More

AP Sues Urban Outfitters, Nordstrom Over Obama 'Hope' Poster Use

Obama Hope

LARRY NEUMEISTER   03/11/11 06:46 PM ET   AP

NEW YORK — The Associated Press has sued Urban Outfitters and other clothing retailers in federal court, accusing them of selling T-shirts that violate the news agency's copyright of a photograph of Barack Obama that an artist's "HOPE" image was based on.

The news agency filed separate lawsuits Wednesday against Urban Outfitters Inc., Nordstrom Inc. and Zumiez Inc., seeking unspecified damages for products using the image that were sold at stores nationwide.

In each lawsuit, the AP said the retailers had engaged in willful and blatant violation of the AP's copyright to a photograph that artist Shepard Fairey's "HOPE" image was based on.

The AP and Fairey settled copyright claims against each other this year. A trial over copyright claims brought against a clothing company that sells apparel bearing graphics created by Fairey is scheduled to go to trial March 21.

"We're aware of the lawsuit and are reaching out to our vendor to determine next steps," said Tara Darrow, a Nordstrom spokeswoman.

Representatives of the other retailers did not immediately respond to several messages left for comment.

AP spokesman Paul Colford said in a statement that the copyright issue was important to the not-for-profit news organization.

"When a commercial entity such as these retailers, or the company that sold the shirts to them, gets something for nothing by using an AP photo without credit or compensation, it undermines the AP's ability to cover the news and devalues the work that our journalists do, often in dangerous locations where they may literally risk life and limb to cover a story," he said.

The lawsuits resulted from a continuing effort by the AP to protect the copyright of a 2006 picture taken of Obama at the National Press Club in Washington while he was a U.S. senator from Illinois.

Fairey used the picture, which became an iconic image in Obama's presidential campaign, as a basis for the red, white and blue image showing a determined Obama gazing upward, with the caption "HOPE."

Apparel manufacturer One 3 Two, which does business as Obey Clothing, has said in court papers that it began manufacturing T-shirts based on the image after one of its largest customers, Urban Outfitters, requested the shirts.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST MEDIA

NEW YORK — The Associated Press has sued Urban Outfitters and other clothing retailers in federal court, accusing them of selling T-shirts that violate the news agency's copyright of a photograp...
NEW YORK — The Associated Press has sued Urban Outfitters and other clothing retailers in federal court, accusing them of selling T-shirts that violate the news agency's copyright of a photograp...
Filed by Jack Mirkinson  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 165
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
03:15 PM on 03/14/2011
They couldn't get any money out of the artist; now they're going after the merchandisers. If only the AP actually did some real journalism for a change....
photo
ls1z28chris
We're on the side of the demons, chief.
03:50 PM on 03/14/2011
You must not read much news, online or in print. AP dominates in terms of both writing and photography.
Mainstream American
To promote peace, simply promote atheism.
06:19 PM on 03/14/2011
And yet in terms of actual journalism... not so much with the dominating.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Peter Bury
12:04 PM on 03/14/2011
In related stories, Shakespeare to sue Akira Kurasawa for Ran and the producers of Forbidden Planet for remakes of King Lear and The Tempest respectively. Kurasawa to sue producers of The Magnificent Seven and Fist Full of Dollars for swiping story lines from The Seven Samurai and Yojimbo.
05:46 PM on 03/14/2011
Actually, Kurosawa did sue successfully for A Fistful of Dollars and apparently told Leone that although it was a fine film it was still his film. In fact, he later said he wound up making more money off of his piece of the Fistful pie he won than he ever did from Yojimbo. Read all about it on wikipedia....
photo
Toddynho
Slartibartfast made me do it.
09:32 AM on 03/14/2011
How about they go after the Christians too?

http://www­.virtuousp­lanet.com/­antiobama/­c000000003­97
Mainstream American
To promote peace, simply promote atheism.
06:26 PM on 03/14/2011
That was one of the scariest sites I've been to.
photo
flossophy
Liberalism is not liberal.
09:02 PM on 03/13/2011
Shepard Fairey is a dupe.
photo
Toddynho
Slartibartfast made me do it.
07:00 PM on 03/13/2011
Maybe Campbell soup should have sued Andy Warhol too?
11:30 PM on 03/13/2011
That was free advertising. Campbell was smart enough to realize they would sell more soup.

