More

Ehud Barak, Israel Defense Minister, Regrets Deaths Of Egyptian Troops

Ehud Barak Egyptian Soldiers

IAN DEITCH and MAGGIE MICHAEL   08/20/11 10:12 PM ET   AP

JERUSALEM — Israel's landmark 1979 peace treaty with Egypt is being tested by a cross-border attack blamed on Palestinian militants. Israel made a rare apology Saturday for the deaths of three Egyptian soldiers after Cairo threatened to withdraw its ambassador.

The attack on Thursday set off a new cycle of Israeli-Palestinian violence. Israeli airstrikes have been answered by Palestinians pelting southern Israel with at least 80 rockets and mortars since Friday. An Israeli was killed Saturday in the desert city of Beersheba, about 25 miles (40 kilometers) from Gaza.

"Israel is sorry for the deaths of the Egyptian policemen during the attack on the Israel-Egypt border," Defense Minister Ehud Barak said after Egypt threatened to withdraw its ambassador to protest the deaths of its soldiers.

The Egyptian government said late Saturday Israel's apology was welcome, but not enough. Still, it reaffirmed Egypt's commitment to the peace.

Israel's apology was a clear move to try to quickly contain the damage to already shaky relations with Egypt. Egypt's threat to take diplomatic action put Israel in the uncomfortable position of having to apologize for violence that was triggered after its borders were breached and its people attacked and killed.

Israeli officials promised to investigate the deaths of the Egyptians and insisted the peace treaty was stable.

"No one had any intention to harm Egyptian security personnel," Amos Gilled, a senior Israeli Defense Ministry official who works closely with Egypt, told Israel Radio.

But even before the clashes on Thursday, the February ouster of longtime President Hosni Mubarak in a popular revolt had unleashed an outpouring of anti-Israel sentiment in Egypt and criticism of the peace treaty. Israeli officials were also growing wary about instability in post-Mubarak Egypt.

Although the military leaders who now rule Egypt have expressed their commitment to the peace accord, Israel is watching closely for signs they might respond to the rising anti-Israel sentiment and distance themselves from the Jewish state.

As the country moves through a chaotic and rocky transition to democracy, Islamist groups tightly curbed under Mubarak look headed for a more powerful role in the new Egypt – something else that rattles nerves in Israel.

Mubarak was seen by his people as too sympathetic to Israel, negotiating a highly unpopular deal to supply it with natural gas. Israel, in turn, counted on Mubarak as a trusted, if cool, ally, maintaining the peace despite Egyptian disappointment that a wider agreement could not be reached with Palestinians and other Arab states.

The simmering hostilities in Egypt boiled over after the soldiers died. Egypt said it was a violation of the peace accord.

Israel says the attacks began when Palestinian militants from the Gaza Strip crossed into Egypt's Sinai Peninsula, probably through one of the hundreds of smuggling tunnels under the border, then made their way more than 100 miles (150 kilometers) through the barren desert before crossing into southern Israel. Israel and Gaza both border the Sinai Peninsula.

The militants ambushed Israeli buses and cars with gunfire and a bomb and killed eight Israelis.

Israel and Egypt gave different versions of how the Egyptian soldiers died. Egypt said they were killed in an airstrike. Israel offered conflicting accounts. One account said there was an exchange of fire between its soldiers as they pursued the militants along the border.

A senior Israeli defense official told The Associated Press Saturday night that "initial reports in the investigation show that the terrorists came from Gaza and apparently opened fire on purpose near Egyptian positions in order to bring them into the fighting." He spoke on condition of anonymity because he was not allowed to speak to reporters.

The Israel-Egypt and Israel-Palestinian issues are closely intertwined. Egypt has tried for decades to broker a peace accord between Israelis and Palestinians. And in recent years, Egypt has tried to mediate an end to the internal Palestinian split between Fatah, which runs the West Bank through the Palestinian Authority, and the Islamic Hamas, which rules Gaza.

The aftermath of the clashes Thursday showed just how quickly Israeli-Palestinian violence can escalate.

Israeli airstrikes have killed 12 Palestinians, including two children, since Thursday, and Israeli leaders have made it clear that they will not put up with mounting violence from Gaza.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu convened senior ministers and security commanders late Saturday in an extraordinary session to discuss the surge in violence.

