More

German Sprouts Likely E. Coli Culprit In Europe

German Sprouts

KIRSTEN GRIESHABER and TOMISLAV SKARO   06/ 5/11 08:52 PM ET   AP

HAMBURG, Germany — The terrifying E. coli outbreak in Europe appears to have been caused by vegetable sprouts grown on an organic farm in Germany, an agriculture official said Sunday as the toll climbed to at least 22 dead and more than 2,200 sickened.

Preliminary tests found that bean sprouts and other sprout varieties from the farm in the Uelzen area, between the northern cities of Hamburg and Hannover, could be traced to infections in five German states, Lower Saxony Agriculture Minister Gert Lindemann said.

"There were more and more indications in the last few hours that put the focus on this farm," Lindemann said.

Many restaurants involved in what is now the deadliest known E. coli outbreak in modern history had received deliveries of the sprouts, which are often used in salads, Lindemann spokesman Gert Hahne told The Associated Press.

Definitive test results should be available Monday, Lindemann said.

In recent days, as health officials tried to pinpoint the source of the unusually lethal outbreak, suspicion fell on lettuce, cucumbers and tomatoes, perhaps from Spain. Spanish farmers complained that the accusations were having a devastating financial effect.

"First it's the `evil' Spaniards, and then you hear, very surprised, that it is our neighbor," said Dietrich Benni, who lives near the German farm. "It's a bit scary all of this, especially that it is coming from an organic place."

He added: "No more organic food for me for now."

The farm was shut down Sunday and all its produce recalled, including fresh herbs, fruits, flowers and potatoes. Two of its employees were also infected with E. coli, Lindemann said. He said 18 different sprout mixtures from the farm were under suspicion, including sprouts of mung beans, broccoli, peas, chickpeas, garlic lentils and radishes.

As for how the sprouts became contaminated, Lindemann noted that they are grown with steam in barrels at 38 degrees Celsius (100 degrees Fahrenheit) – an ideal environment for bacteria to multiply.

He said it is possible that the water was contaminated with E. coli or that the sprout seeds – purchased in Germany and other countries – contained the germ. He said the farmers had not used any manure, which is commonly spread on organic farms and has been known to cause E. coli outbreaks.

Lindemann urged Germans not to eat sprouts until further notice. He said authorities could not yet rule out other possible sources and warned Germans to continue avoiding tomatoes, cucumbers and lettuce for now.

AP journalists went to the farm on Sunday night, but nobody was available to talk. Telephone messages left at the farm's office were also not immediately returned.

The outbreak has been blamed on a highly aggressive, "super-toxic" strain of E. coli, perhaps one that scientists have never seen before.

E. coli can be found in the feces of humans and livestock and can spread to produce through sloppy bathroom habits among farmworkers and through animal waste in fields and in irrigation water. Organic farms tend to use more manure than other producers do.

Sprouts have been implicated in previous E. coli outbreaks, particularly one in 1996 in Japan, where tainted radish sprouts killed 12 people and reportedly sickened more than 12,000 others.

The head of Germany's national disease control center raised the death toll to 22 Sunday – 21 in Germany and one in Sweden – and said an additional 2,153 people in Germany have been sickened. That figure included 627 people who have developed a rare, serious complication of the disease that can cause kidney failure. Ten other European nations and the U.S. have reported a total of 90 other victims.

Earlier Sunday, Germany's health minister fiercely defended his country's handling of the crisis as he toured a hospital in Hamburg, the epicenter of the emergency.

The comments by Health Minister Daniel Bahr reflected a sharp shift in his public response to the crisis and came after AP journalists reported on emergency room chaos and unsanitary conditions at the same hospital, the University Medical Center in Hamburg-Eppendorf.

On Saturday, Bahr admitted that hospitals in northern Germany were overwhelmed and struggling to provide beds and medical care for victims of the outbreak, and he suggested that other German regions start taking in sick patients from the north.