The AP gets nothing for their copyright of the image and the related t shirt sales.
photo
Toddynho
Slartibartfast made me do it.
07:05 AM on 03/14/2011
And the images of Elvis Presley? Marilyn Monroe? Mickey Mouse?
photo
Toddynho
Slartibartfast made me do it.
06:49 PM on 03/13/2011
The last grasps of a dying agency. Digital k1lled the photography star.
photo
liberalsrheros
GOP PLATFORM:Mean Talkin Blues. Woody Guthrie
02:46 PM on 03/14/2011
nope, the internet just facilitated people of low m oral character stealing photographer's and copyright holder's property.
photo
Toddynho
Slartibartfast made me do it.
03:03 PM on 03/14/2011
And how many illegal downloads do you have in your ipod? lol. For starters, the work abuot is not the original, it's an intrepratation
photo
Toddynho
Slartibartfast made me do it.
03:06 PM on 03/14/2011
interpretation, and I would suspect that the artist who made this silkscreen spend more time on it that the photographer that snapped the shot. This is AP looking for cash, nothing more nothing less. Why else wouldn't they go after the Christian agency selling the same image on their shirts? That agency has little money.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:41 PM on 03/13/2011
Way to go, Associated Press. The field is collapsing all around you, and yet here you are, bringing the doctrine of fair use along with you as you circle the drain.
photo
Toddynho
Slartibartfast made me do it.
07:01 PM on 03/13/2011
Gotta fan you for that one, although most here won't understand.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:26 AM on 03/14/2011
assume much?
photo
liberalsrheros
GOP PLATFORM:Mean Talkin Blues. Woody Guthrie
02:36 PM on 03/14/2011
using an image on a commercial product is not fair use. the ignorance about copyright is not surprising but the number of people who have it so wrong with such confidence is.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:32 AM on 03/15/2011
The image we're talking about, "Hope," represents fair use of the AP's photo. The artist who created "Hope" may have a case against the t-shirt people if they used his art without permission, but that's not what this story is about. It's about the AP claiming that this artwork is, despite everything, their property. Not the photo, but the artwork.

You really should be a little more careful about tossing around words such as "ignorance," given the circumstances.
03:24 PM on 03/13/2011
AP should join with our queen of petty squabbles and whine, whine, whine! Not much in the credibility department anymore.
photo
Toddynho
Slartibartfast made me do it.
07:02 PM on 03/13/2011
When you're watching your entire empire crash around you, you lash out. Most photography agencies are this petty in the new digital world.
02:02 PM on 03/13/2011
A little late isn't it AP? Those shirts were all the rage 3 years ago, but I don't know if they are even produced anymore.
Just want damages, not interested in actually stopping the product. Maybe that will make these shirts valuable after people start tossing them.
photo
theoriginalmatt
I want this because of reasons.
01:38 PM on 03/13/2011
I'm not sure what hope there is left for the Obama administration. On balance it's been a pretty spectacular failure.
photo
Toddynho
Slartibartfast made me do it.
06:49 PM on 03/13/2011
Well, as long as there are people like you who haven't a clue, I think he'll be just fine.
photo
theoriginalmatt
I want this because of reasons.
05:09 PM on 03/17/2011
You obviously haven't been paying attention. Obama could pass as a Republican just a couple decades ago.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:27 AM on 03/14/2011
geesh Really?
photo
theoriginalmatt
I want this because of reasons.
05:10 PM on 03/17/2011
Yah really. Obama is virtually a Republican.
photo
Someone Out There
..................................................
01:33 PM on 03/13/2011
People aren't buying the photograph. They are buying the artist's unique stylization of the photograph. The AP photograph is unremarkable, it is the use of color that is memorable.
photo
Toddynho
Slartibartfast made me do it.
07:03 PM on 03/13/2011
Visions of Warhol come to mind.
photo
liberalsrheros
GOP PLATFORM:Mean Talkin Blues. Woody Guthrie
02:43 PM on 03/14/2011
right, if that were the case fairey should have drawn, or photographed obama himself and not taken another person's technical and artistic work, or he could have simply paid to use the image. fact is he knew he was wrong so he lied and got caught in court about using AP's image. fairey has a formula, steal, rehash the same old colorizing, sell to people who don't care about thie very.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:44 AM on 03/13/2011
Didn't AP lose against Fairely? Why do they think they would win now against those companies? I don't get it.
08:23 AM on 03/13/2011
The AP and Fairey reached an agreement that neither side surrenders its view of the law. They also agreed to work together going forward with the Hope image and share the rights to make the posters and merchandise bearing the Hope image and to collaborate on a series of images that Fairey will create based on AP photographs.

