iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Twitter Still Dominated By Noisy Minority, Study Finds (UPDATE)

Twitter

The Huffington Post   First Posted: 03/28/11 06:53 PM ET Updated: 05/28/11 06:12 AM ET

See update below

Cornell University and Yahoo! Research have released a ten-page research report that offers insight into how content is being created, consumed, and shared by different groups of users on Twitter.

Though Twitter recently shared statistics highlighting its considerable growth over the past five years, the researchers found that a small minority of users--around .05% of the site's population--are generating half of all Twitter posts.

The researchers distinguished between ordinary and elite users, which they divided into four categories: celebrities (such as Lady Gaga or Barack Obama), media (such as CNN), organizations (such as Google), and blogs (such as BoingBoing, Gizmodo, Engadget, and Copyblogger).

Though Twitter has around 200 million users, the report found that 50% of tweets (there are around 140 million sent each day) are generated by 20,000 "elite" users, or less than .05% of all users. A 2009 Harvard study drew a similar conclusion, reporting that just 10% of Twitter's users produced 90% of the service's tweets.

The Cornell/Yahoo! Research study also found that the lifespan of tweets varies by user category, noting that this can be explained by the type of content that the differing users tend to post to Twitter:

URLs originated by media actors generate a large portion of short-lived URLs (especially URLs with lifespan=0, those that only appeared once); and second, URLs originated by bloggers are over-represented among the longer-lived content. Both of these results can be explained by the type of content that originates from different sources: whereas news stories tend to be replaced by updates on a daily or more frequent basis, the sorts of URLs that are picked up by bloggers are of more persistent interest, and so are more likely to be retweeted or reintroduced months or even years after their initial introduction.

Not only are a small minority of elite users producing half of all tweets, but it appears that these elite users seem to be most focused on following others within their category.

"Within the population of elite users, moreover, attention is highly homophilous, with celebrities following celebrities, media following media, and bloggers following bloggers," the researchers wrote.

On the other hand, "ordinary" users are not receiving information directly from media outlets, but second hand, via other tweeters.

"Even though media outlets are by far the most active users on Twitter, only about 15% of tweets received by ordinary users are received directly from the media," the report notes.

According to the study, the URLs that last the longest on Twitter are those linking to videos and music, evergreen content from sources like YouTube and Last.fm (See chart below).

Read the full study, including the researchers' methodology, here.

UPDATE: Twitter contacted HuffPostTech to correct the conclusion drawn that .05% of the site's users are responsible for half of all tweets.

Twitter directed HuffPostTech to two tweets from Twitter's Sean Garrett, which noted, "BTW, it's technically impossible for 20K users to create 50% of all Tweets given limit of 1K Tweets/day per user [...]" and added, "even if 20K 'elite users' tweeted every 90 secs for 24 hrs, w/no sleep, it would be just 14% of 140M daily Tweets."


LOOK:

FOLLOW HUFFPOST TECH

See update below Cornell University and Yahoo! Research have released a ten-page research report that offers insight into how content is being created, consumed, and shared by different groups of u...
See update below Cornell University and Yahoo! Research have released a ten-page research report that offers insight into how content is being created, consumed, and shared by different groups of u...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 19
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:10 PM on 03/31/2011
I don't particularly care for twitter. It seems like a useful tool for celebrities, PR, and news stories. I wouldn't be sad if twitter disappeared. I have a twitter account for a class that I am in and only use it to follow the teacher and her updates and a few bands I like. I would rather just use facebook...
10:10 PM on 03/29/2011
No surprise at all. Twitter is the biggest VC scam ever - it's a friggin' alphanumeric page, 1980s technology! The only people who are enamored of it are the press, because it gives them a free vehicle to send mass blasts for story topics/content/leads. Celebrities/politicians love it because it feeds their ego to know some people actually care about their inane one sentence pronouncements. Oh, and yeah its great if you are in a third world revolt and are trying to reach the press. But for the real world, and the people who live in it, it is utterly useless. You watch how fast twitter fades away once the VCs unload this pig on the clueless investors - it will make the CB radio craze of the seventies seem like innovation of the century!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
IrishEyes21
Where are the games on this thing?
09:11 PM on 03/29/2011
Maybe this means twitter will finally die. What a monumental waste of time and energy.
03:29 PM on 03/29/2011
I signed up to Twitter a few weeks ago to see what all the hype was about. While I understand how it works, I'm not sure what the point of it is or who the intended audience is. I mean, facebook is obviously for regular people looking for an easy way to keep in touch or share photos with friends or sort-of-friends.