In Israel, one person was killed Saturday and dozens have been wounded in the barrage from Gaza, including a 2-week-old baby, hospital officials said. The flurry of exploding rockets damaged buildings all over Israel's south.

It was the heaviest salvo of rockets from Gaza since Israel staged an all-out ground and air operation in Gaza to stop daily rocket attacks in early 2009.

Israel is also concerned about an upsurge in Islamic militant activity in Sinai since Mubarak's fall. But no Israeli official has gone on record faulting Egypt for the way it is policing Sinai, where mountainous desert terrain and permeable borders have beckoned to extremists, contraband smugglers and African migrants for years.

Last week, Egypt moved thousands of troops into Sinai as part of a major operation against al-Qaida inspired militants who have been increasingly active since Mubarak's ouster. Since Mubarak was toppled, the natural gas pipeline running through Sinai has been sabotaged five times, disrupting supplies to Israel and Jordan.

Under Mubarak, the killings of troops would have elicited criticism on the front pages of Egyptian dailies. In post-Mubarak Egypt, however, youth activists on social networking sites spread calls for demonstrations in front of the Israeli embassy.

Thousands of protesters gathered outside the embassy in Cairo for a second day on Saturday, demanding the expulsion of the Israeli envoy who is now vacationing abroad. A Palestinian flag was unfurled at the site, and some of the demonstrators threw firecrackers at the building. A protester climbed up the building and took down the Israeli flag, drawing cheers from the crowd.

A dozen armored vehicles were stationed in the area and soldiers formed a cordon in front of the main gates to prevent any protesters from reaching the embassy building.

In Jordan, the only other Arab country at peace with Israel, about 150 protesters called Saturday for cancellation of the 1994 treaty and expulsion of the ambassador.

____

Michael reported from Cairo. AP writer Tia Goldenberg in Jerusalem also contributed to this report.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST WORLD

JERUSALEM — Israel's landmark 1979 peace treaty with Egypt is being tested by a cross-border attack blamed on Palestinian militants. Israel made a rare apology Saturday for the deaths of three E...
JERUSALEM — Israel's landmark 1979 peace treaty with Egypt is being tested by a cross-border attack blamed on Palestinian militants. Israel made a rare apology Saturday for the deaths of three E...
Filed by Eline Gordts  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 1,946
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (16 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
King Stevie Harper
10:03 PM on 09/21/2011
Wow what a great site Talab
http://www.jewsagainstzionism.com/

``American traditional Jews are rolling their eyes. No doubt, we are going to see a repeat of Netanyahu’s performance in Congress earlier this year. The Zionist leader is going to use the Torah in support of an ideology that is fundamentally anti-Torah. Zionism’s goal has always been to replace the Torah with nationalism. We can be sure that he will take verses of the Torah out of context so that they fit his agenda. He will certainly use the word “Jews” over and over again, and he will call his state “the Jewish state.” All this with one goal: to take the Jews as hostages and put world Jewry on the line for his purposes. He wants to hide under the mantle of the Jewish people, so that they bear the responsibility for whatever he does. He will use the Jewish credit card so that, G-d forbid, the Jewish people will have to pay the bills, with interest. He has one malicious goal: to put all the eggs in one basket, to take the entire Jewish people into his ship so that he can be their captain, and if it sinks, it will take the entire Jewish people down with it, G-d forbid. World Jewry is Netanyahu’s cannon fodder to further his agenda.``

The Truth is refreshing.
06:57 PM on 08/25/2011
Brother Talab , Feel free to use me . These people are strangers to the truth and see muslims as legitimate targets . Not one will respond or acknowledge my observation that it was the Muslims kingdoms of the Islamic golden age that protected them as People of teh Book from The blood thirsty Crusaders who killed more Jews on their way to the Holy Land than arabs in their campaigns Neither will they admit that anti semitisim is a direct result of Zionist invasion and dissposseon or arab land . Now they will attack me for calling you my Brother. Let it Be . May the Peace of God be with You ex us mil
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Talab
I tot i taw a putty tat
07:59 PM on 08/25/2011
this used to be a site with good info about How real Jews feel about Zionism but alas it seems the zionists have shut the page down ... they cant stand the truth to be known

