iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Colon Cleansing Does More Harm Than Good: Study

Huffington Post   First Posted: 08/01/11 05:56 PM ET Updated: 10/01/11 06:12 AM ET

Colon Cleansing

Trendy colon cleanses don't actually do anything to help your health, and they can even cause unwanted side effects, according to a new review of studies.

The review of 20 studies published over the last 10 years shows that there is little evidence that colon cleansing improves health or promotes weight loss, while there is much evidence that shows it is associated with bloating, vomiting, cramping, renal failure and even death.

The review, published in the subscription-only Journal of Family Practice, looked at both colon-cleansing drinks, as well as processes like colon hydrotherapy, where water is pumped in and out of the rectum via a tube to clean the colon.

"This is not a manifesto against complementary and alternative medicine, since I’m a big proponent," study researcher Dr. Ranit Mishori, a family medicine physician at Georgetown University Medical School, told MSNBC, but there's no scientific evidence that colon cleansing improves health, and scientists actually found that it can be harmful.

The idea of colon cleansing -- that is, ridding the body of toxins that supposedly accumulate in the colon, which can then spur a variety of ills -- has been around for centuries, but the American Medical Association said that the "procedure was invalid" in the early 1900s, CNN reported.

However, that hasn't hindered the popularity of colon cleanses. These days, colon cleanses include herbal teas, laxatives or other drinkable concoctions (which don't require FDA oversight) like the Master Cleanse, and colonic hydrotherapy, which involves a "colon hygienist" or "colon hydrotherapist" pumping water in and out of the rectum with a rubber tube, MSNBC reported.

However, this practice has the potential to damage the colon tissue, CBS News reported. In addition, some of these hygienists don't have the right training, which adds to the danger.

However, the procedure is safe if performed by a qualified therapist who uses the correct FDA-approved equipment, Dick Hoenninger, a spokesman for the International Association for Colon Hydrotherapy, told CBS News.

The FDA only approves colon hydrotherapy equipment for medical purposes, like cleaning the colon before undergoing a colonoscopy or radiological exam, TIME, reported.

While the digestive system is efficient enough at removing waste on its own, according to the Mayo Clinic, proponents of colon cleansing say that the practice helps people to feel better, boosts the immune system and gets rid of toxins that are lurking in the gastrointestinal tract.

Russell Kolbo, a naturopathic doctor based in Washington who believes in the theory behind colon cleansing, said more rigorous studies are needed on the subject before people come to an absolute opinion on it, MSNBC reported. And an important note: People should not administer a colon cleanse unless they're licensed to do so.

If you want to undergo a colon cleanse to relieve constipation, the Mayo Clinic suggests instead trying these options: drinking water and fluids, eating a fiber-rich diet and getting regular exercise.

WATCH:

FOLLOW HUFFPOST HEALTHY LIVING

Trendy colon cleanses don't actually do anything to help your health, and they can even cause unwanted side effects, according to a new review of studies. The review of 20 studies published over th...
Trendy colon cleanses don't actually do anything to help your health, and they can even cause unwanted side effects, according to a new review of studies. The review of 20 studies published over th...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 217
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (7 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:22 AM on 09/15/2011
Thanks for the post! I found this very interesting and informative. I bookmarked your site! http://www.myhealthstoreonline.com/XtremeNo-MuscleBuilderSupplements
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:21 AM on 09/15/2011
Hello, I like your page. I’m glad Google pointed me to it. I was able to get the know-how I was searching so badly for days now. Thanks for the post! I'll definitely be back. Good luck! http://www.myhealthstoreonline.com/XtremeNo-MuscleBuilderSupplements
photo
drramsey
Your Partner In Health
01:40 PM on 08/17/2011
The outcome of any procedure is as good as the trained professional, equipment and technique. I have witnessed many life altering experiences with colon hydrotherapy from ending an acute asthmatic attack to relieving built up barium (a very toxic metal) from the system that had been there for 25 years. I agree it can be overused. It is not only used to increase peristalsis in constipated individuals though and is the last treatment I refer for this. The immune building and de-pocketing of toxins are the main reasons I refer for this. The colon is an intussuscepted tube that can and does pocket a lot of waste unless stretched for the purpose of liberation. In addition, this exposes larger surfaces for the re-implantation of essential pro-immune components.
~ Dr. Theresa Ramsey, Practicing Physician, Speaker, Author of Healing 101, www.DrRamsey.com
10:25 AM on 08/15/2011
Ideally we would be eating a diet rich in fruits, veggies, whole grains, lean, clean cuts of meat and other whole foods.  Then we would not need a detox/cleanse.  But, unfortunately, that is not the case for many. For those that want a quick fix, you could risk a day in the bathroom on a cleanse but then use it to kick off you new healthy lifestyle.  blog.mydiscoverhealth.com
05:08 PM on 08/05/2011
Everyone I've known that's into this colonic cleaning thing--only a few did it religiously--are more ill than I've ever been. It's nuts and can't imagine who thought it up.. people w/too much time on their hands and they must be OCD at least. What a bizarre concept this has always seemed.. wacko
04:39 PM on 08/03/2011
According to the Chinese medicine of one Dr. Tei Fu Chen; a world renown herbal pharmecologist and head of the oldest and largest "grower" and mfg of health foods in the world, Sunrider International..."never cleanse one system individually"! If one needs cleansing, they all do! What if the toxins, paracites etc. have no place to dump into, when you "detox"?! What if there is so much toxin in your blood and you don't drink enough water to rinse it out?! Sunriders, which I a one< believe , we nourish to cleanse. WE NEED TO EAT GOOD FOOD! Stop the clogging!! I am sorry folks, McDonalds, Diet Coke and the pharmeceutical addictions will kill you...it will take a few years, but it works! Oh, and the death...you won't just slip off in your sleep, you will rot!! I will leave you for now with this...protein...causes cancer, dairy is so acidic, that the body leeches calcium from the bones to buffer it, we get colds and flu from what we eat, in order for a germ to make you sick, a rotting interior terrains required. Remember this...we are "organic" living beings, made up mostly of water, and we must eat that way!! Goddess, I am wondering when the "simple" folks of this planet will wake up and ask...what the hecks goin on??!!
I am wondering about the "selling out" thing myself...emmasdolly!
08:07 AM on 08/04/2011
And here you are on this thread, so here's a question. I've suffered my whole adult life with a Hiatal Hernia and IBS. I used to take antacids daily but was put on the acid blockers eventually. My question is about gut bacteria. I was wondering if some people have 'allergic' digestive reactions to some common gut bacteria and if a type of colon cleanse would 'sterilize' the system so you could effectively start over. My symptoms came on almost overnight in highschool and I've wondered if I might have been exposed to some type I wasn't genetically able to deal with by kissing, like mono is spread. I've tried diet changes and even spirilina with no results.
06:43 PM on 08/19/2011
