Cell Phones Don't Kill Bees (STUDY)

The Internet is all abuzz about a reported new study suggesting cell phones cause the world's suddenly dwindling population of bees.

Now the British tabloid the Daily Mail is getting stung.

The paper recently published a story about a study that suggested in the first sentence that cell phone signals "could be partly to blame for the mysterious deaths of honeybees."

Problem is, the actual study never said such a thing.

The story was based on research done by Swiss researchers who studied the effects of cell phones on bees by placing active phones in or near hives.

Apparently, the bees were able to tell when the handsets made and received calls, and the insects responded by making "piping" sounds, the high-pitched tones that spread the message through the colony that something disturbing is happening.

The media swarmed around the story, but while the study provided evidence that bees do get agitated by cell phones -- as do most humans, at times -- there was no proof that they caused death, despite the use of the phrase "could be partly to blame."

As the website CleanTechnica pointed out, the Daily Mail article explicitly states, all the way down in paragraph 17, that "the study did not show that mobile phones were deadly for bees."

CleanTechnica columnist Jeremy Bloom, who helped expose the fallacy, tried to jokingly explain the discrepancy between the headline and the part of the story that admits there was no actual evidence of bee deaths by surmising the headline writer may not have read that far.

"It's the headline writer's job to pump things up to make sure that folks read the article. So he went all out," Bloom wrote.

Whoever wrote the Daily Mail headline did indeed go all out, using headlines like "Why a mobile phone ring may make bees buzz off: Insects infuriated by handset signals;" taglines like: "Phone signals confuse bees and cause them to begin flying erratically before suddenly dying" and photo captions like "Researchers placed mobile phones in bee hives under controlled conditions and monitored the results. They found the phone signals confused the bees who began to fly erratically before dying suddenly."

To its credit, however, the Daily Mail did include comments from British-based bee expert Norman Carreck of Sussex University, who said the study was "interesting," but didn't prove that mobile phones are responsible for colony collapse disorder, a condition that has affected, according to some estimates, nearly half the bee population in the U.S.

"If you physically knock a hive, or open one up to examine it, it has the same result," Carreck said. "And, in America, many cases of colony collapse disorder have taken place in remote areas far from any mobile phone signals."

WATCH:

Comments

[hornedcog]

04:22 PM on 05/21/2011

Quit trucking bees around. See what happens.

[Jake Thomas]

12:07 PM on 05/21/2011

There should be a law against bee's texting and flying, I am sure if it is banned colonies will rebound.

[Tim Arheit]

12:55 AM on 05/20/2011

This is old new from several years ago repackaged by one media outlet to make it appear new. Fortunately for me the solution was quite simple. I just took away my bees cell phone privileges.

[chaya]

12:26 PM on 05/19/2011

Okay, two points here:

1. Any time you disturb a bee colony, you are potentially interfering with their finely attuned survival mechanisms. It doesn't matter whether they fall dead right in front of your eyes or not.

2. "And, in America, many cases of colony collapse disorder have taken place in remote areas far from any mobile phone signals." I sincerely doubt that. I have only found a few areas where I could not use my phone, all in national protected areas without houses, much less bee hives--and there is a 100-200 ft. dead zone on a street downtown. No bee hives there. So apparently these guys have found colony collapse disorder inside trees in remote areas. I somehow doubt that as well.