iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Jon Huntsman Predicts 'Major Problems' Ahead For China

Jon Huntsman

First Posted: 06/20/11 01:00 PM ET Updated: 08/20/11 06:12 AM ET

WASHINGTON -- Former U.S. Ambassador to China Jon Huntsman usually speaks about that country in general terms: China is rising; America must reform to stay ahead.

But in a private conference call with a handful of university students around the country last week, the Republican presidential candidate predicted "major problems" ahead for China, as a rising standard of living increases awareness of political oppression and intensifies resistance to the government's control.

"There's still that great divide between the economic class and the political class," Huntsman said, according to a recording of the call obtained by The Huffington Post. "And at some point, as you get 300 and 400 million people who now become members of what will be the largest middle class in the world, they're going to have to make some really tough choices about how you bridge the economic and the political chasm, which is not easily done."

"If they don't do it, they're likely to have some sort of head-on collision, I would say four or five years into the future."

While China's economy has become more open, Huntsman said, the country's internal political system lags far behind.

"If you do not have political freedoms that run in parallel with economic development and reform -- if you don't have political reform -- at some point you're going to find yourself in a pretty precarious situation, one that will force you to address it as opposed to allowing you to evolve," he said.

Beijing's centralized control of the political system through the nine-member Politburo Standing Committee, Huntsman said, has enabled China's leaders to stay "singularly focused" on building the country into an economic and military superpower.

But, he said, "longer term, you're going to find real problems."

"So look at the economic model of China, but make sure that any analysis you do is caveated with where people are politically -- lack of political reform, liberalization, lack of real market opening reforms -- where you still have a lot of what I would consider to be crony capitalism and markets that are showing favoritism to certain groups within the country," he said.

The call was organized by Students for Solvency, a group that grew out of Students for Daniels, which had hoped that Indiana Gov. Mitch Daniels would run for president. After Daniels declined to jump in the race, about 38 of the group's 68 chapters united behind Huntsman. The chapters range in size from a few members to as many as 20 people.

Huntsman returned at the end of April from Beijing, after serving as ambassador for a little less than two years. Prior to his foreign service, he was governor of Utah. He is set to officially launch his campaign for president on Tuesday with a speech in front of the Statue of Liberty in New York, and will then travel to New Hampshire.

Huntsman's comments on China are the most expansive he has given since he began campaigning one month ago. He has said that America's global dominance is threatened by China's ascendance, but has also said that the U.S. does not have to be overtaken. He has also shared anecdotes about political dissidents in China, highlighting oppression by the regime in Beijing.

But in his comments to the students on the call, Huntsman also painted a dire picture of America's trajectory if nothing is done to reduce the U.S. government's mounting debt.

"You just extrapolate the numbers to 2022 and you all can do the math. You can kind of see what you're likely to inherit if you move along in your professional careers. You're basically kissing goodbye to the end of the American century," Huntsman said.

As for how to rein in the debt, Huntsman did not mention entitlement spending, but did say he favors an amendment to the Constitution requiring a balanced federal budget each year, a proposal is also being championed by Sen. Jim DeMint (R-S.C.).

"We're going to have to fight for a balanced budget amendment," Huntsman said. "Every governor in this country has a balanced budget amendment. It keeps everybody honest. It's the best safeguard imaginable."

He also said the federal budget should be "more like 18 or 19 percent" of gross domestic product, rather than the current rate of 25 percent.

Students on the call asked Huntsman which books had most influenced his views on governance. His answer: Alexis de Tocqueville's "Democracy in America," Kuan Yew Lee's "From Third World To First: The Singapore Story: 1965-2000" and Ronald Reagan's memoirs.

One student did not like what the book selections reflected.

"He strikes me as a pro-business technocrat, a la [Mitt] Romney, and not a conservative of conviction and political courage," Jeremy Rozansky, a rising senior at the University of Chicago who is policy director of Students for Solvency, told The Huffington Post. "I was especially dismayed by his three books answer. 'Third World to First' is not the story of the success of conservative principles but of the success of smart economic cronyism."

But others were impressed with Huntsman.

"Our generation is more pessimistic than ever about the future of their country and Governor Huntsman projects an attitude of confidence and optimism that is largely absent from the GOP discussion of austerity," said Merrill Anovick, a rising sophomore at Johns Hopkins University. "More than any of the other candidates on either side of the aisle, Huntsman speaks to the issue that most concerns our generation: unsustainable debt and deficits."

Matthew Kidd, a Texas Tech student who was on the call, called Huntsman "the best candidate in the Republican field."