But after one E. coli survivor told the AP that conditions at the Hamburg hospital were horrendous when she arrived with cramps and bloody diarrhea, Bahr announced a visit and told reporters that German medical workers and northern state governments were doing "everything necessary" to help victims.

Nicoletta Pabst, 41, told the AP that sanitary conditions at the Hamburg-Eppendorf hospital were shocking and its emergency room was overflowing with ailing people when she arrived May 25.

"All of us had diarrhea and there was only one bathroom each for men and women – it was a complete mess," she said Saturday. "If I hadn't been sick with E. coli by then, I probably would have picked it up over there."

Doctors and nurses in northern Germany have been working overtime for weeks since the crisis began May 2.

___

Grieshaber reported from Berlin.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST WORLD

HAMBURG, Germany — The terrifying E. coli outbreak in Europe appears to have been caused by vegetable sprouts grown on an organic farm in Germany, an agriculture official said Sunday as the toll...
HAMBURG, Germany — The terrifying E. coli outbreak in Europe appears to have been caused by vegetable sprouts grown on an organic farm in Germany, an agriculture official said Sunday as the toll...
Filed by Adam J. Rose  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 1,222
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (23 total)
01:00 PM on 06/07/2011
One thing seems certain--there's no end to the theories...notably, the concept that this mutation must have been created in a lab is fascinating in a morbid way. That's what they do in places like Plum Island. Scary, man's inhumanity to man...or nature's inhumanity to man.
02:09 PM on 06/07/2011
The latter is more to the point. For me the tinfoil suggestions demonstrate a deep need on the part of the person proposing it to exert human control in a situation that clearly shows yet again that we are not in charge, and maintain even temporary control only with the greatest effort, clarity, and social coordination.

With all due respect, "nature's inhumanity to man" is a good example of pathetic fallacy, and also makes about as much sense as "man's inmicrobiality to microbes."
outnow
Ban the bomb
03:26 PM on 06/07/2011
So you would attribute the anthrax attacks to the Red Cross or Santa Claus? There are people with motives that you cannot understand.

This bug is either spontaneous or engineered. If it is the former, it will be one of the greatest milestones in bacteriology and the pathogenisis of disease in the entire history of infectious disease. If doubt if that is the case.

Check out computer virus(es). They are not placed there out of the kindness of one's heart.

Malice is not tin foil hat stuff. I wish it were. From everything that I know about bacteriology, this is totally unprecedented.

I referred a patient to the NIH lab yesterday in a case that I have been studying for two years. They can diagnose things that cannot be diagnosed in commercial labs because the evolution has been very fast.

While there are rapid changes in immunity-defeating genetic evolution in bacteria, that speed seen by this e-coli is too rapid for nature. I'm afraid that it is man who created this one.

Believe it or not, some have the motivation and the means to bring this about. Why?

On the other hand, if there can be spontaneous generation in infectious disease, that would be an even bigger problem. Evolution in bacteria is slower than say in viruses that can recombine without a great deal of selection. But if there is no record - a genetic paper trail - then the bug did not likely evolve, more likely, it was engineered.
09:05 AM on 06/08/2011
So you would deny the existence of Plum Island and their mission as fantasy? Strange, given that this was started by a NAZI scientist, brought in under Operation Paperclip after WW II and well documented.

The statement "nature's inhumanity to man" was simply an attempt to be glib. That someone should take it literally demonstrates to me a deep need on the part of the person proposing it to exert ego control in a conversation...pathetic fallacy did you say?

Indeed.
09:29 AM on 06/07/2011
Barn door folks, doesn't matter where it came from anymore. Shutting down that source is irrelavant, it's in the population. The only question in my mind is will it displace "normal" E. coli in most exposed people. If not, less of a problem, if it does, Major problem. E.coli is pretty much a universal part of all mammalian gut flora. We will know in a short time-doubling time for E.coli is every 20 minutes.
02:05 PM on 06/07/2011
This is exactly correct.

