More

Philippines Shuts Art Show Deemed Offensive

Philippines Art Contro

08/ 9/11 07:03 AM ET   AP

MANILA, Philippines — Officials at the state-run Cultural Center of the Philippines shut an art exhibit on Tuesday after it provoked heated debate as well as threats and hate mail for combining Christian symbols with phallic objects.

The decision by the center's board of directors came a day after former first lady and art patron Imelda Marcos joined politicians and Roman Catholic church leaders in denouncing the exhibit.

The board said it made the decision because of "an increasing number of threats to persons and property," including the artists and the cultural center staff.

It said the threats increased after critics vandalized an installation by removing a wooden penis from a poster depicting Jesus Christ.

The exhibit by contemporary Filipino artists including Mideo Cruz prompted heated debate about freedom of expression, with President Benigno Aquino II describing it as offensive to the 85 percent of Filipinos who are Christian like him.

Aquino said he reminded the cultural center that freedoms should be ennobling, and "when you stoke conflict, that is not an ennobling activity."

One sculpture portrayed Christ as Mickey Mouse, while a collage combined an image of Christ with pictures of celebrities, commercial products and characters from children's TV shows. Condoms, rosaries and wooden penises adorned the wall.

The exhibit, which opened in June, had been scheduled to run through Aug. 21.

The cultural center said Cruz's art had been exhibited without the same degree of controversy since 2002 in various other venues, including the Jesuit-run Ateneo de Manila University and the Vargas Museum at the state-run University of the Philippines.

An introduction to Cruz's work said it "speaks of idolatry and the deconstruction of neo-deities."

It described the cross and the image of Christ as representative of Filipinos' cultural past because the Southeast Asian nation was ruled by Spain and conservative Catholic friars for almost four centuries before it was administered as an American territory for 48 years.

Cruz declined to comment on the closure of the exhibit. However, he posted on his Facebook page a statement from a group named Artist Formation to Uphold Freedom of Artistic Expression saying it will fight against censorship.

"The bishops and religious lay leaders pushing for the closure of the exhibit are demanding not only that we persecute one person's creative expression, but that we hinder any other creative expressions whose concept and presented ideologies they do not agree with. To allow the exhibit's closure based on such would set the precedent for all other exhibitions that would follow," the group said.

National artist Bienvenido Lumbera, who chairs another group called Concerned Artists of the Philippines, said the cultural center's decision would open it to pressure "any time an art object raises the ire of certain sectors."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST ARTS

MANILA, Philippines — Officials at the state-run Cultural Center of the Philippines shut an art exhibit on Tuesday after it provoked heated debate as well as threats and hate mail for combining ...
MANILA, Philippines — Officials at the state-run Cultural Center of the Philippines shut an art exhibit on Tuesday after it provoked heated debate as well as threats and hate mail for combining ...
Filed by Sydney Edelist  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 25
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dennissinned
Progressive but not a Democrat.
02:06 PM on 08/11/2011
Philippines is a lot more conservative now than its colonial ruler, Spain. Sad.
REDSTATEREFUGEE
Texan by birth ; Californian by choice
11:00 AM on 08/11/2011
Great.....Imelda Marcos, queen of the 500 pair-shoe closet and wife of the late dictator Ferdinand, is the arbiter of artistic taste in the Philippines? I would have thought that the country would have exercised good sense and taste, disallowing her voice to be heard on any citizen tax-supported organisation. Just another example of the intense cronyism being alive and well in the PI....
05:15 PM on 08/10/2011
This person has no artistic talent so he gets some religious artifacts and slaps sexual items to it? Sounds familiar! This happened here in the 90's as well and it is just as tasteless now as then.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wulidncr
Believe nothing. Question all. Love boundlessly
05:44 PM on 08/10/2011
Accidentally marked as favorite,

Using sexual imagery to communicate a point is valid since all humans are sexual beings. Whether something is deemed tasteless is dependent upon the observer. Even if a majority deemed an exhibit tasteless would not mean it was intrinsically so. Eating the unhatched embryo of a duckling is considered disgusting to many people. This is no way means it is intrinsically so. The danger is the idea that it's proper to silence voices deemed offensive by the majority. Right and wrong are not democratic. Slavery was once favored by the majority in America. An exhibit depicting the horrors of slavery would receive very different receptions depending on the time it was displayed in. The artist, Cruz, is making a statement, provoking, inviting consideration. Should there be questions that should not be asked? Art, literature, opera and poetry are rich and powerful ways to say things more common forms of communication cannot. The real value of the exhibit is learning from responses to it. Is the public saying our god is so frail, this will injure him? Our belief and idolization of it is more important than freedom of expression? Freedom of speech is ok only if the majority agrees with what you are saying?