http://www.jewsagainstzionism.com/about/index.cfm
photo
Greg Mirsky
Riga dimd, Riga dimd, Kas to Rigu dimdinaj?
01:23 PM on 08/25/2011
The Muslim Brotherhood among other organizations is planning one-million man demonstration at a-Tahrir Square in Cairo on August 26. Video and printed materials give a clue of what kind of demonstration it will be:
Our soldiers are killed in cold blood on the border
Planes bomb Gaza and people die
And we did not lift a finger
The million man protest against Israel on Friday August 26
as a background to images of the previous million man demonstration in a-Tahrir Square in which the crowd shouted "a million martyrs march to [liberate] al-Quds [Jerusalem]".
In its official statement issued yesterday, the Muslim Brotherhood demanded "the expulsion of the Zionist ambassador and the recalling of our ambassador from Tel Aviv" and called for a halt to gas exports to Israel and the cancellation of the Qualifying Industrial Zones (QIZ).
More fruits of the "Arab Spring"! More speeches in Cairo!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Talab
I tot i taw a putty tat
03:24 PM on 08/25/2011
Palestinians humiliated before their children at checkpoints daily , farmers cut of from their fields and not allowed to harvest their orchards, water rationed to Palestinians from sources on their own lands while Israelis fill their swimming pools but you expect the Palestinian people to welcome you to take more without a fight .... the pure unmitigated gall of israelis is amazing to behold ... and all based on a kingdom that lasted 80 years at best 2000 years ago
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
King Stevie Harper
09:26 PM on 09/21/2011
Umipnay chatoenu golinu mayartsaynu
04:01 PM on 08/24/2011
You did not address most pressing issue that of formidable nuclear force in hands of a state that has no doubt that God is on their side . Your duty perhaps did not prepare you with objective hisorical facts involving the IDF killing civillans, This as indisputable and bserved by some israeli as well as other national historians . Are you not concerned with the potential threat nuclear disaster-especially with the detalied broad forces you described w your expertise ? Can you not imagine the horror of a nuclear exchange w other Nuclear powers in reigon ? Arqument re Turks vs IDF is moot. Have you ever seen the ferocity of the Turks ? Wouldnt bet agaisnt them
Leaving all this aside, is it not incumbent upon us who know the horror of war to work for peace ? Should we not be the first to be advocating solutions insted of pointless circular atquements that convince no one ? Finally as CAS I never had a chance to thank the air force for cas in viet nam-especially arc lites in cambodia and fighter support at Ahn khe and dak to
existed aircraft whike in flight 41 x We killed a lot of civillians there too intentionallu or otherwise Agree to disagre but serious study will show IDF killing civillians itentionally or not Their My Lay was at Deir Yassin in 1948 No Myth . On behalf of The Airborne Infantry, thank you for your sevice . Over and Out
08:50 AM on 08/24/2011
IDF investigation: Egyptians took part in attack near Eilat

Army inquiry shows at least three of the terrorists that perpetrated attack were Egyptians; clips, radio communication show IDF did everything in its power to prevent Egyptian troops from getting hurt