I would just eat Sunrider...especially NuPlus and VitaDophilus...each packet of VitaDophilus contains 1.5 billion Lactobacillus Acidophilus micro-organisms wrapped in a base of high fiber apple flakes. Heres the problem with most probiotics and enzymes, they are eaten up by the stomach acid before they reach the small intestine and therefore rendering them nearly useless. Sunrider's VitoDophilus is patented by Chen and different. The apple is eaten away and the "goods" go into the tract and rebuild it. It sounds as though you might have lots of yeast and mold in your gut...makes for lots of gas and misery. My husband went from 22-30 antacids a day, now he is somewhere around 2-6, depending what he eats. If he ate better it would probably cure!! Get ahold of me if you want more info... I no longer have any illness in my body and I am 62!!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
emmasdolly
03:03 PM on 08/03/2011
I am sensing a bit of pro "medical industry" slant in Huffington Post that didn't used to be there. This is disapponting. There are a lot of things that people should know that are not available in the mainstream media. Has HP sold out completely?
11:34 AM on 08/03/2011
Very simple solution.............go vegan/vegetarian. Natural elimination of toxins and waste from body. You feel good and it's good for the animals too! I forgot to mention good karma!!
11:17 AM on 08/03/2011
My friend Di and I are about to try a 9-Day Cleanse in the Isagenix system. Isagenix is a multi-level marketing ("pyramid scheme") and they want people to sign up for an ongoing consumption of their products. I feel this is an inherent conflict of interest; and, I think we'll achieve the weight loss we want during this short period to help us get back on track with the Medical Weight Loss Clinic (of S.E. Michigan) program that we have kept weight off with for 2 years. Keeping at a healthy weight is a key to slowing aging, and since I'm in my 50s, that's important to me.
03:59 PM on 08/03/2011
i did isagenix a few years ago. it worked pretty well. the hardest part is still trying to be social while you detox not being able to eat the same foods or drink alcohol is hard if you're out with friends or colleagues. one thing to note: most of my weightloss occurred in the 3 months after the cleanse, which is a good sign that it helped my body get rid of some toxins (as well as help me change my diet/portions).
11:55 PM on 08/02/2011
I thoroughly enjoyed reading these threads. It's great when a topic can be discussed in a civil tone when there are opposing opinions.
10:23 PM on 08/02/2011
Huffington Post is one of the souces were I get my news.. here and there I put my two cents in by posting a comment. Now my comment and people who have responded to is been taken out.. disappeared. There were no curses, it was a polite comment.. so much for freedom of speech. Free.. within a circle of rules. Go ahead and remove this one too!
02:29 AM on 08/03/2011
The problem is not that you might say something rude or obnoxious but that you made a statement that goes against the political correctness imposed by the particular editor reviewing these posts. Just like any other so called blog or news group this site demands articles meet a specific ideological slant. If you don't slant the right way you will get censored right away.
09:49 AM on 08/18/2011
I must thank you for the well explanation, so every piece of information has to have partial.. perspective? And we criticize other nations political view? Do you get your news from another (no bias) source? Did I just make a comic statement? Anyway, Thanks again. JP.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GiveMittAChance
Barefoot in Arizona
09:25 PM on 08/02/2011
Penn and Teller did a Bullsh!t episode on this one time. Colon Cleansers are garbage
08:18 PM on 08/02/2011
I have cleansed my colon any number of times, but never on purpose.
02:30 AM on 08/03/2011
I'm evacuating my colon, does that count??
08:14 PM on 08/02/2011
Time to start up the "Fleet".
03:24 PM on 08/02/2011
The medical community want to poke fun of holistic health because they want to keep you sick so they can make money lol, holistic health works, it's been around for years and it's natural but go ahead and make fun of it and pay your money and be sick later on when you're old, you'll see.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bob Metcalfe
Caught at 1st. slip trying to cut
11:08 PM on 08/02/2011
Okay here's the thing, something which should sound an alarm, a naturopath asking for more rigorous studies. Normally they oppose rigorous studies, because they tend to prove that their notions are rubbish. Here's another thing, just because something is natural, doesn't mean to say that it's good. Foxgloves are natural but if you eat them you die. And how can colonic cleansing the natural? The natural way is to go to the toilet and empty your bowels. They, the colonic cleansers, stick a pipe up your bum and flush it out with water, involving all sorts of machinery and electrical power, what's natural about that?
04:01 PM on 08/03/2011
That is such a bogus belief-doctors are worked to death, and the last thing they need is to keep people sick! Docs don't need to keep you sick when there are gullible people out there who will believe all sorts of unscientific nonsense. Don't forget, doctors are also people, they and their families get sick too, and they do not promote illness!
01:18 AM on 08/06/2011
The junk you say are the same people dying from colon cancer for eating meat every damn day and not having enough bowel movements but everything is fine right?
You have no idea