Twitter isn't really very "social" at all for a supposedly social network or a part of the new social media. Plus, it isn't even a good place to hold converations unless you really love one way conversations.

Twitter only seems beneficial as a news service or PR tool for celebs. And even if you follow some of the celebs who talk to their fans, you are still one in a million (or more) and the chances of your own tweet being singled out for response is unlikely.

So again, what is twitter supposed to be for and who is their audience? Because it is not useful for regular people looking to meet new people or be heard.
02:47 PM on 03/29/2011
I'm still amazed that Twitter still supports consonants. Does anyone know why?
12:59 PM on 03/29/2011
Not that I care that much about twitter, but this article is grossly misleading.

After reading the abstract of the actual study, it's pretty clear that that statistic refers to the amount of tweets consumed (or the attention garnered), not the number of tweets generated.

"...attention remains highly concentrated, where roughly 0.05% of the population accounts for almost half of all attention."

"roughly 50% of tweets CONSUMED are generated by just 20K elite users"

This makes a lot of sense considering how many followers celebrities and blogs have. Obviously people with a lot of clout get more attention.

I think Ms. Bosker should have spent a little more time reading the study...
11:59 AM on 03/29/2011
Did they mean "Losers" instead of "Users?"
10:03 AM on 03/29/2011
I dont think this is surprising at all. I know a lot of people who only twitter to read celebrity tweets.
06:01 AM on 03/29/2011
I knew there was a reason I ignored twitter.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:58 AM on 03/29/2011
I did not realize that most of the pointless gibberish on Twitter was considered to be "Content" tweeted by "Elite" users. I would hate to have to sift through the less-than-elite Tweets.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Brian Hudson
Educator and freelance creator.
12:11 PM on 03/29/2011
Don't forget to hold your pinkie out when you drink your tea, sir.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mediamarv
1-2-3 Is this thing working?
01:50 AM on 03/29/2011
Ok let me get this straight.... a minority dominates? Isn't that oxymoron material?
Just askin.
01:37 PM on 03/29/2011
ever hear of the top 1% of wage earners being in control of 90% of the wealth?
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
General Public
Microbiologists have found my microbio contagious.
10:43 PM on 03/28/2011
@huffingtonpost Twalf twof twall tweets tware twby 0.05 twercent twof tweeple twon Twitter, twunfortunately... Twerrible twituation...
photo
PenguinLinux
got root ?
01:54 PM on 03/29/2011
I thought twi taw ta tuddy tat.........
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Anthony Abney
Independent thought offends both sides.
10:30 PM on 03/28/2011
I'm on twitter not to tweet at all. I'm on it to follow people / organizations I like. I have not issued one tweet. I don't care to share every second of my life. However, I am interested in following / keeping up with my personal interests, which Twitter helps me do very well.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:03 AM on 03/29/2011
You make Twitter sound like an ideal tracking app for stalkers.
07:42 PM on 03/28/2011
I think most people 1) hear all the buzz about Twitter, 2) sign-up, 3) realize they don't understand how it works, and 4) discontinue tweeting.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
General Public
Microbiologists have found my microbio contagious.
10:28 PM on 03/28/2011
RT @CourtneyParham I think most people 1) hear all the buzz about Twitter, 2) sign-up, 3) realize they don't understand how it works, and 4) discontinu­e tweeting. #thatswhativebeensayingforyears