More

Rob Woodall On Medicare: 'When Do I Decide I'm Going To Take Care Of Me?'

Rob Woodall Medicare

First Posted: 05/23/11 04:29 PM ET Updated: 07/23/11 06:12 AM ET

WASHINGTON -- Rep. Rob Woodall, a Georgia Republican, made a vigorous ideological defense of ending Medicare as it currently exists, telling seniors at a local town hall that they ought not look to the government to provide health care for the elderly just because their private employer doesn't offer health benefits for retirees.

A Woodall constituent raised a practical obstacle to obtaining coverage in the private market within the confines of an employer-based health insurance system: What happens when you retire?

"The private corporation that I retired from does not give medical benefits to retirees," the woman told the congressman in video captured a local Patch reporter in Dacula, Ga.

"Hear yourself, ma'am. Hear yourself," Woodall told the woman. "You want the government to take care of you, because your employer decided not to take care of you. My question is, 'When do I decide I'm going to take care of me?'"

Large portions of the crowd responded enthusiastically to the congressman's barb, with some giving him a standing ovation, underscoring the fierce divisions within the electorate.

William Robert Woodall III, who goes by "Rob," doesn't appear to have been referring literally to himself, but rather speaking figuratively. It's a good thing, because financial records show the 41-year-old congressman has done very little to take care of himself in his retirement. Woodall's 2009 financial disclosure forms, filed with the House of Representatives, show that his two largest IRAs have between $15,000 and $50,000 worth of assets, hardly the type of nest egg that would be able to cover the health care costs associated with aging absent government health care.

Woodall was chief of staff to former Rep. John Linder (R-Ga.), a job taxpayers shelled out more than $100,000 a year for in 2002, rising to more than $150,000 in 2009, plus gold-plated health and retirement benefits. Woodall, who has taken his former boss's seat, now makes $174,000 a year with generous benefits.

Another woman at the Woodall town hall told the congressman that it was unrealistic to think that the market would provide affordable policies to the elderly.

"When you become a senior, you will not be created equal when they take away your Medicare," she said.

Another woman told the congressman that Medicare provides peace of mind to her children, who would be on the hook for her care otherwise, much as they were before the social safety net was stitched together.

"I'm fine with my Medicare, and my children and my grand children -- my children especially -- would have a lot of heartburn if they know that I'm not on Medicare, because that voucher is not going to go very far,†said the woman.

Across the country, Republicans have faced hostile town hall attendees angered by the House vote to end Medicare for people under 55 and replace it with a voucher system that would not rise with health care costs, leaving it to cover less and less treatment as the years go on.

Woodall suggested that the woman concerned about vouchers might find the type of health care system she and her children approve of in Canada or another industrialized nation.

"If you want a socialized health care program, there are lots of places to find that," he said. "But, for your children's sake, I beg you: There aren't many places to find the freedom to succeed by the sweat of your brow like we have here.â€

"We consider overall the town hall pretty good stuff,†said Jennifer Drogus, a spokeswoman for Woodall contacted by HuffPost. "Folks who were misinformed and guided by the scare politics of the left hopefully left better informed."

WATCH:
FOLLOW HUFFPOST POLITICS
Subscribe to the HuffPost Hill newsletter!
WASHINGTON -- Rep. Rob Woodall, a Georgia Republican, made a vigorous ideological defense of ending Medicare as it currently exists, telling seniors at a local town hall that they ought not look to th...
WASHINGTON -- Rep. Rob Woodall, a Georgia Republican, made a vigorous ideological defense of ending Medicare as it currently exists, telling seniors at a local town hall that they ought not look to th...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 12,220
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (264 total)
  1 of 28  
COMMUNITY PUNDITS
photo
peacekitten 12:40 AM on 05/24/2011
my dad passed away at age 61, having paid into medicare and social security all his life.  his health care was provided by his employer, who, because of his skills, provided him with a solid gold policy that paid for everything, down to the box of kleenex he needed during his many hospital stays.

as for what he paid in for years to medicare and social security, he collected not one dime of that  Read More...
photo
Sleepers Awake
Google this: "Fighting for peace is like" ...
03:26 AM on 07/07/2011
The Military Industrial Complex is not sacrosanct.

The president and Congress (and their contributors, plus lobbyists, shareholders, CEOs, and all their full time attorneys, of course) should come to terms with the bloated budget of the MIC.

To think we need to throw money at wars is absurd.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LightSnowOvernight
A worker in song
07:16 PM on 05/30/2011
I was referring to catastrophic illness, not work
05:07 PM on 05/29/2011
I have to say it again. Medicare is a promise made by our government for affordable health care.