Polls, however, show Huntsman with a very steep hill to climb to overcome negative perceptions of his affiliation with Obama and some of his more centrist positions.

When asked about those polls on the call, Huntsman said, "Polls that are taken at this stage are very fickle ... subject to immediate change."

* * * * *

The Huffington Post wants to know about the campaign ads, town halls, robocalls, mailings and other election news happening where you live. E-mail us your tips, videos and photos to offthebus@huffingtonpost.com.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST POLITICS
Subscribe to the HuffPost Hill newsletter!
WASHINGTON -- Former U.S. Ambassador to China Jon Huntsman usually speaks about that country in general terms: China is rising; America must reform to stay ahead. But in a private conference call ...
WASHINGTON -- Former U.S. Ambassador to China Jon Huntsman usually speaks about that country in general terms: China is rising; America must reform to stay ahead. But in a private conference call ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 612
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (17 total)
08:50 AM on 06/29/2011
A balanced budget amendment? Why don't we go back on the gold standard while we're at it? Idiot.
03:29 AM on 06/22/2011
Yup! Yes'iree Bob! China with the $3 Trillion in foreign currency reserves and minimal deficit and 17% government (as percent of total economy) will face insurmountable problems. America, on the other hand, has extra trillions to give away (over $3 T given to the banksters since the 2008 debacle), 25,000 executed every single year by gunshot alone (according to the CDC), and decades more of unending wars, has no problems.

Wow, such confident leaders. Americans are really blessed. Is Hunter Mormon? Have you watched the Mormon muscial? What's the name of the equivalent (or direct opposite) of Hakuna Matada?
02:41 PM on 06/21/2011
Seeing as how we're faced with a lack of jobs and economic opportunity instead of a lack of vitriol and religiously motivated hate, I'll take a pro-business technocrat over a conservative of conviction, thanks.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DAE
11:01 AM on 06/21/2011
Here's why Huntsman doesn't know what he's talking about. I just came across this headline at Google News: "Chinese man gets death in pollution protest case." Now upon reading that headline most would think, oh those poor Chinese, their government sentences you to death for protesting pollution, How dreadful. Well read the story (http://af.reuters.com/article/energyOilNews/idAFL3E7HL1ZG20110621). The death sentence was given to a Han Chinese who killed an ethnic Mongolian pollution protester! Just the opposite of what one would think from the headline. It goes to show that, 1) headlines can be very misleading and 2) the Chinese authorities will go to great lengths to try to quell protests by placating the protesters. They have the resources and savvy to do so,
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ethical Cat
09:03 AM on 06/21/2011
Those predictions are nothing new, having appeared in various magazines and international papers years ago. Mr Huntsman is not "predicting" anything new. He is merely repeating what he has read and many have known all these while. Move on...
photo
WiltonDiary
JoeMcNamara
04:26 AM on 06/21/2011
When you see American Manufacturing going down, down, and down. Put the blame where it belongs, the people who buy the cheap foreign products. The American People. I know, I know, asking Americans to take responsibility is a tall order.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DAE
11:50 PM on 06/20/2011
Most of the unrest in China comes from four sources. First, disaffected minorities in the border regions. The Chinese can easily control these disturbances by force of arms, but they're smarter than that now and send in work teams to resolve outstanding problems to placate them. Of course the ringleaders are generally given prison sentences for disturbing the peace. That happens here as well. A local lawyer who advocates for the homeless in Santa Cruz, CA is now in jail on high bail for leading a sleep-in at City Hall protesting an outdoor local sleeping ban. The second group of protests are engaged in by migrant workers, peasants from the countryside who take low-paying menial jobs in construction and low skilled jobs in industry. Many are young women. They are equivalent to undocumented workers in the US and have the lowest status. The government is starting to address the migrant labor problem by extending urban residency status to them and other reforms including increases in minimum wage and enforcement of laws that require payment of wages. Third, other labor issues that lead to strikes are being resolved by negotiations and experiments with collective bargaining. The fourth source results from illegal seizures of peasant land by local governments in league with land speculators. The central government has issued edicts prohibiting this practice but it's hard to enforce. All of these issues are destabilizing but the government should be able to deal with them if it plays its cards right.
10:16 PM on 06/20/2011
He doesn't appear to understand the Chinese. The Chinese are TRUE believers in loyalty and UNITY. Political unity and obedience to authority is a powerful motif in Chinese culture. it's the reason the government would likely never be overthrown.
12:32 PM on 06/21/2011
Loyalty, hmm..
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_rebellions_in_China

Still I agree with what you said about the belief in unity. Look back at the history of China between 221BC (end of feudalism and the first unification in China) and Year 2011, there were over 60% of the time that China existed as a state of peace and unity. Separation, war and chaos never lasted long, even if they were lasting, the ultimate purpose for every warfare was never to plunder, but to pursue peace and unity.