Congrats are due the artist. I think his exhibit has been as a diagnostic tool, an Art-MRI, and in my judgement, the scan has not come up clear.
02:19 PM on 08/10/2011
"… hate mail for combining Christian symbols with phallic objects."

What do they suppose a crucifix is? And let's not even get into Jesus' usually quite conspicuous "phallic object…"
12:27 PM on 08/10/2011
When you've got Imelda Marcos AND the Catholic Church against you, you know you've got some good art....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FogBelter
Illegitimis non carborundum
12:02 PM on 08/10/2011
The Philippines has an interesting psyche. In many ways, it is a very hip society, and at the same time, quite puritanical.
10:08 AM on 08/10/2011
Other than the fact that the art world is beginning to feel like Russia - the exhibit seems to be more about shock than art, and i also am sick of those regurgitating the same themes over and over for shock value.
02:21 PM on 08/10/2011
One of the functions of art is to shock observers into new perceptions. When the same themes shock the same people over and over again, either the art or the observer is a failure.
03:34 PM on 08/10/2011
Well said. Fanned.
07:11 AM on 08/11/2011
yes, shock is just one of the functions of art - used over and over so that it no longer has power.
My point was that - art has become so homogenized that something new needs to be created to shock, I don't happen to blame it on the observer, but the creator. Did this piece really shock anyone? - or just get attention that pissing on Christ or penis placing always gets.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mustardhead98
Professional Fine Artist
09:27 AM on 08/10/2011
Personally I'm glad it was shut down if for no other reason than it being bad - mediocre shock art. Frankly I'm SO done with shock art-I want to see some talent!!
03:35 PM on 08/10/2011
I think Thomas Kincade has some stuff on sale.
photo
GraphicMatt
Somebody make me a sandwich!
03:35 PM on 08/10/2011
So do you think all art exhibits you deem bad should be shut down?
photo
Vieux Charles
Educating America, one liberal at a time
09:07 PM on 08/09/2011
Why don't artists ever depict the Prophet Muhammad with a wooden penis?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mustardhead98
Professional Fine Artist
09:26 AM on 08/10/2011
Excellent point! Christianity is constantly picked on and demon ized, yet folks run in the other direction when anyone even talks about, say, a Muhammad cartoon................
10:17 AM on 08/10/2011
Muslim extremists commit violence to shut down expression they find religiously offensive. Now so do Philippine catholics. Congratulations.
photo
GraphicMatt
Somebody make me a sandwich!
03:37 PM on 08/10/2011
"Christiani­ty is constantly picked on and demon ized"

Awwww, poor Christianity. I can't imagine why anyone would want to demonize that religion. Hitory's saddest vicitms.
02:25 PM on 08/10/2011
That's very short-sighted. If Islam receives less controversial attention, it's only because Islamic fundamentalists are known for violently stifling anything that could be take as criticism of their religion.

Just as Christians were doing not so very long ago, and - given America's growing flirtation with theocracy - may begin to do again. Coming soon to an auto da fé near you!
photo
Vieux Charles
Educating America, one liberal at a time
07:41 PM on 08/11/2011
How can a question be 'short-sighted'?
photo
illumination1
Artist and consultant, Tufts University
08:55 PM on 08/09/2011
Not unexpected in a country where religious authority exerts strong influence over government affairs. That never happens in America, does it?
REDSTATEREFUGEE
Texan by birth ; Californian by choice
11:56 AM on 08/10/2011
x 78 , i1.....I appreciate your wry observation. Too often, we Americans are quick to condemn other cultures of the very behavior we exhibit.
02:26 PM on 08/10/2011
Speaking as someone who's a second-class citizen in the US for no other than reason than Yahweh says I am… Oh, never mind. Why bother?