iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Fracking Well Shutdown Extended As Researchers Study Link To Earthquakes In Arkansas

Fracking Earthquakes Arkansas

By SARAH EDDINGTON   04/20/11 11:41 PM ET   AP

LITTLE ROCK, Ark. -- Two natural gas exploration companies have agreed to extend the shutdowns of two injection wells in Arkansas as researchers study whether the operations are linked to more than 1,000 unexplained earthquakes in the region, a state commission said Wednesday.

Chesapeake Energy Corp. and Clarita Operating LLC asked to postpone a scheduled April 26 hearing on the shutdowns until the Arkansas Oil and Gas Commission's next meeting on May 24, said Shane Khoury, deputy director and general counsel for the commission.

Khoury said the commission agreed to the continuance provided the companies not restart injection well operations at the two wells, both located in Faulkner County, before the May hearing.

"It was fine with us," Khoury said. "Our goal was to request a 60-day continuance of the shutdown at that meeting anyway. The more time we have, the more confident we will be with results of study."

BHP Billiton acquired the well from Chesapeake on March 31, but Khoury said the transfer request has not yet been received, so the commission recognizes Chesapeake as the owner.

It was the second time the owners of the two wells have filed for a continuance, with the first occurring before the March 29 hearing. The wells are used to dispose of waste fluid from natural gas production.

Clarita and Chesapeake agreed March 4 to temporarily cease injection operations at the request of the commission so scientists could analyze whether injection well operations were possibly causing the tremors.

The commission has said preliminary studies showed evidence potentially linking injection activities with more than 1,000 quakes in the north-central cities of Greenbrier and Guy since September, including the largest quake to hit the state in 35 years – a magnitude 4.7 on Feb. 27.

Kris Sava, BHP Billiton spokesperson, said in a written statement that the company's goal is "to develop the Fayetteville shale in line with our values of ensuring we fully protect people, the environment and communities where we operate."

"We will use the coming months to review the available data, and speak with interested stakeholders to understand the facts about the operating history of the well and the recent seismic activity in Faulkner County," Sava said.

Scott Ausbrooks, a geo-hazards supervisor for the Arkansas Geological Survey, said the area's seismic activity has dramatically declined since the injection well closures.

"We're still having earthquakes, but that's not unexpected," he said. "We've definitely seen a marked decrease in the number of earthquakes since the shutdown, especially the larger ones."

He said that in the month before the shutdown, there were more than 80 seismic events with a magnitude 2.5 or greater, compared with 20 in the month after.

The largest quake before the well closures was the magnitude 4.7 in February, while the largest since the closures were the two quakes in early April with magnitudes 3.9.

Ausbrooks said it's too soon to say if the quakes are directly related to the injection well operations, but that scientists are ready to show their research to the commission.

"We would have been ready two months ago to present our findings, but more time is fine. We can see if the trend continues," he said.

The Fayetteville Shale, an organically-rich rock formation underlying the region, is a major source of natural gas in Arkansas. Drillers free up the gas by using hydraulic fracturing or "fracking," which requires injecting pressurized water to create fractures deep in the ground. The two injection wells at issue dispose of "frack" water when it can no longer be re-used by injecting it into the ground.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST GREEN

LITTLE ROCK, Ark. -- Two natural gas exploration companies have agreed to extend the shutdowns of two injection wells in Arkansas as researchers study whether the operations are linked to more than 1,...
LITTLE ROCK, Ark. -- Two natural gas exploration companies have agreed to extend the shutdowns of two injection wells in Arkansas as researchers study whether the operations are linked to more than 1,...
Filed by Travis Donovan  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 191
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Malcolm Hensley
Last of the Reagan Republicans
05:25 PM on 04/24/2011
maybe I'm wrong but I always thought a 1000 little quakes is better than one 1000 time stronger big quake.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
HawaiiShira
He that knows & knows he knows is wise.
08:53 PM on 04/22/2011
These poor folks in Arkansas...they were sold a bill of goods. Nightlife did an excellent story on all the earthquakes caused by the injection wells, and these folks houses just splitting apart at the seams from the quakes. Then for them to discover there is a previously unknown fault that they've awakened.....over 1000 since September.

It seems more feasible that a Great Quake could in fact, occur in middle America....watch out Missouri & western Tennessee.

It makes the possibility
07:32 PM on 04/22/2011
Why is it so hard to believe these corporations have missed even one beat, since their public statement they have stopped operations?
11:10 PM on 04/21/2011
"He said that in the month before the shutdown, there were more than 80 seismic events with a magnitude 2.5 or greater, compared with 20 in the month after."

