iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Israeli 'Freedom Riders' Ensure A Woman's Place At Front Of The Bus

Orthodox Jewish Women Bus

First Posted: 07/13/11 03:01 PM ET Updated: 09/12/11 06:12 AM ET

By Michele Chabin
c. 2011 Religion News Service

JERUSALEM (RNS) Vera Kreidlin boarded an empty No. 56 bus for the 25-minute ride from a religious neighborhood in the heart of the city to Ramat Shlomo, an ultra-Orthodox Jewish enclave in East Jerusalem.

Dressed in a cotton shirt and jeans on a sweltering July day, Kreidlin opted for a seat near the front, three rows behind the driver. It would have been enough to make Rosa Parks proud.

Along the way, the bus stopped to pick up fervently religious men in crisp black suits. The vast majority of the women who boarded the bus, all of them modestly dressed, entered through the bus' center door. And every single one headed for the rear.

For years, the No. 56 route has been known as a segregated line, one of nearly 60 public bus lines around the country where women have felt compelled to sit in the back of the bus while the men rode up front.

Although Kreidlin, a 25-year-old graduate student at Hebrew University, appeared relaxed, she was on high alert for passengers who might try to force her -- verbally or physically -- to join the other women at the back of the bus.

In the ultra-Orthodox world, it is religiously immodest for unrelated men and women to interact on a casual basis, even if they're all crammed onto a crowded bus. In recent years, public Israeli bus companies have tried to woo religious passengers by promoting gender separation.

Last January, Israel's High Court ruled gender segregation must be entirely voluntary.

"I'm here to see whether the court's ruling banning religious coercion on public buses is being enforced," said Kreidlin, a secular Jew. "The court ruled that every bus must have a sign stating that passengers may sit wherever they choose, and that intimidating someone is illegal."

The sign was nowhere to be found on the No. 56.

Gazing at the women and girls in the rear, Kreidlin said she has taken many such rides in recent weeks "to show the passengers, and especially the religious women, that they're free to sit wherever they want. Sometimes, when they see other women already sitting in the front, they decide to sit up here too."

On July 7, the Jerusalem-based Israel Religious Action Center (IRAC), which had successfully petitioned the High Court to ban religious coercion on public transit, officially launched a program to encourage visiting Jewish tour groups to ride the once-segregated buses.

Anat Hoffman, who heads IRAC, said the Freedom Rider program, which was inspired by the civil rights activists who challenged racial segregation in the American South, is a way to share Israelis' struggle against religious coercion with Jews around the world.

Prior to the court ruling, Israelis and foreigners rode the segregated buses, and their reports were eventually tallied and
submitted to the court, Hoffman said.

Like the female passengers who initiated the court petition, some of the volunteers were subjected "to verbal abuse, pushing, name calling and shouting," Hoffman noted.

Since the court's decision, Hoffman said, the number of bus lines that are segregated has fallen from 56 to 16. "On some of these buses," she said, "women can't even go up to the front door to pay for their tickets."

Still, she noted, reported incidents of violence or the driver actively prohibiting women from the front of buses have "decreased considerably."

Egged, the bus company that runs most of the once-segregated bus lines, declined to comment on the bus monitors, but Egged spokesman Ron Retner said the company has trained drivers and installed signs on every route to comply with the court ruling.

"Except for occasional incidents that interfere with public order, there has been no need for any further involvement," Retner said.

The volunteer riders will be expected to sit near the front half of buses on the segregated routes, space permitting, and report any harassment by the driver or fellow passengers.

Amy Milin, a recent graduate of Florida Atlantic University who spent the past three months interning at IRAC, said the atmosphere on the buses has recently changed for the better.

Standing at a Jerusalem bus stop, Milin, who rode on 60 buses during her internship, said "there were times a group of people crowded around me and said I don't belong here and I'm ruining their religion." But it got better toward the end of her internship, she said.

Milin said the struggle is worthwhile "because there are many, many Orthodox women" who have called IRAC and other organizations "to say they want to be able to sit with their husbands or sons but are afraid to out of fear of being ostracized in their communities."

At another stop along route 56, an ultra-Orthodox high school student who would only give her name as Sarah said she'd head to the back of the bus "not because anyone is forcing me to, but because the Torah commands us to live modestly.

"This is my decision," she asserted, "no one else's."