http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4113302,00.html
07:30 AM on 08/24/2011
Later w you
09:54 PM on 08/24/2011
Sam, you are right on the numbers and I am wrong. Detroit is however the largest concentration of arab americans in US I believe. metro area is 3000,000 . I was also way off on Us aid actual is 3 billion not 30 -noted is that most of this is for military use-not allme a certain persp . Because my grandparents who came in 1900 from s, Lebanon were Marionite Christians, they were always pro Israel I never gave it another thought until oct73 while serving in the 82nd Abn Div and was loaded on a plane bound for ME Mission was to intervene bevause IDF counter attack had egypt on the run. Their ally Russia, alerted all 13 of it's Airborne Divisions . I was 18 . I started thinking why I am I about to Die ? . read about Der Yassin in a text book by Isreli author Mark Tessler- a fool can spot a problem but a superiot mind will seek a solution Enough. Neither side is going to go away . I have known war on the ground I fear It Perhaps you have too But let me be clear I WAS WRONG ON The Numbers . . I dont want see a nushroom cloud on the morning news from I Stand Corrected Thanks for pointing this out I do hope that you do appreciate the fact that me and 10,000 other men were ready to go to war Russian Airborne Divison -20,000 troops
07:23 PM on 08/23/2011
You dont think we need that money more? Dude Look around people are in the streets-armed- I woulndt be so smug Also as you learned in High school must be ratified by Senate probably Will Meanwhile you might want to protect yourself from rising crime and poverty here 30 billion would help a lot of our people Dude dont tell combat vets what to do-just friendly advice- maybe your one too if so you know we dont jive I aint no hero but no punk neither Be Cool. ex mil ex- spec ops (no such thing as ex ) That sarcasm gonna get you someday
10:25 PM on 08/22/2011
Austin thats your right 63% is not correct Come up w a solution Im sick of all this hate EX Mil
photo
Anybodyseenthepopos
Like you Really give a rats...
08:06 PM on 08/22/2011
NO demand for APOLOGY from GAZA? And gee, none of you Pro Pals demanded it either huh? Why does this NOT surprise?
09:37 PM on 08/22/2011
who you talking to ?
08:10 AM on 08/23/2011
Do you ever demand an apology from Israel when it kills civilians? No you just blame Palestinians for it, why does this NOT surprise?
photo
Anybodyseenthepopos
Like you Really give a rats...
01:51 PM on 08/23/2011
IF I see Israel targeting civilians for DEATH I'll demand both Justice and an apology! You will note Israel's response to the Baruch Goldstein murderous rampage was the Outlawing of his political party!
The Palestinians response is to dance in the streets and vote them INTO power.
puffadder
The truth is ONE!
07:26 PM on 08/22/2011
I have nothing but praise for the hundreds of thousands of Jews in Israel who seek peace with their neighbors. May their wish become a reality, the sooner the better, which will bring an end to all the hatred and gnashing of teeth.
08:51 AM on 08/23/2011
Too bad they're just a small minority.
puffadder
The truth is ONE!
06:27 PM on 08/22/2011
The militants! Just as long as they all wear their yamulkas, which by the way are becoming smaller and smaller, and will probably soon disappear, except on the heads of the hassidim; they feel that they are all holier than thou, when in fact they are no more holier than anyone else.
photo
SaneUSA
American, Jew, Zionist.
07:07 PM on 08/24/2011
What are you on about?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
season555
Allaah knows best
04:55 PM on 08/22/2011
It is only a matter of time when Israel annexes rest of Palestine with the help of the US neo-cons then they they will either kill or e.th,nicly cleanse the rest of the people.

I think they would do it right now, except they want to wait until they can push the US in to war with Iran.
08:54 AM on 08/23/2011
They will eventually have to annex the West Bank since they'll never remove their settlements. They won't be able to kill or ethnically cleanse the population since they can't get away with it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
season555
Allaah knows best
04:43 PM on 08/22/2011
Zionist are so scary they will kill other Jews who don't agree with them:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SeNB0v8SXUA
photo
ChiBloger
And the truth shall set us ALL free
01:42 PM on 08/22/2011
It is in these two nations best interest to keep the peace. I hope for their sake they do. I would not hold my breath though. Israel has for many years not had to worry quite so much about Egypt. Let’s see if they sabotage themselves?
photo
Djay0252
American First, Second, and ALWAYS
11:08 AM on 08/22/2011
Did Israel regret the killing of children too?. The word apology does not seem to be in their language; neither does peace.
11:18 AM on 08/22/2011
Only a few days ago (on a different website) I asked a group of 'pro-Israel' supporters the following...

Question: "Do you wholly condemn the killing of unarmed Palestinian civilians by Israelis"?

Not a single 'pro-Israel' supporter would condemn the killing of unarmed Palestinian civilians by Israelis.

One would think that the unlawful killing of ANY unarmed innocent civilian would be condemnable regardless who committed the crime, apparently not so for the 'pro-Israel' camp!

Try asking this question yourself and see how you get on.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
erehwon2
11:36 AM on 08/22/2011
Why not answer the question yourself? Do you condemn the actions of Palestinian ter.rorists who DELIBERATELY k.ill Israeli civilians, including targe.ting children?

I eagerly await your reply.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cdncommentator
11:52 AM on 08/22/2011
I am pro-Israel and I condemn killing unarmed Palestinian civilians.