More

Kelly Thomas, Fullerton Homeless Man, Had Been A 'Normal Teen,' Says Dad

GILLIAN FLACCUS   08/ 4/11 12:58 AM ET   AP

FULLERTON, Calif. — In the nearly two decades since his son descended into madness, Ron Thomas has worried every day that the schizophrenic 37-year-old would die of exposure or illness on the streets. He never imagined the end would come in a violent confrontation with police.

The death last month was the end of a trajectory that began when Kelly Thomas was in his early 20s and started showing the first signs of what would later be diagnosed as schizophrenia: he shuttled between addresses, preferred to sleep on the floor and stopped showering.

In treatment, Thomas did well and was able to hold down a job – but when he stopped taking his pills, he disappeared onto the streets. He racked up an array of charges, from public urination to assault with a deadly weapon, and alarmed his parents with his bizarre behavior.

"My daughter and I have talked for years that we'd get the call that something had happened to him, whether it was from organ failure because he's not drinking enough fluids or the elements or maybe gang activity," said his father, Ron Thomas.

Last month, he was sitting on a bench at the Fullerton Transportation Center, a hub for buses and commuter trains where homeless people congregate, when six police officers arrived to investigate reports of a man burglarizing cars nearby. Police said he ran when they tried to search his backpack and that he resisted arrest.

The incident was captured by a bystander with a cell phone, and bus surveillance tape released Monday showed agitated witnesses describing how officers beat Thomas and used a stun gun on him repeatedly as he cried out for his father.

On the cell phone video, a man can be heard screaming over a fast, clicking sound that those on the tape identify as a stun gun being deployed.

Thomas was taken off life support five days after the July 5 altercation. His father said Wednesday he was stunned when he learned police officers caused his son's severe head and neck injuries.

"When I arrived at the hospital to see him, I honestly thought that gang bangers had got a hold of him like the cowards sometimes do and just beat him with a baseball bat in the face," he said. "Immediately my thoughts were to get with Fullerton police ... and I didn't learn until a certain amount of hours later the truth. That put me in absolute shock."

A police spokesman, Sgt. Andrew Goodrich, said the case was an isolated incident.

"We have a good department full of good individuals," he said. "We've made more than half-a-million law enforcement contacts over the past 4.5 years ... This is the only instance of this kind that's happened."

Goodrich said officers receive training on how to deal with the mentally ill and the homeless. But an attorney representing the department, Michael D. Schwartz, said that "public perception of officers' trying to control a combative, resistive suspect rarely conform to those officers' training, experiences, and what those officers were experiencing at the time or reality."

The revelations have caused growing outrage in this quiet college town. More than 70 people spoke at the City Council meeting Wednesday, and a city councilwoman called for the resignation of the police chief. Thomas' father and others were planning a protest outside the police station this weekend, the second in as many weeks.

"My son needs a voice," he said. "Now, the people have become Kelly's voice and, yeah, I'm leading the charge."

Kelly Thomas was an outgoing child who loved to play the guitar, participated in Boy Scouts and Cub Scouts and aspired to be a wildland firefighter, said his father, who raised him alone after he and Thomas' mother divorced.

After his diagnosis, he went to a live-in facility that provided meals and monitored his medication, his father said. Thomas was able to hold down a job at a gas station and then a printing facility and even started to train with the California Department of Forestry and Protection.

But each time he began to improve, he stopped his medications and wound up back on the streets, moving between Yorba Linda, Placentia, Fullerton and Cypress – all places where he had once lived or had family and friends. One of the hardest parts of his death has been hearing their son described as homeless, the father said.

"That's the heartbreaking part for all of us. We all have ideas of what we'd like our kids to be like and to do in life. With Kelly, we didn't get to realize that and it constantly broke our heart," his father said. "Kelly wasn't homeless at all, he had so many homes, but he wanted to be a drifter and he did."

Life on the streets led to criminal charges.

He pleaded guilty to assault with a deadly weapon other than a firearm in 1995 and since 2004 has had a string of arrests for a host of lesser crimes including public urination, trespassing, battery, unlawful camping, petty theft and vandalism. He racked up traffic violations for jaywalking and failing to obey traffic signals.

His mother sought a restraining order against him in December 2010 after he refused to leave her front porch, took off his clothes and urinated by the front door, according to court papers. The family said they sought the order to try to get him into treatment as his behavior spiraled out of control.

