More

AARP Launches Second Ad To Fight GOP Medicare Plan

Aarp Medicare

First Posted: 06/16/11 09:06 AM ET Updated: 08/16/11 06:12 AM ET

WASHINGTON -- Maybe the government should cut funding for treadmills for shrimp and poetry in zoos before hacking away at Medicare or Social Security, the influential lobby for older Americans, AARP, is arguing in a new national TV ad released Thursday.

With Congress and the White House locked in intense negotiations over spending cuts and the nation's looming debt limit, the multimillion-dollar ad buy marks AARP's second major campaign aimed at derailing proposals to cut and privatize Medicare and Social Security.

AARP had been relatively quiet when House Budget Committee Chairman Rep. Paul Ryan (R-Wis.) first released his proposal in the spring that included a spending plan that replaces Medicare with a private system the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office found would nearly double costs for seniors over 10 years.

Democrats had worried that AARP was standing on the sidelines, but sources familiar with the influential lobby say it didn't think the Ryan plan could pass.

The fact that it has made its second expensive ad buy suggests it is much more worried now that some of the Ryan ideas could be adopted in the high-pressure budget negotiations being conducted on Capitol Hill. That pressure will only rise as negotiations near Aug. 2, the date by which Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner has warned the country must hike its $14.3 trillion borrowing cap or face default.

"While some members of Congress are considering making changes to Medicare’s structure, what few people realize is that some proposals being discussed behind closed doors include harmful cuts to the critical Medicare and Social Security benefits that are lifelines for millions of today’s seniors," said AARP's Nancy LeaMond.

The new ad takes a more mocking tone thanAARP's first spot, pointing to several questionable programs funded by Congress over the last few years, including a cotton institute in Brazil, treadmills for shrimp and poetry in zoos.

Those efforts likely don't amount to much in the greater federal budget, but the point is clear.

"Instead of cutting waste, or closing tax loopholes, next month Congress could make a deal that cuts Medicare, even Social Security," says the ad script. "I guess it’s easier to cut the benefits we earned -- than to cut pickle technology."

WATCH:

AARP has also mounted a broader lobbying effort that includes a petition that it says has been signed by nearly 1.5 million people, and a campaign that has generated almost 260,000 phones calls and emails to members of Congress.

LeaMond says the new ad "will put Congress on notice that AARP will fight with the strength of our millions of members to prevent harmful cuts to Medicare and Social Security from being included in any deal to pay the nation’s bills."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST POLITICS
Subscribe to the HuffPost Hill newsletter!
WASHINGTON -- Maybe the government should cut funding for treadmills for shrimp and poetry in zoos before hacking away at Medicare or Social Security, the influential lobby for older Americans, AARP, ...
WASHINGTON -- Maybe the government should cut funding for treadmills for shrimp and poetry in zoos before hacking away at Medicare or Social Security, the influential lobby for older Americans, AARP, ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 2,877
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (37 total)
  1 of 6  
COMMUNITY PUNDITS
photo
Cambridge9 09:56 AM on 06/16/2011
A few weeks ago I received an e-mail (which was meant as a 'funny') but I've been thinking about it.

The e-mail suggested that all 'seniors' should be put in jail where they would get free room and board, free medical treatment, free TV and exercise in a protected yard.

Meanwhile prison inmates should be incarcerated in 'senior citizens' homes' - where they would have to pay their own way  Read More...
06:07 PM on 07/13/2011
AARP already backed the Democrats cuts to Medicare when they cut $460 BILLION from them.
Now they're crying over peanuts?


"AARP Backs Democrats On Medicare Cuts In Senate Health Care Fight"
12/ 2/09

"With a Senate showdown looming, the politically potent AARP rode to the rescue of Democrats on Wednesday, supporting $460 billion in Medicare cuts to help pay for landmark health care legislation."

