a lucrative, online education empire that uses these trappings to sell itself to students as a traditional college experience. That strategy was the brainchild of the corporation behind Ashford: Bridgepoint Education Inc., a publicly traded venture started by a group of former executives from the University of Phoenix, a name now synonymous with for-profit higher education and the controversial marketing practices that have brought the industry crosswise with federal regulators.

Six years ago, Bridgepoint purchased what was then called Franciscan University of the Prairies, a near-bankrupt, 300-student college that for decades had been run by a local order of Franciscan nuns. The school delivered a crucial commodity: legal accreditation. That enabled Ashford's students to tap federal financial aid dollars, the source of nearly 85 percent of the university's revenues -- more than $600 million in the last academic year. Ashford now counts nearly 76,000 students, 99 percent of whom take classes online.

Two years ago, Bridgepoint engineered an initial public stock offering that brought in $142 million.

WATCH a tour of Ashford's campus:

The story of how a California corporation managed to use a small campus in Iowa as the springboard for a national, online education venture underscores a key element that has enabled explosive growth in the for-profit college industry: Schools with dubious educational records have secured the imprimatur of legitimacy simply by owning an accredited institution.

Many accreditors do major reviews of colleges just once every 10 years. The next comprehensive evaluation for Ashford is not scheduled until 2014.

"It's an area where the old rules don't fit," said David Longanecker, a former assistant secretary of education in the Clinton administration who now serves as president of the Western Interstate Commission for Higher Education, a consortium of colleges founded by Western states in the 1950s. "Accreditation hasn't quite caught up with the contemporary world."

Just as Wall Street managed to use simple things like home mortgages as raw material for complex and profitable investments, Bridgepoint has pulled off its own bit of alchemy here in Iowa: It has leveraged the purchase of of a failing but accredited campus into a badge of authenticity for its entire sprawling operation -- even as students have fared poorly, dropping out in large numbers and increasingly unable to pay back their federal debts.

POTEMKIN UNIVERSITY

The cachet of the traditional ground campus in Iowa, with its sports teams and historic buildings, has been a key marketing tool for Ashford, a feature that distinguishes it from other online rivals such as the University of Phoenix or Kaplan University, according to former and current employees.

The school's website boasts idyllic autumn scenes and photos of smiling students walking the Iowa campus. Just a few months back, Bridgepoint Education sponsored a major college football contest, the Holiday Bowl. Slick commercials for Ashford University were beamed out to a national television audience.

But for the thousands of new recruits who enroll online at Ashford each year, the friendly image of the Iowa campus ends soon after their applications are complete.

Behind the university's rapid growth is a pressure-cooker recruiting environment that treats prospective students like figures on a balance sheet, not people seeking opportunity through education, according to more than a half-dozen current and former employees ranging from management to entry-level recruiters interviewed by The Huffington Post in the past month.

All cited the central importance of a rigid performance matrix handed down by management -- one that rewards and punishes employees almost entirely on the basis of whether they are able to meet six-month recruitment targets.

WATCH Clinton, Iowa residents discuss Ashford's role in the community:

The goal, employees say, is getting "starts": students who fill out the paperwork for student loans and make it through at least four weeks of their first five-week course. That is the point at which the university is able to keep the student's federal aid money, regardless of whether they continue their studies. After that, according to the Ashford employees, any form of counseling drastically drops off.

"There were numerous times when I enrolled students and thought, 'All I've got to do is babysit them for four weeks,'" said a former leader in the admissions department, who spoke on the condition that he not be identified because he is still employed at another for-profit university. "I'd be thinking, 'Come on, this person is clearly not ready to go to school.' But I'd call you, pump you up, keep you confident for four weeks, and once I knew you completed, you were forgotten. It's easy when I'm counting the money."


FOLLOW HUFFPOST BUSINESS
Subscribe to the HuffPost Money newsletter!
CLINTON, Iowa -- Inside the red brick campus of Ashford University, perched on a bluff above the Mississippi River, the door marked "President's Office" remains perpetually shut. Telephone calls to th...
CLINTON, Iowa -- Inside the red brick campus of Ashford University, perched on a bluff above the Mississippi River, the door marked "President's Office" remains perpetually shut. Telephone calls to th...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 2,116
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (50 total)
08:24 PM on 04/10/2011
" Park wrote in an email. "The people Ashford preys on are single parents, poor people, people who don't know any better ... We know most of these people will drop out, but again, we have quotas, and we have no choice."

Yes, there is a choice. We can choose not to work for these "birds of prey." Until people are willing to do that, these degree mills will continue to function.
02:09 AM on 03/22/2011
huffpost videos do not a weak stomach soothe.
04:29 AM on 03/19/2011
I don't think Ashford "bought" legitimacy, they are legit. The campus in my view is just one more good thing about Ashford. I am a proud student of Ashford University and despite all of the controversy about for profit colleges, I know I made the right choice. I will be graduating Ashford this Summer 2011 with a B.A.; from there I will go on to complete a masters at National University, La Jolla. I can't speak for many other schools but Ashford is great, I simply love it.
01:40 PM on 03/14/2011
the marketing is hilarious. on LAtimes or huff post, there are critical articles of said school, but yet Banner- Ads are displayed

classic americana
03:38 AM on 03/13/2011
Anyone thinking he or she should get an MBA from a mill like Ashford & Simpson should get second and third opinions, like this post from last October as the for-profit situation was just starting to crack...