Funny how one can look at the data and see things differently.

The USGS total count of epicenters in Faulkner County is in excess of 260 for the time since the 4.7 on February 28, and only 170 for the prior month.

Why does Mr. Ausbrooks use a select set of these data then? And why is a preponderance of the events clustered around the the 4.7 foci, several miles distant from either well, and not around the subject wells?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
aligatorhardt
Cut on the bias
09:05 PM on 04/21/2011
The article made no mention of the history of tremors in that area. The records for previous years should be compared to see if this is an unusual event or not. Hopefully the investigation will be done realistically, and we will get their conclusions. The charge of inducing earthquakes has been raised before, and this issue needs some serious investigation, as gas drilling is getting ramped up lately.
11:12 PM on 04/21/2011
You might ask Mr. Ausbrooks that? He published a map of the seismicity for 2010 up to last October.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PAGasDriller
04:32 PM on 04/22/2011
It's already been documented that if you drill an injection well in a faulted zone it can lead to earthquakes. What fails to be documented OVER AND OVER on HuffPO is that injection wells have nothing to do with the actual fracking of a gas well. Injection wells are not fracked in most cases.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
aligatorhardt
Cut on the bias
08:06 PM on 04/22/2011
Are you responding to the wrong post? Do you see fracking in my comment?
08:53 PM on 04/21/2011
California is next it is going to drop into the ocean never to be seen again.
photo
hazyafternoonsunshine
Life's a ball, buster!
11:55 PM on 04/21/2011
And that is according to your crystal ball, or tarot cards? California is due for a mega-thrust event, and there may be some subsidence, but it is not going to drop into the ocean. The ocean is going to come to it in the form of a tsunami, and there may be a nuclear catastrophe. Oyster production may be negatively impacted, but luckily the bread basket of the US will remain where it is, and continue to produce its phenomenal array of edibles and ideas.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ivanczar
08:23 PM on 04/21/2011
The bigger and much more dangerous problem with fracking not mentioned in this article is the poisoning of well water and our underground aquifers caused by the fracking process. Large amounts of pressurized water, mixed with know carcinogenic chemicals is forced into the shale rock, cracking it and allowing the entrapped gas to escape.Once the gas is captured the non reusable and polluted pressurized water is left to sink into the aquifer below.Google fracking.
11:17 PM on 04/21/2011
Except that the potable water of which you speak is in aquifers thousands and thousands of feet shallower. And since you think water sinks down you probably will not believe that these gas reservoirs are totally isolated by the overlying rock which has, in no way, been subjected to the fraccing process.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
observingstupiditydaily
Nice to be important,but more important to be nice
11:43 PM on 04/21/2011
No problems with the aquifiers? Quick search on google, Texas has problems:

“We know they’ve polluted the aquifer,” Armendariz said. “We know they’re getting natural gas in there. We don’t know yet how far it’s spread.”

The EPA instructed Range, among the nation’s largest gas-producing companies, to indicate within 24 hours whether it intends to comply with the order and to provide potable water to the two families within 48 hours.
It also must install meters in the homes

http://plexco.wordpress.com/2010/12/07/epa-says-parker-county-homes-at-risk-of-explosion-after-natural-gas-fracking-contaminates-aquifer/ for exp
06:45 PM on 04/21/2011
I am CURIOUS...Did anyone ELSE see the reports of so called GENIUS Scientists sending Powerful Blast Rockets into the MOONS Crust JUSt to see what Effect it MIGHT Have Last year?...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
aligatorhardt
Cut on the bias
09:07 PM on 04/21/2011
Yes I remember that. They never run out of ways to throw away money on pointless pursuits, but yet have no money for the needs of the taxpayers. Priorities are confused.
06:40 PM on 04/21/2011
The Earth is a Huge Ball...Basically....
Think of it like a beach ball...
There were ORIGINALLY ....Everything in it's righful accidental Place...
As the Planet was formed..and found it's Place in the Universe..within it's Orbit.....Where LIFE ITself began...
Now...in the last couple of hundred YEars...(More or less)...Man...in his Infinite Wisdom...has decided to drill into it...possibly MILLIONS of times...to draw OUT the ORIGINAL contents...(YOU know...the Ones that kept it literally BALANCED within it's ORiginal Orbit...the one where LIFE occured..and began...
NOW..we have siphoned off a good deal of its HEavier than water Liquids..and mined deep into its crust....Moved Perhaps Trillions of pounds of it's ores ..to other places...all the while...changing the Earth...
We wonder how it happens to react to such changes?..Hm...
Guess one would have to wait and see...
GOODBYE HUMAn interlopers...
Hopefully...IF this ONCE BEautiful Planet even Stays in it's orbit...and does NOT go hurtling off into SPace....She will be more careful as to the NExt Population She Allows...
The EARTH and THe SUN are the Only Real Givers of LIFE...
06:32 PM on 04/21/2011
Fracking is not the only cause.... I live in Arkansas, and have experienced many of these quakes. There were low magnitude quakes here long before they started doing their drilling. It's basically the blame game. We live on a freakin' fault line, what do you expect? When we moved to our property in 2000, we were digging post holes and found sea shells. The seizmologists came out and discovered we were sitting right on top of a fault line, and this was once an ancient sea bed. We will continue to have quakes. If fracking was the only cause, we would have seen a reduction of quakes since they stopped drilling and that is not the case.
11:21 PM on 04/21/2011
Shut your mouth woman and do not be about the 'devil' gas companies business. We know it is them and wee will twist every "fact". Natural seismicity? Bah Humbug!