Social Security is also a promise made to us from government and paid for ourselves.

Republican Rob Woodall is slamming this woman for wanting what she and all of us have paid out of every paycheck for 45 years.

The rest of the audience must be hired to clap or work for the stock market or health insurance.
photo
Sleepers Awake
Google this: "Fighting for peace is like" ...
03:27 AM on 07/07/2011
It seemed the audience was full of goons.
06:40 AM on 05/27/2011
Is it just me or is it ironic that after Woodall said "When am I going to take care of me?" one of the people who gave him a standing ovation was an obese man who's obviously NOT taking care of himself?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MarkInEugene
A blasphemy a day keeps the deities away.
03:13 PM on 05/26/2011
Apportioning 1/3 of all tax revenues to the world’s most massive defense spending together with the runaway cost in the Health Care sector of the US economy and $60 billion/year in Medicare fraud are the glaring elephants in the room and Republicans refuse to look at that side of the ledger!

If Republican's would put the effort into Cost containment, Fraud reduction, and Defense spending reduction, Medicare would be solvent for the foreseeable future. Instead their attacking the people from their cushy gold plated government benefit packages paid for by the people.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cassie reinara
02:56 PM on 05/26/2011
This same hypocrite asks this lady to take of herself while justifying his own health care coverage as a government employee as something he would not give up because "it's free!" Republicans should copyright HYPROCRISY. They've taken it to another level. Maybe rebrand and call it something else, you sure are masters of Slogans and catch phrases.
photo
Al91206
Educating the right on why they are wrong.
02:54 PM on 05/26/2011
Can't wait to see the smug people applauding in the audience at 65 and having NO MEDICARE. Maybe I'll ask them how taking care of themselves is working out for them - after they get their first post-retirement medical premium bill - that is.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ForVivi
Another button, another buttonhole.
02:33 PM on 05/26/2011
These repubs are setting up their own demise because they are too stupid to understand history's lessons, the dynamics of a society, human nature, our changing world. Ideology is their noose.
photo
SunnyDaySam
To Err is Human, to Forgive is Canine
02:59 PM on 05/26/2011
Willful ignorance is part of it too.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chaserblue
Shaving my legs with Occam's razor
02:32 PM on 05/26/2011
I think people are missing the big picture...with what's going on in Wisc. right now---and around the country. If you put it all together it paints a terrifying picture of the future, one we won't want any of our loved ones in.
Hamstringing the unions, changing child labor laws, taking away medicare, stopping food programs for indigent families, stopping the AIDS medication programs...
Sounds to me like the GOP plans on eliminating everyone that can't work, taking children away from families that can't feed their children so they can put them to work, eliminating the middle class so there are only two classes of people, the rich and the slaves---we're heading right into a serfdom and just maybe we're gonna be looking at those massive prison camps all the conspiracy theorists keep screaming about.
It's terrifying!! And we have the Koch brothers and the GOP to thank for it.
Once you gather up all these threads and put them together--- it scares me...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cam1002
The People's Budget - It WILL Work
03:31 PM on 05/26/2011
Me too. We can't let them win. We need to vote straight Democrat in 2012, fed, state and local. That might bring them back to reality.
photo
Sleepers Awake
Google this: "Fighting for peace is like" ...
03:36 AM on 07/07/2011
Straight Democrat in 2012?

They're going right along with the Republicans whose objective is to throw senior citizens under the bus.

Long live the MIC, its CEOs and shareholders!
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Artos
Down with Tyrants
02:30 PM on 05/26/2011
dI find it very ironic that this jackanape who took a job with the very government he scorns, is making out like a fat cat from that Government yet telling every one else, "tough luck, I got mine.".
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ForVivi
Another button, another buttonhole.
02:28 PM on 05/26/2011
I believe we in the U.S have moved into the "Second World" category and approaching a "Third World" status.

In impoverished countries it is not uncommon to hear of parents being walked down to a ravine and left to die, or sick people jumping out of a window to spare their families the burden of medical expenses. Is this what we want for our society?

I am convinced by the overwhelming evidence that Republicans are a very short-sighted group. they truly have no understanding of the dynamics of a society, beyond a few people hoarding money at the expense of the many.