But I still think that the AP is coming across like a 1/2 term governor from a northern state complaining everyone is picking on me.
photo
ls1z28chris
We're on the side of the demons, chief.
03:54 PM on 03/14/2011
That isn't how AP comes across to me. They spend a lot of money sending photographers into the field to capture newsworthy events. If people are permitted to steal from them, then they are going to start hemorrhaging money so bad that they will no longer be able to employ photographers. Then there would be nothing for Fairely to steal and he'd be out of a job, too.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
1088
06:41 AM on 03/13/2011
Yet, AP didn't mind that same picture was used by tea bagger, depicting President Obama as Hitler!
12:33 PM on 03/13/2011
I doubt that tea bagger was selling it, or using to make money like a store would be.
photo
Toddynho
Slartibartfast made me do it.
06:51 PM on 03/13/2011
Not too sure about that.

http://www.virtuousplanet.com/antiobama/c00000000397
photo
Cdangers
wish people would pick up a book once in a while.
04:46 AM on 03/13/2011
I hate pettiness. How in anyway is this hurting the AP financially or otherwise?
photo
ls1z28chris
We're on the side of the demons, chief.
10:55 AM on 03/13/2011
That photo is their property. Your question is akin to asking how is someone hurt, financially or otherwise, when they steal a wallet.
12:35 PM on 03/13/2011
Exactly, should my wallet with $14 not be reported if stolen? Theft it theft.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:51 PM on 03/13/2011
Hardly. In that case, my wallet is gone. In this case, the AP still holds the picture and can continue to do whatever it likes with it. What's being stolen here is the notion of fair use. Note that the settlement between the AP and the artist didn't get into any findings about theft.

BTW, it's Obama's face. Shouldn't he get a say in this? Doesn't he hold rights to his own image?
photo
Toddynho
Slartibartfast made me do it.
06:46 PM on 03/14/2011
It's not. AP is infamous for going after any legal loophole to make a buck. They went after bloggers arguing that they had intellectual property rights over WORDS. If it were not for the fame this iconic art generated, no one would be the wiser. The photographer didn't even know for heck's sake.

It's pure AP corporate thuggery and greed. Pushing the boundaries of copyright law.
photo
wonketteRAWKS
Hypocrisy is prevalent in BOTH parties!
12:22 AM on 03/13/2011
Ironically, all ears, and yet never listens to anyone who isn't a rich campaign donor.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
FoxyOldBroad
01:12 AM on 03/13/2011
Really? 'Cause I'm a breast cancer survivor and now have health insurance. So he must have listened to me and I'm not rich.
photo
Toddynho
Slartibartfast made me do it.
06:55 PM on 03/13/2011
WHACK! Nice comment Foxyoldbroad!