The hope in unity has been not only a common aspiration among people in Mainland China, but also a deep-rooted ideology among Taiwan nationalists and conservatives. This becomes the reason that the expectation of "recapture Mainland China" has never vanished in minds of Taiwan people, despite the obvious difference between the military power of Taiwan and that of People's Republic of China.
05:33 PM on 06/21/2011
To understand China regarding to moral, ethic teaching, loyality, ymanity, righteousness, you need to compare her with the west in term of christianity. There are hyprocrites in both societies and di bad things in those names and there are people who really believed them and being "stupid". In the final analysis, is there better to have standards than without. I believe so. When the hyprocrites are much more than the stupid ones, you have a terible period. When you have more stupid ones, you have a better period. Just tell this to the Washington politicians.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
westronandnan
08:02 PM on 06/20/2011
The decisions and programs promoted by Huntsman while he was governator of Utah will create problems for him among the more conservative members of the Republican/Tea Party. They'll end up spittin' him out like a sunflower seed even though he's a very bright person.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
smburwick
07:51 PM on 06/20/2011
RINO.
07:39 PM on 06/20/2011
Sad. He is supposed to be an expert on China. He missed the whole boat. China's fear is not the middle class will gain more freedom. Her fear is 2/3 of the population who are poor trying to stop the train.
03:40 AM on 06/22/2011
Kissinger was the only real expert on China. He was able to secure for Americans from China, 30 years of peace and unwavering financial support - well priced daily necessities and small luxuries kept inflation at close to zero, and Beijing recycled much of the trade dollars (not just trade profits, but all the dollars exchanged for the newly minted RMB) to buy American treasuries and GSEs at ridiculously low rates, thereby providing Americans with ultra cheap financing. For 3 decades there were lots of jobs, and asset prices keep rising. That was the good life - until the banksters totally blew it for everyone in 2008.

Kissinger does not speak Chinese, but he speaks a language that the Chinese can understand and respect. The likes of Huntsman and Australia's Rudd can speak enough Chinese to get in trouble, but they have no clue. Did you ever see Dr. K rooting around Beijing on a Hog, and bragging about supporting subversives?

Don't have a clue.
07:30 PM on 06/20/2011
Huntsman's scant two years in China wasn't enough to really understand the culture, apparently. The Chinese are very competitve and much more willing to sumit to authority than we are. They also have a much more developed sense of honor and behaviour that mitigates against abuse of power, and probably does no worse than our tricameral system, over all.
Huntsman is making the American Classic Error: inside every Asian is a Middle Class American, just waiting to get out.
Viet Nam and Korea should have taught us, that's not true.
China's gov't has done well for it's people.
Nobody wants "freedom" for it's own sake.
Freedom from what? They own America!
China's gov't only has to get a better grip on a few problems, and it has the money to do it.
Whether it will or not, is the question, which has only a a little to do with China's rising middle class.
As for us, I think the American Century is about over.
We might be able to get it back, in a few decades, but trying to save it, at this point, is a lost cause.
And really, who wants to dominate the world?
Lots of countries don't and things are fine, for them.
Conversely, things have ended poorly for every country that did.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
flossophy
the unfamous anti-establishment classical liberal
07:35 PM on 06/20/2011
Watch the video I linked below. You'll enjoy it.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
flossophy
the unfamous anti-establishment classical liberal
07:36 PM on 06/20/2011
And youtube some Niall Ferguson while you're at it.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PierreSD
07:28 PM on 06/20/2011
There's also a demographic nightmare approaching due to the regime's shortsighted One Child policy. Too many boys, not enough girls, sure to create problems...
03:42 AM on 06/22/2011
How is that a problem? There are LOTS of neighboring countries' girls dying to marry into China.
07:08 PM on 06/20/2011
Last week the Wall Street Journal ran a front-page article entitled "Wave of Unrest Rocks China:"
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304665904576383142907232726.html
None of the mainstream US media picked it up, and I don't even hear Huntsman mentioning it. The comment by "mathomps" is interesting, "They are more "free" in their everyday lives than we are and they are much happier and far more proud of their own country than we are." Hmmm, something isn't adding up.
07:03 PM on 06/20/2011
they really gonna be screwed holding all those worthless dollar securities.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kevin Rayburn
GET YOUR GOVERNMENT OUT OF MY LIVINGROOM
11:30 PM on 06/20/2011
china sure has bought bags of wooden nickles from the usa.