On the day of the beating, bystanders said Thomas was approached by two officers and ran from them. Bus surveillance video showed witnesses talking about the confrontation to the driver of a bus that pulled up minutes later.

In the grainy, black-and-white video, a woman who appears upset says: "The cops are kicking this poor guy over there. ... He's almost halfway dead."

A male witness says the man, identified as Thomas, was sitting on a bench when he was approached by two officers and ran from them. The man says police used a stun gun on Thomas six times.

"They caught him, pound his face, pound his face against the curb ... and they beat him up," the man said. "They beat him up, and then all the cops came and they hogtied him, and he was like, `Please God! Please Dad!'"

The police department has turned over the investigation to the district attorney's office and placed on paid administrative leave six officers involved in the beating. The FBI also launched a probe into whether the officers violated Thomas' civil rights in the incident.

People with untreated mental illness make up about one-third of the nation's 600,000 homeless, said Kristina Ragosta, legislative and policy counsel for the Treatment Advocacy Center.

More needs to be done by police departments to train officers in how to recognize symptoms and deal with people with mental illness, said Elaine Deck, the senior program manager at the International Association of Chiefs of Police.

Sometimes, an untrained officer can make a situation worse, she said.

"Handcuffing them may escalate the behavior where the officer may think they are trying to calm the person," Deck said. "They may not know that this may actually escalate a response."

___

Associated Press writers Amy Taxin in Tustin and Thomas Watkins in Los Angeles contributed to this report.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST LOS ANGELES

FULLERTON, Calif. — In the nearly two decades since his son descended into madness, Ron Thomas has worried every day that the schizophrenic 37-year-old would die of exposure or illness on the st...
FULLERTON, Calif. — In the nearly two decades since his son descended into madness, Ron Thomas has worried every day that the schizophrenic 37-year-old would die of exposure or illness on the st...
Filed by Anna Almendrala  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 825
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (22 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ugotstyle
02:29 PM on 08/19/2011
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/08/02/kelly-thomas-fullerton-ho_n_916306.html this is security camera inside a bus as witnesses describe the attack and subsequent murder. Listen to the dialogue.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ugotstyle
02:19 PM on 08/19/2011
We also must realize that many many of southern california police officers are NOT the race as those they attack. I would like to know how many of these officers have more allegance to south of the boarder than north. This has the trademark of racial hatred all over it.
04:36 PM on 08/12/2011
It is time for the socio-economically challenged to demand equal protection of the law. Anyone and everyone knows that this class is subject to discriminatory laws and application of laws, yet the unconstitutional trend is on the rise.

One out of four hate crimes against homeless people ends in death, compared with a fraction of one percent in the federally and state recognized hate crime categories. Fullerton could lead the nation, if she made a declaration of equality pursuant to socio-economic status and implemented a program to educate her public officials, respectively. Anything less would be a disgrace and dishonor, IMHO.
01:21 AM on 08/10/2011
Unfortunately, this is the result of the court cases that make it hard to commit the mentally ill unless they can be proven to be a danger to themselves or others.

Kelly did not deserve to be beaten to death, but was clearly mentally ill. He spent most of his time hanging out in various local shopping centers and had a history of breaking into cars and causing trouble. Had not activist judges made their rulings in the 1970's, Kelly would have been forced to take his meds and would likely be alive today.

But by making it very difficult to institutionalize the mentally ill, such outcomes will result.

A good recent example is a mentally ill homeless woman that in the LA Toy district ripped a baby out of a stroller and hit the baby against a railing and a car and then engaged in a death match with the mother and relative. Eventually she was subdued, the baby was bruised but had no permanent injury. What was the reason, the homeless woman wanted to eat the baby's arm. Note: authorities believe this is not the first time the woman tried this.