http://lairigmarketing.typepad.com/lairig_marketing/2010/10/no-profit-in-a-for-profit-mba.html
08:26 PM on 03/11/2011
America's educational system is for credentials, not education. One can learn any place, any time, any way. But to get credentials - ah, there's the rub.
Perhaps we may just dispense with expensive universities, and offer quarterly national examinations on various topics. Those that pass, can enter that into their professional resumes.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Toka248
01:53 PM on 03/12/2011
Legit universities provide far more. One only need look at the academic sources available at a university library as opposed to a public library to see the tip of the iceberg of the university experience. As one goes farther, the action of performing academic research gives an experience that you won't get at one of these for-profit universities or at an 'on your own' experience. I don't denigrate that there are other forms of knowledge, absolutely. But credentials are for specified actions, not to be used as a gauge of 'You're smart, you're not.'
04:49 PM on 03/12/2011
There is nothing intrinsically superior to doing research at a "legit" university versus research done outside of one.
The result is what matters.
And measuring that result is what an examination is about.
The credentials granted for one's achievements is the whole reason for the "university" experience. I doubt if people would go through the effort and expense if no credentials were acquired.
07:30 PM on 03/11/2011
This is yet another example of White Collar Crime targeting America's educational system. Here is a story that exposes blatant corruption preying on unsuspecting citizens & profiting through misuse & manipulation of American tax dollars. The berating and belittling of teachers, who, incidentally, are at the bottom of the food chain in education, is a smoke screen to divert attention from the day-to-day pillaging of America's tax revenues & sound-mindedness of its citizens by means of the USA's educational network at every level.
06:21 PM on 03/11/2011
My question is will the government forgive the unsuspecting students their debts? If this is a big farce (which it apparently is) how can they not?
Their practices are totally unscrupulous! This is horrible! And most of the students are single mothers or military vets.
07:00 PM on 04/06/2011
The description you gave fits most of the students in my classes at Ashford. Most of the students are single mothers or military vets.
05:36 PM on 03/11/2011
I can't personally speak to Bridgepoint, however I can personally speak to many other similar institutions. When some similar institutions were investigated, they simply changed their names and continued operating as usual with slick T.V. ads. Some of the students could not read on a 2nd grade level. As an adjunct professor I pointed this out in a meeting and was told I should not be asking them to read in class. There is also pressure not to fail any students. There are some good students, and some good professors, but that is not the average. Students don't seem to realize, and won't accept that they can't just show up occasionally, turn in unacceptable attempts, and graduate. I feel so sorry for those students.
04:55 PM on 03/11/2011
I went to Ashford to be an English teacher and now I are one.
03:35 PM on 03/11/2011
I don't understand how people can complain about the drop rate, and call it a diploma mill in the same posting, over and over again. If it was a diploma mill, that simply sold degrees to those willing to take federal funding to get them, why would ANYONE drop out of school? I have taken campus classes and online classes a a few different schools, and the online classes at AU are just as difficult as any other. The Football field is not fake, the soccer team currently uses it, with plans in the works for a football team in the future. I live in Clinton and take classes online because I work. People are not paid to recruit. They are paid to provide information to the student and help them through the process of going to school. If there was not a demand for students to go to school, there would be no growth in education. I am not a lemming. If someone calls me and I don't want what they are offering, I would say no.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
tacevad
American SS Card Carrying Socialist
01:20 PM on 03/11/2011
American Greed is at work
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SameBoat
Retired cop, educator
12:55 PM on 03/11/2011
Bridgepoint has been painted as a "diploma mill," which it is definitely not. It allows thousands of people who do not live close to a traditional campus the opportunity for an education. For the other side of the story, go here:

http://bpitransparency.com/

And yes, I do work for Ashford and am proud of its programs. So let's hear it; I'm sure the uninformed comments will be priceless.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lonewolfwisconsin
03:05 PM on 03/11/2011
Any "diploma" from Ashford just identifies you as a FOOL.
03:21 PM on 03/11/2011
Maybe you can explain the fake football field?

Or the way people are paid to recruit, as if they were selling penny stocks in a boiler room?

You must be SOOO proud.
12:48 PM on 03/11/2011
This article truly struck a chord. I was an employee of Argosy University Orange County and was stunned to find out how diverse the pay wages were for the same positions within the admissions department. Wages ranged from $35,000.00-$100,000.00. The Director of Admissions was paid a significant bonus when our team met our numbers and we, Assistant Directors of Admissions worked our behinds off only to receive delayed 6 month reviews with up to 5% potential raise benefit, most of which was geared to make us feel as if we did not preform proficiently leaving us to receive nothing less than a 2.0 or 2.5 raise. The review was structured in a way where the employee rated themselves then the Director of Admissions rated the employee on a scale of 1-5, five being exceeding your goals or something to that effect. We were told that over exceeding our numbers made us look good but when review day came and I gave myself a 5, my boss gave me under a 2.4. I questioned her. Her response was that the number I had exceeded was not enough. Employees were fired for not exceeding their numbers after 3 starts and tuition reimbursements stripped away. Ratings changed and were conveniently lost or not given to us signed so to not have a trail. I say employees should make a class action law suit to receive wages that were stripped away and given to the fat cats.
12:11 PM on 03/11/2011
With the devastating increases in student costs and curtailments in admissions at public universities, the siren call of these corporate phonies draws students who would otherwise attend accredited institutions.
03:37 PM on 03/11/2011
AU is accredited and that accreditation is recognized by the US DOE.