If Republicans were true conservatives, they would not be destroying society so radically.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chaserblue
Shaving my legs with Occam's razor
03:55 PM on 05/26/2011
I don't think they're short sighted...I think they have long range plans that have everything to do with the billions they've been putting into the prison systems (private prisons) the elimination of the middle class, the changing of the child labor laws, the elimination of medicare, the refusal to tax rich corporations, the elimination of food programs for the poor and the stopping of the AIDS
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chaserblue
Shaving my legs with Occam's razor
03:58 PM on 05/26/2011
It cut it off---

The stopping of the AIDS
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ForVivi
Another button, another buttonhole.
04:18 PM on 05/26/2011
Yes, chaserblue, to them long-term may be ten years. Meanwhile, the Chinese are showing us what they have learned as one of the world's oldest cultures. They plan for the future in hundreds of years. They have patience.

It has been proved impossible throughout history to maintain an intact higher socioeconomic class at the expense of the impoverished masses over a long period of time. We are being shown on TV in real time what happens when the population is driven to its knees. How desperate does a young person have to be to light themselves on fire because they have exhausted all possibilities to sustain themselves?

The point of the pyramid needs all the levels below it to be at the top. Our society seen as a pyramid is loosing its base (the middle class). The conditions are being created for the upper class to live in fear of their lives (see Mexico's rich), afraid to leave home.

All this to say, I agree with you as to how they are destroying our society.
photo
SunnyDaySam
To Err is Human, to Forgive is Canine
02:25 PM on 05/26/2011
Boy, I thought I was arrogant. This guy has me beat in spades!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ForVivi
Another button, another buttonhole.
04:20 PM on 05/26/2011
Who gave you that label anyway? Maybe the people who see you are right a lot of the time?
photo
SunnyDaySam
To Err is Human, to Forgive is Canine
04:30 PM on 05/26/2011
Well thanks FV! It's a term of respect and affection my friends gave me. ;-]
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
grainysmith
I heart worms
02:02 PM on 05/26/2011
What he really is saying is we want you to work harder for less and it's your fault for getting a job at Wall Mart.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MiddleMolly
Working to better the USA!
02:15 PM on 05/26/2011
That's about the size of it.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
sharmaine73
I Love Music!
01:26 PM on 05/26/2011
So what it sounds like he's saying is, "If you didn't work hard enough to earn enough to take care of your medical needs in your twilight years that's YOUR problem, not mine."

What bothers me is that we are all playing a zero sum game by design. If I'm going to get ahead, become wealthy, naturally someone else is going to get the bad end of the bargain. Someone has to lose. I can't honestly expect those people who as a result of this basic truth in life are not successful or financially as well off as I, to be able to afford the things that I as a wealthy person take for granted or berate them because I was able to figure out how to outgame them. It's like spiking the ball and doing a dance after a field goal.

I don't know if I explained that well. I tried.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MiddleMolly
Working to better the USA!
02:11 PM on 05/26/2011
Unfortunately, for the most part, I agree with you. The idea behind capitalism SHOULD be that "capitalism lifts all boats". In other words, if you, as a business owner, come up with a good product or service, you make more money, you can pay your employees better and hire more of them, you and your workers can buy more stuff and help raise the boat of others who are providing the product or service that you buy. If you are a decent worker, you can move up and get raises and promotions. Or, if you have entrepreneurial skills and access to capital, you can start your own company, hire people and provide goods and services, and thus raise everybody's "boat".

This is the American Dream based on capitalism. This is what Repubs talk about when the go on about "the sweat of your brow".

It may work for small business people. I know of a small business that actually does run on that principle. They have a 40 year history; they treat their employees well, and everybody has a pretty decently-rising "boat".

More....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MiddleMolly
Working to better the USA!
02:12 PM on 05/26/2011
But it doesn't happen for more and more people. The rich guys who own and run these megacorporations don't value their employees.. they are expendable. They are "expenses", and the idea is to make sure their boats don't get raised by keeping expenses, including employee expenses, down. They reward themselves for keeping their prices down ("staying competitive"), however with bigger and bigger bonuses.

They assuage any conscience they may have towards their treatment of employees, either here or abroad, by adhering to some rhetoric about "making it by the sweat of your brow", trying to convince themselves and others that those who have "made it" are somehow superior to or more hard-working than those who played the game and didn't come out as well.
photo
Zork4
You can have your own opinion, not your own facts.
02:31 PM on 05/26/2011
Right. Fanned and Faved.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cam1002
The People's Budget - It WILL Work
03:35 PM on 05/26/2011
Great, as always. Fanned long ago fav'd again
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ejfreeman
01:15 PM on 05/26/2011
How dare that women not being born to wealth or corrupt politictians or wall st. bankers, how
dare her .