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/12/02/aarp-backs-democrats-on-m_n_377582.html
09:13 AM on 06/18/2011
RE: "Too bad that Aarp has betrayed us. "

===AARP is for AARP and what sells their products. They were formed by the insurance industry to speak for the seniors What part of that information is confusing about AARP They will support whatever is in their best interest. They support Medicare because they allow the plans they promote The govt has given AARP plans their approval. They support senior programs because it is in their interest.
07:13 AM on 06/18/2011
Too bad that Aarp has betrayed us.

The Republican leaders have created this crisis with expensive wars, tax cuts and giving tax breaks to those who move jobs overseas.

There has been a lack of control over Medical care. Some say we pay twice for health care than other countries. The government could bid and negotiate and bring prices down.

The government spends a lot of money on medical care. Most of the elected and appointed are eligible for a cadilac version. They can also retire at 56, so we are paying them a pension for continuing doing nothing.
06:59 PM on 06/17/2011
everyone needs to leave SS alone. If indeed those people needs to "cut" somewhere let them cut their own pay or not get raises. After all the people on SS does not get pay raises anymore. Why? Because no one wants to accept the responisbilty to cut their own pay or refuse pay rasies.
05:38 PM on 06/17/2011
This is the best and most truthful political commercial I have ever seen...I once seen where the govement pay's people to study how fast ketsup comes out of the bottle....Most definitely they should cut all the frivolous studies before cutting anything from the Social Secuity.....Our elderly have nothing as it is!!!
07:00 PM on 06/17/2011
I have heard of this too. Someone needed a job so a job was "thought up" for them. Do u know how much we paid for this? I would like to know.
sammayer
1957 Classic
04:46 PM on 06/17/2011
AARP, the powerful lobbying group for older Americans, is dropping its longstanding opposition to cutting Social Security benefits, a move that could rock Washington's debate over how to revamp the nation's entitlement programs.

http://www.facebook.com/l.php?u=http%3A%2F%2Fonline.wsj.com%2Farticle%2FSB1000142405270230418640457638976095...5403414.html%3Fmod%3Dgooglenews_wsj%23articleTabs%3Darticle&h=cd117

AARP is a money making corporation and not a social service/union of elders they purport to be. I joined AARP at 50 and found some discounts...but only those I could get in any other way, like asking the hotel if they had a discount. They want to fill their rooms...duh!

For the most part, scheduling trips, buying insurance, getting loans and other services were less beneficial through AARP than going it alone. This is certainly the last straw for me. EXPEDIA IS ALSO HISTORY!

Being a card carrying senior does not have its advantages when the group, who you think would be on your side, acts so diametrically opposed to your best interest. I'm cancelling my memberships for my partner and I as soon as I stroke this last key.
photo
K August
Research alecexposed
11:45 PM on 06/17/2011
WSJ was NOT accurate in their reporting according to the AARP.

Their reporting is probably aimed at getting people like you worked up.
sammayer
1957 Classic
11:02 AM on 06/20/2011
I would not be so gullible to believe AARP's defense of AARP, "...probably aimed at getting people like you..." more confused.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:29 PM on 06/17/2011
for our political cult in Washington anyone not giving into the system with time money and labor are taking out of the system..everything they think and do is about reducing the output and increasing the input..older people have no value to the system becasue they can not be indentured servants anymore best they wither and die and unburden the politicians load...

this is what your dealing with...people that have let personal gain and greed decide their humanity..This is why they commit war crimes around the world..this is why they fund ethnic cleansing in the middle east..this is why they allow corporations to exploit indigenous peoples in other nations..this is why they allow BP no regulation or oversight...i could go on and on....ACTIONS don't match words of "Concern"
12:56 PM on 06/17/2011
For those 54 and under, think about how you would have asked for a raise in order to finance your retirement, if you had known this cutting was going to happen.

They need to increase benefits, not cut them because you are paying in more than some of the boomers have because the ceiling keeps going up.
07:03 PM on 06/17/2011
yes I agree. I am on disabilty. I do not get a cost of living raise. I make about 400 a month. My mother is 89 and her pay is about 800 a month. How can anyone live off this?
07:20 AM on 06/18/2011
You are probably eligible for a lot of help like with food stamps.

Your health care should be paid by the government. So should your mother's.