http://blogs.laweekly.com/informer/2011/07/baby_assault_angeles_stroller.php
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hsspringman
We can cure fundamentalist.
01:13 AM on 08/12/2011
Stop attempting to putt the blame for this where it does not belong. The cops in this and many other instances are out of control thugs and should be treated as such. Do a simple search for "cops beating video" and you will see that this is a coast to coast problem. It is not all cops of course but as long as a few get away with it there will be others that follow.
04:52 PM on 08/12/2011
The danger of forced institutionalization, IMHO, is that there is not conclusive test, as to who should be institutionalized, and psyche doctors may have unrevealed and/or inherent conflicts of interest. Psyche doctors, often, decide the fate of divorce, parental custody, adoption and criminal cases; without a jury. The damages are astronomical and irreparable, when it happens, and the system is without sufficient oversight or avenue of redress.
03:31 PM on 08/09/2011
I am angry, sad, frustrated, hurt and confused that my fellow man can be this cruel. I hope this isn't swept under the rug and the good ole boy system put in place to protect the policeman.
03:27 PM on 08/09/2011
This raises an important issue to me. The republicans are wanting congress to cut programs and reduce spending. Cutting funding for the mentally ill is wrong. Many of these programs are necessary, they are humane. Many programs help the poor and those that cannot help themselves. California has been held hostage by those conservatives who do not believe in raising taxes to pay for anything which causes trickle down problems, and poor Kelly Thomas was the victim. I blame 30 years of deregulation, cutting taxes on the rich, The CONSERVATIVE REPUBLICAN AND LIBERTERIAN PARTY has a hand in this injustice and they should never be voted in office again. Please vote for moderates only.
02:14 AM on 08/06/2011
As part of my yearly training to maintain my peace officer status (Probation Officer) we had one session with LAPD's mental health response unit officers. It consists of officers specially trained to handle mentally ill offenders. The officer is then teamed with a Dept. of Mental Health professional. Both respond to the scene when available to confront a mentally ill offender. My daughter is a Psychiatrict Social Worker at a county hospital who at times receives these individuals who are taken to a hospital instead of jail. In her 4 years at the hosptal she has never witnessed a patient who was brought in by this LAPD unit to have any injuries.

It is obvious the Fullerton Police Dept. has been deficient in its training procedures regarding incidences with the mentally ill. This lack of training resulted in this tragedy and/ or possible crime. Not only the responding officers must be held accountable but the Chief of Police appears derelict for failing to implement vital training modalities.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dbrett480
02:20 AM on 08/07/2011
I'm glad the LAPD has a PERT team (all departments should), but I'm not sure this incident was a result of bad mental health training. Rather I think the issue is with use of force training. I can't remember the last time I had to get in a long fight with a person who was already on the ground and had been tased (PCP users are the notable exception to this rule, only a good slug from a shotgun can bring them down). Most of these types of fights are over very quickly, with only one or two officers involved, especially if the person is a small guy like Thomas.
11:25 PM on 08/27/2011
The officer who was mainly involved in the beating aspect of this case was an ex-LAPD officer. So if you say that the LAPD have training in order to work with the mentally-ill, it doesn't seem like lack of training was the issue.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dbrett480
10:36 PM on 08/05/2011
I hope that this tragedy is not used to demean all police officers in their interactions with the mentally ill. I'm pretty sure that's what Thomas's father (a retired Deputy Sheriff) would want.

Officers interact every single day with people with serious mental illnesses. Hopefully this tragedy shouldn't define how law enforcement officers do their jobs.
08:34 PM on 08/09/2011
dbrett, actually Thomas' father said that he wants the officers involved in the brutal killing of his son in jail for murder, which is exactly what should happen, since they are murderers.
11:27 PM on 08/27/2011
I don't think that this case should demean all officers and how they do there job. In any profession there are some who are bad apples. MY issue with the Fullerton PD in this situation is how the good old boys club has stuck up for one another, lied, covered up the truth, etc, etc. This makes all of them (In the Fullerton PD) guilty.
06:14 PM on 08/05/2011
The FPD can drag the case to calm people down, eventually people will calm down, but the thing is that if those six police officers don't get justice here on earth, they will have to answer to their higher sources if they believe in such thing one way or another. God save those six police officers and any evil doers.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ugotstyle
02:23 PM on 08/19/2011
In mexico the federalis are known for corruption. They make money in the drug trade, human trafficing, and are feared because they will beat or kill with no chance of recourse. I've heard more than once (alot more) that it's this reason many latin americans seek to get jobs in with the police. As we've seen cops can do anything and never be brought to justice.
03:54 PM on 08/05/2011
An "isolated incident" involving six officers, probably including a sergeant? That should count as six incidents.
01:21 PM on 08/05/2011
So sad that our country can finance multibillion dollar wars across the ocean under false pretenses but we cannot afford to take care of the people in our own country that so desperately need help. Our mental health system is broken, our Social Security is soon to be non-existent, most health care is a joke and where are the jobs? This man should have been restrained and brought to jail and dealt with from there, not beat to death in public.