Perhaps you have seen this today:

http://www.promedmail.org/pls/apex/f?p=2400:1001:308548810583496::NO::F2400_P1001_BACK_PAGE,F2400_P1001_PUB_MAIL_ID:1000,88778

It may "displace 'normal' /E. coli/ in most exposed people," as you note is a dim possibility. More likely it won't. It will do what many microbial evolutionary experiments do: flourish here and there, and die.

For years I've tried to explain to "raw" milk fanatics that when they talk about how "their grandparents didn't pasteurize milk," they are revealing a truly frightening lack of understanding of food safety principles. I once ran calculations on how many generations of, say, /Listeria/ this represented, then tried to put that in terms of how many human generations that would equal. Not that it seemed to matter; they clung all the more strongly to the romantic principal that nobody in their grandparents' generations ever died of Liquidified Intestine.
outnow
Ban the bomb
03:02 PM on 06/07/2011
We need e-coli.

Bio-gas plants in northern Germany with genetic engineering. They could have done some genetic engineering.

Look at L-tryptophan with "EMS." A bacterium was irradiated to produce more L-tryotophan for use as a Amino-acid supplement. The toxins producede cause people to need heart and lung transplants.

But to systematically breed a bacterium that is immune to all seven major groups of antibiotics and other biological defenses of the human immune system is unprecedented. These bugs must have been bred by systematically exposing the bacteria to sequential doses of antibiotics until only surviving colonies could reproduce, then repeating the process, selectively breeding the most resistent strains.
03:15 PM on 06/06/2011
organic foods are a waste, nothing guarentees they're not compromised... however, it makes libs feel better
01:46 PM on 06/07/2011
You are, of course, entitled to your opinion and your buying choices. And you are entitled to frame your views of the world in whatever way sustains the world view you choose to adopt.

But to argue that "organic foods are a waste" because nothing guarantees 100% purity is a religious argument, not a scientific/empirical observation grounded in the documented effects of agrochemicals on ecosystems and biological systems.

I would much prefer we have the discussion on more intelligent grounds, myself.
outnow
Ban the bomb
03:28 PM on 06/07/2011
"Organic" refers to the manner in which the food is grown, not whether it has bacterial contamination.
03:12 PM on 06/06/2011
figures it would be those "crunchy granola" organic libs food
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:29 PM on 06/06/2011
Because it's not like non-"organic" and processed vegetables and meats have ever had contamination that killed people. *cough* jack in the box *cough*.

The schadenfreude here was entertaining for a while, but now a certain proverb about stones and glass houses begins to come to mind.
11:27 PM on 06/06/2011
or...ahem...taco bell
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
mmkay
Holy Sith! 'mkay?
05:21 PM on 06/06/2011
Hey, don't burn out your 5 watts on our account. We'll manage. Thanks.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robert Turner
News? I hurt the news.
11:43 AM on 06/06/2011
As if we needed a reason to NOT eat bean sprouts.
01:49 PM on 06/07/2011
I laughed. To me, alfalfa sprouts are like a mouthful of hairball.

I sprout all beans before cooking--i.e., soak in water 24 hours, rinse, soak an hour, rinse, keep moist and cool for another 24 or so hours, rinse rinse rinse, then cook. This way the beans require much less energy to cook--10-15 minutes on a low simmer, then an hour or two in the thermal (heatless) cooker.

But once they grow tails, they deserve a little plot of soil for their trouble.
11:40 AM on 06/06/2011
FDA experts have been asking for money from the Government for a program aimed at preventing this exact type of thing. The Republicans have cut their funding because they do not care about people dying. That is a fact.
03:13 PM on 06/06/2011
give it up, you libs are really getting pathetic
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:30 PM on 06/06/2011
You do realize that this situation happened in Europe, in Germany of all places. Where they *have* such programs that you speak of.
photo
cheo
better a bleeding heart than none at all
11:30 AM on 06/06/2011
I meant to mention, HP, it's sort of weird to have a story on one HP page which says it's sprouts, and another story on another HP page which says it isn't sprouts after all.