PS Thank You
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
observingstupiditydaily
Nice to be important,but more important to be nice
11:47 PM on 04/21/2011
You have to read the article, it's pretty self explanatory:

Scott Ausbrooks, a geo-hazards supervisor for the Arkansas Geological Survey, said the area's seismic activity has dramatically declined since the injection well closures.

"We're still having earthquakes, but that's not unexpected," he said. "We've definitely seen a marked decrease in the number of earthquakes since the shutdown, especially the larger ones."
02:40 PM on 04/22/2011
Apparently you do not start at the top of the page. Why the gentleman made that statement is beyond me

"http://folkworm.ceri.memphis.edu/recenteqs/Quakes/quakes0.html"
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
rockymtngma
Science rocks!
05:21 PM on 04/21/2011
"The most economically damaging earthquake in Colorado’s history occurred on August 9, 1967 in the northeast Denver metropolitan area. This magnitude 5.3 earthquake, which was centered near Commerce City, caused more than a million dollars damage in Denver and the northern suburbs.
This earthquake is believed to have been induced by the deep injection of liquid waste into a borehole at Rocky Mountain Arsenal. It was followed by an earthquake of magnitude 5.2 three months later in November 1967. "
-- From the Colorado Division of Emergency Management.

The whole article is at http://dola.colorado.gov/dem/public_information/earthquake.htm
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
REMEMBER2050
Bring on that War on Women, GOP! I'm game.
06:33 PM on 04/21/2011
Thanks for that link. I can barely wait for "clean coal," which is what we'll finally have when they figure out how to pump all the CO2 underground. Hmm. How could that possibly ever backfire?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
James Adam Carrington
07:49 PM on 04/21/2011
I've been fearing this all along here in Ohio, and now that they've been given the green light to do it all over the place, God help us all. There WILL be consequences of a dire nature for this.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
magedfoxx
05:13 PM on 04/21/2011
why is this thread locked down?
11:32 PM on 04/21/2011
The epicenters still keep coming. Ruining the foregone conclusion.
05:00 PM on 04/21/2011
Fracking to get natural gas is simply another way that the oil industry is doing whatever it can to stop renewable energy development. Natural gas is an oil product and does damage the environment through the release of carbon. Until people wake up and realize that we should have started developing renewable energy back during Jimmy Carter's administration, which he tried to do, we will risk destroying our economy. Ronald Reagan put an end to Carter's correct assesment of future energy needs, and the current crop of in denial Republicans continue to risk every American's future to keep their lies alive in support of their rich oil industry supporters.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
James Adam Carrington
07:50 PM on 04/21/2011
Absolutely correct.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kaymettee
04:58 PM on 04/21/2011
I never heard of this before. How can the government let this happen to these people. We had a natural gas line put in which none of us knew about until it was well underway. I live in a lake community and pay dues each year and still knew nothing. One day on the way shopping I drove the road leading to town and nearly had a accident, because of the total distruction of the wooded area near my house. Hundreds upon hundreds of trees were chopped down and the earth looked like a bomb dropped on it. A building was put up and trucks were parked all over. I can't discribe how ugly this is. Birds, Bears and small animals no longer have a home. My neighborhood resembles a war zone. This is what happened not only to us but all across the country. Shouldn't something like this and Fracking be put before the people of the towns involved? Where's the tea party on this one?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
evalela
04:56 PM on 04/21/2011
GEE really,I wonder if those propritary chemicals they use might have something to do with the weather,just a thought !!!!!!!!!
05:58 PM on 04/21/2011
No worries, nothing to do with the weather....just poisoning the groundwater!