Even with his mental illness...he cried out for the person he loved. This is murder anyway you slice it and they will get away with it. Tragic.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AndyWright68
Freedom is inevitable!
12:31 PM on 08/05/2011
The cops need to be abolished. They do far more harm than good.

Google: 50+ really good reasons to abolish the cops and there are a few YouTube channels that expose cops for what they really are. copsoutofcontrol is one of the best.

Abolish the cops before someone you love becomes one of their victims.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:08 PM on 08/04/2011
There is speculation that the following Fullerton police officers MAY have been present during the fatal beating of Kelly Thomas:

http://www.fullertonsfuture.org/
“According to our sources:
Officer Jay Cicinelli was there
Officer Kenton Hampton was there
Officer Manny Ramos was there
Officer Joe Wolfe was there
Officer James Blatney was there
The sixth officer would have been a sargent called to the scene due to the use of a Taser. There are two patrol sargents not reporting for duty at the moment who may have been on duty that night. When we figure out which one was there, we’ll let you know.”
11:45 PM on 08/04/2011
Thank you very much for adding these names. (I'm serious.) We need to help this man win a case for all of us. I have looked for his charity but cannot find it. If anyone has that contact info, please post it. I'd even put a page up outlining what these officers did, but I'll need some help. If this story compelled you to act, let's do something about it! This was heart wrenching, I'm sorry, I'm a kinda rough city guy and this has me very upset. I know many of you are feeling the same way. Even though we don't know this person, the thought that our countrymen could be so terribly abusive, and that they are sworn "officers of the law" is plain scary. Cops all consider one another to be brothers - that means whatever State you're in - there are officers on your force that you pay city/county taxes for, who are calling their friends to try and get these guys out of trouble. Every favor under the sun, from a Judge to a CI, the Fullerton PD has asked other LEOs for help in making this go away. We all expect these pigs to walk, I mean, most of them do on almost every case of abuse. Cops are *always* afraid, 80% are weak people. I wish brain cancer on each officer who either dealt a blow to Kelly or is helping to try and cover it up.
01:40 AM on 08/05/2011
Here you go. The Kelly Thomas Memorial Fund: http://ktmf.org/
07:06 PM on 08/04/2011
I feel for this man, and his family, because, like many others, I to
have a family member who is going through what this young man
has gone through. My family member is now in jail (although from
past events, this may be the best place for him at this time). I do
think that the police are getting better at handling mental illness
patients, but, still too often, accidental deaths occur. What to
do to help avoid these incidents? Court rulings prevent forcing
mentally ill patients to take their medication. The police are not
qualified to determine when someone is going to flip out. Thus,
they can only react to a situation on a case by case basis. Our
states now have limited mental health facilities, and, unfortunely,
due to budget constraints, and some court rulings, mentallly ill
patients cannot be forcibly admitted to a facility unless something
happens that forces the issue like the person hurt/killed someone
in a bizzar way forcing an evaluation. So, until we have better ways
of dealing with the mentally ill, we are going to continue to hear about
things like this.
06:12 PM on 08/04/2011
I'm getting really tired of seeing all these negative comments from people who probably don't even know where Fullerton is and have no idea what they're talking about.. I'm a long-time Fullerton resident, and my contacts with the Fullerton PD have always been positive. I have found Fullerton officers to be pleasant, friendly, professional and helpful. I was pulled over a couple of times--once for talking on my cell phone, and once for having expired registration--and both times I was let off with a friendly warning. For a smaller police department, it is very professional and community-service oriented. Sgt. Goodrich is right--this was an isolated incident. It escalated for a variety of reasons, and yes, Kelly Thomas had a history with FPD, and yes, certain officers didn't quite know how to handle a violent "5150," but that doesn't mean the whole department should be condemned. This is a crisis that FPD and the city will learn from, and I have every confidence that it will never happen here again. I stand with the Fullerton Police Department and applaud the job that they have done over the years keeping my community safe.
11:31 PM on 08/04/2011
Thanks for your perspective as a resident of Fullerton.
10:58 AM on 08/05/2011
IF nothing comes of this, then the whole department should be condemned.

But I must say, after looking at that guy's face while in the hospital, it's hard to view those involved as anywhere near "professional".