If women like Sarah truly want to sit in the back of the bus, that's fine with Kreidlin, the Hebrew University grad student.

"I would never try to convince a woman to sit in the front. The goal is to inform people of their option to sit wherever they want," she said. "The issue is free choice."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST RELIGION

By Michele Chabin c. 2011 Religion News Service JERUSALEM (RNS) Vera Kreidlin boarded an empty No. 56 bus for the 25-minute ride from a religious neighborhood in the heart of the city to Ramat Shl...
By Michele Chabin c. 2011 Religion News Service JERUSALEM (RNS) Vera Kreidlin boarded an empty No. 56 bus for the 25-minute ride from a religious neighborhood in the heart of the city to Ramat Shl...
Filed by Bryan Maygers  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 452
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (7 total)
05:04 PM on 07/19/2011
How so very sad. I am not referring to the actual story of religious fanatics enforcing, illegally it seems, gender segregation on some Israeli buses but rather to the widespread jewish paranoia that any criticism of Israel or in this case a part of Israel society must be viewed as a nefarious plot to destroy Israel. They view the world as Israel haters, trying to demonizing or delegitimizing Israel and that any criticism is an existential threat that must be attacked by whatever means available. They do Israel no great favor as in a sense they are creating a self fulfilling prophecy and does great harm. They so overreact that most of the world tunes them out and treats them with scorn. My advice, and I'm sure it's unwanted, is to pick your battles where it is important and stop overreacting.
photo
Down in FL
It's all about the density of states
12:36 AM on 07/18/2011
Why couldn't we have been stuck with less prudish religions?
02:58 PM on 07/23/2011
I invented my own religion. It is only slightly prudish.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Barbara Graham
Comin at u from Area 5150
07:52 PM on 07/17/2011
Wow...John Lennon was right!
02:51 PM on 07/18/2011
You'll need to be more specific.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thebosssssny
01:42 AM on 07/17/2011
The religous men and women WANT to sit seperate. The men don't mind giving the women the front of the bus and they will gladly take the back. No one can force them to sit together. The men and women are both for this. If a man or woman has an urge to sit together let them, no one stops them.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
KrautMan
Carpe jugulum
08:18 AM on 07/18/2011
You obviously didn't read the article.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thebosssssny
08:01 AM on 07/20/2011
I was once part of that crowed, lived there and rode those busses. I have seen it and am more qualified to write an article about this then this writer
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Forester
Overeducated woods worker.
04:24 PM on 07/16/2011
There are public buses today that run from NYC to upstate NY that mostly hesidics use that have a curtain running down the center of the bus to separate the genders.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
candyekane
Singer, Songwriter, Libertarian, Activist
03:15 AM on 07/16/2011
What makes Israel a democracy is the existence of Christian Churches, synagogues, Buddhist and Hindu Temples and Mosques. Women vote and drive and are given equality. In no other country in the Middle East, including relatively progressive Dubai, will you see synagogues and Christian and Catholic churches side by side Mosques. This is what gives Israel the right to claim democratic status. Israel has nothing to gain by "preferring dictators" or dictatorships in their neighboring countries, nor has the Israeli govt or citizenry ever stated such. Israel wants to be left alone in peace. Every war with Israel was provoked by another country.

If you actually read this article, The Israeli government is forcing the Ultra Orthodox to de-segregate the bus lines. Thats what the article is about. A government cannot stop religious extremists from wanting to practice Biblically based inequality but the government can enforce laws that protect those who dont want to adhere to these backward practices. The Israeli government created this law and uses the freedom fighters to enforce the law. Hooray for Israel that they are finding small ways to fight religious extremism within their own borders.
photo
Marcus047
given up on HP
10:38 AM on 07/16/2011
not to mention that gay and lesbian palestinians are doing everything they can to get into israel where they are safe from persecution and death at the hands of their families.
11:23 PM on 07/15/2011
If Israel's leaders didn't proudly declare to the world, in speeches and interviews time and again, that they deserve support because of their Judeo-Christian Western values of freedom, justice, equality, democracy blah blah blah this wouldn't be news. If those same excuses weren't used by American politicians to justify shoveling American money to Israel faster than Israel can spend it this wouldn't be such big news. But because those things are true, news like this grates.
photo
Marcus047
given up on HP
07:18 PM on 07/15/2011
Good for them. Religious based intolerance and descrimination is as vile as intolerance and descrimination because of someone's religion.
04:48 PM on 07/15/2011
We have a similar situation here in the U.S. as well.
http://www.nytimes.com/1994/09/09/nyregion/discrimination-discourtesy-commuter-won-t-leave-her-bus-seat-for-hasidic-prayer.html
I am always amazed as to why women put up with such misogyny. If only they would refuse to accept second class treatment from religion. What is worse they often willingly embrace it.
photo
YafoDalet
a secular Jew
11:58 PM on 07/14/2011
Another revealing aspect of the comments to this article is that, contrary to claims repeatedly heard in this forum, commenters who typically support Israel ARE liberals! Yey!
photo
YafoDalet
a secular Jew
11:52 PM on 07/14/2011
This article triggers some interesting responses. When the French government banned veils in public places, many commenters here were up in arms defending religious freedoms and the right for cultural determination. The French government were the bad guys and those wearing veils as a protest were the heroes.