Most people who are disabled get more money than you do. They use to pay what you would get if you reached full retirement age.
photo
K August
Research alecexposed
11:48 PM on 06/17/2011
Don't vote Republican then.......they are the ones who are trying to abolish Medicare and turn Social Security into a big wallet for Wall Street and the Bankers.
They want to scare everyone.......so they are telling us that we must privatize everything.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cliff53
10:58 AM on 06/17/2011
If our leaders would just stop using their head for a hat rack and bring our brave men and women home from Iraq and Afghanistan, and any other foreign country where we have bases and troops, and stop giving foreign countries aid countries that hate us, using our troops to secure our borders, we would probably have money left over to increase benefits, and hopefully even cut taxes. Now see, that was easy and I do not even wear a hat.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cliff53
10:48 AM on 06/17/2011
If all the politicians were covered under SS and Medicare like all citizens, instead they are covered by their own Neiman Marcus plan, this subject of reducing SS, Medicare would probably not even be up for discussion.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:29 AM on 06/17/2011
AARP sold seniors out in 2003. They remained quiet because they can benifit from the Ryan Medicare Reform plan. There commerical "Stinks!" Instead of talking about Govt. Programs that are so trivial as far as funding waist, why dont they really tell the truth. The Weather and Corporations are UNDER TAXED. They should be paying there share of Taxes. AARP would certainly alienate themselves from there Supporters for sure. That is why I refuse to Join AARP. The're as phoney as a 6 dollar bill.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GrumpyinAZ
My opinion is worth every penny you paid for it
10:22 AM on 06/17/2011
The GOP Pathway bto Poverty Voucher Plan will destroy Medicare Suppliment plans and leave millions of seniors paying 3-5 times as much for health insurance
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
stargazer13
To Love One Is To Love All
08:43 AM on 06/17/2011
yeah I think I do hear something ?

what is it ?

54 and younger being pulled down the bathtub drain
12:31 PM on 06/17/2011
People who are 54 have been working for 35 years or so and paying their fair share all that time. Jerking the rug out from under them is no more fair than for the folks born a year or two earlier...it is not fair for 53 year olds or 52 year olds...or 51 year olds...50 year olds...or...well you get the pix.
12:46 PM on 06/17/2011
You are right. They want to make sure that you will have to invest in the stock market by cutting Social Security benefits.

They want to cut Medicare benefits rather than control the greed in the health industry.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
stargazer13
To Love One Is To Love All
08:38 AM on 06/17/2011
nobody over 55 will have to worry those 54 and under !

good luck your on your own I guess !

now can I have all that money that was paid in over the the 40 years by me and my husband

I mean we would like to have all of it back with interest of course calculated for every year !
07:22 AM on 06/18/2011
Those over 54 are working to stop them from cutting benefits on the under 55 crowd.

I think they will cut it slowly. I am not positive though. At 54 you won't be cut as much as if you were 34, etc. The thing is the retirees under 55 now will need more money than ever, not Social Security and Medicare cuts.

The gov doesn't have the money to pay off those who want to settle for cash. They have to pay back a lot to Social Security for what they borrowed.
07:47 AM on 06/17/2011
On Bloomberg this morning they said that Aarp has decided not to try to stop them from cutting Social Security benefits.

It isn't Aarp's money or the government's money. It should not be up to them what happens to the program.

Aarp is also reneging on protecting Medicare.

Aarp may have been offered a deal they couldn't refuse. Aarp sells lots of Medicap policies. One of the cuts to Medicare is 'prohibiting Medicap from paying the first $500 and half of the next $5000. Of the first $5500 of medical costs, the elderly will pay $3000, plus premiums. Aarp probably wrote that clause.

It will increase their profits by a lot.

The expense is going to stop people up front from using Medicare and Medicap.

I don't know if those on Medicap now are grandfathered in.

I don't know if they will count medicine as part of the first medical costs, since neither program pays for prescriptions. When people have high prescription costs because there is no generics there should be an adjustment for that.

Many people have told me not to trust Aarp, now I believe them. Too sad.

It is a double whammy.