Keeping this story doesn't seem too relevant.
photo
cheo
better a bleeding heart than none at all
11:25 AM on 06/06/2011
Sprouts aren't the problem and neither is whether they are organic or not. Whether it's certified organic or it's the stuff in the bigger bins isn't going to guarantee better food handling practices, or guarantee what it was fertilized with or growing next to, or sitting next to when shipped.

There are many strains of e.coli, and I haven't heard any conclusions about the strain. More will come as the investigation narrows it down.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/06/06/sprouts-e-coli-outbreak-germany-_n_871756.html

But whoever on this thread said it was a bad time to be trying to defund the FDA is spot on. More frequent inspections wouldn't eliminate all outbreaks, but would help limit them.
And more research needs to be funded, by other than invested parties.
photo
piul05
Can I have a biscuit yet?
photo
cheo
better a bleeding heart than none at all
09:12 PM on 06/06/2011
They have; so has lettuce, cucumbers, other raw vegetables and so has ground beef.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
naschkatze
A free man creates himself.
11:02 AM on 06/06/2011
Guess I will not be making my Gado-Gado salad afterall.
photo
gwinegarden
She's an Arctic Wolf
10:47 AM on 06/06/2011
If true, this is not the first time. A while back, restaurants were offering food without sprouts.
10:39 AM on 06/06/2011
Today's news (see USA Today
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hungrypilot
Iraq Vet, Far From Ordinary
10:27 AM on 06/06/2011
Nobody's blaming Obama? It must be Monday...
10:29 AM on 06/06/2011
babblebabblebabblebabbleOBAMAbabblebabblebabble!!!

There. Happy?
photo
stevef123811
Veteran and legal American
12:09 PM on 06/06/2011
Blame Obama? Get up to date it's G.W. Bush's fault.
photo
NYnotLiberal
Don't crush that Dwarf, hand me the pliers.
10:14 AM on 06/06/2011
Sprouts....I only eat these buggers in Szechuan Chinese fare. Hmmmm. And I like to give a shout-out to my pal Capsaicin........man, my mouth is watering just thinking about it....where's the take-out menu?
photo
TheDodoBird
Registered Voter
10:12 AM on 06/06/2011
Hey everyone, E.coli is not a virus. It is a Bacteria.

There is a BIG difference between the two. For one, you can treat viruses with antibiotics (so long as they are not resistant). For two, BAC is considered living, whereas a virus is not. They both affect the body in much different ways.

A few posts down, Scully001 raised a good point: this strain had to have been created in a lab for it to be resistant to so many antiBACs. Genetic mutation from random evolutionary events would have a VERY low probability of resulting in a strain that was, coincidentally, resistant to so many different types of antiBACs.

Now I am not saying that this is some sort of intention... but it is perplexing.
photo
TheDodoBird
Registered Voter
10:14 AM on 06/06/2011
Sorry, typo.... "For one, you can treat viruses with antibiotic­s (so long as they are not resistant)­." should have said "you can treat bacteria with antibiotics"

I guess this is how easy it is to mix this one up!
10:27 AM on 06/06/2011
Neither am I, but of course the tin foil hat comments keep coming.
10:05 AM on 06/06/2011
Update: German bean sprouts NOT the culprit!!!

Best to wait to make sure about something before publishing/posting a story like this.

I expect some law suits.
photo
piul05
Can I have a biscuit yet?
11:01 AM on 06/06/2011
still to early to tell what it was, but there is evidence showing it was not the sprouts.
10:43 AM on 06/06/2011
Hmmmm, Every major credible news outlet is pinning it on German bean sprouuts. Unless you have a link otherwise, I'll believe them.

By the way; you may not be familiar with this in the German ministry of propaganda, but in the US, we have a law against astroturfing: 16 CFR 255.