Now here, we have almost an identical situation. Only unlike the French, the Israeli leave the choice to the people, while emphasizing the right to choose. It's like the French would outlaw the veils if they are forced on the women, yet leaving women the choice wear them if they wanted. Just like the commenters desired back in the day.

But what do we get in return? Slamming of the Israelis by the commenters here. Suddenly those choosing to ride the bus in the back are "backwards" and the legal system that stresses rights and religious freedoms is "Taliban state."

What am I missing here?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Nwo2012
Sue me, I boycott products from the settlements
07:42 AM on 07/15/2011
If women want to privately and freely express their religion by wearing a burka in France. They cant.

If Israeli men want to express their religion by asking a woman to move seats they cant do it without explicitly invading her freedom and privacy.

How are they even related?
photo
YafoDalet
a secular Jew
06:02 PM on 07/15/2011
Personally, I don't believe that women choose to cover their face or choose to ride at the back of the bus. In both cases, they are brought up to believe that they want to do that and in both cases these are sad leftovers of old, male-dominated cultural practices that do not have place in modern society.

But following your logic, just like a woman can 'choose' to express her religion by wearing a burka in France, why shouldn't she be able to 'choose' to express her religion by riding at the back of a bus in Israel. Just read the last comment in the article.

The two cases are identical in terms of the tensions between personal freedom and religious coercion. The fact that people like you interpret it the way you just did, only shows the bias and double standard towards anything that has to do with Israel on this website.
01:29 PM on 07/15/2011
The Israeli women aren't hiding their faces. They can be identified, so your comparison is flawed.
photo
YafoDalet
a secular Jew
05:56 PM on 07/15/2011
I don't see how it's flawed. In both cases there is a rather disrespectful towards women religious custom. In both cases the democratic institutions step in to defend the freedom of religious choice and freedom from religion. In one case, the commenters here are up in arms defending the woman's choice to cover her face. In the other case, the commenters here are up in arms labeling an entire society as backwards, because some women still choose to ride the bus in the back. And it does not stop here. The commenters are going on to label the institutions that stepped in to protect personal freedoms as oppressive. That's a ridiculous double standard, which is what flawed here!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hello All
09:14 PM on 07/14/2011
Welcome to the only democracy in the Middle East.
photo
YafoDalet
a secular Jew
11:30 PM on 07/14/2011
Welcome indeed! Pick your sit!
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Angie Tyne 1
I want my disagree button!!
06:54 PM on 07/14/2011
It is a truism that almost any sect, cult, or religion will legislate its creed into law if it acquires the political power to do so, and will follow it by suppressing opposition, subverting all education to seize early the minds of the young, and by killing, locking up, or driving underground all heretics. [Robert A. Heinlein, Postscript to Revolt in 2100]
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Json
Cynical dreamer, sarcastic idealist...
05:01 PM on 07/14/2011
I wonder if people would be so upset if the women got the front of the bus and the men got the back?
What if women got the left side and men the right (or vice versa)?

A little creativity and we can reconcile religious modesty with modernity.
09:48 AM on 07/16/2011
Or we could just let people sit where they will. Now that's modern, isn't it?
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Json
Cynical dreamer, sarcastic idealist...
10:20 AM on 07/16/2011
How diplomatic of you.
My solution tries to reconcile the two ideas. Your is to tell the religious folks who are in favor of separation, to just shut up.
photo
snurps
your micro-bio did not meet our guidelines
04:29 PM on 07/14/2011
You find out something new everyday.